Advertisement

Protect, accommodate, retreat or avoid (PARA): Canadian community options for flood disaster risk reduction and flood resilience

  • Brent DobersteinEmail author
  • Joanne Fitzgibbons
  • Carrie Mitchell
Original Paper

Abstract

This paper uses the “protect/accommodate/retreat/avoid” or “PARA” framework to categorize and examine flood disaster risk reduction approaches used to build climate change resilience in communities across Canada. We suggest that the PARA framework, first developed for climate change adaptation planning in communities facing sea level rise, is also a useful framework for flood risk reduction and flood resilience. The paper reviews four case studies of Canadian flood disaster risk reduction, with each case chosen to represent one of the four PARA risk reduction options. The extensive network of dikes and pumping stations employed in British Columbia’s Lower Mainland (Fraser River) is used in the paper as an example of a “protect” approach to flood risk reduction; Winnipeg, Manitoba’s Basement Flood Relief Program is used to highlight the “accommodate” approach; zoning changes and land expropriation following Toronto, Ontario’s 1954 Hurricane Hazel flood disaster are used to showcase the “retreat” approach; and, modern floodplain development planning approaches in Calgary, Alberta are used to highlight the “avoid” approach. Overall, this paper contends that the PARA framework can be an effective approach for comprehensive flood disaster risk reduction and flood resilience; however, contextual factors, including equity considerations, should guide its application in situ.

Keywords

Resilience Natural hazards Disaster risk reduction Climate change Canada Flooding 

