Spatial and non-spatial factors: When do they affect landscape indicators of watershed loading? Research article Received: 19 December 2003 Accepted: 16 August 2004 DOI:
Cite this article as: Gergel, S. Landscape Ecol (2005) 20: 177. doi:10.1007/s10980-004-2263-y Abstract
The percentage of a watershed occupied by agricultural areas is widely used to predict nutrient loadings and in-stream water chemistry because water quality is often linked to non-point sources in a watershed. Measures of the spatial location of source areas have generally not been incorporated into such landscape indicators although empirical evidence and watershed loading models suggest that spatially explicit information is useful for predicting loadings. I created a heuristic grid-based surface-flow model to address the discrepancies between spatially explicit and non-spatial approaches to understanding watershed loading. The mean and variance in loading were compared among thousands of simulated watersheds with varying percentages of randomly located source and sinks. The variability in loading among replicate landscapes was greatest for those landscapes with ~65% source areas. This variance peak suggests that considering the spatial arrangement of cover types is most important for watersheds with intermediate relative abundances of sources and sinks as the wide variety of different spatial configurations can lead to either very high or very low loading. Increasing the output from source pixels (relative to the amount absorbed by sink pixels) among different landscapes moved the peak in variance to landscapes with lower percentages of sources. A final scenario examined both broad- and fine-scale heterogeneity in source output to disentangle the relative contributions of spatial configuration, percentage of source covers, and heterogeneity of sources in governing variability in loading. In landscapes with high percentages of source pixels, fine-scale heterogeneity in source output was responsible for a greater portion of the total variability in loading among different watersheds than was spatial arrangement. These results provide several testable hypotheses for when spatial and non-spatial approaches might be most useful in relating land cover to water chemistry and suggest improvements for the spatial sensitivity analyses of eco-hydrologic watershed models.
Keywords Landscape metrics Land use Monitoring Neutral landscape models Non-point source pollution Nutrient loading model Percolation theory Random maps Spatial models Spatial sensitivity analysis Water chemistry References Alexander, R.B., Johnes, P.J., Boyer, E.W., Smith, R.A. 2002 A comparison of models for estimating the riverine export of nitrogen from large watersheds Biogeochemistry 57 295 339 Google Scholar Band, L.E., Tague, C.L., Groffman, P., Belt, K. 2001 Forest ecosystem processes at the watershed scale: hydrological and ecological controls of nitrogen export Hydrological Processes 15 2013 2028 Google Scholar
Boyer E.W., Goodale C.L. Jaworsk N.A. et al. 2002. Nitrogen sources and relationships to riverine nitrogen export in the northeastern USA. Biogeochemistry 57(1): 137–169.
Google Scholar Correll, D.L. 1991 Human impact on the functioning of landscape boundaries Holland, M.M. Risser, P.J. Naiman, R.J. eds. The Role of Landscape Boundaries in the Management and Restoration of Changing Environments Chapman & Hall New York 90 109 Google Scholar Cahn, M.D., Hummel, J.W., Brouer, B.H. 1994 Spatial analysis of soil fertility for site-specific crop management Soil Science Society of America Journal 58 1240 1248 Google Scholar
Carpenter S.R., Caraco N.R., Correll D.L., Howarth R.H., Sharpley A.N. and Smith V.H. 1998. Issues in Ecology No. 3, Nonpoint pollution of surface waters with phosphorus and nitrogen. Ecological Society of America.
