Journal of Paleolimnology

, Volume 39, Issue 1, pp 83–99 | Cite as

The accuracy of methods used to estimate the whole-lake accumulation rate of organic carbon, major cations, phosphorus and heavy metals in sediment

  • Brian Rippey
  • N. John Anderson
  • Ingemar Renberg
  • Tom Korsman
Original Paper

Abstract

The accuracy of three methods used to estimate the whole-lake accumulation rate of chemicals in sediment, the simple mean accumulation rate, regression against water depth and the mean accumulation rate in sedimentation zones, was assessed. The concentrations and accumulation rates of organic carbon, four major cations, phosphorus and four heavy metals in the 1902 to 1988 sediment layer at 43 sites in Kassjön were used and the three methods gave identical results. The accuracy of the simple mean accumulation rate method using 5 or 10 sites was investigated using Monte Carlo simulation and both versions gave accurate results. If the method used the dry sediment accumulation rate at 5 or 10 sites, along with chemical concentration at one central site, then the errors were less than ±10% for five of the chemicals and larger for the others (−20 or 20–40%), although the direction of the bias was predictable. If chemical accumulation rate at the central site only was used to estimate the whole-lake value, the bias increased to 25% for the major cations, 50% for the heavy metals and P, and 85% for organic carbon. Having 43 sites in Kassjön meant that the true whole-lake chemical accumulation rate was known and so the accuracy of the methods and their variants could be assessed for the first time. These findings allow the particulars of the simple mean accumulation rate method to be chosen to suit the accuracy needed for a palaeolimnological investigation.

