Modelling vagueness: what can we ignore?
- First Online:
- 167 Downloads
A theory of vagueness gives a model of vague language and of reasoning within the language. Among the models that have been offered are Degree Theorists’ numerical models that assign values between 0 and 1 to sentences, rather than simply modelling sentences as true or false. In this paper, I ask whether we can benefit from employing a rich, well-understood numerical framework, while ignoring those aspects of it that impute a level of mathematical precision that is not present in the modelled phenomenon of vagueness. Can we ignore apparent implications for the phenomena by pointing out that it is “just a model” and that the unwanted features are mere artefacts? I explore the distinction between representors and artefacts and criticise the strategy of appealing to features as mere artefacts in defence of a theory. I focus largely on theories using numerical resources, but also consider other, related theories and strategies, including theories appealing to non-linear structures.
KeywordsVagueness Modelling Sorites paradox Degree theories Artefacts
- Edgington, D. (1996). Vagueness by degrees. In R. Keefe & P. Smith (Eds.), Vagueness: A reader (pp. 294–316). Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Edgington, D. (unpublished manuscript). Vagueness: Filling the gaps.Google Scholar
- Keefe, R. (1998). Vagueness by numbers. Mind, 107, 565–579.Google Scholar
- Keefe, R. (2000). Theories of vagueness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Machina, K. (1976). Truth, belief and vagueness. Journal of Philosophical Logic, 5, 47–78. Reprinted in R. Keefe & P. Smith (Eds), Vagueness: A reader. MIT Press, 1996.Google Scholar
- Shapiro, S. (1998). Logical consequence: Models and modality. In M. Schirn (Ed.), Philosophy of mathematics today: Proceedings of an international congress in Munich (pp. 131–156). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Tye, M. (1994). Sorites paradoxes and the semantics of vagueness. Philosophical Perspectives 8: Logic and Language, 189–206.Google Scholar
- Williamson, T. (1994). Vagueness. London: Routledge.Google Scholar