Cambardella, C.A., Moorman, T.B., Novak, J.M., Parkin, T.B., Karlen, D.L., Turco, R.F., Konopka, A.E. 1994 Field-scale variability of soil properties in Central Iowa soils Soil Science Society of America Journal 58 1501 1511 Google Scholar Cresser, M.S., Smart, R., Billett, M.F., Soulsby, G., Neal, C., Wade, A., Langan, S., Edwards, A.C. 2000 Modelling water chemistry for a major Scottish river from catchment attributes Journal of Applied Ecology 37 171 184 Google Scholar Delgado, J.A., Mosier, A.R., Valentine, D.W., Schimel, D.S., Parton, W.J. 1996 Long term N-15 studies in a catena of the shortgrass steppe Biogeochemistry 32 41 52 Google Scholar Delgado, J.A. 2002 Quantifying the loss mechanisms of nitrogen Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 57 389 398 Google Scholar Fisher, P., Abrahart, R.J., Herbinger, W. 1997 The sensitivity of two distributed non-point source pollution models to the spatial arrangement of the landscape Hydrological Processes 11 241 252 Google Scholar Gergel, S.E., Turner, M.G., Miller, J.R., Stanley, E.H., Melack, J.M. 2002 Landscape indicators of human impacts to riverine systems Aquatic Sciences 64 118 128 Google Scholar Gergel, S.E., Turner, M.G., Kratz, T.K. 1999 Scale-dependent landscape effects on north temperate lakes and rivers Ecological Applications 9 1377 1390 Google Scholar Griffith, J.A. 2002 Geographic techniques and recent applications of remote sensing to landscape-water quality studies Water Air and Soil Pollution 138 181 197 Google Scholar Groffman, P.M., Hanson, G.C. 1997 Wetland denitrification: influence of site quality and relationships with wetland delineation protocols Soil Science Society of America Journal 61 323 329 Google Scholar Hanrahan, G., Gledhill, M., House, W.A., Worsfold, P.J. 2001 Phosphorus loading in the Frone CatchmentUK: seasonal refinement of the coefficient modeling approach Journal of Environmental Quality 30 1738 1746 PubMed Google Scholar Harding, J.S., Benfield, E.F., Bolstad, P.V., Helfman, G.S., Jones, E.B.D. 1998 Stream biodiversity: the ghost of land use past Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 95 14834 14847 Google Scholar Herlihy, A.T., Stoddard, J.L., Johnson, C.B. 1998 The relationship between stream chemistry and watershed level land cover data in the mid-atlantic region, US Water Air and Soil Pollution 105 377 386 Google Scholar Hill, A.R., Devito, K.J., Campagnolo, S., Sanmugadas, K. 2000 Subsurface denitrification in a forest riparian zone: interactions between hydrology and supplies of nitrate and organic carbon Biogeochemistry 51 193 223 Google Scholar Hornberger, G.M., Raffensperger, J.P., Wiberg, P.L., Eshleman, K.N. 1998Elements of Physical Hydrology Johns Hopkins University Press Baltimore 302 Google Scholar Jetten, V., Govers, G., Hessel, R. 2003 Erosion models: quality of spatial predictions Hydrological Processes 17 887 900 Google Scholar Johnes, P.J. 1996 Evaluation and management of the impact of land use change on the nitrogen and phosphorus load delivered to surface waters: the export coefficient modeling approach Journal of Hydrology 183 249 323 Google Scholar Johnes, P.J., Moss, B., Phillips, G. 1996 The determination of total nitrogen and total phosphorous concentrations in freshwaters from land usestock headage and population data: testing a model for use in conservation and water quality management Freshwater Biology 36 451 473 Google Scholar Johnson, L.B., Richards, C., Host, G.E., Arthur, J.W. 1997 Landscape influence on water chemistry in Midwestern stream ecosystems Freshwater Biology 37 193 218 Google Scholar Jones, K.B., Neale, A.C., Nash, M.S., Riitters, K.H., Wickham, J.D., O’Neill, R.V., van Remortel, R.D. 2000a Landscape correlates of breeding bird richness across the United States mid-Atlantic region Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 63 159 174 Google Scholar Jones, K.B., Heggem, D.T., Wade, T.G., Neale, A.C., Ebert, D.W., Nash, M.S., Mehaffey, M.H., Hermann, K.A., Selle, A.R., Augustine, S., Goodman, I.A., Pedersen, J., Bolgrien, D., Viger, J.M., Chiang, D., Lin, C.J., Zhong, Y.H., Baker, J., van Remortel, R.D. 2000b Assessing landscape condition relative to water resources in the western United States: a strategic approach Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 64 227 245 Google Scholar Jones, K.B., Neale, A.C., Nash, M.S., Van Remortel, R.D., Wickham, J.D., Riitters, K.H., Oȁ9Neill, R.V. 2001 Predicting nutrient and sediment loadings to streams from landscape metrics: a multiple watershed study from the United States Mid-Atlantic region Landscape Ecology 16 301 312 Google Scholar Jordan, T.E., Correll, D.L., Weller, D.E. 1997 Relating nutrient discharges from watersheds to land use and streamflow variability Water Resources Research 33 2579 2590 Google Scholar
Kelling K.A., Bundy L.G., Combs S.M. and Peters J.B. 1998. 973 Soil Test Recommendations for Field, Vegetable and Fruit 974 Crops. University of Wisconsin, Cooperative Extension Ser-975 vice Bulletin A2809.
