Liverpool Law Review

, 32:65 | Cite as

Abolishing Some More Obsolete Crown Prerogatives

  • Graham McBain


The Crown had many prerogatives (privileges) which other legal and natural persons did not have, due to the pre-eminent role of the sovereign. Some of these the Crown delegated to its subjects. That is, it franchised them, in return for money. In modern times—with the sovereign only having a formal role—it needs to be considered whether these Crown prerogatives should pass to the control of Parliament. Also, where they are obsolete, their abolition. A previous article has argued for the abolition of many obsolete prerogatives relating to the military. This article argues that the prerogatives of the Crown to levy pontage (a toll for the building, and repair, of bridges) and murage (a toll for the building, and repair, of town and city walls for defensive purposes) should be abolished. So too, the right of the Crown to waifs (stolen goods cast away by a thief in flight) and estrays (animals wandering in any manor or lordship whose owner is unknown). Also, that the prerogative of the Crown to unmarked mute swans in open water be restricted to the Thames—where it is only presently exercised. Finally, this article argues for the abolition of the palatinates of Lancaster, Chester and Durham—since the prerogatives once given to them by the Crown have now reverted to the same—and for the abolition of various long obsolete prerogatives given to the Cinque Ports.


Crown prerogatives Tolls for pontage and murage Waifs and estrays Swans The counties Palatine The Cinque ports 


