Effects of hydrogen peroxide treatment on measurements of lake sediment grain-size distribution
Grain-size analysis is routinely performed on soft sediments, and has been applied in numerous paleoenvironmental studies using lake sediment archives. Despite the frequent use of this method, no common protocol exists for the treatment of lake sediment samples prior to analysis. In this study, differences in grain-size distribution before and after treatment with hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) were evaluated for sediment sequences from four lakes in Norway characterized by different geological and environmental settings. We found that removal of organic matter had a profound effect on the grain-size distribution of the sediment samples, which might have important bearing on how such data are interpreted. One of the analysed sediment sequences showed a systematic shift toward more fines after treatment, whereas no clear systematic effects were observed for the remaining three. The observed differences might derive from (1) variable concentrations of biogenic silica, which could cause shifts in the Sedigraph readings as a consequence of the porosity and fragility of diatom frustules, (2) clogging of organic matter during initial mechanical sieving, and (3) disturbance of the internal flow regime in the Sedigraph as a result of the dispersive agent having a viscosity that is too low. These possible explanations require further testing. Nevertheless, we propose that the paleolimnological community should develop a common protocol for pre-treatment of sediments from lacustrine settings that both enables reproducibility of results and reduces the risk of misinterpretation. Our observations suggest that sediments from boreal lakes should be treated with hydrogen peroxide prior to grain-size analysis, although treatment should be relatively mild to avoid possible mineral degradation.
KeywordsLake sediment Grain-size analysis Sedigraph Pre-treatment Hydrogen peroxide
The authors thank Jostein Bakke, Eivind Støren, Marius Bakkeng and Svein Olaf Dahl, who helped retrieve the sediment cores used in this study. Coring and analyses of samples from Oldevatnet and Nerfloen were partly funded through the NORLAKE project at the Bjerknes Centre for Climate Research, and the coring of Sverigedalsvatnet was in part funded by the ARCTREC project at the Bjerknes Centre for Climate Research. We are very grateful for constructive feedback from two anonymous reviewers, an Associate Editor, and Co-Editor-in-Chief Mark Brenner.
- Fedotov AP, Phedorin MA, De Batist M, Ziborova GA, Kazansky AY, Semenov MY, Matasova GG, Khabuev AV, Kugakolov SA, Rodyakin SV (2008) A 450-ka long record of glaciation in Northern Mongolia based on studies at Lake Khubsugul: high-resolution reflection seismic data and grain-size variations in cored sediments. J Paleolimnol 39:335–348CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Goossens D (2008) Techniques to measure grain-size distributions of loamy sediments: a comparative study of ten instruments for wet analysis. Sedimentology 55:65–96Google Scholar
- Nichols G (2009) Sedimentology and stratigraphy. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Wartel S, Barusseau J-P, Cornand L (1995) Improvement of grain-size analyses using the automated SEDIGRAPH 5100. Studiedocumenten van het K.B.I.N. = Documents de Travail de l'I.R.Sc.N.B., 80. Koninklijk Belgisch Instituut voor Natuurwetenschappen: Brussel. 28 ppGoogle Scholar
- Wetzel RG (2001) Limnology, 3rd edn. Academic Press, San DiegoGoogle Scholar