Keywords

Whole-lake accumulation of chemicals Methods Accuracy Kassjön 

References

  1. Anderson NJ (1990) Variability of diatom concentrations and accumulation rates in sediments of a small lake basin. Limnol Oceanogr 35:497–508Google Scholar
  2. Anderson NJ, Korsman T, Renberg I (1994) Spatial heterogeneity of diatom stratigraphy in a varved and non-varved sediments of a small, boreal-forest lake. Aquat Sci 56:40–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Anderson NJ, Renberg I, Segerström U (1995) Diatom production responses to the development of early agriculture in a boreal forest lake-catchment (Kassjön, northern Sweden). J Ecol 83:809–822CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Auer MT, Johnson NA, Penn MR, Effler SW (1996) Pollutant sources, depositional environment, and the surficial sediments of Onondaga lake, New York. J Environ Qual 25:46–55CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Blais JM, Kalff J (1993) Atmospheric loading of Zn, Cu, Ni, Cr, and Pb to lake sediments: the role of catchment, lake morphometry, and physico-chemical properties of the elements. Biogeochemistry 23:1–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Blais JM, Kalff J (1995) The influence of lake morphometry on sediment focusing. Limnol Oceanogr 40:582–588CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Blais JM, Duff KE, Laing TE, Smol JP (1999) Regional contamination in lakes in the Noril’sk region in Siberia, Russia. Water Air Soil Pollut 110:389–404CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bock R (1979) A handbook of decomposition methods in analytical chemistry. International Textbook Company, GlasgowGoogle Scholar
  9. Brannvall M-L, Bindler R, Emteryd O, Renberg I (2001) Four thousand years of atmospheric lead pollution in northern Europe: a summary from Swedish lake sediments. J Paleolimnol 25:421–435CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Dean WE (1974) Determination of carbonate and organic matter in calcareous sediments and sedimentary rocks by loss on ignition: comparison with other methods. J Sedimentol 41:242–248Google Scholar
  11. Dean WE, Gorham E (1998) Magnitude and significance of carbon burial in lakes, reservoirs, and peatlands. Geology 26:535–538CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Delfino JJ, Bortleson GC, Lee GF (1969) Distribution of Mn, Fe, P, Mg, K, Na, and Ca in the surface sediments of Lake Mendota, Wisconsin. Environ Sci Technol 3:1189–1192CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Dillon PJ, Evans HE (1993) A comparison of phosphorus retention in lakes determined from mass balance and sediment core calculations. Water Res 27:659–668CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Edmondson WT (1974) The sedimentary record of the eutrophication of Lake Washington. Proc Natl Acad Sci 71:5093–5095CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Engstrom DR, Swain EB (1986) The chemistry of lake sediments in time and space. Hydrobiologia 143:37–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Evans RD, Dillon PJ (1982) Historical changes in anthropogenic lead fallout in southern Ontario, Canada. Hydrobiologia 91:131–137Google Scholar
  17. Evans RD, Rigler FH (1980) Calculation of the total anthropogenic lead in sediment of a rural Ontario lake. Environ Sci Technol 14:216–218CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Evans RD, Rigler FH (1983) A test of lead-210 dating for the measurement of whole lake soft sediment accumulation. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 40:506–515Google Scholar
  19. Evans RD, Rigler FH (1985) Long distance transport of anthropogenic lead as measured by lake sediments. Water Air Soil Pollut 24:141–151CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Evans HE, Smith PJ, Dillon PJ (1983) Anthropogenic zinc and cadmium burdens in sediments of selected Southern Ontario lakes. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 40:570–579Google Scholar
  21. Evans HE, Dillon PJ, Scholer PJ, Evans RD (1986) The use of Pb/210Pb ratios in lake sediments for estimating atmospheric fallout of stable lead in south-central Ontario, Canada. Sci Total Environ 54:77–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Fernandez P, Vilanova RM, Martinez C, Appleby PG, Grimalt JO (2000) The historical record of atmospheric pyrolitic pollution over Europe registered in the sedimentary PAH from remote mountain lakes. Environ Sci Technol 34:1906–1913CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Furlong ET, Cessar LR, Hites RA (1987) Accumulation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in acid sensitive lakes. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 51:2965–2975CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Galloway JN, Likens GE (1979) Atmospheric enhancement of metal deposition in Adirondack lake sediments. Limnol Oceanogr 24:427–433Google Scholar
  25. Golden Software (1999) SURFER 7, 7. Golden Software Inc., ColoradoGoogle Scholar
  26. Hakanson L (1977) The influence of wind, fetch, and water depth of the distribution of sediments in Lake Vanern, Sweden. Can J Earth Sci 14:397–412Google Scholar
  27. Hakanson L, Jansson M (1983) Principles of lake sedimentology. Springer-Verlag, BerlinGoogle Scholar
  28. Hilton J (1985) A conceptual framework for predicting the occurrence of sediment focusing and sediment redistribution in small lakes. Limnol Oceanogr 30:1131–1143Google Scholar
  29. Hilton J, Gibbs MM (1984/1985) The horizontal distribution of major elements and organic matter in the sediment of Esthwaite Water, England. Chem Geol 47:57–83Google Scholar
  30. Hilton J, Lishman JP, Allen PV (1986) The dominant process of sediment distribution and focusing in a small, eutrophic, monomictic lake. Limnol Oceanogr 31:125–133Google Scholar