  1. Allen, J. 1849. Inquiry into the rise and growth of the royal prerogative in England. London: Longmans.Google Scholar
  2. Anon. 1765. The Laws and Customs, Rights, Liberties, and Privileges of the City of London. Google Scholar
  3. Anson, W.R. 1935. The law and custom of the constitution, 4th ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  4. Bacon, M. 1798. New Abridgment of the Law. 5th edn, ed. Gwillim H. London.Google Scholar
  5. Ballard, A. 1913. British borough charters 1042–1216. Cambridge: The University Press.Google Scholar
  6. Ballard, A., and J. Tait. 1923. British borough charters 1216–1307. Cambridge UP: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  7. Barendt, E. 1998. An introduction to constitutional law. Oxford: OUP.Google Scholar
  8. Birch, W. 1884. The historical charters and constitutional documents of the city of London. Whiting.Google Scholar
  9. Blackstone, W. 1979. Commentaries on the laws of England, 1st ed, 1765–1769. Oxford: Clarendon Press. University of Chicago Press, rep 1979.Google Scholar
  10. Bohun, W. 1723. Privilegia Londini or the rights, liberties and privileges, laws and customs of the city of London. 3rd edn. Ed. Browne D. etc. London.Google Scholar
  11. Bracton (trans Thorne, S.). 1240. On the law and customs of England c. Cambridge (1968–1976).Google Scholar
  12. Bradley, A.W., and K.D. Ewing. 2006. Constitutional and administrative law, 14th ed. London: Longman.Google Scholar
  13. Brecknock, T. 1764. Droit Le Roy. London.Google Scholar
  14. Britton, c. 1290. (trans FM Nichols, 1901) John Byrne and Co, London.Google Scholar
  15. Brooke, R. 1586. La Graunde Abridgment. London: Tottell.Google Scholar
  16. Brougham, H. 1861. The British constitution. London: Griffin Bohn & Co.Google Scholar
  17. Burrows, M. 1888. The Cinque ports. London: Longmans.Google Scholar
  18. Chitty Jun, J. 1820. A treatise of the law of the prerogatives of the crown, 118–119. London: Butterworths.Google Scholar
  19. Coke, E. 1824. Institutes of the laws of England. London: W. Clarke & Sons.Google Scholar
  20. Comyns, J. 1822. Digest of the laws of England. Ed. Hammond A.Google Scholar
  21. Cooper, A. 2006. Bridges, law and power in medieval England 700–1400. NY, USA: Boydell Press.Google Scholar
  22. Crieghton, O. 2007. Town defences and the making of urban landscapes. In Medieval landscapes, ed. M. Gardiner, and S. Rippon. UK: Windgather Press.Google Scholar
  23. Dalton, M. 1619. The countrey justice. London: Society of Stationers.Google Scholar
  24. de Haas, E. and Hall, G.D.G. 1970. Early register of writs, Selden Society, vol 87.Google Scholar
  25. De Smith, S.A., and R. Brazier. 1998. Constitutional and administrative law, 8th ed. London: Penguin.Google Scholar
  26. DNB. 2004. Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Google Scholar
  27. Downer, L.J. 1972. Leges Henrici Primi. Clarendon Press: Oxford.Google Scholar
  28. Finch, H. 1759. Law or a discourse thereof. Savoy: H Lintott.Google Scholar
  29. Fitzherbert, A. 1793. New Natura Brevium (last ed).Google Scholar
  30. Fitzherbert, A. 1577. La Graunde Abridgment. Ed. Tottell, 3rd edn. London.Google Scholar
  31. Fleta, c. 1290. Selden Society, vol 72.Google Scholar
  32. Fordyce, W. 1857. History and antiquities of the county Palatine of Durham. vol 2.Google Scholar
  33. Fraser, C.M. 1956. Edward I of England and the Regalian franchise of Durham. Speculum 31: 329–342.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Given-Wilson, C. 2005. Parliament Rolls (Rotuli Parliamentorum) now on CD (Scholarly Digital Editions. 2005.
  35. Goebel, J. 1976. Felony and misdemeanor. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania PressGoogle Scholar
  36. Green, I. 1984. The book of the Cinque ports. UK: Barracuda Books.Google Scholar
  37. Gunning, A. 1833. Practical treatise on the law of tolls. London: Saunders & Benning.Google Scholar
  38. Hale, M. 1736. Pleas of the crown.Google Scholar
  39. Hallam, H. 1897. Constitutional history of England. London: J Murray.Google Scholar
  40. Halsbury. 1994. Laws of England., 5th ed.Google Scholar
  41. Hardy, W. 1845. The charters of the Duchy of Lancaster. London.Google Scholar
  42. Hawkins, W. 1739. A treatise on the pleas of the crown, 3rd ed. London: E & R Nutt & R Gosling.Google Scholar
  43. Holdsworth, W. 2009. A history of english law. London: Sweet & Maxwell.Google Scholar
  44. Hueffer, M., and W. Hyde. 1930. The cinque ports. Edinburgh: Blackwood.Google Scholar
  45. Hughes, W. 1660. Grand abridgment of the law. Ed. Henry Twyford et al., London.Google Scholar
  46. Jacob, G. 1732. City liberties; or the rights and privileges of freeman.Google Scholar
  47. Jeake, S. 1728. Charters of the Cinque Ports, two ancient towns and their members. London: B Lintot.Google Scholar
  48. Jennings, I. 1959. The law and the constitution, 5th ed. London: University of London Press.Google Scholar
  49. Jolliffe, J.E.A. 1948. Constitutional history of medieval England, 2nd ed. London: A & C Black.Google Scholar
  50. Jones, J.B. 1937. The Cinque Ports. Their history and present condition, 2nd ed. USA: Dover Express.Google Scholar
  51. Jusserand, J.J. 1897. English wayfaring life in the middle ages. London: Fisher Unwin.Google Scholar