References

  1. 2011 Flood Review Task Force, Province of Manitoba (2013) Report to the minister of infrastructure and transportation. Retrieved from http://www.gov.mb.ca/asset_library/en/2011flood/flood_review_task_force_report.pdf
  2. Adger WN (2000) Social and ecological resilience: are they related? Prog Hum Geogr 24(3):347–364CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Alberta Council for Environmental Education (ACEE) (2017) Climate Change in Calgary: what will it look like? Presented at Climate Change and Education Outreach Workshop, December 7, 2017. CalgaryGoogle Scholar
  4. Alberta Government (2014) Updated provincial flood statistics. News Release. Retrieved from https://www.alberta.ca/release.cfm?xID=3659373BD1D92-CFDB-0D72-DB4C37C4D35EBCFE
  5. Alberta Municipal Affairs (2014) Discussion paper (Draft)—floodway development regulation. 20 Aug 2014. Retrieved from http://www.municipalaffairs.alberta.ca/documents/ms/Floodway_Reg_DiscussionPaper.pdf
  6. Aldunce P, Beilin R, Handmer J, Howden M (2014) Framing disaster resilience: the implications of the diverse conceptualisations of “bouncing back”. Disaster Prev Manag Int J 23(3):252–270CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Bahadur AV, Ibrahim M, Tanner T (2013) Characterising resilience: unpacking the concept for tackling climate change and development. Clim Dev 5(1):55–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Béné C, Mehta L, McGranahan G, Cannon T, Gupte J, Tanner T (2018) Resilience as a policy narrative: potentials and limits in the context of urban planning. Clim Dev 10(2):1–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Berbés-Blázquez M, Mitchell CL, Burch SL, Wandel J (2017) Understanding climate change and resilience: assessing strengths and opportunities for adaptation in the Global South. Clim Change 141(2):227–241CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Birkmann J, von Teichman K (2010) Integrating disaster risk reduction and climate change adaptation: key challenges-scales, knowledge, and norms. Sustain Sci 5(2):171–184CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Birkmann J, Buckle P, Jaeger J, Pelling M, Setiadi N, Garschagen M, Fernando N, Kropp J (2010) Extreme events and disasters: a window of opportunity for change? Analysis of organizational, institutional and political changes, formal and informal responses after mega-disasters. Nat Hazards 55:637–655CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Bonanno GA (2004) Loss, trauma, and human resilience: have we underestimated the human capacity to thrive after extremely aversive events? Am Psychol 59(1):20CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Boulet C (2013) Basement flood risk reduction city of Winnipeg. (Presentation) Toronto: ICLR Urban and Basement Flooding Symposium. Retrieved from https://www.iclr.org/images/Charles_-_Full.pdf
  14. British Columbia Ministry of Environment (2013) Sea level rise adaptation primer: a toolkit to build adaptive capacity on Canada’s South Coasts. The Arlington Group et al.: Victoria. Retrieved from https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/environment/climate-change/adaptation/resources/slr-primer.pdf
  15. British Columbia MoFLNRO (Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations) (2014) Simulating the effects of sea level rise and climate change on fraser river flood scenarios: final report. British Columbia MoFLNRO: VancouverGoogle Scholar
  16. Brownhill S, Carpenter J (2007) Participation and planning: dichotomies, rationalities, and strategies for power. Town Plan Rev 78(March):1–9Google Scholar
  17. Canadian Disaster Database (2018) Canadian disaster database. Retrieved from http://cdd.publicsafety.gc.ca/srchpg-eng.aspx?dynamic=false
  18. Carmin J, Dodman D, Chu E (2013) Urban climate adaptation and leadership: from conceptual understanding to practical action (No. 2013/26). OECD Publishing, ParisGoogle Scholar
  19. CBC News (2015, June 2). Winnipeg, province offer basement flooding subsidy to keep homes dry. CBC News. Retrieved from http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/winnipeg-province-offer-basement-flooding-subsidy-to-keep-homes-dry-1.3097248
  20. City of Calgary (1980) The city of Calgary land use bylaw. Retrieved from http://www.calgary.ca/PDA/pd/Documents/bylaw-2P80/bylaw2p80.pdf
  21. City of Calgary (2014) Calgary’s Flood resilient future—report from the expert management panel on river flood mitigation. Retrieved from https://postmediacalgaryherald2.files.wordpress.com/2014/08/expert-management-panel-report-to-council.pdf
  22. Cooke B, Kothari U (2001) Participation: the new tyranny?. Zed Books, LondonGoogle Scholar
  23. CTV News (2017, November 2) Ravaged by floods of 2011, Manitoba First Nation finally welcomes families home. Retrieved from https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/ravaged-by-floods-in-2011-manitoba-first-nation-finally-welcomes-families-home-1.3661089
  24. Cumming Cockburn Ltd (2000) Hurricane Hazel and extreme rainfall in Southern Ontario. ICLR research paper series no. 9. ICLR: TorontoGoogle Scholar
  25. Cutter SL, Barnes L, Berry M, Burton C, Evans E, Tate E, Webb J (2008) A place-based model for understanding community resilience to natural disasters. Glob Environ Change 18(4):598–606CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Dotto et al (2010) Canadians at risk: our exposure to natural hazards. ICLR research paper series no. 48. ICLR: TorontoGoogle Scholar
