Compensating human subjects providing oocytes for stem cell research: 9-year experience and outcomes
Human oocytes are arguably one of the most important cell types in humans, yet they are one of the least investigated cells. Because oocytes are limited in number, the use of high-quality oocytes is almost entirely in reproduction. Furthermore, regulatory hurdles for research on gametes and regulations on funding related to research on gametes present significant obstacles to research and the advancement of reproductive treatments. Here we report the outcomes of the largest compensated oocyte donation program for research in the USA to date, and probably worldwide.
Women who participated in oocyte donation for research between 2008 and 2017 were contacted in a phone interview and completed a standardized questionnaire.
Of 114 participants, 98 oocyte donors completed donation, donating 1787 mature MII oocytes and a total of 86 skin biopsies. Complication rate, including minor complications, of oocyte donation was 8/98, or 8.1%, for which two involved follow-up. Fifty-seven donors answered questions about their experience. Participants were incentivized primarily by money and a desire to help others and reported an overall favorable experience. Most, but not all, human subjects recalled that they had donated for research, and approximately half recalled that their oocytes were being used specifically for stem cell research.
Compensated oocyte donation provides a reliable path to obtaining high-quality oocytes for research and is reviewed favorably by oocyte donors. The continuation of programs that offer compensation for oocyte donation is invaluable to continued progress and advancements in stem cell research and human embryology, and for the advancement of novel reproductive treatments.
KeywordsOocyte donation Stem cells Nuclear transfer Mitochondrial replacement Survey
L. Z. S. was supported by a clinical fellowship in reproductive endocrinology and infertility. DE is a NYSCF-Robertson Investigator. We thank Robin Goland for help with the IRB protocol.
Compliance with ethical standards
Oocyte donation for research skin biopsy donation, and conducting this survey was approved by the Columbia University IRB and filed under protocol AAAI1347.
- 1.2008 Guidelines for gamete and embryo donation: a Practice Committee report. Fertility and sterility 90, S30–44.Google Scholar
- 2.Board, E.S.S.C. Statement of the Empire State Stem Cell Board on the Compensation of Oocyte Donors (NY.Gov).Google Scholar
- 6.Congress, t. H.R.2880—Balanced Budget Downpayment Act. In: I; 1995.Google Scholar
- 9.Harmon K. For sale: human eggs become a research commodity. In Scientific American. 2009.Google Scholar
- 10.Hiltzik M. Should we pay women to donate their eggs for research? No, and here’s why. In Los Angeles Times. 2016.Google Scholar
- 11.Hynes RO, Moreno JD, Price Foley E, Fost N, Horvitz HR, Imbrescia M, et al. Guidelines for human embryonic stem cell research. Washington, D.C.: The National Academies Press; 2005.Google Scholar
- 12.Hyslop LA, Blakeley P, Craven L, Richardson J, Fogarty NM, Fragouli E, et al. Towards clinical application of pronuclear transfer to prevent mitochondrial DNA disease. In: Nature, vol. 534; 2016. p. 383–6.Google Scholar
- 14.ISSCR (2007). Guidelines for the conduct of human embryonic stem cell research. Curr Protoc Stem Cell Biol Appendix 1, Appendix 1A.Google Scholar
- 15.Johannesson B, Sagi I, Gore A, Paull D, Yamada M, Golav-Lev T, LeDuc C, Shen Y, Stern S, Xu N, et al. Comparable frequencies of coding mutations and loss-of-imprinting in human pluripotent cells derived by nuclear transfer and defined factors. Cell stem cell in press. 2014Google Scholar
- 17.Knaub K. Egg donors get pay limits axed with antitrust settlement, law360, ed. 2016Google Scholar
- 18.Kort DH, Chia G, Treff NR, Tanaka AJ, Xing T, Vensand LB, et al. Human embryos commonly form abnormal nuclei during development: a mechanism of DNA damage, embryonic aneuploidy, and developmental arrest. In: Human reproduction. Oxford: England; 2015. p. dev281.Google Scholar
- 19.LEGISLATURE, C. ( ). California code, health and safety code. In HSC § 125355.Google Scholar
- 21.Ma H, O'Neil RC, Marti Gutierrez N, Hariharan M, Zhang ZZ, He Y, et al. Functional human oocytes generated by transfer of polar body genomes. In: Cell stem cell; 2016.Google Scholar
- 24.Panel HER. N.I.o. Health, ed. Bethesda, MD: NIH; 1994.Google Scholar