Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy

, Volume 14, Issue 1, pp 19–27 | Cite as

The ethics of implementing human papillomavirus vaccination in developed countries

  • Erik Malmqvist
  • Gert Helgesson
  • Johannes Lehtinen
  • Kari Natunen
  • Matti Lehtinen
Scientific Contribution

Abstract

Human papillomavirus (HPV) infection is the world’s most common sexually transmitted infection. It is a prerequisite for cervical cancer, the second most common cause of death in cancer among women worldwide, and is also believed to cause other anogenital and head and neck cancers. Vaccines that protect against the most common cancer-causing HPV types have recently become available, and different countries have taken different approaches to implementing vaccination. This paper examines the ethics of alternative HPV vaccination strategies. It devotes particular attention to the major arguments for and against one strategy: voluntary, publicly funded vaccination for all adolescent boys and girls. This approach seems attractive because it would protect more people against cervical cancer and other HPV-related cancers than less inclusive alternatives, without the sacrifice of autonomy that a comparably broad compulsory programme would require. Also, the herd immunity that it would likely generate would protect those who remain unvaccinated, a major advantage from a justice perspective. However, there is a possibility that a HPV vaccination programme targeting all adolescents of both sexes is not considered sufficiently cost-effective. Also, it might pose more difficulties for achieving informed consent than comparable vaccination programmes against other diseases. Ultimately, society’s choice of HPV vaccination strategy requires careful consideration not only of the values at stake but also of available and emerging scientific evidence.

