Advertisement

Journal of Happiness Studies

, Volume 9, Issue 1, pp 105–138 | Cite as

Autonomy or Dependence – or Both?: Perspectives from Bangladesh

  • Joe Devine
  • Laura Camfield
  • Ian GoughEmail author
Article

Abstract

The idea of personal autonomy is central to many accounts of eudaimonic well-being. Yet it is often criticized as a Western concept celebrating individualism and independence over group obligations and interdependence or dependence. This paper rejects this view and argues that coherent accounts of autonomy must always recognize the interdependence of people in groups, and that autonomy can coexist with substantial relationships of dependence. It illustrates this drawing on evidence from Bangladesh, a poor country usually absent from cross-cultural studies and one where personal relationships of hierarchy and dependence are endemic. Argument and evidence are presented showing the coexistence of personal autonomy and dependence, and the relationship between collective action and autonomy. We also address some of the specific problems encountered in researching autonomy in a social context where it is mainly expressed in relational forms. We conclude that autonomy can be directed toward both personal and social goals, and can be enacted individually, or by participation in groups. Autonomy is a universal psychological need but its expression is always contextual.

Keywords

autonomy Bangladesh eudaimonic wellbeing individualism and collectivism relationships 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Notes

Acknowledgements

We are grateful to Des Gasper, Severine Deneulin, Ed Deci, and an anonymous reviewer for insightful comments on earlier drafts. Thanks also to the leaders of the QoL research in Bangladesh (Kaneta Choudhury and Mohammed Tapan), and the Bangladesh Country team. The support of the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) is gratefully acknowledged. The work was part of the programme of the ESRC.

