Abstract
How have property buyouts and disaster recovery assistance programs been implemented in Canadian communities? This paper compares contrasting policies and programs in two Canadian jurisdictions, Pointe Gatineau, Quebec and Constance Bay, Ontario—both of which experienced major flooding from the Ottawa River in 2017 and 2019. The floods highlighted the need for government interventions, including disaster recovery compensation and property buyouts, to support homeowners through the recovery process. This research adopts the Protect, Accommodate, Retreat and Avoid (PARA) framework to characterize and evaluate the different policy responses to the flood events in the two provinces in the broader context of climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction. Through qualitative research methods, the study assessed the strengths and weakness of the provincial policy responses, explained why different policies were created in Ontario and Quebec (despite sharing a common river and flood risks), described how the policy deployment strategies evolved and examined how the programs prompted homeowners to make the decision to either retreat or rebuild. Both case studies involved reviewing flood timelines and recovery efforts, examining the disaster recovery policies implemented and assessing the application of property buyouts in flooded communities. The case studies were then compared to draw out cross-case insights. The paper concludes with lessons for designing effective property buyout programs. This study is intended to assist policymakers to make informed, evidence-based decisions that can protect communities from inundations risks and build long-term resilience against flood hazards.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Binder SB, Barile JP, Baker CK, Kulp B (2019) Home buyouts and household recovery: neighborhood differences three years after Hurricane Sandy. Environ Hazards 18(2):127–145
Baker CK, Binder SB, Greer A, Weir P, Gates K (2018) Integrating community concerns and recommendations into home buyout and relocation policy. Risk, Hazards Crisis Public Policy 9(4):455–479
Boucher, A.C., & Nolin, M. (2019). Canada: Quebec tightens restrictions on construction and other projects in flood-prone areas. Mondaq. https://www.mondaq.com/canada/construction-planning/829028/quebec-tightens-restrictions-on-construction-and-other-projects-in-flood-prone-areas
Boudreault, M., & Bourdeau-Brien, M. (2020) Lifetime limit on successive floods: toward a new social covenant?., Research Report. 18p. https://archipel.uqam.ca/13310/2/MB%20MBB%20-%20Lifetime%20limit%20on%20successive%20floods.pdf
Carey J (2020) Core concept: managed retreat increasingly seen as necessary in response to climate change’s fury. Proc Natl Acad Sci 117(24):13182–13185
Constance & Buckham’s Bay Community Association. (2017). Constance Bay and WC flooding. Here is our story. http://cbbca.ca/cms/constance-bay-wc-flooding/
CBC News. (2017). The Ottawa and Gatineau flood: A photo timeline https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/ottawa-gatineau-floods-photos-week-1.4110510
CBC News. (2018). 'We can never say thank you enough': Constance Bay looks back on devastating floods. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/constance-bay-flooding-volunteers-1.4630058
CBC News. (2019a). Quebec premier says province will cap flood compensation. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/gatineau-floods-ottawa-francois-legault-1.5106522
CBC News. (2019b.) 'We have no choice': Flooded gatineau residents mull buyouts. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/gatineau-residents-quebec-flood-buyouts-1.5144128
CBC News. (2019c). Gatineau aims to 'take back' lots left vacant by floods. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/flood-gatineau-vacant-land-1.5362532
CBC News. (2019d). Hundreds of Constance Bay residents told to leave their homes. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/ottawa-river-flooding-2019-news-1.5116309#:~:text=According%20to%20an%20update%20issued,from%20Monday%20morning%2C%20and%20is
CBC News. (2019e). Timeline: Rising water, rising fears. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/timeline-2019-flooding-ottawa-gatineau-1.5114254
CBC News. (2019f). Ottawa: Under water, again. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/ottawa-river-flooding-2019-recap-1.5119980
Corbin J, Strauss A (2008) Strategies for qualitative data analysis Basics of Qualitative Research, 3rd edn. Sage Publications, Techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory
CTV News. (2019). Flood 2019: Constance Bay evacuation. https://ottawa.ctvnews.ca/flood-2019-constance-bay-evacuation-1.4402132
de Loë R (2008) Floodplain management in Canada: overview and prospects. Can Geogr 44(4):355–368
Doberstein B, Fitzgibbons J, Mitchell C (2019) Protect, accommodate, retreat or avoid (PARA): Canadian community options for flood disaster risk reduction and flood resilience. Nat Hazards 98:31–50
Doberstein B, Tadgell A, Rutledge A (2020) Managed retreat for climate change adaptation in coastal megacities: a comparison of policy and practice in Manila and Vancouver. J Environ Manag 253:109753
Fernandez G, Ahmed I (2019) “Build back better” approach to disaster recovery: research trends since 2006. Prog Disaster Sci 1:100003
Freudenberg R, Calvin E, Tolkoff L, Brawley D (2016) Buy-in for buyouts: the case for managed retreat from flood zones. Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, Cambridge, MA
Georgetown Climate Center. (2020). Managed retreat toolkit – introduction https://www.georgetownclimate.org/adaptation/toolkits/managed-retreat-toolkit/introduction.html
Golnarghi M, Thistlethwaite J, Henstra D, Stewart C (2020) Flood risk mangement in Canada. The Geneva Association
Government of Canada. (2019). Better flood protection for Gatineau residents. Infrastrucuture Canada. https://www.canada.ca/en/office-infrastructure/news/2019/07/better-flood-protection-for-gatineau-residents.html
