“Group Rights” and Racial Affirmative Action
This article argues against the view that affirmative action is wrong because it involves assigning group rights. First, affirmative action does not have to proceed by assigning rights at all. Second, there are, in fact, legitimate “group rights” both legal and moral; there are collective rights—which are exercised by groups—and membership rights—which are rights people have in virtue of group membership. Third, there are continuing harms that people suffer as blacks and claims to remediation for these harms can fairly treat the (social) property of being black as tracking the victims of those harms. Affirmative action motivated in this way aims to respond to individual wrongs; wrongs that individuals suffer, as it happens, in virtue of their membership in groups. Finally, the main right we have when we are being considered for jobs and places at colleges is that we be treated according to procedures that are morally defensible. Morally acceptable procedures sometimes take account of the fact that a person is a member of a certain social group.
KeywordsAffirmative action Collective rights Diversity Group rights Harm Identitarian harms Identity Membership rights Probabilistic harms Race
I am grateful to J. Angelo Corlett for comments and suggestions on an earlier draft.
- Appiah, Kwame Anthony, and Amy Gutmann. 1996. Color conscious: The political morality of race. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Appiah, Anthony. 2001. Stereotypes and the shaping of identity. In Prejudicial appearances: The logic of American anti-discrimination law, ed. Robert Post, 55–71. Durham: Duke University Press.Google Scholar
- Appiah, Anthony. 2005a. The ethics of identity. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
- Appiah, Anthony. 2005b. Thinking it through. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Corlett, J. Angelo. 1994. The problem of collective moral rights. Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence, 7:242–256.Google Scholar
- Eliot, T.S. 1968. Four quartets. New York: Harcourt.Google Scholar
- Feinberg, Joel. 1987. Harm to others. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Harris-Lacewell, Melissa. 2007. Political science and the study of African American public opinion. In African American perspectives on political science, ed. Wilbur Rich. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
- May, Larry. 1990. The morality of groups: Collective responsibility, group-based harm, and corporate rights. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
- Sterba, James P. 2009. Affirmative action for the future. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar