The evolution of public health ethics frameworks: systematic review of moral values and norms in public health policy

  • Mahmoud Abbasi
  • Reza Majdzadeh
  • Alireza Zali
  • Abbas Karimi
  • Forouzan Akrami
Review Article

Abstract

Given the evolution of the public health (PH) and the changes from the phenomenon of globalization, this area has encountered new ethical challenges. In order to find a coherent approach to address ethical issues in PH policy, this study aimed to identify the evolution of public health ethics (PHE) frameworks and the main moral values and norms in PH practice and policy. According to the research questions, a systematic search of the literature, in English, with no time limit was performed using the main keywords in databases Web of Science (ISI) and PubMed. Finally, the full text of 56 papers was analyzed. Most of the frameworks have common underpinning assumptions and beliefs, and the need to balance PH moral obligation to prevent harm and health promotion with respect for individual autonomy has been specified. As such, a clear shift from liberal values in biomedical ethics is seen toward the community’s collective values in PHE. The main moral norms in PH practice and policy included protecting the population against harm and improving PH benefits, utility and evidenced-based effectiveness, distributive justice and fairness, respect for all, privacy and confidentiality, solidarity, social responsibility, community empowerment and participation, transparency, accountability and trust. Systematic review of PHE frameworks indicates utilization of the aforementioned moral norms through an practical framework as an ethical guide for action in the PH policy. The validity of this process requires a systematic approach including procedural conditions.

Keywords

Public heath Health policy Morals/ethics Justice 

References

  1. Abbasi, Mahmoud, Mehran Seif-Farshad, and Mehrzad Kiani. 2015. Moral Aspects of the Laws and Regulations Governing the Health System in Iran. Trends in Life Sciences 4 (3): 145–153.Google Scholar
  2. Ahola-Launonen, Johanna. 2015. The Evolving Idea of Social Responsibility in Bioethics. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 24 (02): 204–213.Google Scholar
  3. Akrami, Forouzan, Mahmoud Abbasi, Abbas Karimi, Reza Majdzadeh, Akbar Shahrivari, and Alireza Zali. 2017. Analyzing the Politico-Moral Foundations of the Iran Health System Based on the Theories of Justice. Journal of Medical Ethics and History of Medicine 10: 4.Google Scholar
  4. Annas, George J., and Wendy K. Mariner. 2016. (Public) Health and Human Rights in Practice. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 41 (1): 129–139.Google Scholar
  5. APHA. 2015. Policy Statement: Public Health Opportunities to Address the Health Effects of Climate Change. Policy Number: 20157. https://www.apha.org/policies-and-advocacy/public-health-policy-statements/policy-database/2015/12/03/15/34/public-health-opportunities-to-address-the-health-effects-of-climate-change. Accessed 03 Nov 2015.
  6. APHA. 2017. 2017 Theme—Creating the Healthiest Nation: Climate Changes Health. https://www.apha.org/events-and-meetings/annual/why-attend/annual-meeting-theme. Accessed 03 May 2017.
  7. Babu, Giridhara R., Sathyanarayana Tn, Anant Bhan, and J.K. Lakshmi, and Megha Kishore. 2014. An Appraisal of the Tuberculosis Programme in India Using an Ethics Framework. Indian Journal of Medical Ethics 11 (1): 11–15.Google Scholar
  8. Barnett, Daniel J, Holly A. Taylor, James G. Hodge Jr, and Jonathan M. Links. 2009. Resource Allocation on the Frontlines of Public Health Preparedness and Response: Report of a Summit on Legal and Ethical Issues. Public Health Reports 124: 295–303.Google Scholar
  9. Baum, Nancy M., Sarah E. Gollust, Susan D. Goold, and Peter D. Jacobson. 2007. Looking Ahead: Addressing Ethical Challenges in Public Health Practice. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE Publications Sage CA.Google Scholar