Klein, R.D. 1979 Urbanization and stream quality impairment Water Resources Bulletin 15 948 963 Google Scholar Khosla, R., Fleming, K., Delgado, J.A., Shaver, T.M., Westfall, D.G. 2002 Use of site-specific management zones to improve nitrogen management for precision agriculture Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 57 513 518 Google Scholar Lee, K.Y., Fisher, T.R., Jordan, T.E., Correll, D.L., Weller, D.E. 2000 Modeling the hydrochemistry of the Choptank River Basin using GWLF and Arc/Info: 1. Model calibration and validation Biogeochemistry 49 143 173 Google Scholar Lowrance, R. 1992 Groundwater nitrate and denitrification in a coastal plain riparian forest Journal of Environmental Quality 21 401 405 Google Scholar Lowrance, R., Todd, R., Fail, J., Jr., Hendrickson, O., Jr., Leonard, R. 1984 Riparian forests as nutrient filters in agricultural watersheds BioScience 34 374 377 Google Scholar Ludwig, J.A., Eager, R.W., Bastin, G.N., Chewings, V.H., Liedloff, A.C. 2002 A leakiness index for assessing landscape function using remote sensing Landscape Ecology 17 157 171 Google Scholar Mattikalli, N.M., Richards, K.S. 1996 Estimation of surface water quality changes in response to lands use change: application of the export coefficient model using remote sensing and geographical information system Journal of Environmental Management 48 263 282 Google Scholar McClain, M.E., Boyer, E.W., Dent, C.L., Gergel, S.E., Grimm, N.B., Groffman, P.M., Hart, S.C., Harvey, J.W., Johnston, C.A., Mayorga, E., McDowell, W.H., Pinay, G. 2003 Biogeochemical hot spots and hot moments at the interface of aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems Ecosystems 6 301 312 Google Scholar Mosier, A.R., Parton, W.J., Valentine, D.W., Ojima, D.S., Schimel, D.S., Delgado, J.A. 1996 CH 4N 2O fluxes in the Colorado shortgrass steppe. Impact of landscape and nitrogen addition Global Biogeochemical Cycles 10 387 399 Google Scholar Moussa, R., Voltz, M., Andrieux, P. 2002 Effects of the spatial organization of agricultural management on the hydrological behaviour of a farmed catchment during flood events Hydrological Processes 16 393 412 Google Scholar Norton, M.M., Fisher, T.R. 2000 The effects of forest on stream water quality in two coastal plain watersheds of the Chesapeake Bay Ecological Engineering 14 337 362 Google Scholar Peterjohn, W.T., Correll, D.L. 1984 Nutrient dynamics in an agricultural watershed: observations on the role of a riparian forest Ecology 65 1466 1475 Google Scholar Richards, D., Johnson, L.B., Host, G. 1996 Landscape-scale influences on stream habitats and biota Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 53 295 311 Google Scholar Schueler, T.R., Galli, J. 1992 Environmental impacts of stormwater ponds Kimble, P. Schueler, T. eds. Watershed Restoration Source Book Metropol, Wash. Counc. Gov Washington DC Google Scholar Sponseller, R.A., Benfield, E.F., Valett, H.M. 2001 Relationships between land usespatial scale and stream macroinvertebrate communities Freshwater Biology 46 1409 1424 Google Scholar Tague, C.L., Band, L.E. 2001 Evaluating explicit and implicit routing for watershed hydro-ecological models of forest hydrology at the small catchment scale Hydrological Processes 15 1415 1439 Google Scholar Turner, M.G., Gardner, R.H., Oȁ9Neill, R.V. 2001Landscape Ecology in Theory and Practice Springer-Verlag NY 401 Google Scholar Verchot, L.V., Groffman, P.M., Frank, D.A. 2002 Landscape versus ungulate control of gross mineralization and gross nitrification in semi-arid grasslands of Yellowstone National Park Soil Biology and Biochemisty 34 1691 1699 Google Scholar Weller, D.E., Jordan, T.E., Correll, D.L. 1998 Heuristic models for material discharge from landscapes with riparian buffers Ecological Applications 8 1156 1169 Google Scholar With, K.A., King, A.W. 1997 The use and misuse of neutral landscape models in ecology Oikos 79 219 229 Google Scholar Zak, D.R., Grigal, D.F. 1991 Nitrogen mineralization, nitrification and denitrification in upland and wetland ecosystems Oecologia 88 189 196 Google Scholar