  27. Dronkers J, Gilbert TE, Butler LW, Carey JJ, Campbell J, James E, McKenzie C, Misdorp R, Quin N, Ries KL, Schroder PC, Spradley JR, Titus JG, Vallianos L, von Dadelszen J (1990) Strategies for adaptation to sea level rise. Report of the IPCC coastal zone management subgroup: intergovernmental panel on climate change. Geneva: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate ChangeGoogle Scholar
  28. Eichhorst U, Bongardt D, Miramontes M (2011) Climate-proofing urban transport planning: opportunities and challenges in developing cities. In: Otto-Zimmerman (ed) Resilient cities: cities and adaptation to climate change (proceedings of the global forum 2010). Springer, GermanyGoogle Scholar
  29. Environment and Climate Change Canada (2013) Canada’s top 10 weather stories of 2013. Retrieved from https://ec.gc.ca/meteo-weather/default.asp?lang=En&n=5BA5EAFC-1&offset=1&toc=hide
  30. Environment and Climate Change Canada (2018a) Hurricane hazel-mitigation. Retrieved from http://www.ec.gc.ca/ouragans-hurricanes/default.asp?lang=En&n=CA3BC939-1
  31. Environment and Climate Change Canada (2018b) Hurricane Hazel impacts-Humber river. Retrieved from www.ec.gc.ca/ouragans-hurricanes/default.asp?lang=en&n=BD91538F-1#raym
  32. EnviroPaul (2016) Flood memories. Retrieved from https://enviropaul.wordpress.com/2016/02/01/flood-memories/
  33. Folke C (2006) Resilience: the emergence of a perspective for social-ecological systems analyses. Glob Environ Change 16(3):253–267.  https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2006.04.002 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Fraser Basin Council (2016) Lower mainland flood management strategy: phase 1 summary report. Fraser Basin Council: Vancouver. Retrieved from https://www.fraserbasin.bc.ca/_Library/Water_Flood_Strategy/FBC_LMFMS_Phase_1_Report_Web_May_2016.pdf
  35. Fraser Basin Council (2018) Flood strategy briefing—lower mainland flood management strategy phase 2. Bulletin 2, May 2018. Fraser Basin Council: VancouverGoogle Scholar
  36. Friend R, Jarvie J, Reed SO, Sutarto R, Thinphanga P, Toan VC (2014) Mainstreaming urban climate resilience into policy and planning; reflections from Asia. Urban Climate. 7:6–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Galea D (2013) Come hell or high water: how Alberta’s best responded to its worst ever disaster. Presentation at 2016 Disaster Forum, May 9–12, 2016. Banff, Alberta. Retrieved from https://www.disasterforum.ca/df-2016/Dave%20Galea.pdf
  38. Grabish, A. (2017, April 17). Death toll in flooded-out Manitoba First Nation hits 92 as evacuees wait to return home. CBC News. Retrieved from http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/death-toll-in-flooded-out-manitoba-first-nation-hits-92-as-evacuees-wait-to-return-home-1.4040365
  39. Harford D (2016) Climate change adaptation: the big picture. Presented at metro Vancouver community sustainability breakfast. Retrieved from http://www.metrovancouver.org/events/community-breakfasts/Presentations/DeborahHarford-April21.pdf
  40. Harris LM, Chu EK, Ziervogel G (2017) Negotiated resilience. Resilience 6(3):1–19CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Hegger DLT, Driessen PPJ, Wiering M, Van Rijswick HFMW, Kundzewicz ZW, Matczak P, Crabbé A, Raadgever GT, Bakker MHN, Priest SJ, Larrue C, Ek K (2016) Toward more flood resilience: is a diversification of flood risk management strategies the way forward? Ecol Soc 21(4):52CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Henstra D, Thistlethwaite J (2017) Climate change, floods, and municipal risk sharing in Canada. IMFG papers on municipal finance and governance, No. 30. University of Toronto: TorontoGoogle Scholar
  43. Holling CS (1973) Resilience and stability of ecological systems. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 4:1–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Holling CS (1986) The resilience of terrestrial ecosystems: local surprise and global change. In: Clark WC, Munn RE (eds) Sustainable development of the biosphere. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 292–317Google Scholar
  45. Holling CS (1996) Engineering resilience versus ecological resilience. Eng Ecol Constraints 31(1996):32Google Scholar
  46. Hollnagel E, Woods DD, Leveson N (2007) Resilience engineering: concepts and precepts. Ashgate Publishing Ltd., AldershotGoogle Scholar
  47. IPCC (2014) Climate change 2014: synthesis report. In: Core Writing Team, Pachauri RK, Meyer LA (eds) Contribution of working groups I, II and III to the fifth assessment report of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. IPCC, GenevaGoogle Scholar
  48. Johnson C (2012) Urban and regional planning and disaster. In: Wisner B (ed) The Routledge handbook of hazards and disaster risk reduction. Routledge, London, pp 641–651Google Scholar
  49. Klein RJ, Nicholls RJ, Thomalla F (2003) Resilience to natural hazards: how useful is this concept? Glob Environ Change Part B Environ Hazards 5(1):35–45CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Kovacs P, Sandink D (2013) Best practices for reducing the risk of future damage to homes from riverine and urban flooding: a report on recovery and rebuilding in southern Alberta. ICLR research paper series—number 53. Retrieved from https://www.firstonsite.ca/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/ICLR-Alberta-Risk-Report-Sept-2013.pdf
