Journal of Quantitative Criminology

, Volume 24, Issue 4, pp 337–362

Using State Child Labor Laws to Identify the Causal Effect of Youth Employment on Deviant Behavior and Academic Achievement

  • Robert Apel
  • Shawn D. Bushway
  • Raymond Paternoster
  • Robert Brame
  • Gary Sweeten
Original Paper

Abstract

On the basis of prior research findings that employed youth, and especially intensively employed youth, have higher rates of delinquent behavior and lower academic achievement, scholars have called for limits on the maximum number of hours per week that teenagers are allowed to work. We use the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1997 to assess the claim that employment and work hours are causally related to adolescent problem behavior. We utilize a change model with age-graded child labor laws governing the number of hours per week allowed during the school year as instrumental variables. We find that these work laws lead to additional number of hours worked by youth, which then lead to increased high school dropout but decreased delinquency. Although counterintuitive, this result is consistent with existing evidence about the effect of employment on crime for adults and the impact of dropout on youth crime.

Keywords

Youth employment Crime and deviance School performance Longitudinal data Instrumental variables 

References

  1. Agnew R (1986) Work and delinquency among juveniles attending school. J Crim Justice 9:19–41Google Scholar
  2. Angrist JD, Imbens GW, Rubin DB (1996) Identification of causal effects using instrumental variables. J Am Stat Assoc 91:444–455CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Apel R, Paternoster R, Bushway SD, Brame R (2006) A job isn’t just a job: the differential impact of formal versus informal work on adolescent problem behavior. Crime Delinq 52:333–369CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Apel R, Bushway SD, Brame R, Haviland AM, Nagin DS, Paternoster R (2007) Unpacking the relationship between adolescent employment and antisocial behavior: a matched samples comparison. Criminology 45:67–97CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Bachman JG, Schulenberg JE (1993) How part-time work intensity relates to drug use, problem behavior, time use, and satisfaction among high school seniors: are these consequences or merely correlates? Dev Psychol 29:220–235CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bachman JG, Johnston LD, O’Malley PM (1981) Smoking, drinking, and drug use among American high school students: correlates and trends, 1975–1979. Am J Public Health 71:59–69Google Scholar
  7. Bachman JG, Safron DJ, Sy SR, Schulenberg JE (2003) Wishing to work: new perspectives on how adolescents’ part-time work intensity is linked to educational disengagement, substance use, and other problem behaviors. Int J Behav Dev 27:301–315CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Blumstein A, Cohen J, Roth JA, Visher CA (eds) (1986) Criminal careers and “career criminals”, vol 1. National Academy Press, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  9. Bound JD, Jaeger A, Baker RM (1995) Problems with instrumental variables estimation when the correlation between the instruments and the endogenous explanatory variable is weak. J Am Stat Assoc 90:443–450CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bremner R, Barnard J, Hareven TK, Mennel RM (1971) Children and youth in America: a documentary history. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  11. Cameron SV, Heckman JJ (1993) The nonequivalence of high school equivalents. J Labor Econ 11:1–47CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Carnegie Council on Policy Studies in Higher Education (1979) Giving youth a better chance: options for education, work, and service. Jossey-Bass, San FranciscoGoogle Scholar
  13. Carr RV, Wright JD, Brody C (1996) Effects of high school work experience a decade later: evidence from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth. Sociol Educ 69:66–81CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Center for Human Resource Research (2002) NLSY97 user’s guide. Center for Human Resource Research, Columbus, OHGoogle Scholar
  15. Coleman JS, Bremner RH, Clark BR, Davis JB, Eichorn DH, Griliches Z, Kett JF, Ryder NB, Doering ZB, Mays JM (1974) Youth: transition to adulthood, report of the panel on youth of the president’s science advisory committee. University of Chicago Press, ChicagoGoogle Scholar
  16. Cullen FT, Williams N, Wright JP (1997) Work conditions and juvenile delinquency: is youth employment criminogenic? Crim Justice Policy Rev 8:119–143CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. D’Amico R (1984) Does employment during high school impair academic progress? Sociol Educ 57:152–164CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Elliott DS (1966) Delinquency, school attendance and dropout. Soc Probl 13:307–314CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Elliott DS, Voss HL (1974) Delinquency and dropout. D. C. Heath, Lexington, MAGoogle Scholar
  20. Entwisle DR, Alexander KL, Olson LS, Ross K (1999) Paid work in early adolescence: developmental and ethnic patterns. J Early Adolesc 19:363–388CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Entwisle DR, Alexander KL, Olson LS (2000) Early work histories of urban youth. Am Sociol Rev 65:279–297CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Entwisle DR, Alexander KL, Olson LS (2004) Temporary as compared to permanent high school dropout. Soc Forces 82:1181–1205CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Entwisle DR, Alexander KL, Olson LS (2005) Urban teenagers: work and dropout. Youth Soc 37:3–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Fagan J, Freeman RB (1999) Crime and work. In: Tonry M (ed) Crime and justice: a review of research, vol 25. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp 225–290Google Scholar
  25. Gottfredson DC (1985) Youth employment, crime, and schooling: a longitudinal study of a national sample. Dev Psychol 21:419–432CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Greenberger E, Steinberg LD (1986) When teenagers work: the psychological and social costs of adolescent employment. Basic Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  27. Greenberger E, Steinberg LD, Vaux A (1981) Adolescents who work: health and behavioral consequences of job stress. Dev Psychol 17:691–703CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Grogger J (1998) Market wages and youth crime. J Labor Econ 16:756–791CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Hagan J (1993) The social embeddedness of crime and unemployment. Criminology 31:465–491CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Hall GS (1904) Adolescence: its psychology and its relations to physiology, anthropology, sociology, sex, crime, religion, and education, vol 1. Appleton, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  31. Hindelang M, Hirschi T, Weis JG (1981) Measuring delinquency. Sage, Beverly Hills, CAGoogle Scholar
  32. Hirschi T (1969) Causes of delinquency. University of California Press, Berkeley, CAGoogle Scholar
  33. Horney J, Osgood DW, Marshall IH (1995) Criminal careers in the short-term: intra-individual variability in crime and its relation to local life circumstances. Am Sociol Rev 60:655–673CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Hotz VJ, Xu LC, Tienda M, Ahituv A (2002) Are there returns to the wages of young men from working while in school? Rev Econ Stat 84:221–236CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Imbens GW, Angrist JD (1994) Identification and estimation of local average treatment effects. Econometrica 62:467–476CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Jarjoura GR (1993) Does dropping out of school enhance delinquent involvement? Results from a large-scale national probability sample. Criminology 31:149–172CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Jarjoura GR (1996) The conditional effect of social class on the dropout-delinquency relationship. J Res Crime Delinq 33:232–255CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Johnson MK (2004) Further evidence on adolescent employment and substance use: differences by race and ethnicity. J Health Soc Behav 45:187–197Google Scholar
  39. Kett J (1977) Rites of passage: adolescence in America, 1790 to the present. Basic Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  40. Kett J (1978) Curing the disease of precocity. Am J Sociol 84:S183–S211CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. LeBlanc M, Fréchette M (1989) Male criminal activity from childhood through youth: multilevel and developmental perspectives. Springer-Verlag, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  42. Lillydahl JH (1990) Academic achievement and part-time employment of high school students. J Econ Educ 21:307–316CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Lochner L, Moretti E (2004) The effect of education on crime: evidence from prison inmates, arrests, and self-reports. Am Econ Rev 94:155–189Google Scholar
  44. Longest KC, Shanahan MJ (2007) Adolescent work intensity and substance use: the mediational and moderational roles of parenting. J Marriage Fam 69:703–720CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Marsh H (1991) Employment during high school: character building or a subversion of academic goals? Sociol Educ 64:172–189CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. McMorris BJ, Uggen C (2000) Alcohol and employment in the transition to adulthood. J Health Soc Behav 41:276–294CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. McNeal R Jr (1997) Are students being pulled out of high school? The effect of adolescent employment on dropping out. Sociol Educ 70:206–220CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Mihalic SW, Elliott DS (1997) Short- and long-term consequences of adolescent work. Youth Soc 28:464–498CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Mortimer JT (2003) Working and growing up in America. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  50. Mortimer JT, Finch MD (1986) The effects of part-time work on adolescent self-concept and achievement. In: Borman KM, Reisman J (eds) Becoming a worker. Ablex Publishing, Norwood, NJ, pp 66–89Google Scholar
  51. Mortimer JT, Finch MD, Ryu S, Shanahan MJ, Call KT (1996) The effects of work intensity on adolescent mental health, achievement, and behavioral adjustment: new evidence from a prospective study. Child Dev 67:1243–1261Google Scholar
  52. National Commission on the Reform of Secondary Education (1973) The reform of secondary education. McGraw-Hill, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  53. National Commission on Youth (1980) The transition of youth to adulthood: a bridge too long. Westview Press, Boulder, COGoogle Scholar
  54. National Panel on High School, Adolescent Education (1976) The education of adolescents. U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  55. National Research Council (1998) Protecting youth at work: health, safety, and development of working children and adolescents in the United States. National Academy Press, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  56. Newman KS (1999) No shame in my game: the working poor in the inner city. Vintage Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  57. Osgood DW (1999) Having the time of their lives: all work and no play? In: Booth A, Crouter AC, Shanahan MJ (eds) Transitions to adulthood in a changing economy: no work, no family, no future? Praeger, Westport, CT, pp 176–186Google Scholar
  58. Paternoster R, Bushway S, Brame R, Apel R (2003) The effect of teenage employment on delinquency and problem behaviors. Soc Forces 82:297–335CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Phillips JC, Kelly D (1979) School failure and delinquency: which causes which? Criminology 17:194–207CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Ploeger M (1997) Youth employment and delinquency: reconsidering a problematic relationship. Criminology 35:659–675CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Rothstein DS (2007) High school employment and youths’ academic achievement. J Hum Res 42:194–213Google Scholar
