Epithelial Plasticity During Human Breast Morphogenesis and Cancer Progression
Understanding the complex events leading to formation of an epithelial-based organ such as the breast requires a detailed insight into the crosstalk between epithelial and stromal compartments. These interactions occur both through heterotypic cellular interactions and between cells and matrix components. While in vivo models may partially capture these complex interactions, there is a need for in- vitro models to study these events. In this review we discuss cell-cell interactions in breast development focusing on the stem cell niche and branching morphogenesis. Given the recent understanding that the basic developmental events underlying branching morphogenesis are closely related to pathways important to cancer progression, i.e. epithelial plasticity and epithelial to mesenchymal transition (EMT), we will also discuss aspects relevant to cancer progression. In cancer, the adoption of mesenchymal phenotype by the malignant cells allows stromal invasion and subsequent intravasation to blood- or lymphatic vessels, a route that is a prerequisite for metastasis. A number of publications have demonstrated that tumor initiating cells, sometimes referred to as cancer stem cells adapt an EMT phenotype that renders them more resistant to apoptosis and drug therapy. The mechanism behind this phenomenon is currently unknown but this may partially explain relapse in breast cancer patients. Increased understanding of branching morphogenesis in the breast gland and the regulation of EMT and its reverse process mesenchymal to epithelial transition (MET) may hold the keys for future development of methods/drugs that neutralize the invading properties of cancer cells.
Keywords3D cell culture Breast cancer EMT Stem cells Plasticity
Breast endothelial cells
Epithelial to mesenchymal transition
Estrogen receptor α
Fibroblast growth factor
Umbilical vein endothelial cells
Mesenchymal to epithelial transtion
Reconstituted basement membrane
Terminal duct lobular unit
Terminal end bud
Vascular endothelial growth factor
Epithelial cells serve multiple functions in the human body. These include barrier functions (skin, trachea), hormonal secretion (pituitary gland, adrenal glands and Langerhans islands in the pancreas), exocrine secretion (prostate, pancreas, salivary gland, breast gland), absorption, filtration and gas exchange (intestine, kidneys and lungs). To serve its function, epithelial cells have adhesion properties that generate tight layer(s) of squamous, cuboidal or columnar epithelium dependent on location and function within the human body. Due to the immediate exposure of epithelial tissue to external environment cellular remodeling and renewal occurs relatively fast, meaning that new cells are continuously replacing older cells. Epithelial organs therefore contain stem cells that are responsible for the continuous cellular remodeling . Furthermore, it has been suggested that epithelial cancers originate in these stem cells or cells that have acquired stem cell properties [1, 2, 3]. The female breast gland is a unique organ in that most of its development occurs postnatally. The breast gland undergoes repeated cycles of cell proliferation, differentiation and involution from menarche to menopause at which point hormonal signals, or lack thereof, cause cell death by triggering a combination of apoptosis and senescence [4, 5, 6]. These cellular remodeling processes are most prominent during pregnancy and lactation when the breast gland becomes fully differentiated.
The branching nature of the epithelial ducts in the breast requires a level of phenotypic plasticity enabling cells to invade the underlying stroma. Cells need to transit from robust epithelial cell-cell binding to a more mobile state to facilitate migration. The cells can achieve this using distinct mechanisms including collective migration [7, 8] or epithelial to mesenchymal transition (EMT) where leading cells at the tip of the branching structures acquire mesenchymal characteristics that facilitate migration into the surrounding stroma . EMT is a fundamental process in normal embryonic development, particularly during formation of mesoderm, neural crest formation and heart valve development . EMT is also an important process during wound healing. Finally, EMT has been closely linked with breast cancer progression where tumors of certain sub-groups have been demonstrated to be driven by cancer stem cells that have acquired mesenchymal traits that greatly enhances their tumorigenicity and metastatic potential [9, 11, 12]. In this review we will focus on the cellular and molecular mechanisms of breast morphogenesis and EMT and its reversed process mesenchymal to epithelial transition (MET) and how these processes can be recapitulated in stromal-rich three-dimensional cell culture assays. In addition, we will discuss the clinical relevance of EMT, MET and cancer stem cells in breast cancer in terms of diagnostic value, prognosis and therapeutic application.