  10. Baylis, Françoise, Nuala P. Kenny, and Susan Sherwin. 2008. A Relational Account of Public Health Ethics. Public Health Ethics 1 (3): 196–209.Google Scholar
  11. Bernheim, Ruth Gaare, Phillip Nieburg, and Richard J. Bonnie. 2007. Ethics and the Practice of Public Health. In Law in Public Health Practice, ed. Goodman RA, 110–135. Oxford, NY: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  12. Bielecki, Andrzej, and Sylwia Nieszporska. 2016. The Proposal of Philosophical Basis of the Health Care System. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 20: 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-016-9717-2.Google Scholar
  13. Buchanan, David R. 2015. Promoting Justice and Autonomy in Public Policies to Reduce the Health Consequences of Obesity. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 25 (4): 395–417.Google Scholar
  14. Bull, Susan, Phaik Yeong Cheah, Spencer Denny, Irene Jao, Vicki Marsh, Laura Merson, Neena Shah More, David Osrin Le Nguyen Thanh Nhan, Decha Tangseefa, and Douglas Wassenaar. 2015. Best Practices for Ethical Sharing of Individual-Level Health Research Data from Low-and Middle-Income Settings. Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics 10 (3): 302–313.Google Scholar
  15. Carter, Stacy M., Lucie Rychetnik, Beverley Lloyd, Ian H. Kerridge, Louise Baur, Adrian Bauman, Claire Hooker, and Avigdor Zask. 2011. Evidence, Ethics, and Values: A Framework for Health Promotion. American Journal of Public Health 101 (3): 465–472.Google Scholar
  16. Chanda-Kapata, Pascalina, Nathan Kapata, Albertina Ngomah Moraes, Gershom Chongwe, and James Munthali. 2015. Genomic Research in Zambia: Confronting the Ethics, Policy and Regulatory Frontiers in the 21st Century. Health Research Policy and Systems 13 (1): 1.Google Scholar
  17. Childress, James F. 2015. Moral Considerations: Bases and Limits for Public Health Interventions. In Essentials of Public Health Ethics, eds. Ruth Gaare Bernheim, James F. Childress, Aalan L. Melnick, and Richard J. Bonnie, 21–43. Burlington: Jones & Bartlett Learning, LLC, an Ascend Learning Company.Google Scholar
  18. Childress, James F., and Ruth Gaare Bernheim. 2015. Introduction: A Framework for Public Health Ethics. In Essentials of Public Health Ethics, eds. Ruth Gaare Bernheim, James F. Childress, Aalan L. Melnick, and Richard J. Bonnie, 1–20. Burlington: Jones & Bartlett Publishers.Google Scholar
  19. Childress, James F, Ruth R. Faden, Ruth D. Gaare, Lawrence O. Gostin, Jeffrey Kahn, Richard J. Bonnie, Nancy E. Kass, Anna C. Mastroianni, Jonathan D. Moreno, and Phillip Nieburg. 2002b. Public Health Ethics: Mapping the Terrain. Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 30 (2): 170–178.Google Scholar
  20. Cockerham, William C. 2005. Health Lifestyle Theory and the Convergence of Agency and Structure. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 46 (1): 51–67.Google Scholar
  21. Coughlin, Steven S. 2008. How Many Principles for Public Health Ethics. Open Public Health Journal 1: 8–16.Google Scholar
  22. Daniels, Norman. 2000. Accountability for Reasonableness : Establishing a Fair Process for Priority Setting is Easier Than Agreeing on Principles. BMJ 321 (7272): 1300–1301.Google Scholar
  23. Daniels, N. 2008. Just Health: Meeting Health Needs Fairly. 1st Aufl. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  24. Daniels, Norman, and James Sabin. 1998. The Ethics of Accountability in Managed Care Reform. Health Affairs 17 (5): 50–64.Google Scholar
  25. Daniels, Norman, and James E. Sabin. 2008. Accountability for Reasonableness: An Update. BMJ: British Medical Journal 337: a1850Google Scholar
  26. Daniels, Norman, J. Bryant, R.A. Castano, O.G. Dantes, K.S. Khan, and S. Pannarunothai. 2000. Benchmarks of Fairness for Health Care Reform: A Policy Tool for Developing Countries. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 78 (6): 740–750.Google Scholar
  27. Faden, Ruth, and Sirine Shebaya. 2016. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Public Health Ethics. Stanford: Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University.Google Scholar
