Advertisement

Muscle microanatomy and its changes during contraction: the legacy of William Bowman (1816–1892)

  • EUGENIO FRIXIONE
Article

Abstract

Striated muscle fine structure began to be really understood following a comprehensive survey of the matter carried out by William Bowman in the late 1830s. The publications resulting from such a study, the first of which earned for the author a precocious election as Fellow of the Royal Society, are herewith examined in the context of contemporary views on the subject as well as of their subsequent repercussion and current knowledge today. It is shown that not only Bowman succeeded in establishing the true architecture of striated muscle fibres to the extent possible with the most advanced technology available in his day – explaining and eradicating alternative erroneous concepts in the process – but also in correctly describing the basic microstructural changes associated with contraction. In addition, although unrecognized by him or others at the time, his experiments with muscle provided direct evidence for the existence of a selectively permeable cell membrane – in the present meaning of the word – over half a century before its officially accepted discovery. Yet, in spite of these remarkable advances, Bowman arrived at the conclusion that the structure of striated muscle fibres is essentially irrelevant for the mechanism of contraction. Possible reasons behind Bowman’s breakthrough accomplishments as a pioneer of modern muscle research, and his failure to understand their significance for muscle physiology, are discussed.

Keywords

Striate Muscle Plain Water Voluntary Muscle Transverse Striation Muscular Motion 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Notes

Acknowledgements

The author is indebted to Professor L. S. Jacyna for kindly reading and commenting on the first draft of this paper. Professor François Delaporte provided valuable help for obtaining important French literature cited in this study. Gratitude is expressed also to Lourdes Ruiz for preparing digital versions of the figures, and to the Wellcome Library for the History and Understanding of Medicine for allowing unlimited access to its superb collections. This work was partly funded by a Travel Award generously granted by the Wellcome Trust Centre for the History of Medicine.

