The Just-So Higgs Story: A Response to Adrian Wüthrich
I give a response to Adrian Wüthrich’s critical review of my analysis of the Higgs mechanism, in which I try to clarify some possible misunderstandings. I concede that, as Wüthrich points out, many physicists see the Higgs mechanism as the roll-over from a symmetrical potential in the initial Lagrangian to a symmetry-breaking potential, while my former analysis had basically focused on the gauge-invariant transformation of the initial Lagrangian into the intended form. My main contention, however, still is that neither Higgs story has (as yet) much explanatory power.
KeywordsHiggs mechanism Gauge invariant account Explanatory power Neutrinos
- Friederich, S. (2012). Gauge symmetry breaking in gauge theories—In search of clarification. European Journal for Philosophy of Science, online first version.Google Scholar
- Murayama, H. (2002). The origin of neutrino mass. Physics World, 5, 35–39.Google Scholar
- Wüthrich, A. (2010). Eating Goldstone bosons in a phase transition: A critical review of Lyre’s analysis of the Higgs mechanism. General Journal for Philosophy of Science, this volume.Google Scholar