Normal Mammary Gland Development
In humans, breast glands are similar in both sexes until the onset of puberty. In women, the second phase of development occurs during puberty. This phase is characterized by marked stromal and epithelial proliferation via hormonal stimulation. Estrogen signaling through the estrogen receptor α (ERα) is the primary force driving ductal branching and elongation, while progesterone signaling through its cognate receptor is required for proliferation and terminal differentiation in the TDLU . The epithelial tubes elongate extensively at this stage and undergo more pronounced branching than during the embryonic stage.
The final major developmental phase involves pregnancy and lactation. During pregnancy, further branching occurs and the cells within the TDLUs proliferate extensively to prepare for the final functional stage of lactation. The luminal epithelial cells finally reach their terminally differentiated state during the lactation period. At all other time periods, the luminal epithelial cells are considered to be in an immature, non-functional state. After lactation, the gland undergoes involution, characterized by massive epithelial apoptosis and return to a near pre-pregnancy non-functioning state. It is well established that the duration of the interval between the pubertal stage and first pregnancy is major risk factor for breast cancer. In that regard it has been proposed that repeated hormone stimulation of the stem cell niche in the course of repeated menstrual cycles prior to first pregnancy may be an important early event in breast carcinogenesis . Overall, pregnancy leads to a long-term protective effect against breast cancer, presumably via a depletion of the stem cell reservoir .
The putative mammary epithelial stem cell is responsible for growth, maintenance and late developmental generation and re-generation (at repeated pregnancies) seen through these distinct different phases of early and late development. The mouse mammary stem cell has been fairly well characterized using genetic techniques for tracking and transplantation assays in cleared mammary fat pad model [18, 19]. This cell type, characterized by a Lin−CD29hiCD24+ immunophenotype, can at a single cell level regenerate the mouse mammary epithelium. The immature mammary gland stem cells have been located in the so-called peripheral cap cells of the mouse terminal end buds. Furthermore, in addition to the mammary stem cell, there is evidence for a hierarchical structure within the mammary epithelial tree, with both lobule- and duct-restricted progenitor cells . While progenitor cells exist within the luminal population, these cells and their descendants have a relatively short lifetime in the gland, and are replaced in the course of a few months. The long term repopulating cells within ducts reside in the myoepithelial/basal layer. These cells give rise to transit amplifying cells within both luminal and myoepithelial layers as evidenced using lineage tracing, clonal expansion of cells that express a single reporter fluorochrome .
The growth and branching morphogenesis of breast epithelium is under instructive influences of the surrounding stroma. The breast stroma is composed of collagenous extracellular matrix (ECM) and resident stromal cells including fibroblasts, immune cells, adipocytes and endothelial cells [14, 27]. In contrast, the mouse mammary gland is enclosed by fat tissue with fewer stromal cells in direct contact with epithelial tissue [13, 14] (Fig. 1). Fibroblasts and immune cells are acknowledged as important players in breast morphogenesis and neoplasia [28, 29, 30] while endothelial cells have been largely neglected except in angiogenesis during cancer growth. Fibroblasts are the main producers of ECM and they are also known to secrete growth factors and remodeling proteins such as matrix-metalloproteases (MMPs) that stimulate proliferation and branching morphogenesis of breast epithelium . It has also been shown that priming of mouse tissue with human fibroblasts before implantation of human epithelial xenografts improves the mouse model for studying molecular signals during human breast branching morphogenesis .