Keywords

Ethics Cervical cancer Herd immunity Human papillomavirus Vaccination 

References

  1. Agosti, J.M., and S.J. Goldie. 2007. Introducing HPV vaccine in developing countries–key challenges and issues. New England Journal of Medicine 356: 1908–1910.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  2. Arbyn, M., M. Rebolj, I.M.C.M. De Kok, M. Fender, N. Becker, M. O’Reilly, and B. Andrae. 2009. The challenges of organising cervical screening programs in the 15 old member states of the European Union. European Journal of Cancer 45: 2671–2678.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. Auvinen, E., M. Niemi, C. Malm, R. Zilliacus, A. Trontti, R. Fingerroos, M. Lehtinen, and J. Paavonen. 2005. High prevalence of HPV among female students in Finland. Scandinavian Journal of Infectious Diseases 37: 873–876.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. Balog, J.E. 2009. The moral justification for a compulsory human papillomavirus vaccination program. American Journal of Public Health 99: 616–622.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  5. Barnabas, R.V., P. Laukkanen, P. Koskela, O. Kontula, M. Lehtinen, and G.P. Garnett. 2006. Epidemiology of HPV 16 and cervical cancer in Finland and the potential impact of vaccination: Mathematical modeling analyses. PLoS Medicine 3: e138.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Bauch, C.T., M. Li, G. Chapman, and A.P. Galvani. 2009. Adherence to cervical screening in the era of human papillomavirus vaccination: How low is too low? Lancet Infectious Diseases 10: 133–137.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Beauchamp, T.L., and J. Childress. 2009. Principles of biomedical ethics, 6th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  8. Blower, S.M., and A.R. McLean. 1994. Prophylactic vaccines, risk behavior change, and the probability of eradicating HIV in San Fransisco. Science 265: 1451–1454.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  9. Brabin, L., S.A. Roberts, F. Farzaneh, and H.C. Kitchener. 2006. Future acceptance of adolescent human papillomavirus vaccination: A survey of parental attitudes. Vaccine 24: 3087–3094.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  10. Brabin, L., S.A. Roberts, R. Strech, D. Baxter, G. Chambers, H. Kitchener, and R. McCann. 2008. Uptake of first two doses of human papillomavirus vaccine by adolescent schoolgirls in Manchester: Prospective cohort study. British Medical Journal 336: 1056–1058.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  11. Bradley, P. 1999. Should childhood immunisation be compulsory? Journal of Medical Ethics 25: 330–334.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  12. Brewer, N.T., and K.I. Fazekas. 2007. Predictors of HPV vaccine acceptability: A theory-informed, systematic review. Preventive Medicine 45: 107–114.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Brown, D.R., S. Kjaer, K. Sigurdsson, et al. 2009. The impact of quadrivalent human papillomavirus (HPV; Types 6, 11, 16, 18) L1 virus-like particle vaccine on infection and disease due to oncogenic nonvaccine HPV types in generally HPV-naïve women aged 16–26 years. Journal of Infectious Diseases 199: 926–935.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  14. Colgrove, J. 2006. The ethics and politics of compulsory HPV vaccination. New England Journal of Medicine 355: 389–391.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Collins, S., S. Mazloomzadeh, H. Winter, P. Bloomfield, A. Bailey, L.S. Young, and C.B. Woodman. 2002. High incidence of cervical human papillomavirus infection in women during their first sexual relationship. BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 109: 96–98.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Dempsey, A.F., G.D. Zimet, R.L. Davis, and L. Koutsky. 2006. Factors that are associated with parental acceptance of human papillomavirus vaccines: A randomized intervention study of written information about HPV. Pediatrics 117: 1486–1493.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  17. EMA (European Medicines Agency). 2009. Human medicines—Cervarix. Available: http://www.emea.europa.eu/humandocs/Humans/EPAR/cervarix/cervarix.htm. Accessed 23 Aug 2010.
  18. EMA (European Medicines Agency). 2010. Gardasil. Available: http://www.emea.europa.eu/humandocs/Humans/EPAR/gardasil/gardasil.htm. Accessed 23 Aug 2010.
  19. Faden, R.R., and T.L. Beauchamp. 1986. A history and theory of informed consent. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  20. Feinberg, J. 1987. The moral limits of the criminal law. Vol. 1: Harm to others. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. French, K.M., R. Barnabas, M. Lehtinen, O. Kontula, E. Pukkala, J. Dillner, and G.P. Garnett. 2007. Strategies for the introduction of human papillomavirus vaccination: Modelling the optimum age- and sex-specific pattern of vaccination in Finland. British Journal of Cancer 96: 514–518.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  22. FUTURE II Study Group. 2007. Quadrivalent vaccine against human papillomavirus to prevent high-grade cervical lesions. New England Journal of Medicine 365: 1915–1927.Google Scholar