References

  1. Alkire S., 2002, Valuing Freedoms. Oxford University Press OxfordGoogle Scholar
  2. Alkire S., 2005, Subjective quantitative studies of agency. Social Indicators Research 74: 217–260CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Alkire S., 2006, Measuring individual freedoms and capabilities In Gough I.R., McGregor J.A., (eds.), Well-being in Developing Countries: New Approaches and Research Strategies Cambridge University Press CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  4. Alsop, R. and N. Heinsohn: 2005, ‚Measuring Empowerment in Practice: Structuring Analysis and Framing Indicators’, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3510Google Scholar
  5. Appadurai A., 1986, Is Homo Hierarchicus American Ethnologist 13: 745–761CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Appadurai A., 2004, The capacity to aspire In: Rao V., Walton M., (Eds.), Culture and Public Action Stanford University Press StanfordGoogle Scholar
  7. Archer M., 1988, Culture and Agency Cambridge University Press CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  8. Barrington Moore J., 1978, Injustice Macmillan LondonGoogle Scholar
  9. Bourdieu P., 1977, Outline of a Theory of Practice Cambridge University Press CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  10. Camfield L., McGregor J.A., 2005, Resilience and well-being in developing countries In Ungar M., (eds.), Handbook for Working with Children and Youth: Pathways to Resilience Across Cultures and Contexts Sage Publications Thousand Oaks, CAGoogle Scholar
  11. Camfield, L., K. Choudhury and J. Devine: 2006, ‚Poor but Happy – An exploration of the cultural construction of happiness in Bangladesh’, (Submitted to Journal for Happiness of Studies)Google Scholar
  12. Chirkov V., Ryan R.M., Kim Y., Kaplan U., 2003, Differentiating autonomy from individualism and independence: A self-determination theory perspective on internalization of cultural orientations and well-being Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 84: 97–110CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Chirkov V., Ryan R.M., Willness C., 2005, Cultural context and psychological needs in Canada and Brazil. Testing a self determination approach to the internalization cultural practices, identity and well-being Journal of Cross Cultural Psychology 36: 423–443CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Choudhury, K.: 2005, `Quality of life-Phase 1 Report Bangladesh (rural sites). Wellbeing in Developing Countries Research Group-Bangladesh', Working PaperGoogle Scholar
  15. Choudhury, K.: 2006, ‚Culture and development: the capacity to aspire, Well-being in Developing Countries Research Group-Bangladesh’, Working PaperGoogle Scholar
  16. Christopher J.C., 1999, Situating psychological well-being: Exploring the cultural roots of its theory and research Journal of Counselling and Development 77: 141–52Google Scholar
  17. de Certeau, M.: 1984, The Practice of Everyday Life (S. Rendell, Trans.) (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)Google Scholar
  18. Deci E.L., Ryan R.M., 1985, Intrinsic Motivation and Self-determination in Human Behaviour Plenum New YorkGoogle Scholar
  19. Del Franco, N.: 2005, ‚Biye dewa (being given in marriage) and biye kora (getting married): Adolescent girls’ experiences of marriage: the space for self-assertion’, in SAAG Workshop, University of SussexGoogle Scholar
  20. Del Franco, N.: 2006, `Negotiating adolescence in rural Bangladesh: a journey through school, love and marriage', Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Sussex, UKGoogle Scholar
  21. Devine, J.: 1999, ‚One foot in each boat. The macro politics and micro sociology of NGOs in Bangladesh’, Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of BathGoogle Scholar
  22. Devine J., 2002, Ethnography of a policy process: A case study of land redistribution in Bangladesh Public Administration and Development 22: 403–422CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Devine, J.: 2004, ‚Change and the everyday politics of community based organisations’, Paper presented at Membership Based Organizations of the Poor Workshop, Organized by Cornell-SEWA-WIEGO at Ahmedabad, India, January 2004Google Scholar
  24. Devine, J.: 2006, `NGOs, Politics and Grassroots Mobilisation: Evidence from Bangladesh,' Journal of South Asian Development 1(1), pp. 77–101Google Scholar
  25. Diener E., Suh E., 2000, Culture and Subjective Well-Being MIT Press Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  26. Diener E., Biswas-Diener R., 2004, Psychological empowerment and subjective well-being In: Narayan D., (eds.), Measuring Empowerment: Cross-disciplinary Perspectives World Bank USAGoogle Scholar
  27. Doyal L., Gough I., 1991, A Theory of Human Need MacMillan BasingstokeGoogle Scholar
  28. Dumont L., 1970, Homo Hierarchicus (Chicago University Press, Chicago)Google Scholar
  29. Dworkin G., 1988, The Theory and Practice of Autonomy Cambridge University Press CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  30. Ewing K.P., 1990, The Illusion of Wholeness: Culture, Self and the Experience of Inconsistency Ethos 18: 215–278CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Ewing K.P., 1991, Can psychoanalytic theories explain the Pakistani women? Intrapsychic autonomy and interpersonal engagement in the extended family Ethos 19: 131–160CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Finnis J., 1980, Natural Law and Natural Rights (Clarendon Press, Oxford)Google Scholar
  33. Freire P., 1972, Pedagogy of the Oppressed Penguin HarmondsworthGoogle Scholar