Endothelial cells have previously been pictured as passive constituents of the conductive system transporting oxygen and nutrients towards tissues and waste products away. In addition, they have more recently been identified as critical regulators of the stem cell niche and organogenesis in many tissues, such as brain, liver and pancreas [33, 34, 35]. In the prostate, post-castration stimulation with androgens expands the vasculature before epithelial recovery suggesting that endothelial-derived signals may be vital for epithelial growth . We have recently shown that endothelial cells facilitate growth and branching morphogenesis of prostate epithelial cells when cocultured in reconstituted basement membrane (rBM) . Evidence supporting the role of the endothelium in modulating the branching epithelial morphogenesis in the lung has also emerged. Like in the prostate, we have shown that endothelial cells profoundly stimulate growth and branching morphogenesis of lung epithelium in 3D culture. In this assay a basal-like human pulmonary epithelial cell line (VA10) with stem cell properties  undergoes branching morphogenesis when cocultured with endothelial cells. These branching colonies were reminiscent of tubulo-alveolar-like structures . Recently, a critical endothelial- epithelial signaling interaction was reported in a study using a mouse lung model. Recovery of lung tissue following pneumonectomy was shown to be mediated by an endothelial-to-epithelial signaling cascade involving the matrix as an intermediary player. The pulmonary endothelial cells were shown to express and secrete matrix metalloproteinase 14 (MMP14) in response to vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and fibroblast growth factor (FGF) stimulation. The endothelial derived MMP14 contributed by generating EGF-like ligands by cleaving native laminin 5-γ2 in the matrix thus activating EGF receptors (EGFR) expressed on the surface of alveolar epithelial cells .
Analogous to the lung, we have shown that microvessels in a normal human breast are abundant and in close proximity to the epithelial cells of the TDLUs . Studies have confirmed that during the menstrual cycle and pregnancy, vascularity of the normal mammary fluctuates in correlation with hormonal levels . Interaction between human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC) and premalignant breast epithelial cells has been shown to support proliferation of endothelial cells and induce ductal-alveolar branching morphogenesis and hyperplasia of premalignant breast epithelial cells [43, 44]. We have improved the isolation protocol and conditions for long term culture of breast endothelial cells (BRENCs) . Using BRENCs we have developed a novel three dimensional co-culture model, where primary breast endothelial cells are seeded with epithelial cells in 3D rBM. Using this assay we have shown that BRENCs stimulate proliferation of both primary luminal- and myoepithelial cells. Furthermore, the endothelial cells stimulated the growth and cloning efficiency of normal and malignant breast epithelial cell lines and this was contributed by soluble factors .
Cellular and Molecular Alteration During EMT
EMT has in recent years caught the attention of the clinical research community as an intrinsic mechanism in pathogenic processes such as fibrosis and progression of many types of cancer including breast cancer [47, 48, 49]. EMT is a term used to describe morphological change of epithelial cells from regularly arranged cuboidal, columnar or squamous form to a fibroblast or stellate appearance accompanied by increased occurrence of cell protrusions. This transition involves reorganization of the rigidly layered epithelium to a more loosely connected assembly of cells with increased migratory potential. Concurrently, each cell undergoing EMT rearranges its cytoskeleton allowing transformation to the mesenchymal trait resulting in a spindle-like phenotype. In developmental biology, EMT is a well-known theme, especially during gastrulation. Prior to gastrulation, the cell layer at the site of ingression has a typical epithelial arrangement characterized by apico-basal polarity, adherens junction and connection to basement membrane. The ingression is initiated by localized disruption of cell-to-cell adhesion altering cell morphology and causing breakdown of the basal membrane and finally, mass migration of the resulting mesenchymal cells into new territories. The sequence can be reversed as the migrating cells form settlements and new epithelial like layers form in a process often referred to as mesenchymal-to-epithelial transition (MET). Thus, EMT and MET represent recurrent programs enhancing cell and tissue plasticity necessary for the complex tissue remodeling during embryonic development .