References

  1. Baker JR, (1952) The Cell-Theory: a restatement, history, and critique. Part III. The cell as a morphological unit Quart J Micr Sci 93: 157–190Google Scholar
  2. Barer R, (1948) The structure of the striated muscle fibre Biol Rev 23: 159–200CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  3. Bennett HS, (1955) Modern concepts of structure of striated muscle Am J Phys Med 34: 46–67PubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. Bennett HS, (1958)The cytology of striped muscle In: Palay SL, (ed.) Frontiers of Cytology Yale University Press New Haven pp. 343–380Google Scholar
  5. Bennett HS, Porter KR, (1953) An electron microscope study of sectioned breast muscle of the domestic fowl Amer J Anat 93: 61–106CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Bernstein J, (1902) Untersuchungen zur Thermodynamik der bioelektrischen Ströme Pflüg Arch f d ges Physiol 92: 521–562CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Boerhaave H, (1744) Dr. Boerhaave’s Academical Lectures on the Theory of Physic... Vol. III, Innys London p. 171Google Scholar
  8. Bowman W, (1840) On the minute structure and movements of voluntary muscle Phil Trans Roy Soc 130: 457–501CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bowman W, (1841) Additional note on the contraction of voluntary muscle in the living body Phil Trans Roy Soc 131: 69–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bowman W, (1842) On the structure and use of the Malpighian bodies of the kidney, with observations on the circulation through that gland Phil Trans Roy Soc 132: 57–80CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Bowman W, (1843a) Muscle In: Todd RB, (ed.) The Cyclopædia of Anatomy and Physiology Vol. 3, Longman, Brown, Green, Longmans London pp. 506–519Google Scholar
  12. Bowman W, (1843b) Muscular motion In: Todd RB, (ed.) The Cyclopædia of Anatomy and Physiology Vol. 3 Longman, Brown, Green, Longmans London pp. 519–530Google Scholar
  13. Brazier MAB, (1998) A History of Neurophysiology in the 19th Century Raven Press New YorkGoogle Scholar
  14. Chance B, (1924) Sir William Bowman, Bart., F.R.S. Anatomist, physiologist and ophthalmologist Ann Med Hist 6: 143–158Google Scholar
  15. Clarke E, Jacyna LS, (1987) Nineteenth-century Origins of Neuroscientific Concepts University of California Press Berkeley – Los AngelesGoogle Scholar
  16. Darwin CR, (1872/1898) The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals Appleton New York p.159–160Google Scholar
  17. Davis BT, (1983) The formative years of Sir William Bowman Proc XXVIII Int Congr Hist Med, 1982 II: 169–171Google Scholar
  18. Dobie WM, (1849) Observations on the minute structure and mode of contraction of voluntary muscular fibre Ann Mag Nat Hist (Ser. 2) 3: 109–119Google Scholar
  19. Dutrochet RJ, (1824) Recherches Anatomiques et Physiologiques sur la Structure Intime des Animaux et des Végétaux et sur leur Motilité Baillière Paris pp. 171–188Google Scholar
  20. Dutrochet RJ (1826) L’Agent Immédiat du Movement Vital, dévoilé dans sa natur et dans son mode d’action, chez les végétaux et chez les animaux (pp. 115 and 126). Baillière, ParisGoogle Scholar
  21. Duval M, (1873) Cours de Physiologie, d’après l’Enseignement du Professeur Küss (2ème éd.) Baillière et fils Paris p. 85Google Scholar
  22. Eknoyan G, (1996) Sir William Bowman: his contributions to physiology and nephrology Kidney Int 50: 2120–2128PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Fine LG, (1985) William Bowman’s description of the glomerulus Amer J Nephrol 5: 437–440CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Fontana F (1781) Traité sur le Venin de la Vipère, sur le Poisons Américains, sur le Laurier – cerise, et sur Quelques Autres Poisons Végétaux (vol. 2, p. 227). FlorenceGoogle Scholar
  25. Frixione E, (2000) Recurring views on the structure and function of the cytoskeleton: a 300-year epic Cell Motil. Cytoskel 46: 73–94CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Fulton JF, (1926) Muscular Contraction, and the Reflex Control of Movement Williams and Wilkins Baltimore pp. 3–55Google Scholar
  27. Fulton JF, Wilson LG, (1966) Selected Readings in the History of Physiology (2nd. ed.), Charles C. Thomas, Springfield. pp. 226–228Google Scholar
  28. Galen C (2nd century AD [1968]) Galen On the Usefulness of the Parts of the Body (De usu partium). May MT (transl., introd., comm.) (pp. 552–553) Cornell University Press, IthacaGoogle Scholar
  29. Hughes A, (1959) A History of Cytology Abelard-Schuman London–New York p. 13Google Scholar
  30. Hall TS, (1969) History of General Physiology. 600 B.C. to A. D. 1900 University of Chicago Press ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  31. Haller A (1753/1755) A Dissertation on the Sensible and Irritable Parts of Animals (De Partibus Corporis Humani Sensibilibus et Irritabilibus). Tissot SA (transl.), Nourse, London. (Republished, Temkin O, introd., Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, 1936)Google Scholar
  32. Haller A (1786) First Lines of Physiology (Primae lineae physiologiae). Translated from the correct Latin edition. Printed under the inspection of William Cullen, and compared with the edition published by H. A. Wrisberg (p. 11). Drummond, Edinburgh. (Reprint ed, King LS, introd., Johnson Reprint Corp, New York, 1966)Google Scholar
  33. Harris H, (2000) The Birth of the Cell Yale University Press New HavenGoogle Scholar
  34. Home E, (1826) The Croonian Lecture. On the structure of a muscular fibre from which is derived its elongation and contraction Phil Trans Roy Soc 116: 64–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Hooke R (1678) Contribution presented to the Royal Society of London on March 28, 1678. In: Birch T (1757) The History of the Royal Society of London for Improving of Natural Knowledge from its First Rise (vol. 3, pp. 396–397). Millar in the Strand, London. (Reprint ed, Johnson Reprint Corp., New York, 1968)Google Scholar