  34. Geertz C., 1984, From the native’s point of view: On the nature of anthropological understanding in: Schweder R., LeVine R., (eds.), Culture Theory: Essays on Mind, Self and Emotion Cambridge University Press Cambridge (pp. 123–136)Google Scholar
  35. Giddens A., 1984, The Constitution of Society Policy Press CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  36. Griffin J., 1996, Value Judgement Oxford University Press OxfordGoogle Scholar
  37. Honderich T., 2005, The Oxford Companion to Philosophy, New Edition Oxford University Press OxfordGoogle Scholar
  38. Kant I., 1948, Groundwork of the metaphysic of morals In Paton H.J., (eds.), The Moral Law Hutchinson University Press LondonGoogle Scholar
  39. Khare R., 1984, The Untouchable as Himself Cambridge University Press CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  40. Lindley R., 1986, Autonomy MacMillan Press LondonGoogle Scholar
  41. Lukes S., 1974, Power. A Radical View MacMillan Press LondonGoogle Scholar
  42. Madhok S., 2005, Autonomy, political literacy and the ‚social woman’: Towards a politics of inclusion in: Bates C., Basu S., (eds.), Rethinking Indian Political Institutions Anthem Press, London (pp. 151–169)Google Scholar
  43. Maloney C., 1988, Behaviour and Poverty in Bangladesh University Press Limited DhakaGoogle Scholar
  44. Markus H.R., Kitayama S., 1991, Culture and the self: Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation Psychological Review 98: 224–253CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Marriot M., 1976, Interpreting Indian Society: A monistic alternative to Dumont’s dualism Journal of Asian Studies 36: 189–195CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Matsumoto D., 1999, Culture and self: An empirical assessment of Markus and Kitayama’s Theory of independent and interdependent self construals Asian Journal of Social Psychology 3: 289–310CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. McGregor J.A., 1994, Village credit and the reproduction of poverty in contemporary Bangladesh (Part IV) in Acheson J., (eds.), Anthropology and Institutional Economics. University Press of America/Society for Economic Anthropology Lanham, Maryland (pp. 261–281)Google Scholar
  48. Murray D.W., 1993, What is the Western concept of the self? On forgetting David Hulme Ethos 21: 3–23CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Nargish, N.: 2004, ‚Purchasing symbolic capital: Middle classes and education in Bangladesh’, Unpublished Dissertation, University of BathGoogle Scholar
  50. Nilsson J., Grafstrom M., Zaman S., Kabir Z.N., 2005, Role and function: Aspects of quality of life of older people in rural Bangladesh Journal of Aging Studies 19: 363–374CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Nussbaum M.C., 2000, Women and Human Development. The Capabilities Approach Cambridge University Press CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  52. Oyserman D., Coon H.M., Kemmelmeier M., 2002, Rethinking individualism and collectivism: Evaluation of theoretical assumptions and meta-analysis Psychological Bulletin 128: 3–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Rahman, L. and V. Rao: 2002, The Relative Impact of Culture, Economics and Public Action on Women’s Agency: A Comparative Analysis of North and South India, Mimeo (London School of Economics and World Bank)Google Scholar
  54. Raz J., 1986, The Morality of Freedom OUP OxfordGoogle Scholar
  55. Robeyns I., 2003, Sen’s capability approach and gender inequality: Selecting relevant capabilities Feminist Economics 9: 61–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Rozin P., 1999, Preadaptation and the puzzles and properties of pleasure in Kahneman D., Diener E., Schwarz N., (eds.), Well-being: The Foundations of Hedonic Psychology Russell Sage Foundation New York (pp. 109–133)Google Scholar
  57. Ryan R.M., Deci E.L., 2000, Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being American Psychologist 55: 68–78CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Ryan R.M., Deci E.L., 2001, On happiness and human potentials: A review of research on hedonic and eudaimonic web-being Annual Review of Psychology 52: 141–166CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Ryff C.D., 1989, Happiness is everything, or is it? Explorations on the meaning of psychological well-being Journal of Personal and Social Psychology 57: 1069–1081CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Schweder R., Bourne E., 1984, Does the concept of the person vary cross culturally? In Schweder R., Levine R., (eds.) Culture Theory Cambridge University Press CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  61. Sen A., 2002, Rationality and Freedom Belknap Press Cambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  62. Uchida Y., Norasakkunit V., Shinobu K., 2004, Cultural constructions of happiness: Theory and empirical evidence Journal of Happiness Studies 5: 223–239CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. White S., 2000, Depoliticising development: The uses and abuses of participation In Pearce J., (eds.), Development, NGOs and Civil Society Oxfam Publication Oxford (pp. 142–156)Google Scholar
  64. White S.C., 1992, Arguing with the Crocodile: Gender and class in Bangladesh Zed books, LondonGoogle Scholar
  65. Wilce J., 1998, Eloquence in Trouble. The Poetics and Politics of Complaint in Bangladesh Oxford University Press OxfordGoogle Scholar
  66. Wolff R., 1970, Defense of Anarchism Harper and Row New YorkGoogle Scholar
  67. Wood G., 2003, Staying secure, staying poor the faustian bargain World Development 31: 455–473CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Wellbeing in Developing Countries, ESRC Research Group (WeD)Univrsity of BathBath, BanesUK

Personalised recommendations