  51. Lambert S (2018, January 12) Judge approves $90 M settlement for flooded Manitoba First Nations. CBC News. Retrieved from http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/manitoba-first-nations-flooding-settlement-1.4482353
  52. Leichenko R (2011) Climate change and urban resilience. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 3(3):164–168CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Madni AM, Jackson S (2009) Towards a conceptual framework for resilience engineering. IEEE Syst J 3(2):181–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Martin R (2012) Regional economic resilience, hysteresis and recessionary shocks. J Econ Geogr 12(1):1–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Masten AS (2001) Ordinary magic: resilience processes in development. Am Psychol 56(3):227CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. McNabb L (2015, October 13) Manitoba insurance broker offers clients overland flooding protection through home insurance. Global News. Retrieved from https://globalnews.ca/news/2274225/manitoba-insurance-broker-offers-clients-overland-flooding-protection-through-home-insurance/
  57. McVeigh T (2014) The Dutch solution to floods: live with water, don’t fight it. The Guardian. 16 Feb 2014. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/feb/16/flooding-netherlands
  58. Meerow S, Newell JP (2016) Urban resilience for whom, what, when, where, and why? Urban Geogr.  https://doi.org/10.1080/02723638.2016.1206395 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Meerow S, Newell JP, Stults M (2016) Defining urban resilience: a review. Landsc Urban Plan 147:38–49CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Merringer I (2011) History runs deep in Toronto’s Humber River. Globe and Mail News Article. Globe and Mail: Toronto. Retrieved from https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/toronto/history-runs-deep-in-torontos-humber-river/article588348/
  61. Michaels S, Goucher NP, McCarthy D (2006) Policy windows, policy change, and organizational learning: watersheds in the evolution of watershed management. Environ Manag 38:983–992CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Middle G (2018) The status of coastal planning in Western Australia. Presented at Coast to Coast Conference: Meeting at the Margin. 16–20 Apr 2018. Retrieved from https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/environment/climate-change/adaptation/resources/slr-primer.pdf
  63. Moench M (2014) Experiences applying the climate resilience framework: linking theory with practice. Dev Pract 24(4):447–464CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Montz BE, Tobin GA, Hagelman RR, Tobin GA (2017) Natural hazards: explanation and integration. The Guilford Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  65. Murray D, Davy N (2017) Locally, regionally, provincially or nationally? What is the best way to manage flood risk? Presented at the Canadian water resources association annual meeting, June 2017. Retrieved from https://www.kwl.ca/sites/default/files/KWL%20Webversion%20Murray%20and%20Davy%2020170605%20-%20Flood%20Risk%20Management%20Across%20Canada-CWRA%202017.pdf
  66. Ong AD, Bergeman CS, Bisconti TL, Wallace KA (2006) Psychological resilience, positive emotions, and successful adaptation to stress in later life. J Pers Soc Psychol 91(4):730CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Pelling M (2003) The vulnerability of cities: natural disasters and social resilience. Earthscan, LondonGoogle Scholar
  68. Perrings C (1998) Resilience in the dynamics of economy-environment systems. Environ Resource Econ 11(3–4):503–520CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Province of Manitoba (2011a) Governments of Canada and Manitoba issue statement regarding first nations affected by Lake St. Martin Flooding (News Release). Retrieved from http://news.gov.mb.ca/news/index.html?archive=2011-05-01&item=11574
  70. Province of Manitoba (2011b) Province to cover full cost of well-water testing for flood-affected areas (media bulletin). Retrieved from http://news.gov.mb.ca/news/index.html?archive=2011-04-01&item=11328
  71. Province of Manitoba (n.d.a) 2011 individual flood protection initiative. Retrieved from http://www.gov.mb.ca/waterstewardship/flood_proofing_programs/flood_protection_initiative/index.html
  72. Province of Manitoba (n.d.b) Manitoba flood facts. Retrieved from https://www.gov.mb.ca/flooding/history/index.html
  73. Rijke J, Herk SV, Zevenbergen C, Ashley R (2012) Room for the River: delivering integrated river basin management in the Netherlands. Int J River Basin Manag 10(4):369–382CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Robinson D, Cruikshank K (2006) Hurricane Hazel: disaster relief, politics, and society in Canada, 1954–1955. J Canad Stud 40(1):37–69CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Rockefeller Foundation (2018) 100 resilient cities main page. Retrieved from https://www.100resilientcities.org/
  76. Rollason K (2015, February 24) Flood of flood insurance on horizon. Winnipeg Free Press. Retrieved from https://www.winnipegfreepress.com/local/flood-of-flood-insurance-on-horizon-293794861.html