  62. Ruggiero M, Greenberger E, Steinberg L (1982) Occupational deviance among first-time workers. Youth Soc 13:423–448CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Ruhm CJ (1995) The extent and consequences of high school employment. J Labor Res 16:293–303CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Safron DJ, Schulenberg JE, Bachman JG (2001) Part-time work and hurried adolescence: the links among work intensity, social activities, health behaviors, and substance use. J Health Soc Behav 42:425–449CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Sampson RJ, Laub JH (1993) Crime in the making: pathways and turning points through life. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  66. Schoenhals M, Tienda M, Schneider B (1998) The educational and personal consequences of adolescent employment. Soc Forces 77:723–762CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Shea J (1997) Instrument relevance in multivariate linear models: a simple measure. Rev Econ Stat 79:348–352Google Scholar
  68. Staff J, Uggen C (2003) The fruits of good work: early work experiences and adolescent deviance. J Res Crime Delinq 40:263–290CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Staiger D, Stock JH (1997) Instrumental variables regression with weak instruments. Econometrica 65:557–586CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Steinberg L, Cauffman E (1995) The impact of employment on adolescent development. Ann Child Dev 11:131–166Google Scholar
  71. Steinberg L, Dornbusch S (1991) Negative correlates of part-time work in adolescence: replication and elaboration. Dev Psychol 17:304–313CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Steinberg LD, Greenberger E, Garduque L, Ruggiero M, Vaux A (1982) Effects of working on adolescent development. Dev Psychol 18:385–395CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Steinberg L, Fegley S, Dornbusch S (1993) Negative impact of part-time work on adolescent adjustment: evidence from a longitudinal study. Dev Psychol 29:171–180CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Sullivan M (1989) Getting paid: youth crime and work in the inner city. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NYGoogle Scholar
  75. Sweeten G, Bushway S, Paternoster R (2008) Does dropping out of school mean dropping into delinquency? Unpublished manuscript. Arizona State University, TempeGoogle Scholar
  76. Thornberry TP, Christenson RL (1984) Unemployment and criminal involvement: an investigation of reciprocal causal structures. Am Sociol Rev 56:609–627Google Scholar
  77. Thornberry TP, Moore M, Christenson RL (1985) The effect of dropping out of high school on subsequent criminal behavior. Criminology 23:3–18CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  78. Tienda M, Ahituv A (1996) Ethnic differences in school departure: does youth employment promote or undermine educational attainment? In: Magnum G, Magnum S (eds) Of heart and mind: social policy essays in honor of Sar A. Levitan. W. E. Upjohn Institute, Kalamazoo, MI, pp 93–110Google Scholar
  79. Tyler JH (2003) Using state child labor laws to identify the effect of school-year work on academic achievement. J Labor Econ 21:381–408CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  80. Uggen C (1999) Ex-offenders and the conformist alternative: a job quality model of work and crime. Soc Probl 46:127–151CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. Uggen C (2000) Work as a turning point in the life course of criminals: a duration model of age, employment, and recidivism. Am Sociol Rev 65:529–546CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  82. Warren JR (2002) Reconsidering the relationship between student employment and academic outcomes: a new theory and better data. Youth Soc 33:366–393CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Warren JR, Cataldi EF (2006) A historical perspective on high school students’ paid employment and its association with high school dropout. Sociol Forum 21:113–143CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. Warren JR, Lee J (2004) The impact of adolescent employment on high school dropout: differences by individual and labor market characteristics. Soc Sci Res 32:98–128CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Warren JR, LePore PC, Mare RD (2000) Employment during high school: consequences for students’ grades in academic courses. Am Educ Res J 37:943–969Google Scholar
  86. Witte AD, Tauchen H (1994) Work and crime: an exploration using panel data. Public Financ 49:155–167Google Scholar
  87. Work-Education Consortium (1978) Work and service experience for youth. National Manpower Institute, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  88. Wright JP, Cullen FT (2000) Juvenile involvement in occupational delinquency. Criminology 38:863–892CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  89. Wright JP, Cullen FT (2004) Employment, peers, and life-course transitions. Justice Q 21:183–205CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  90. Wu LT, Schlenger WE, Galvin DM (2003) The relationship between employment and substance use among students aged 12–17. J Adolesc Health 32:5–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  • Robert Apel
    • 1
  • Shawn D. Bushway
    • 1
  • Raymond Paternoster
    • 2
  • Robert Brame
    • 3
  • Gary Sweeten
    • 4
  1. 1.School of Criminal JusticeUniversity at AlbanyAlbanyUSA
  2. 2.Department of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Maryland Population Research CenterUniversity of Maryland at College ParkCollege ParkUSA
  3. 3.Department of Criminal JusticeUniversity of North Carolina at CharlotteCharlotteUSA
  4. 4.School of Criminology and Criminal JusticeArizona State UniversityGlendaleUSA

Personalised recommendations