  36. Hunter J (1781) Croonian lecture on muscular motion, No. V. In: Palmer JF (ed, 1837) The Works of John Hunter, F. R. S. with Notes (vol. 4, pp. 255–266). Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, Green and Longman, LondonGoogle Scholar
  37. Huxley AF, (1977) Looking back on muscle In: Hodgkin AL, Huxley AF, Feldberg W, Rushton WAH, Gregory RA, McCance RA, edsThe Pursuit of Nature Cambridge University Press Cambridge (UK) pp. 23–64Google Scholar
  38. Huxley AF (1980) Reflections on Muscle The Sherrington Lectures (vol. 14, pp. 1–28). Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  39. Jacyna S, (2003) Moral fibre: the negotiation of microscopic facts in Victorian Britain J Hist Biol 36: 39–85CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Kölliker A (1854) Manual of Human Microscopical Anatomy (Handbuch der Gewebelehre des Menschen). Busk G and Huxley TH (transl.), Da Costa J (ed), Lippincott–Grambo & Co, PhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
  41. Lister JJ and Hodgkin T (1832) On the microscopic characters of some of the animal fluids and tissues. In: Edwards WF (ed) On the Influence of Physical Agents on Life (pp. 424–447). Hodgkin T & Fisher (transl.) S. Highley, LondonGoogle Scholar
  42. Lauth EA, (1834) Anatomie. Séance du 15 juillet 1834, Societé d’Histoire Naturelle de Strasbourg L’Institut, J Général des Societés et Travaux Scientifiques de la France et de l’Étranger 70: 300–301Google Scholar
  43. Law FW, (1975) Sir William Bowman Survey Ophthalmol 19: 302–307Google Scholar
  44. Mandl L, (1838–1847) Anatomie Microscopique Baillière Paris (vol. 1, pp. 5–12)Google Scholar
  45. Mandl L, (1843) Manuel d’Anatomie Générale, Appliquée a la Physiologie et a la Pathologie Baillière Paris p. 427Google Scholar
  46. Melland B, (1885) A simplified view of the histology of the striped muscle-fibre Quart J Micr Sci 25: 371–390Google Scholar
  47. Müller J (1840–1842) Elements of Physiology (Handbuch der Physiologie des Menschen für Vorlesungen). Baly WM (transl.) (pp. 878–904). Taylor and Walton, LondonGoogle Scholar
  48. Needham D, (1971) Machina carnis; the Biochemistry of Muscular Contraction in its Historical Development Cambridge University Press Cambridge (UK) pp. 128–129Google Scholar
  49. Obituary (1892) Sir William Bowman, Bart., F.R.C.S., F.R.S., LL.D., M.D Br Med J April 2: 742–745Google Scholar
  50. Overton E, (1902) Beiträge zur allgemeinen Muskel- und Nervenphysiologie. II. Mittheilung. Ueber die Unentbehrlichkeit von Natrium- (oder Lithium-) Ionen für den Contractionsact des Muskels Pflüg Arch f d ges Physiol 92: 346–386CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Overton E, (1904) Beiträge zur allgemeinen Muskel- und Nervenphysiologie. III. Mittheilung. Studien über die Wirkung der Alkali- und Erdalkalisalze auf Skelettmuskeln und Nerven Pflüg Arch f d Ges Physiol 105: 176–290CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Power H, (1892) Prefatory memoir. In: Burdon-Sanderson J, Hulke JW, (eds.) The Collected Papers of Sir William Bowman, Bart., F.R.S (vol. 2,pp. xi–xxiii). Harrison and Sons LondonGoogle Scholar
  53. Prévost JL, Dumas JB, (1823a) Mémoire sur les phénomènes qui accompagnent la contraction de la fibre musculaire J Physiol Expér Pathol 3: 301–338Google Scholar
  54. Prévost JL, Dumas JB, (1823b) Additions au mémoire sur la contraction musculaire J Physiol Expér Pathol 3: 339–344Google Scholar
  55. Prochaska J, (1778) De carne musculari tractatus anatomico-physiologicus Graeffer ViennaGoogle Scholar
  56. Robertson D, (1981) Membrane structure J Cell Biol 91(No. 3, Pt. 2): 189s–204sPubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Rooseboom, Maria, (1956) Microscopium Rijksmuseum voor de Geschiedenis der Natuurwetenschappen Leiden. p. 17Google Scholar
  58. Schwann T (1839) Mikroskopische Untersuchungen über die Uebereinstimmung in der Struktur und dem Wachsthum der Thiere und Pflanzen (pp. 1845–1856). Reimer, Berlin (Microscopical Researches into the Accordance in the Structure and Growth of Animals and Plants. Smith H, transl., Sydenham Society, London, 1847)Google Scholar
  59. Shepherd G, (1991) Foundations of the Neuron Doctrine Oxford University Press New York-Oxford p. 133Google Scholar
  60. Skey FC, (1837) On the elementary structure of the muscular fibre of animal and organic life Phil Trans Roy Soc 127: 371–385CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Stedman’s Medical Dictionary (2000) LippincottWilliams & Williams BaltimoreGoogle Scholar
  62. Thomas KB, (1966) The manuscripts of Sir William Bowman Med Hist 10: 245–256PubMedGoogle Scholar
  63. Thomas KB, (1975) Bowman, William In: Gillispie CC, (ed.) Dictionary of Scientific Biography Vol. 1, Charles Scribner’s Sons New York pp. 375–377Google Scholar
  64. Todd RB, (1836–1852) The Cyclopædia of Anatomy and Physiology Longman, Brown, Green, Longmans LondonGoogle Scholar
  65. Todd RB, Bowman W, (1857) The Physiological Anatomy and Physiology of Man. Blanchard and Lea Philadelphia (Original British ed., Parker, London, 1845–1856)Google Scholar
  66. van Leeuwenhoek A, (1682) Letter to Robert Hooke, March 3rd. In: Committee of Dutch Scientists (ed, 1948) The Collected Letters of Antoni van Leeuwenhoek (vol. 3, pp. 385–415). Swets & Zeitlinger, AmsterdamGoogle Scholar
  67. Vesalius A (1543[1999]) On the Fabric of the Human Body (De Humani Corporis Fabric Libri Septem, II, pp. 218–222). Richardson WF & Carman JB (transl.) (Book II, pp. 110–119). Norman Publishing, San Francisco, 1999Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Sección de Metodología y Teoría de la Ciencia, Centro de Investigación y de Estudios Avanzados (CINVESTAV)Mexico cityMexico

Personalised recommendations