Who Fears the HPV Vaccine, Who Doesn’t, and Why? An Experimental Study of the Mechanisms of Cultural Cognition
- 1.9k Downloads
The cultural cognition thesis holds that individuals form risk perceptions that reflect their commitments to contested views of the good society. We conducted a study that used the dispute over mandatory HPV vaccination to test the cultural cognition thesis. Although public health officials have recommended that all girls aged 11 or 12 be vaccinated for HPV—a sexually transmitted virus that causes cervical cancer—political controversy has blocked adoption of mandatory school-enrollment vaccination programs in all but one state. An experimental study of a large sample of American adults (N = 1,538) found that cultural cognition generates disagreement about the risks and benefits of the vaccine through two mechanisms: biased assimilation, and the credibility heuristic. We discuss theoretical and practical implications.
KeywordsCultural cognition Risk perception HIV Biased assimilation Source credibility
This study was funded by the National Science Foundation, Grant SES 0621840, the Oscar M. Ruebhausen Fund at Yale Law School. We would like to thank Katherine Bell for editorial assistance.
- Ackerman, B. A., & Fishkin, J. S. (2004). Deliberation day. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
- Aiken, L. S., West, S. G., & Reno, R. R. (1991). Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
- Alliance for Human Research Protection (2007, Feb. 8). More re: Merck’s “help pay for vioxx” mandatory vaccine campaign. Retrieved from http://www.ahrp.org/cms/content/view/463/29/.
- Blumenthal, R. (2007, Feb. 2). Texas is first to require cancer shots for schoolgirls, New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/03/us/03texas.html.
- Breyer, S. G. (1993). Breaking the vicious circle: Toward effective risk regulation. Cambridge, MA.: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Brody, J. E. (2007, May 15). HPV vaccine: Few risks, many benefits. New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/15/health/15brod.html.
- Carreyrou, J. (2006, Apr. 16). Viral marketing: Questions on efficacy cloud a cancer vaccine. Wall Street Journal, p. 1.Google Scholar
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Office of Enterprise Communications. (2006, June 29). CDC’s advisory committee recommends human papillomavirus virus vaccination. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/od/oc/media/pressrel/r060629.htm.).
- Cohen, J., Cohen, P., West, S. G., & Aiken, L. S. (2003). Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavioral sciences (3rd ed.). Mahwah, NJ: L. Erlbaum Associates.Google Scholar
- Douglas, M. (1986). How institutions think. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.Google Scholar
- Douglas, M. (1997). The depoliticization of risk. In R. J. Ellis & M. Thompson (Eds.), Culture matters: Essays in honor of Aaron Wildavsky (pp. 121–132). Boulder, CO: Westview Press.Google Scholar
- Douglas, M., & Wildavsky, A. B. (1982). Risk and culture: An essay on the selection of technical and environmental dangers. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Elliot, J. (2007, Mar. 9). Perry won’t veto bill blocking HPV order. Houston Chronicle. Retrieved from: http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/4785851.html.
- Fishkin, J. S. (1991). Democracy and deliberation: New directions for democratic reform. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
- Fishkin, J. S. (1995). The voice of the people: Public opinion and democracy. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
- Focus on the Family. (2007). Focus on the family’s position statement: Human papillomavirus vaccines. Retrieved from http://www.family.org/sharedassets/correspondence/pdfs/PublicPolicy/Position_Statement-Human_Papillomavirus_Vaccine.pdf.
- Gastil, J. (2008). Political communication and deliberation. Los Angeles: SAGE Publications.Google Scholar
- Gelman, A., & Hill, J. (2007). Data analysis using regression and multilevel/hierarchical models. Cambridge, NY: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Gibbs, N. (2006, June 21). Defusing the war over the “promiscuity vaccine.” Time. Retrieved from http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1206813,00.html.