  23. Garnett, G.P. 2005. Role of herd immunity in determining the effect of vaccines against sexually transmitted disease. Journal of Infectious Diseases 191(Suppl. 1): S97–S106.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  24. Hoover, D.R., B. Carfioli, and E.A. Moench. 2000. Attitudes of adolescent/young adult women toward human papillomavirus vaccination and clinical trials. Health Care for Women International 21: 375–391.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  25. Insinga, R.P., E.J. Dasbach, and F.H. Elbasha. 2008. Structural differences among cost-effectiveness models of human papillomavirus. Expert Review of Vaccines 7: 895–913.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  26. Isaacs, D., H.A. Kilham, and H. Marshall. 2004. Should routine childhood immunizations be compulsory? Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health 40: 392–396.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  27. Isaacs, D., H. Kilham, J. Leask, and B. Tobin. 2009. Ethical issues in immunisation. Vaccine 27: 615–618.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  28. Jakobsson, M., M. Gissler, J. Paavonen, and A.M. Tapper. 2009. Loop electrosurgical excision procedure and the risk of preterm birth. Obstetrics and Gynecology 114: 505–510.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Javitt, G., D. Berkowitz, and L.O. Gostin. 2008. Assessing mandatory HPV vaccination: Who should call the shots? Journal of Law Medicine & Ethics 30: 384–395.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Kass, N.E. 2001. An ethics framework for public health. American Journal of Public Health 91: 1776–1782.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  31. Kjaer, S., C. Munk, J.F. Winther, H.O. Jorgensen, C.J. Meijer, and A.J. van den Brule. 2005. Acquisition and persistence of human papillomavirus infection in younger men: A prospective follow-up study among Danish men. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention 6: 1528–1533.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Kulasingam, S.H. 2007. Implementation of an HPV-vaccination program. Disease Management & Health Outcomes 15: 141–149.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Lehtinen, M., K. French, J. Dillner, J. Paavonen, and G. Garnett. 2008. Sound implementation of HPV vaccination. Future Medicine (Therapy) 5: 289–294.Google Scholar
  34. Lenselink, C.H., M.M.J.G. Gerrits, W.J.G. Melchers, L.F.A.G. Massuger, D. van Hamonta, and R.L.M. Bekkers. 2008. Parental acceptance of Human papillomavirus vaccines. European Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology and Reproductive Biology 137: 103–107.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  35. Lo, B. 2006. HPV vaccine and adolescents’ sexual activity. British Medical Journal 332: 1106–1107.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  36. Marra, F., K. Cloutier, B. Oteng, C. Marra, and G. Ogilvie. 2009. Effectiveness and cost effectiveness of human papillomavirus vaccine: A systematic review. Pharmacoeconomics 27: 127–147.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  37. Näsman, A., P. Attner, L. Hammarstedt, J. Du, M. Eriksson, G. Giraud, S. Ahrlund-Richter, L. Marklund, M. Romanitan, D. Lindquist, T. Ramqvist, J. Lindholm, P. Sparén, W. Ye, H. Dahlstrand, E. Munck-Wikland, and T. Dalianis. 2009. Incidence of human papillomavirus (HPV) positive tonsillar carcinoma in Stockholm, Sweden: An epidemic of viral-induced carcinoma? International Journal of Cancer 125: 362–366.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Ogilvie, G.S., V.P. Remple, F. Marra, S.A. McNeil, M. Naus, K.L. Pielak, T.G. Ehlen, S.R. Dobson, D.M. Money, and D.M. Patrick. 2007. Parental intention to have daughters receive the human papillomavirus vaccine. Canadian Medical Association Journal 177: 1506–1512.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  39. Paavonen, J., and the HPV PATRICIA Study Group. 2009. Efficacy of human papillomavirus (HPV)-16/18 AS04-adjuvanted vaccine against cervical infection and precancer caused by oncogenic HPV types (PATRICIA): Final analysis of a double-blind, randomised study in young women. Lancet 374: 310–314.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Parkin, D.M. 2006. The global health burden of infection-associated cancers in the year 2002. International Journal of Cancer 118: 3030–3044.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Rawls, J. 1971. A theory of justice. Cambridge, Mass: Belknap.Google Scholar
  42. Regan, D.G., D.J. Philip, J.S. Hocking, and M.G. Law. 2007. Modelling the population-level impact of vaccination on the transmission of human papillomavirus type 16 in Australia. Sexual Health 4: 147–163.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  43. Ross, L.F. 2002. Adolescent autonomy in health care? APA Newsletter: Philosophy and Medicine 2: 193–200.Google Scholar
  44. Taira, A.V., P. Neukermans, and G.D. Sanders. 2004. Evaluating human papillomavirus vaccination programs. Emerging Infectious Diseases 10: 1915–1923.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  45. Trottier, H., and A.N. Burchell. 2009. Epidemiology of mucosal human papillomavirus infection and associated diseases. Public Health Genomics 12: 291–307.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  46. WHO (World Health Organization). 2010. Viral cancer. Human papillomavirus. Available: http://www.who.int/vaccine_research/diseases/viral_cancers/en/index3.html. Accessed 04 Feb 2010.
  47. Winer, R.L., J.P. Hughes, Q. Feng, S. O’Reilly, N.B. Kiviat, K.K. Holmes, and L.A. Koutsky. 2006. Condom use and the risk of genital human papillomavirus infection in young women. New England Journal of Medicine 354: 2645–2654.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  48. Woodhall, S., M. Lehtinen, T. Verho, H. Huhtala, M. Hokkanen, and E. Kosunen. 2007. Anticipated acceptance of HPV vaccination at the baseline of implementation: A survey of parental and adolescent knowledge and attitudes in Finland. Journal of Adolescent Health 40: 466–469.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  49. Zimmerman, R.K. 2006. Ethical analysis of HPV vaccine policy options. Vaccine 24: 4112–4120.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  • Erik Malmqvist
    • 1
  • Gert Helgesson
    • 2
  • Johannes Lehtinen
    • 3
  • Kari Natunen
    • 3
  • Matti Lehtinen
    • 3
    • 4
  1. 1.Centre for Research on Meaning, Ethics and Society (CERSES)Université Paris DescartesParis Cedex 06France
  2. 2.Stockholm Centre for Healthcare Ethics, LIME, Karolinska InstitutetStockholmSweden
  3. 3.University of TampereTampereFinland
  4. 4.National Institute for Health and WelfareHelsinkiFinland

Personalised recommendations