Revisiting the Great Moderation: Policy or Luck?
- 210 Downloads
We investigate the relative roles of monetary policy and shocks in causing the Great Moderation, using indirect inference where a DSGE model is tested for its ability to mimic a VAR describing the data. A New Keynesian model with a Taylor Rule and one with the Optimal Timeless Rule are both tested. The latter easily dominates, whether calibrated or estimated, implying that the Fed’s policy in the 1970s was neither inadequate nor a cause of indeterminacy; it was both optimal and essentially unchanged during the 1980s. By implication it was largely the reduced shocks that caused the Great Moderation—among them monetary policy shocks the Fed injected into inflation.
KeywordsGreat moderation Causes Indirect inference Test Wald statistics
JEL ClassificationE42 E52 E58
We are grateful to Michael Arghyrou, Michael Hatcher, Vo Phuong Mai Le, David Meenagh, Edward Nelson, Ricardo Reis, Peter Smith, Herman van Dijk and Kenneth West for helpful comments. We also thank Zhongjun Qu and Pierre Perron for sharing their code for testing of structural break. A supporting annex to this paper is available at www.patrickminford.net/wp/E2012_9_annex.pdf.
- Canova F (2005) Methods for applied macroeconomic research. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
- Carare A, Tchaidze R (2005) The use and abuse of Taylor Rules: how precisely can we estimate them?. IMF Working Paper, No. 05/148, JulyGoogle Scholar
- Chib S, Kang KH, Ramamurthy S (2010) Term structure of interest rates in a DSGE model with regime changes. Olin Business School working paper, Washington University, http://apps.olin.wustl.edu/MEGConference/Files/pdf/2010/59.pdf, especially appendix D, p 46
- Fernandez-Villaverde J, Guerron-Quintana P, Rubio-Ramirez JF (2009) The new macroeconometrics: a Bayesian approach. In: O’Hagan A, West M (eds) Handbook of applied Bayesian analysis. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Fernandez-Villaverde J, Guerron-Quintana P, Rubio-Ramirez JF (2010) Reading the recent monetary history of the U.S., 1959–2007. Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia working paper, No. 10–15Google Scholar
- Giannoni MP, Woodford M (2005) Optimal interest rate targeting rules. In: Bernanke BS, Woodford M (eds) Inflation targeting. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
- Gourieroux C, Monfort A (1996) Simulation based econometric methods, CORE Lectures Series. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Gregory AW, Smith GW (1991) Calibration as testing: inference in simulated macroeconomic models. J Bus Econ Stat Am Stat Assoc 9(3):297–303Google Scholar
- Gregory AW, Smith GW (1993) Calibration in macroeconomics. In: Maddla GS (ed) Handbook of statistics, 11th edn. Elsevier, St. Louis, pp 703–719Google Scholar
- Ingber L (1996) Adaptive simulated annealing (ASA): lessons learned. Control Cybern 25:33Google Scholar
- Le VPM, Meenagh D, Minford APL, Wickens MR (2012) Testing DSGE models by Indirect inference and other methods: some Monte Carlo experiments. Cadiff University Working Paper Series, E2012/15, JuneGoogle Scholar
- McCallum BT, Nelson E (2004) ‘Timeless perspective vs. discretionary monetary policy’. Review, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 86(2):43Google Scholar
- Minford P (2008) Commentary on ‘Economic projections and rules of thumb for monetary policy’. Review, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 90(4):331Google Scholar
- Rotemberg JJ, Woodford M (1998) An optimization-based econometric model for the evaluation of monetary policy. NBER Technical Working Paper, No. 233Google Scholar
- Stock JH, Watson MW (2002) Has the Business Cycle Changed and Why? NBER Working Papers 9127, National Bureau of Economic Research, IncGoogle Scholar
- Svensson LEO, Woodford M (2004) Implementing optimal policy through inflation-forecast targeting. In: Bernanke BS, Woodford M (eds) Inflation targeting. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
- Woodford M (2003b) Interest and prices: foundations of a theory of monetary policy. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar