Product Market Competition and Lobbying Coordination in the U.S. Mobile Telecommunications Industry
- 242 Downloads
This paper empirically investigates market behavior and firms’ lobbying in a unified structural setup. In a sequential game, where firms lobby for regulation before they compete in the product market, we derive a testable measure of lobbying coordination. Applying the setting to the early U.S. cellular services industry, we find that lobbying expenditures, as measured by campaign contributions, and market conduct were consistent with a one-shot Nash equilibrium and that price caps were binding on average. Furthermore, campaign contributions from cellular firms effectively lowered the burden of the price caps and reduced production costs.
Keywordscollusion lobbying price caps regulation rent-seeking interest groups telecommunications
JEL ClassificationD72 L13 L51 L96 C31
We are indebted to Marc Ivaldi and Lars-Hendrik Röller for their advice and to Raja Chakir for discussing aspects of the empirical implementation. We are also grateful to Zava Aydemir, Christopher Klein, Eugenio Miravete, Jennifer Rontganger, Ralph Siebert, and seminar audiences at the WZB, the IUI in Stockholm, the meetings of the EEA, EARIE, IIOC, SEA, and EC-2, as well as three anonymous referees for their comments. The second author would like to thank the IDEI in Toulouse, where part of this paper was completed, for their hospitality. Both authors gratefully acknowledge partial financial support from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft grant number Ro 2080/4. Tomaso Duso also gratefully acknowledges financial support from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft through SFB/TR 15.
- Baron D (1999) Integrated market and nonmarket strategies in client and interest group politics. Bus Polit 1:7–34Google Scholar
- Damania R, Fredriksson PG (2002) Trade policy reform, endogenous lobby group, and environmental policy. J Econ Behav Organ 15:1–23Google Scholar
- Grossman G, Helpman E (1994) Protection for sale. Am Econ Rev 84:833–850Google Scholar
- Olson M (1965) The logic of collective action. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
- Shew WB (1994) Regulation, competition, and prices in the US cellular telephone industry. Working paper, American Enterprise InstituteGoogle Scholar
- The Council of State Governments (1984) The book of the states 1984–1985, vol 25. The Council of State Governments, LexingtonGoogle Scholar
- The Council of State Governments (1986) The book of the states 1986–1987, vol 26. The Council of State Governments, LexingtonGoogle Scholar
- The Council of State Governments (1988) The book of the states 1988–1989, vol 27. The Council of State Governments, LexingtonGoogle Scholar
- US Bureau of Census (1989) Statistical abstract of the United States: 1989, 109th edn. US Bureau of Census, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
- Wisconsin Department of Transportation (1996) State highway maintainance manual. Policies 96.31, 96.41Google Scholar