One of the critical epithelial characteristics lost during EMT is cell-to-cell adhesion. This property is mediated by adherens junctions that are based on transmembrane proteins including cadherins, connecting adjacent cells via homophilic attachments made by their extracellular domains. Importantly, monitoring a switch from the expression of epithelial cadherin (E-cadherin) to a type of cadherin expressed by neurons and fibroblasts (N-cadherin), is the most commonly used method to assess EMT on a molecular level . Alteration of cell-to-cell contact is also enforced through changes in desmosome expression allowing increased cell mobility. An important feature of EMT is the down-regulation of tight junction proteins including occludin and claudins constituting the trans-epithelial barrier . In the normal tissue, occludin and claudins facilitate strong epithelial binding, and during EMT these proteins are progressively lost. In the breast epithelium, EMT is accompanied by a number of additional cytoskeletal changes including down-regulation of epithelial cytokeratins (CK5/6, CK8, CK14, CK17, CK18 and CK19), upregulation of vimentin, and smooth muscle actin, resulting in cells closely resembling myofibroblasts, a population of fibroblasts important for stromal tissue remodeling that are commonly activated during wound healing . Finally, the EMT process is accompanied by loss of apical-basal polarity and anchoring junctions attaching the cells to the extracellular matrix and/or basement membrane. Cells that have undergone full EMT are practically indistinguishable from stromal fibroblasts .
Extracellular signals triggering EMT may channel through multiple pathways including the transforming growth factor beta (TGFβ), Notch, WNT, hedgehog, receptor tyrosine kinases (RTKs) and nuclear factor kappa-light chain enhancer of activated B-Cells (NFkB) [12, 53]. The most potent extracellular EMT inducer in breast epithelium and breast cancer is TGFß which promotes heterodimerization of TGFß receptors (Type I and II) following binding to the cell surface. TGFß ligand binding further triggers trans-phosphorylation of the cytosolic receptor domain which then enables them to phosphorylate downstream targets, the SMAD proteins. Phosphorylated SMADs dimerize in the cytosol, allowing entry to the nucleus and binding to promoter regions of target genes.
In view of the importance of EMT in promoting pathogenesis, identifying cells that may serve as paracrine source of TGFß or other EMT inducing ligands in cancerous or fibrotic tissue is being increasingly emphasized. Likely candidates include leukocytes, platelets, endothelial cells and cancer associated fibroblasts (CAFs) [54, 55, 56, 57]. Immunohistochemical staining in breast cancer suggests that the microvessels in the vicinity of invading cancer cells may be a critical factor for adapting an EMT phenotype although the paracrine mechanisms contributing to this effect have not been fully elucidated .
The ability of TGFß to confer EMT seems to be context specific and in some models epithelial cells are susceptible to other factors. For instance, contact dependent activation of the Notch pathway through the ligand Jagged 2 has been shown to induce EMT in colorectal cancer cells that do not adapt the phenotype in response to TGFß treatment [58, 59]. The importance of Notch signaling in breast cancer is supported by studies showing up-regulation of Notch genes in metastases of the brain and clinical studies showing increased mortality in patients with high level co-expression of Notch and JAG1 in the tumors [59, 60, 61].
The canonical Wnt signaling pathway is directly related to the regulation of E-cadherin adhesion properties through control of its stabilizing partner ß-catenin. ß-catenin also functions as a transcription factor that can quickly transfer from cytosol to the nucleus in response to WNT signals where it activates promoters of target genes by displacing the co-repressor Groucho . Wnt signaling molecules bind to the Frizzled family of receptors that associates with various co-receptors depending on ligand and cell type. The signal is further channeled to the cytosol through the canonical pathway affecting proteolytic control of ß-catenin or the non-canonical pathway that is independent of ß-catenin. These different pathways ultimately control transcriptional regulatory factors such as beta-catenin, SNAIL, SLUG, TWIST, ZEB1 and ZEB2 leading to increased expression of mesenchymal and decreased expression of epithelial markers .
MicroRNAs (miRNAs) have been implicated at several levels to be involved in the regulation of EMT . Although a number of miRNAs have been shown to participate in EMT the miRNA-200 family is probably the best known . The miR-200 family is an important regulator of epithelial integrity and loss of its expression is strongly associated with EMT. MiR-200 is a repressor of ZEB1 and ZEB2 that are the main EMT transcription factors that down regulate E-cadherin . Recently, we demonstrated that miR-200c-141 induced MET when overexpressed in D492M. Furthermore, we also demonstrated that ectopic expression of miR-200c-141 in D492 and D492M prevented endothelial induced EMT. Thus, the miR-200 family and miR-200c-141 in particular are important caretakers of epithelial integrity in the human breast gland .