  77. Shi L, Chu E, Anguelovski I, Aylett A, Debats J, Goh K et al (2016) Roadmap towards justice in urban climate adaptation research. Nat Clim Change 6(2):131–137CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Simonsen R, Biggs M, Schlüter M, Schoon E, Bohensky G, Cundill V, Dakos T, Daw K, Kotschy A, Leitch A, Quinlan G, Peterson FM (2013) Applying resilience thinking: seven principles for building resilience in social-ecological systems. Stockholm Resilience Centre, Stockholm, pp 1–20Google Scholar
  79. Skerritt J (2011, February 24) Flood-fight subsidy is official. Winnipeg Free Press. Retrieved from https://www.winnipegfreepress.com/local/flood-fight-subsidy-is-official-116801508.html
  80. Smith K (2013) Environmental hazards: Assessing risk and reducing disaster. Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, LondonCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Stadnyk T, Dow K, Wazney L, Blais E, Stadnyk T, Dow K, Blais E (2016) The 2011 flood event in the Red River Basin: causes, assessment and damages. Can Water Resour J 41(1–2):65–73CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Statistics Canada (2017a) Map 15.4: Red River Valley, 1997 Flooding. Canada Year Book. Statistics Canada Catalogue no. 11-402-X. Ottawa. Accessed 1 Aug 2018Google Scholar
  83. Statistics Canada 2017b Winnipeg, CY [Census subdivision], Manitoba and Canada [Country] (table). Census Profile. 2016 Census. Statistics Canada Catalogue no. 98-316-X2016001. Ottawa. Released November 29, 2017. Accessed 2 May 2018Google Scholar
  84. Swiss Re (2016) The road to flood resilience in Canada. Map 15.4: Red River Valley, 1997 Flooding. http://www.swissre.com/library/The_road_to_flood_resilience_in_Canada.html
  85. Tadgell A, Mortsch L, Doberstein B (2017) Assessing the feasibility of resettlement as a climate change adaptation strategy for informal settlements in Metro Manila, Philippines. Int J Disaster Risk Reduct 22:447–457CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Tanner A (2016) Exploring flood risk perceptions and risk management preferences in the aftermath of the calgary flood of 2013. Unpublished Master’s Thesis, University of Calgary. Retrieved from https://prism.ucalgary.ca/bitstream/handle/11023/3222/ucalgary_2016_tanner_alexa.pdf;jsessionid=6EC3871043B9B150027895912ACEDC1C?sequence=5
  87. The Globe and Mail (1954) 54 Die, 69 Lost. News Article. Oct 15, 1954. Retrieved from https://globalnews.ca/news/598817/42-areas-in-gta-at-risk-of-flooding-during-extreme-weather-events/
  88. Thomalla F, Downing T, Spanger-Siegfried E, Han G, Rockström J (2006) Reducing hazard vulnerability: towards a common approach between disaster risk reduction and climate adaptation. Disasters 30(1):39–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Toronto Public Library Archives (1954) Hurricane Hazel images. Retrieved from https://www.torontopubliclibrary.ca/search.jsp?N=38550&No=30&Ntt=hurricane+hazel
  90. TRCA: Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (1998) State of the watershed report: Etobicoke and Mimico creek watersheds. TRCA, TorontoGoogle Scholar
  91. TRCA: Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (2005) 50 years later: Hurricane Hazel’s legacy at the Mouth of Etobicoke Creek. Etobicoke and Mimico Creek Watershed Newsletter. Spring 2005 7(1):1–12Google Scholar
  92. TRCA: Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (2018) Flood risk management—history. Retrieved from https://trca.ca/conservation/flood-risk-management/history/
  93. TRCA: Toronto and Region Conservation Authority (n.d.) The history of flood control in the TRCA. Retrieved from http://www.trca.on.ca/dotAsset/18310.pdf
  94. Tyler K (2015) Sea level rise adaptation primer: a toolkit to build adaptive capacity on Canada’s Coasts. Presentation. Climate Action Secretariat, BC Ministry of Environment: Prince George. http://slideplayer.com/slide/8946965/
  95. Tyler S, Moench M (2012) A framework for urban climate resilience. Clim Dev 4(4):311–326CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  96. UNISDR (2015) Sendai framework for disaster risk reduction 2015–2030. UN, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  97. Vale LJ (2014) The politics of resilient cities: Whose resilience and whose city? Build Res Inf 42(2):191–201CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Walker B, Meyers JA (2004) Thresholds in ecological and social–ecological systems: a developing database. Ecol Soc 9(2):3CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  99. Walker B, Holling CS, Carpenter SR, Kinzig A (2004) Resilience, adaptability and transformability in social-ecological systems. Ecol Soc 9(2):5CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  100. Walker BH, Carpenter SR, Rockstrom J, Crépin A-S, Peterson GD (2012) Drivers, “slow” variables, “fast” variables, shocks, and resilience. Ecol Soc 17(3):30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Ziervogel G, Pelling M, Cartwright A, Chu E, Deshpande T, Harris L, Zweig P (2017) Inserting rights and justice into urban resilience: a focus on everyday risk. Environ Urban 29(1):123–138CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Geography and Environmental Management, Faculty of EnvironmentUniversity of WaterlooWaterlooCanada
  2. 2.School of Planning, Faculty of EnvironmentUniversity of WaterlooWaterlooCanada

Personalised recommendations