- Harris, G. (2006, June 9). U.S. approves use of vaccine for cervical cancer. New York Times, p. A1.Google Scholar
- Hovland, C. I., & Weiss, W. (1951–1952). The influence of source credibility on communication effectiveness. Public Opinion Quarterly, 15(4), 635-650.Google Scholar
- Jaccard, J., & Turrisi, R. (2003). Interaction effects in multiple regression (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
- Jenkins-Smith, H. (2001). Modeling stigma: An empirical analysis of nuclear waste images of Nevada. In J. Flynn, P. Slovic, & H. Kunreuther (Eds.), Risk, media, and stigma: Understanding public challenges to modern science and technology (pp. 107–132). London; Sterling, VA: Earthscan.Google Scholar
- Judd, C. M. (2000). Everyday data analysis in social psychology: Comparisons of linear models. In H. T. Reis & C. M. Judd (Eds.), Handbook of research methods in social and personality psychology (pp. 370–392). New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Kahan, D. M. (2007). The cognitively illiberal state. Stanford Law Review, 60, 115–154.Google Scholar
- Kahan, D. M. (2008). Two conceptions of emotion in risk regulation. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 156, 741–766.Google Scholar
- Kahan, D. M., & Braman, D. (2006). Cultural cognition and public policy. Yale Law & Policy Review, 24, 147.Google Scholar
- Kahan, D., & Braman, D. (2008). The self-defensive cognition of self-defense. American Criminal Law Review, 45(1), 1–65.Google Scholar
- Kahan, D., Braman, D., Monahan, J., Callahan, L. & Peters, E. (in press). Cultural cognition and public policy: The case of outpatient commitment laws, Law & Human Behavior. Advanced publication at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10979-008-9174-4.
- Kahan, D. M., Hoffman, D. A., & Braman, D. (2009b). Whose eyes are you going to believe? Scott v. Harris and the perils of cognitive illiberalism. Harvard Law Review, 122, 837–906.Google Scholar
- Kahan, D. M., Slovic, P., Braman, D., & Gastil, J. (2006). Fear of democracy: A cultural critique of Sunstein on risk. Harvard Law Review, 119, 1071–1109.Google Scholar
- Kahneman, D., Slovic, P., & Tversky, A. (1982). Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Cambridge, NY: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Kaufman, M. (2006, June 9). FDA approves vaccine that should prevent most cervical cancers. Washington Post, p. A1.Google Scholar
- Mackie, D. M., & Quellar, S. (2000). The impact of group membership on persuasion: Revisiting “who says what to whom with what effect? In D. J. Terry & M. A. Hogg (Eds.), Attitudes, behavior, and social context: The role of norms and group membership (pp. 135–155). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associate Publishers.Google Scholar
- Margolis, H. (1996). Dealing with risk: Why the public and the experts disagree on environmental issues. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
- McCrocsky, J. C., & Young, T. J. (1981). Ethos and credibility: The construct and its measurement after three decades. Central States Speech Journal, 32, 24–34.Google Scholar
- National Conference of State Legislatures. (2009). HPV vaccine: state legislation. Available at http://www.ncsl.org/programs/health/HPVvaccine.htm.
- National Organization of Women (2006, June 8). NOW applauds the FDA for approving the first vaccine for cervical cancer. Retrieved from http://www.now.org/press/06-06/06-08a.
- Peters, E. M., Burraston, B., & Mertz, C. K. (2004). An emotion-based model of risk perception and stigma susceptibility: Cognitive appraisals of emotion, affective reactivity, worldviews, and risk perceptions in the generation of technological stigma. Risk Analysis, 24(5), 1349–1367.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Philipson, T. J., & Posner, R. A. (1993). Private choices and public health: The AIDS epidemic in an economic perspective. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Pollock, A. (2005). Same-sex marriage would harm children. In K. Burns & H. Conrath (Eds.), Gay marriage (pp. 45–53). Detroit: Greenhaven Press.Google Scholar
- Rayner, S. (1992). Cultural theory and risk analysis. In S. Krimsky & D. Golding (Eds.), Social theories of risk (pp. 83–115). Westport, CT: Praeger.Google Scholar
- Rosenthal, E. (2008, August 20). Drug makers’ push leads to vaccines’ fast rise. New York Times (Late Edition), p. A1.Google Scholar
- Saul, S., & Pollack, A. (2007, Feb. 17). Furor on rush to require cervical cancer vaccine. New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/17/health/17vaccine.html.
- Schkade, D., Sunstein, C. R., & Hastie, R. (2007). What happened on deliberation day? California Law Review, 95(3), 915–940.Google Scholar
- Siegel, R. B. (2007). The new politics of abortion: An equality analysis of woman-protective abortion restrictions. Illinois Law Review, 3, 991–1029.Google Scholar
- Slovic, P. (2000). The perception of risk. London; Sterling, VA: Earthscan Publications.Google Scholar
- Sunstein, C. R. (2006). Misfearing: A reply. Harvard Law Review, 119(4), 1110–1125.Google Scholar
- Thompson, M., Ellis, R., & Wildavsky, A. (1990). Cultural theory. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.Google Scholar
- Viscusi, W. K. (1983). Risk by choice: Regulating health and safety in the workplace. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Wildavsky, A., & Dake, K. (1990). Theories of risk perception: Who fears what and why? Daedalus, 114, 41–60.Google Scholar