In a recent study we demonstrated that Sprouty-2 a conserved negative feedback regulator of receptor tyrosine kinases affected branching morphogenesis and EMT of D492 cells in 3D culture. In this study we showed that knocking down Sprouty-2 in D492 resulted in large hyperplasia-like branching structure and in coculture with endothelial cells almost all colonies displayed mesenchymal phenotype . These data implicate Sprouty-2 as an important regulator in linking branching morphogenesis and EMT together and underlines the importance of 3D cultures in experiments when dealing with spatial and temporal biological events.
Therapeutic Intervention of EMT and Cancer Stem Cell Phenotype
Typically, tissue stem cells proliferate slowly and are therefore more resistant to chemotherapy as many cancer drugs specifically target proliferating cells by inducing DNA damage, causing growth arrest and apoptosis. Survival statistics underlining increased mortality in breast cancer patients with mesenchymal elements in the primary tumor, e.g. triple negative and claudin-low breast cancers, suggests that EMT cells are less sensitive to chemotherapeutic agents. This is further supported by the finding that cell populations displaying an EMT and CSC phenotype are likely to be present within residual breast cancer after conventional chemotherapy .
At present there is not a full understanding of the inherent drug resistance of the EMT phenotype but several mechanisms could be at play. Firstly, the mesenchymal phenotype may be associated with higher expression of drug transporters such as ABCB1 (also known as multidrug resistance protein 1, MDR1) and ABCG2 that actively export cytotoxic drugs. Up-regulation of these protein pumps has been suggested as an important protection mechanism of the cancer stem cells that contribute to treatment failures and relapse. Although the EMT phenotype may be a step closer to stem cell character than the epithelial state, evidence supporting this mechanism is lacking and treatment of patients with ABCB1 inhibitors such as tariquidar and zosuquidar have not improved therapeutic response . Another mechanism of how EMT may contribute to drug resistance includes altered cell cycle dynamics. Cells undergoing EMT may proliferate at lower rates or increase the proportion of quiescent cells, thereby minimizing the damaging effect of drugs targeting DNA. Moreover, EMT may favor migration of the cancer cells to a microenvironment that is not easily targeted by drugs. The blood–brain barrier is a simple example of such a restriction as it inhibits diffusion of macromolecules including the antibody based drug Herceptin. HER2 overexpressing cancer cells transpassing the blood–brain barrier prior to drug administration, possibly as consequence of EMT reprogramming, are thereby left untouched by the drug and may proceed to form metastatic colonies .
In addition to all the above mentioned mechanisms the number of gene expression changes in cells undergoing EMT may also directly involve genes affecting the sensitivity to apoptosis signals. In fact, accumulating data implicates key EMT transcription factors directly in acquisition of chemo- and radio-resistant cancer phenotype. As an example, a study of ovarian cancer cells suggest that key EMT regulatory factors Slug and Snail directly promote both chemo- and radio-resistance by suppressing p53-mediated apoptosis . Snail has also been identified as a critical regulator of EMT in cisplatin-resistant lung cancer cells . In breast cancer, another master EMT regulator, ZEB1, confers resistance to radiation therapy by allowing homologous recombination-dependent DNA repair through stabilization of CHK1. Interestingly, ZEB1 was found to be phosphorylated by ATM which is a key signaling protein in the DNA damage response pathway . ZEB1 has additionally been identified as a mediator of chemo-resistance in models of lung and brain cancer and may therefore be considered a promising therapeutic target [79, 80]. Interestingly, ZEB1 has higher expression in basal-like breast cancer than luminal breast cancer. Basal-like breast cancers seem to have a higher proportion of CSC and they also have increased tendency to undergo EMT .