  28. Fox, Brion J. 2005. Framing Tobacco Control Efforts Within an Ethical Context. Tobacco Control 14 (Suppl 2): ii38–ii44.Google Scholar
  29. Glanz, Jason M., Courtney R. Kraus, and Matthew F. Daley. 2015. Addressing Parental Vaccine Concerns: Engagement, Balance, and timing. PLoS Biology 13 (8): e1002227.Google Scholar
  30. Greenhalgh, Trisha, and Richard Peacock. 2005. Effectiveness and Efficiency of Search Methods in Systematic Reviews of Complex Evidence: Audit of Primary Sources. BMJ 331 (7524): 1064–1065.Google Scholar
  31. Health Council of the Netherlands. 2007. The Future of the National Immunisation Programme: Towards a Programme for all Age Groups. The Hague: Health Council of the NetherlandsGoogle Scholar
  32. Herington, Jonathan, Angus Dawson, and Heather Draper. 2014. Obesity, Liberty, and Public Health Emergencies. Hastings Center Report 44 (6): 26–35.Google Scholar
  33. Hofrichter, R. 2003. Health and Social Justice: Politics, Ideology, and Inequity in the Distribution of Disease. San Francisco: Wiley.Google Scholar
  34. Institute of Medicine. 2003. The Future of the Public’s Health in the 21st Century. Washington: National Academy Press.Google Scholar
  35. Isaacs, David. 2012. An Ethical Framework for Public Health Immunisation Programs. New South Wales public health bulletin 23 (6): 111–115.Google Scholar
  36. Jaffe, Harold W., and Tony Hope. 2010. Treating for the Common Good: A Proposed Ethical Framework. Public Health Ethics 3 (3): 193–198.Google Scholar
  37. Jayasinghe, K.S.A., D. De Silva, N. Mendis, and R.K. Lie. 1998. Ethics of Resource Allocation in Developing Countries: The Case of Sri Lanka. Social Science and Medicine 47 (10): 1619–1625.Google Scholar
  38. Kapiriri, Lydia, Ole Frithjof Norheim, and Douglas K. Martin. 2007. Priority Setting at the Micro-, Meso-and Macro-Levels in Canada, Norway and Uganda. Health Policy 82 (1): 78–94.Google Scholar
  39. Kapiriri, Lydia, Ole F Norheim, and Douglas K. Martin. 2009. Fairness and Accountability for Reasonableness. Do the Views of Priority Setting Decision Makers Differ Across Health Systems and Levels of Decision Making? Social Science and Medicine 68 (4): 766–773.Google Scholar
  40. Karen, M., and B. A. Meagher. 2011. Considering Virtue: Public Health and Clinical Ethics. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 17 (5): 888–893.Google Scholar
  41. Kass, Nancy E. 2001. An Ethics Framework for Public Health. American Journal of Public Health 91 (11): 1776–1782.Google Scholar
  42. Kenny, Nuala P, Susan B. Sherwin, and Françoise E. Baylis. 2010. Re-Visioning Public Health Ethics: A Relational Perspective. Canadian Journal of Public Health/Revue Canadienne de Sante’e Publique 101: 9–11.Google Scholar
  43. Lee, Lisa M. 2017. A Bridge Back to the Future: Public Health Ethics, Bioethics, and Environmental Ethics. American Journal of Bioethics 17 (7): 5–12.Google Scholar
  44. Lee, Lisa M, Celia B. Fisher, and Bruce Jennings. 2016. Revising the American Public Health Association’s Public Health Code of Ethics. American Public Health Association 106: 1198–1199Google Scholar
  45. Levine, Mark A., Matthew K. Wynia, Paul M. Schyve, J. Russell Teagarden, David A. Fleming, Sharon King Donohue, Ron J. Anderson, James Sabin, and Ezekiel J. Emanuel. 2007. Improving Access to Health Care: A Consensus Ethical Framework to Guide Proposals for Reform. Hastings Center Report 37 (5): 14–19.Google Scholar
  46. MacDonald, Melanie. 1999. Resource Allocation in Integrated Delivery Systems and Healthcare Networks: A Proposed Framework to Guide Ethical Thinking.  Healthcare Management Forum 12 (4): 24–29.Google Scholar
  47. MacNaughton, Gillian. 2015. Human Rights Impact Assessment: A Method for Healthy Policymaking. Health and Human Rights Journal 17 (1): 63–75.Google Scholar
  48. Marckmann, Georg, Harald Schmidt, Neema Sofaer, and Daniel Strech. 2015. Putting Public Health Ethics into Practice: A Systematic Framework. Frontiers in Public Health 3: 23.Google Scholar