  31. Johansson K (1989) Metals in sediment of lakes in Northern Sweden. Water Air Soil Pollut 47:441–455CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Jordan P, Rippey B, Anderson NJ (2001) Modelling diffuse phosphorus loads from land to freshwater using the sedimentary record. Environ Sci Technol 35:815–819CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Lamborg CH, Fitzgerald WF, Dumman AWH, Benoit JM, Balcom PH, Engstrom DR (2002) Modern and historic atmospheric mercury fluxes in both hemispheres: global and regional mercury cycling implications. Global Biogeochem Cycles 16:1104. doi:10.1029/2001GB001847 Google Scholar
  34. Landers DH, Gubala C, Verta M, Lucotte M, Johansson K, Vlasova T, Lockhart WL (1998) Using lake sediment mercury flux ratios to evaluate the regional and continental dimensions of mercury deposition in Arctic and boreal ecosystems. Atmos Environ 32:919–928CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Malmquist C, Binder R, Renberg I, van Bavel B, Karlsson E, Anderson NJ, Tysklind M (2003) Time trends of selected persistent organic pollutants in lake sediments from Greenland. Environ Sci Technol 37:4319–4324CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Menounos B (1997) The water content of lake sediments and its relationship to other physical parameters: an alpine case study. The Holocene 7:207–212CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Meybeck M (1995) Global distribution of lakes. In: Lerman A, Imboden DM, Gat JR (eds) Physics and chemistry of lakes. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp 1–35Google Scholar
  38. Mulholland PJ, Elwood JW (1982) The role of lake and reservoir sediments as sinks in the perturbed global carbon cycle. Tellus 34:490–499CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Murphy J, Riley JP (1958) A single solution method for the determination of soluble phosphate in sea water. J Mar Biol Assoc UK 37:9–14CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Murphy J, Riley JP (1962) A modified single-solution method for the determination of phosphate in natural waters. Anal Chim Acta 27:31–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Renberg I (1986) Concentration and annual accumulation values of heavy metals in lake sediments: their significance in studies of the history of heavy metal pollution. Hydrobiologia 143:379–385CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Renberg I (1990) The HON-Kajak sediment corer. J Paleolimnol 6:167–170Google Scholar
  43. Renberg I, Brannvall M-L, Bindler R, Emteryd O (2002) Stable lead isotopes and lake sediments – a useful combination for the study of atmospheric lead pollution history. Sci Total Environ 292:45–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Rippey B, Anderson NJ (1996) Reconstruction of lake phosphorus loading and dynamics using the sedimentary record. Environ Sci Technol 30:1786–1788CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Rippey B, Douglas RW (2004) Reconstructing regional-scale lead contamination of the atmosphere (1850–1980) in the United Kingdom and Ireland using lake sediments. Global Geochem Cycles 18:GB4026. doi:10.1029/2004GB002305, 2004
  46. Rippey B, Murphy JM, Kyle SW (1982) Anthropogenically derived changes in the sedimentary flux of Mg, Cr, Ni, Cu, Zn, Hg, and P in Lough Neagh, Northern Ireland. Environ Sci Technol 16:23–30CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Rippey B, Doe S, McElarney Y, Neale M, Hale P, Crone V (2001) Classification of lakes and communities of phytoplankton, macrophytes and littoral macroinvertebrates. TemaNord 584:69–73Google Scholar
  48. Rowan DJ, Kalff J (1993) Predicting sediment metal concentrations in lakes without point sources. Water Air Soil Pollut 66:145–161CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Rowan DJ, Kalff J, Rasmussen JB (1992) Estimating the mud deposition boundary depth in lakes from wave theory. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 49:2490–2497Google Scholar
  50. Rowan DJ, Cornett RJ, King K, Risto B (1995a) Sediment focusing and 210Pb dating: a new approach. J Paleolimnol 13:107–118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Rowan DJ, Rasmussen JB, Kalff J (1995b) Optimal allocation of sampling effort in lake sediment studies. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 52:2146–2158CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Semkin RG, Kramer JR (1976) Sediment geochemistry of Sudbury-area lakes. Can Mineral 14:73–90Google Scholar
  53. Simpson HJ, Bopp RF, Deck BL, Larsen RJ (1984) Regional accumulation amounts per unit area of persistent pollutants derived from analyses of recent sediments. Mem Soc Geol Italy 27:423–445Google Scholar
  54. Stephenson M, Schwarta WJ, Motycka MF, Rowan DJ, Kelley C, Roshon RD (1995) Fate and distribution in sediments of carbon-14 added to Canadian Shield lakes of differing trophic state. Limnol Oceanogr 40:779–790CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Sutherland RA (1998) Loss-on-ignition of organic matter and relationships to organic carbon in fluvial sediments. Hydrobiologia 389:153–167CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Swain EB, Engstrom DR, Brigham ME, Henning TA, Brezonik PL (1992) Increasing rates of atmospheric mercury deposition in midcontinental North America. Science 257:784–787CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Yang H, Rose NL, Battarbee RW, Monteith D (2002) Trace metal distribution in the sediments of the whole lake basin for Lochnagar, Scotland: a palaeolimnological assessment. Hydrobiologia 479:51–61CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2007

Authors and Affiliations

  • Brian Rippey
    • 1
  • N. John Anderson
    • 2
  • Ingemar Renberg
    • 3
  • Tom Korsman
    • 3
  1. 1.School of Environmental SciencesUniversity of UlsterColeraineUK
  2. 2.Department of GeographyLoughborough UniversityLoughboroughUK
  3. 3.Department of Ecology and Environmental ScienceUmeå UniversityUmeåSweden

Personalised recommendations