To be rational, or not to be rational—that is the question
In this highly enjoyable, carefully argued, thought-provoking book, Michael Tye invites us to consider the difficult question of how widespread consciousness is in nature. Despite its circumscribed title, Tense Bees and Shell-Shocked Crabs: Are Animals Conscious? is not just a book about animal consciousness. It is a book about consciousness in general and, more specifically, under what circumstances we can be justified in attributing it to different entities—be they human or nonhuman, natural or artificial, similar to us or radically different from us. It is also a book on what animal consciousness means from an ethical perspective, although the reflections on this topic unfortunately leave a lot to be desired, as we shall see.
In Chapter 1, Tense Bees and Shell-shocked Crabskicks off with an explanation of why consciousness cannot be defined in purely objective terms, and how any definition of a given experience will necessarily leave out the subjective “felt” quality, which one...
I would like to thank Judith Benz-Schwarzburg, Samuel Camenzind, and Annika Huber for their comments on a previous draft of this review.
- Paul, Steven M., et al. 2010. How to improve R&D productivity: the pharmaceutical industry’s grand challenge. Nature Reviews Drug Discovery 9 (3): 203–214.Google Scholar
- Singer, Peter. 2009. Animal liberation: the definitive classic of the animal movement, Reissue ed. New York: Harper Perennial Modern Classics.Google Scholar