  49. Martin, Doug, and Peter Singer. 2003. A strategy to Improve Priority Setting in Health Care Institutions. Health Care Analysis 11 (1): 59–68.Google Scholar
  50. McGill, Natalie. 2015. APHA Section Creates Task Force to Revise Public Health Code of Ethics. The Nation’s Health 45 (8): 17–17.Google Scholar
  51. Menne, B., and R. Bertollini. 2005. Health and Climate Change: A Call for Action. BMJ 331 (7528): 1283–1284. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.38684.496354.DE.Google Scholar
  52. Nord, Erik. 1999. Cost-Value Analysis in Health Care: Making Sense Out of QALYs. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  53. Nuffield Council On Bioethics. 2007. Public Health: Ethical Issues. London, England: Nuffield Council.Google Scholar
  54. Petricca, Kadia, and Asfaw Bekele. 2017. Conceptualizations of Fairness and Legitimacy in the Context of Ethiopian Health Priority Setting: Reflections on the Applicability of Accountability for Reasonableness. Developing World Bioethics 00: 1–8.Google Scholar
  55. Petrini, Carlo. 2010. Theoretical Models and Operational Frameworks in Public Health Ethics. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 7 (1): 189–202. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph7010189.Google Scholar
  56. Petrini, Carlo, and Sabina Gainotti. 2008. A Personalist Approach to Public-Health Ethics. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 86 (8): 624–629.Google Scholar
  57. Petrini, Carlo, and Gualtiero Ricciardi. 2015. Ethical Issues in Public Health Surveillance: Drawing Inspiration from Ethical Frameworks. Annali dell’Istituto Superiore di Sanità 51 (4): 270–276.Google Scholar
  58. Powers, Madison, and Ruth R. Faden. 2006. Social Justice: The Moral Foundations of Public Health and Health Policy. 1st Aufl. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  59. Powers, Madison, and Ruth Faden, and Yashar Saghai. 2012. Liberty, Mill and the Framework of Public Health Ethics. Public Health Ethics 5 (1): 6–15.Google Scholar
  60. Prainsack, Barbara. 2013. Taking Solidarity Seriously—Can it Help? In Justice & Solidarity in Priority Setting in Healthcare. Brussels: Brussels Joint Initiative of the King Baudouin Foundation and the Belgian Advisory Committee on Bioethics.Google Scholar
  61. Prainsack, B., A. Buyx, and Nuffield Council on Bioethics Staff. 2011. Solidarity: Reflections on an Emerging Concept in Bioethics. London: Nuffield Council on Bioethics.Google Scholar
  62. Rajabi, Fateme, Hamid Esmailzadeh, Narges Rostamigooran, and Reza Majdzadeh. 2013. What must be the Pillars of Iran’s Health System in 2025? Values and Principles of Health System Reform Plan. Iranian Journal of Public Health 42 (2): 197.Google Scholar
  63. Resnik, David B. 2015. Food and Beverage Policies and Public Health Ethics. Health Care Analysis 23 (2): 122–133.Google Scholar
  64. Riiser, Kirsti, Knut Løndal, Yngvar Ommundsen, Nina Misvær, and Sølvi Helseth. 2015. Targeting and Tailoring an Intervention for Adolescents Who are Overweight Some Ethical Concerns. Nursing Ethics 22 (2): 237–247.Google Scholar
  65. Roberts, Marc J., and Michael R. Reich. 2002. Ethical Analysis in Public Health. Lancet 359 (9311): 1055–1059.Google Scholar
  66. Rogers, Wendy A. 2004. Virtue Ethics and Public Health: A Practice-Based Analysis. Monash Bioethics Review 23 (1): 10–21.Google Scholar
  67. Rozier, Michael D. 2016. Structures of Virtue as a Framework for Public Health Ethics. Public Health Ethics 9 (1): 37–45.Google Scholar
  68. Ruger, Jennifer Prah. 2008. Ethics in American Health 2: An Ethical Framework for Health System Reform. American Journal of Public Health 98 (10): 1756–1763. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2007.121350.Google Scholar
  69. Shickle, Darren. 2009. The Ethics of Public Health Practice: Balancing Private and Public Interest within Tobacco Policy. British Medical Bulletin 91: 7–22Google Scholar