Government of Ontario. (2019). Guidelines to apply for Disaster Recovery Assistance for Ontarians (DRAO). https://www.ontario.ca/document/guidelines-apply-disaster-recovery-assistance-ontarians-drao
Government of Ontario. (2020). Ontario’s approach to managing flood risk. https://www.ontario.ca/document/independent-review-2019-flood-events-ontario/ontarios-approach-managing-flood-risk
Government of Quebec. (2019). Simplified Guide: Homeowners and Tenants –General Indemnity and Financial Assistance Program Regarding Actual or Imminent Disasters – Flooding. https://www.securitepublique.gouv.qc.ca/fileadmin/Documents/securite_civile/aidefinanciere_sinistres/guide/guide_homeowners_tenants_08-05-2019.pdf
Government of Quebec. (2020) Special intervention zone -delimitation of the territory flooded during the spring floods of 2017 and 2019 included in the special intervention zone. https://www.cehq.gouv.qc.ca/zones-inond/zone-intervention-speciale.htm
Greer A, Binder SB (2017) A historical assessment of home buyout policy: are we learning or just failing? Hous Policy Debate 27(3):372–392
Greiving S, Du J, Puntub W (2018) Managed retreat — a strategy for the mitigation of disaster risks with international and comparative perspectives. J Extreme Events 5:1850011
Hino M, Field CB, Mach KJ (2017) Managed retreat as a response to natural hazard risk. Nat Clim Chang 7(5):364–370
Helmer, A. (2017). Sheer force of Constance Bay flood 'caught everybody off guard'. Ottawa Citizen Local News. https://ottawacitizen.com/news/local-news/sheer-force-of-constance-bay-flood-caught-everybody-off-guard
Henstra D, Thistlethwaite J (2017) Flood risk and shared responsibility in Canada: operating on flawed assumptions? CIGI policy brief. Centre for International Governance Innovation
Henstra D, Thistlethwaite J (2017) Flood risk management: what is the role ahead for the government of Canada? CIGI policy brief. Centre for International Governance Innovation
Henstra D, Thistlethwaite J (2018) Buyer beware: evaluating property disclosure as a tool to support flood risk management CIGI policy brief. Centre for International Governance Innovation
Henstra D, Thistlethwaite J, Brown C, Scott D (2019) Flood risk management and shared responsibility: exploring Canadian public attitudes and expectations. J Flood Risk Manag 12(1):e12346
Insurance Bureau of Canada. (2019). Options for Managing Flood Costs of Canada’s Highest Risk Residential Properties. http://assets.ibc.ca/Documents/Studies/IBC-Flood-Options-Paper-EN.pdf
Insurance Bureau of Canada & Federation of Canadian Municpalities. (2020). Investing in Canada’s Future: The Cost of Climate Adaptation at the Local Level. https://data.fcm.ca/documents/reports/investing-in-canadas-future-the-cost-of-climate-adaptation.pdf
Laframboise, K. (2019). Major spring flooding struck 250 municipalities in Quebec. Global News. https://globalnews.ca/news/5364923/quebec-floods-final-report-2019/
Mach KJ, Kraan CM, Hino M, Siders AR, Johnston EM, Field CB (2019) Managed retreat through voluntary buyouts of flood-prone properties. Sci Adv 5(10):eaax8995
McNeil, D. (2019). An Independent Review of the 2019 Flood Events Ontario. Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry: Ontario. https://files.ontario.ca/mnrf-english-ontario-special-advisor-on-flooding-report-2019-11-25.pdf
Montreal Gazette. (2018). One year after the Quebec floods, an infernal waiting game plays out. https://montrealgazette.com/news/local-news/flood-victims-living-in-bureaucratic-limbo
Montreal Gazette. (2019). Quebec flooding: Province has so far paid out $26 million in financial aid. https://montrealgazette.com/news/quebec-flooding-province-has-so-far-paid-out-26-million-in-financial-aid
Ottawa River Regulation Planning Board. (2017). Summary of the 2017 Spring Flood. https://www.ottawariver.ca/docs/2017_Spring_Flood_Summary.pdf
Saunders-Hastings, P., Bernard, M., and Doberstein, B. (2020). Planned Retreat Approaches to Support Resilience to Climate Change in Canada. Natural Resources Canada: Ottawa, Canada, in press.
Shrubsole D (2000) Flood management in Canada at the crossroads. Glob Environ Change Part b: Environ Hazards 2(2):63–75
Siders AR (2019a) Managed retreat in the United States. One Earth 1(2):216–225
Siders AR (2019b) Social justice implications of US managed retreat buyout programs. Clim Change, 152(2):239–257
Siders AR, Hino M, Mach KJ (2019) The case for strategic and managed climate retreat. Science 365(6455):761–763
Thistlethwaite, J., & Ziolecki, A. (2020). Where Will We Go When the Water Comes? Lessons for Cities seeking a managed retreat from flood risk. NewCities. https://newcities.org/the-big-picture-where-will-we-go-when-the-water-comes/
United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction. (2015). Sendai Framework for Disaster Reduction 2015–2030. Geneva: UNDRR http://www.unisdr.org/files/43291 _sendai frameworkfordrren.pdf
Ville de Gatineau. (2019). Spring Flood: Gatineau is asking residents to prepare for flooding as bad as, if not worse than, in May 2017. News Release. https://www.gatineau.ca/portail/default.aspx?p=nouvelles_annonces/communiques/communique_2015&id=466664658
Acknowledgements
This research is funded by the Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction (ICLR) under its "Quick Response Program for 2019 Spring Flooding".
Funding
This research is funded by the Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction (ICLR) under its "Quick Response Program for 2019 Spring Flooding".
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflicts of interest
Not applicable.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cottar, S., Doberstein, B., Henstra, D. et al. Evaluating property buyouts and disaster recovery assistance (Rebuild) options in Canada: A comparative analysis of Constance Bay, Ontario and Pointe Gatineau, Quebec. Nat Hazards 109, 201–220 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-021-04832-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-021-04832-4