  52. Keir, D.L., and F.H. Lawson. 1979. Cases in constitutional law, 6th ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  53. King, P.W. 2007. Medieval turnpikes. Journal of Railway and Canal Historical Research 35: 10.Google Scholar
  54. Kitchin, J. 1653. Jurisdictions or the lawful authority of courts leets etc. 2nd edn. Ed. Walbancke M. London.Google Scholar
  55. Lapsley, G.T. 1900. The County Palatine of Durham: A Study in Constitutional History. Harvard Historical Studies, vol 8.Google Scholar
  56. Le Sueur, and M. Sunkin. 1997. Public law. London: Longman.Google Scholar
  57. Lilley, J. 1765. Practical register. 2nd edn.Google Scholar
  58. Lyon, J. 1813. History of Dover with a short account of the Cinque Ports (1813–14). Google Scholar
  59. Maitland, F.W. 1963. The constitutional history of England. England: CUP.Google Scholar
  60. Marshall, G. 1971. Constitutional theory. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  61. Maxwell, W.H. 1955. A legal bibliography of the British commonwealth of nations. Sweet and Maxwell. 2nd edn, 2 vols.Google Scholar
  62. McBain, G.S. 2010. Modernising the monarchy in legal terms. King’s LJ 21: 529–560.Google Scholar
  63. McBain, G.S. 2011a. Abolishing obsolete crown prerogatives relating to the military. vol 20, 14–37. Nottingham LJ.Google Scholar
  64. McBain, G.S. 2011b. Modernising the monarchy in legal terms: part 2. King’s LJ 22: 95–118.Google Scholar
  65. McKechnie, W.S. 1914. Magna Carta. Glasgow: Macleshose & Sons.Google Scholar
  66. Murray, K.M.E. 1935. Constitutional history of the Cinque Ports. Manchester.Google Scholar
  67. Nelson, W. 1725a. Abridgment of the common law. London: E & R Gosling.Google Scholar
  68. Nelson, W. 1725b. Lex maneriorum. London: E & R Nutt & R Gosling.Google Scholar
  69. Palmer, N. 2009. Palmer on Bailment, 3rd ed. London: Sweet & Maxwell.Google Scholar
  70. Phillips, O.H., and P. Jackson. 2001. Constitutional and administrative law, 8th ed. London: Sweet & Maxwell.Google Scholar
  71. Pierce, P. 2001. Old London Bridge. Headline.Google Scholar
  72. Pollock, F., and F.W. Maitland. 1984. The history of english law, 2nd ed. London: Cambridge UP.Google Scholar
  73. Pulling, A. 1842. The laws, customs, usages and regulations of the city and port of London, 2nd ed. London: WH Bond.Google Scholar
  74. Riley, T. 1868. Memorials of London and London life. London: Longmans.Google Scholar
  75. Robertson, C.G. 1935. Select statutes cases and documents. 7th edn.Google Scholar
  76. Rolle, H. 1668. Abridgment des plusieurs cases et resolutions del common ley. Ed. Crooke, A. et al.Google Scholar
  77. Russell, J. 1809. Ancient liberties and privileges of the Cinque Ports and ancient towns.Google Scholar
  78. Salzman, L.F. 1935. A history of the county of sussex. Ed. Salzman, L.F.Google Scholar
  79. Scammell, J. 1966. The origins and limitations of the liberty of Durham. English Historical Review 81(320): 449–473.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Sharpe, R.R. 1901. Calendar of Letter Books of the City of London. London.Google Scholar
  81. Sheppard, W. 1759. Grand abridgment of the common and statute law of England. Ed. George Sawbridge et al., London.Google Scholar
  82. Statham, N. 1490. Abridgment of the Law. London: Pynson.Google Scholar
  83. Staunford, W. 1557. Pleas of the crown. (Law Book Exchange, Reprint).Google Scholar
  84. Staunford, W. 1607. An exposition of the king’s prerogative, 2nd ed. London: Company of Stationers.Google Scholar
  85. Stephen, H.J. 1841. New commentaries on the laws of England. London: Butterworth.Google Scholar
  86. Stow, J. 1603. A survay of London. London: Dent. Rep 1965.Google Scholar
  87. Stubbs, W. 1874. Constitutional history of England, 1st ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  88. Sunkin, and Payne. 1999. The nature of the crown. Oxford: OUP.Google Scholar
  89. Taswell-Langmead, P. 1960. English constitutional history, 11th ed. London: Sweet & Maxwell.Google Scholar
  90. Thomas, H. 1852. The vale royal of England (pub Morten, E.J. 1976 from 1852 ed).Google Scholar
  91. Thomson, M.A. 1938. Constitutional history of England. London: Methuen.Google Scholar
  92. Viner, E. 1741. A general abridgment of the law and equity, 1st ed. London: GCJ & J Robinson.Google Scholar
  93. Walker, D.M. 1980. The Oxford companion to law. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  94. Weinbaum, M. 1943. British borough charters 1307–1660. Cambridge: Cambridge UP.Google Scholar
  95. Welch, C. 1909. History of the worshipful company of Paviors. London: Worshipful Company of Paviors.Google Scholar
  96. Wilkinson, B. 1958. Constitutional history of medieval England. London: Longmans.Google Scholar
  97. Witherings, J. 1664. Rules, laws and ancient customs of swans, 2nd ed. London: Printed in the Harleian Miscellany of Edward Harley, Earl of Oxford.Google Scholar
  98. Woolrych, H.W. 1829. A treatise on the law of ways, including highways, turnpike roads and tolls, private rights of way, bridges and ferries. London: Saunders & Benning.Google Scholar
  99. Yale, D.E.C. (ed.). 1976. Sir Matthew Hale’s prerogatives of the king, vol. 92. London: Selden Society.Google Scholar
  100. Yates, J.B. 1854. Rights and jurisdiction of the county palatine of Chester. Manchester: Cheetham Society.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.LLB CambridgeCambridgeUK
  2. 2.LLM HarvardCambridgeUSA

Personalised recommendations