Since the TGFβ signaling pathway has been extensively linked to carcinogenesis and cancer progression, the pharmaceutical industry has been interested in developing drugs antagonizing its effect . The relatively recent discoveries placing TGFβ at the centre of EMT and formation of metastatic disease further stimulates interest in targeting TGFβ pathways. Some of the recently discovered inhibitors are potentially useful in treating breast cancer e.g. an inhibitor of TGFβ type I and II receptors termed LY2109761 has been shown to reduce the metastatic formation of basal cell-like MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells . Another example is the recently discovered inhibitor EW-7195 that selectively targets the TGFβ type I receptor ALK5. This inhibitor dramatically reduces levels of phoshorylated Smad-2, expression of EMT phenotype and formation of lung metastases in xenograft mouse models following TGFβ stimulation .
Since EMT in normal and cancerous tissue is likely to be dynamically regulated by the epigenetic machinery, therapeutically targeting mechanism involved in regulating the epigenetic machinery is an attractive strategy. It has been shown that drugs (e.g. 5-azacytidine) that suppress normal promoter methylation inhibit EMT. The histone deacetylase inhibitor Panobinostat (LBH589) is being considered for the treatment of triple negative breast cancer and preliminary studies show that the drug prevents EMT in cell lines through its influence on ZEB transcription factors and E-Cadherin. Furthermore, this novel drug inhibits formation of metastasis by the breast cancer cell line MDA-MB-231 [85, 86]. The general effect of histone deacetylation antagonizes EMT by relieving suppression of important promoters including CDH1 (E-cadherin).
The drug Eribulin mesilate that influences microtubule assembly has been shown to improve survival in late-stage breast cancer patients through an unknown mechanism. A recent study suggests that the influence of the drug is mainly through suppression of mesenchymal conversion, further stressing the importance of cytoskeleton reorganization for the completion of EMT .
The anti-diabetic drug metformin, that is known to possess anti-cancer properties is reported to influence EMT. According to a recent study, this effect is probably due to activation of the AMPK pathway that is central to the regulation of energy metabolism and can be triggered by TGFβ signals . A selective inhibitor of AMPK-alpha termed Compound C, abolishes the ability of TGFβ1 to induce apoptosis and EMT . Recently, Hollier et al. demonstrated that FOXC2 transcription factor was efficient in inducing CSC and EMT phenotype in breast cancer cell lines. Interestingly, FOXC2 is expressed at high level in the claudin low breast cancer subtype associated with CSC and EMT phenotype . Furthermore, they show that PDGFR-β is upregulated in FOXC2 induced EMT and that the FDA approved inhibitor of PDFGR, sunitinib reduced growth of CSC and metastasis.
The branching epithelium of the adult female mammary gland undergoes repeated rounds of proliferation, differentiation and apoptosis during each menstruation cycle that is further exaggerated during pregnancy, lactation and involution. This continuous cellular remodeling has highlighted the importance of stem and progenitor cells within the mammary epithelium that provide the glandular epithelium with new functional cells. Furthermore, there is increasing interest in these stem cells, as they are believed to be targets for carcinogenic agents due to their longevity in tissues. It is debatable, however, whether or not it is the stem cells themselves, their progenitors or the more differentiated cells that have acquired stem cell properties and represent the true tumor initiating cells. It is of great importance that we are able learn more about the cellular hierarchy in the mammary gland and how the cross talk between the epithelium and stroma is maintained and how this goes awry during breast cancer progression. The inherent plasticity of the epithelium reflected in its ability to respond to external cues and change phenotype towards mesenchymal morphology via EMT is important, particularly since accumulating evidences implicates EMT in drug resistance and tumor relapse.
This work was supported by grants from Landspitali University Hospital Science Fund, University of Iceland Research Fund, Grant of Excellence from the Icelandic Science and Technology Policy Council-Research fund and “Göngum saman,” a supporting group for breast cancer research in Iceland (www.gongumsaman.is).
- 65.Hilmarsdottir B et al. Functional role of the microRNA-200 family in breast morphogenesis and neoplasia. Genes (Basel). 2014;5(3):804–20.Google Scholar
- 78.Zhang P, et al. ATM-mediated stabilization of ZEB1 promotes DNA damage response and radioresistance through CHK1. Nat Cell Biol. 2014.Google Scholar
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.