  70. Shickle, Darren, Erica Richardson, Fiona Day, Christian Munthe, Albert Jovell, Heta Gylling, Rein Vos, Tuija Takala, Carlo Petrini, and Gaetano Torlone. 2006. Public Policies, Law and Bioethics: A Framework for Producing Public Health Policy Across the European Union. EuroPHEN: European Public Health Ethics Network. http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/100247/1/EuroPHENfullreport_libre.pdf  
  71. Stone, John R., and Groesbeck P. Parham. 2007. An Ethical Framework for Community Health Workers and Related Institutions. Family and Community Health 30 (4): 351–363.Google Scholar
  72. Strech, Daniel, and Neema Sofaer. 2011. How to Write a Systematic Review of Reasons. Journal of Medical Ethics. https://doi.org/10.1136/medethics-2011-100096.Google Scholar
  73. Swain, G. R., K. A. Burns, and P. Etkind. 2008. Preparedness: Medical Ethics Versus Public Health Ethics. Journal of Public Health Management and Practice 14 (4): 354–357. https://doi.org/10.1097/01.phh.0000324563.87780.67.Google Scholar
  74. Tannahill, Andrew. 2008. Beyond Evidence—to Ethics: A Decision-Making Framework For Health Promotion, Public Health And Health Improvement. Health Promotion International 23 (4): 380–390.Google Scholar
  75. Ten Have, Marieke, Agnes Van Der Heide, Johan P. Mackenbach, and Inez D. De Beaufort. 2013. An Ethical Framework for the Prevention of Overweight and Obesity: A Tool for Thinking Through a Programme’s Ethical Aspects. European Journal of Public Health 23 (2): 299–305.Google Scholar
  76. Thomas, James C., M. Sage, J. Dillenberg, and V.J. Guillory. 2002. A Code of Ethics for Public Health. American Journal of Public Health 92 (7): 1057–1059. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.92.7.1057.Google Scholar
  77. Thompson, Alison K., Karen Faith, Jennifer L Gibson, and Ross E.G. Upshur. 2006. Pandemic Influenza Preparedness: An Ethical Framework to Guide Decision-Making. BMC Medical Ethics 7 (1): 1.Google Scholar
  78. Tiong, Wei Wei, and Gerald C.H. Koh. 2013. Ethical Considerations in the Review of Singapore’s H1N1 Pandemic Response Framework in 2009. Annals of the Academy of Medicine, Singapore 42 (5): 246–250.Google Scholar
  79. Torda, Adrienne. 2006. Ethical Issues in Pandemic Planning. Medical Journal of Australia 185 (10): S73.Google Scholar
  80. Turoldo, Fabrizio. 2009. Responsibility as an Ethical Framework for Public Health Interventions. American Journal of Public Health 99 (7): 1197–1202.Google Scholar
  81. Upshur, Ross E.G. 2002. Principles for the Justification of Public Health Intervention. Canadian Journal of Public Health/Revue Canadienne de Sante’e Publique 93: 101–103.Google Scholar
  82. Verweij, Marcel F., and Hans Houweling. 2014. What is the Responsibility of National Government with Respect to Vaccination? Vaccine 32 (52): 7163–7166.Google Scholar
  83. Wang, Yan-Guang. 1997. Aids, Policy and Bioethics: Ethical Dilemmas Facing China in HIV Prevention. Bioethics 11 (3-4): 323–327.Google Scholar
  84. Wilcox, David. 1994. Community Participation and Empowerment: Putting Theory into Practice. London: RRA Notes.Google Scholar
  85. Wilding, Ethan T. 2012. Framing Ethical Acceptability: A Problem with Nuclear Waste in Canada. Science and Engineering Ethics 18 (2): 301–313.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V., part of Springer Nature 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  • Mahmoud Abbasi
    • 1
  • Reza Majdzadeh
    • 2
  • Alireza Zali
    • 3
  • Abbas Karimi
    • 4
  • Forouzan Akrami
    • 1
  1. 1.Medical Ethics and Law Research CenterShahid Beheshti University of Medical SciencesTehranIran
  2. 2.Community Based Participatory Research Center and Knowledge Utilization Research CenterTehran University of Medical SciencesTehranIran
  3. 3.Functional Neurosurgery Research Center, Shohada Tajrish Neurosurgical Center of ExcellenceShahid Beheshti University of Medical SciencesTehranIran
  4. 4.Faculty of Law and Political ScienceUniversity of TehranTehranIran

Personalised recommendations