Should Scientific Research Involving Decapod Crustaceans Require Ethical Review?
Decapod crustaceans are faceless animals with five pairs of legs, an external skeleton and multiple nerve centres (ganglia) rather than a single brain (as in vertebrates). They include common seafood species such as crayfish, crabs, lobsters, prawns and shrimp. These characteristics make them difficult to empathise with and consequently legal protection of decapods ranges from strong (Norway and New Zealand), through circumstantial (Australia and Italy) to non-existent (in many other countries). Whether they are capable of experiencing pain depends on definitions and the requirement for absolute proof of an inherently subjective psychological experience. Yet like other animals, decapods fulfil neuroanatomical, pharmacological and behavioural criteria that are consistent with a pain response. Whether they experience stress, harm and distress is less controversial because these conditions are more measurable than the pain response. To balance animal welfare concerns with scientific merit whilst providing confidence for the growing public awareness of crustacean welfare, use of decapod crustaceans in research should require ethical review.
KeywordsAnimal Decapod Ethics Pain Physiology Nociceptor
The author thanks Robyn Hall, Alison Small and Sharyn Zrna for helpful discussions while writing this manuscript.
- ACT legislation. (1992). http://www.legislation.act.gov.au/a/1992-45/. Accessed 29 May, 2018.
- Animals Australia. (2017). The shocking practice that shows prawn farming is as cruel as factory farming. http://www.animalsaustralia.org/features/prawn-farming.php. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Bioscience Sector. (2009). A bioscience sector response to the house of lords European Union Committee Inquiry: Revision of directive 86/609 on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes. https://wellcome.ac.uk/sites/default/files/wtx055911.pdf. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Birch, J. (2017a). Crabs and lobsters deserve protection from being cooked alive. https://aeon.co/ideas/crabs-and-lobsters-deserve-protection-from-being-cooked-alive. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Birch, J. (2017b). Animal sentience and the precautionary principle. Animal Sentience, 16, 1.Google Scholar
- Birch, J. (2017c). Refining the precautionary framework. Animal Sentience, 16, 20.Google Scholar
- Burnett, N. P., Seabra, R., de Pirro, M., Wethey, D. S., Woodin, S. A., Helmuth, B., et al. (2013). An improved noninvasive method for measuring heartbeat of intertidal animals. Limnology and Oceanography: Methods, 11, 91–100.Google Scholar
- Caines, K. (2017). Court backs lobster cruelty fine against Sydney Fish Markets store. https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/newslocal/central-sydney/court-backs-lobster-cruelty-fine-against-sydney-fish-markets-store/news-story/4ab791afd3d803895eac503b6a49c335. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Crustacean Compassion. (2018). Campaigning for the humane treatment of crabs, lobsters and other decapod crustaceans in the UK. https://www.crustaceancompassion.org.uk/. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Derbyshire, D. (2017). Prawns do feel pain, say scientists. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-492323/Prawns-feel-pain-say-scientists.html. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Deutsche Welle. (2018). Switzerland bans boiling live lobsters in animal welfare reform. http://www.dw.com/en/switzerland-bans-boiling-live-lobsters-in-animal-welfare-reform/a-42104175. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Diarte-Plata, G., Sainz-Hernández, J. C., Aguiñaga-Cruz, J. A., Fierro-Coronado, J. A., Polanco-Torres, A., & Puente-Palazuelos, C. (2012). Eyestalk ablation procedures to minimize pain in the freshwater prawn Macrobrachium americanum. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 140, 172–178.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Elwood, R. W. (2017). Assessing negative and positive evidence for animal pain. Animal Sentience, 16, 21.Google Scholar
- European Parliament and of the Council. (2010). Directive 2010/63/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22 September 2010 on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32010L0063. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Flecknell, P. (2002). Replacement, reduction and refinement. Altex, 19, 73–78.Google Scholar
- Fox News. (2017). Seafood company convicted of animal cruelty for improperly killing lobster. http://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/2017/03/10/seafood-company-convicted-animal-cruelty-for-improperly-killing-lobster.html. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Global Aquaculture Alliance. (2016a). Seajoy’s ablation-free shrimp answers emerging welfare concern. https://www.aquaculturealliance.org/advocate/seajoys-ablation-free-shrimp-answers-emerging-welfare-concern/?PageSpeed=noscript. Accessed 28 May, 2018.
- Global Aquaculture Alliance. (2016b). Stirling researcher preps eyestalk-ablation alternative trials. https://www.aquaculturealliance.org/advocate/stirling-researcher-preps-eyestalk-ablation-alternative-trials/?PageSpeed=noscript. Accessed 28 May, 2018.
- Greenwood, A. (2017). A seafood company killed a lobster—And was convicted of animal cruelty. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/animalia/wp/2017/03/07/a-seafood-company-killed-a-lobster-and-was-convicted-of-animal-cruelty. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- International Association for the Study of Pain. https://www.iasp-pain.org/terminology?navItemNumber=576#Pain. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Key, B., Arlinghaus, R., Browman, H. I., Cooke, S. J., Cowx, I. G., Diggles, B. K., et al. (2017). Problems with equating thermal preference with ‘emotional fever’ and sentience: Comment on ‘Fish can show emotional fever: Stress-induced hyperthermia in zebrafish’ by Rey, et al. (2015). Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 284, 20160681.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- National Health and Medical Research Council. (2013). Australian code for the care and use of animals for scientific purposes. http://www.nhmrc.gov.au/guidelines-publications/ea28. Accessed 28 May, 2018.
- National Research Council of the National Academies. (2011). Guide for the care and use of laboratory animals. https://grants.nih.gov/grants/olaw/guide-for-the-care-and-use-of-laboratory-animals.pdf. Accessed 28 May, 2018.
- New Zealand legislation ‘Animal Welfare Act. (1999). http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/1999/0142/latest/whole.html. Accessed 28 May, 2018.
- Nicholls, S. (2018). Swiss law bans boiling lobsters alive. http://www.euronews.com/2018/01/11/swiss-law-bans-boiling-lobsters-alive. Accessed 29 May, 2018.
- Norway legislation ‘Animal Welfare Act. (2010). https://www.regjeringen.no/en/dokumenter/animal-welfare-act/id571188/. Accessed 25 May, 2018.
- NSW legislation. (1979). NSW Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1979 No 200. https://www.legislation.nsw.gov.au/#/view/act/1979/200/part1/sec4. Accessed 25 May, 2018.
- NT legislation ‘Animal Welfare Act.’ https://legislation.nt.gov.au/Legislation/ANIMAL-WELFARE-ACT. Accessed 25 May, 2018.
- PETA Australia. (2017). Ground-breaking case: Seafood store convicted for cruelty to Lobster. https://www.peta.org.au/news/nicholas-seafood-convicted-cruelty-lobster/. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Queensland legislation. (2001). Animal Care and Protection Act 2001. http://www8.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdb/au/legis/qld/consol_act/acapa2001229/. Accessed 25 May, 2018.
- Queensland legislation. (2012). Animal Care and protection regulation 2012. http://classic.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/qld/consol_reg/acapr2012320/. Accessed 25 May, 2018.
- RSPCA Australia. (2018). What is the most humane way to kill crustaceans for human consumption? http://kb.rspca.org.au/What-is-the-most-humane-way-to-kill-crustaceans-for-human-consumption_625.html. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Seajoy ‘Non Ablation.’ http://www.seajoy.com/index.php/sustainable/non-ablation. Accessed 28 May, 2018.
- Sneddon, L. U., & Leach, M. C. (2016). Anthropomorphic denial of fish pain. Animal Sentience, 3, 28.Google Scholar
- Stelling, T. (2014). Do lobsters and other invertebrates feel pain? New research has some answers. https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/do-lobsters-and-other-invertebrates-feel-pain-new-research-has-some-answers/2014/03/07/f026ea9e-9e59-11e3-b8d8-94577ff66b28_story.html. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Stevens, E. D., Arlinghaus, R., Browman, H. I., Cooke, S. J., Cowx, I. G., Diggles, B. K., et al. (2016). Stress is not pain. Comment on Elwood and Adams (2015) ‘Electric shock causes physiological stress responses in shore crabs, consistent with prediction of pain’. Biology Letters, 12, 20151006.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Stevens, E. D., & Diggles, B. K. (2016). Stress must not be confused with pain. http://atlasofscience.org/stress-must-not-be-confused-with-pain/. Accessed 30 May, 2018.
- Tannenbaum, J., & Bennett, B. T. (2015). Russell and Burch’s 3Rs then and now: The need for clarity in definition and purpose. Journal of the American Association for Laboratory Animal Science, 54, 120–132.Google Scholar
- The Fish Site. (2016). Will ablation-free shrimp become a reality? https://thefishsite.com/articles/will-ablationfree-shrimp-become-a-reality. Accessed 28 May, 2018.
- Tomlinson, M. (2018). Open letter to Rt Hon Michael Gove MP. https://www.crustaceancompassion.org.uk/. Accessed 28 May, 2018.
- Victoria legislation. (1986). Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1986. http://www5.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/vic/consol_act/poctaa1986360/index.html. Accessed 25 May, 2018.
- Zhou, N. (2017). Sydney fishmonger convicted of animal cruelty over lobster treatment. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/feb/15/sydney-fishmonger-convicted-of-animal-cruelty-over-lobster-treatment. Accessed 30 May, 2018.