Commentary: Alignment of time scales and joint models
- 12 Downloads
Some may have an impression that survival analysis is a mature field in which models and methods are well developed. The thought-provoking paper by Dempsey and McCullagh challenges our conventional thinking on how survival and health outcomes data shall be analyzed. I congratulate the authors for publishing this intriguing piece of work. In the following, I would like to offer discussions on some of their interesting findings, as well as my observations and thoughts on this important and interesting topic.
Two processes or just one?
The authors devoted a considerable amount of effort to explain that when death is an absorbing state of the health process, then the time to death is a deterministic function of the process. Therefore, it is more natural to consider the health process and time to death as a single process instead of two separate, but correlated, processes. This is certainly an interesting point of view and one that is unarguable when the health process is brain electrical...
I would like to thank Prof. Niels Keiding for inviting me to be a discussant of Prof. McCullagh’s talk at 2017 Conference on Lifetime Data Science, and subsequently invited me to be part of this discussion. My research is partially supported by the US National Institutes of Health and National Science Foundation.
- Dempsey W, McCullagh P (2018) Survival models and health sequences. Lifetime Data Anal. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10985-018-9424-9