Advertisement

Field Deaths in Plant Agriculture

  • Bob FischerEmail author
  • Andy Lamey
Articles

Abstract

We know that animals are harmed in plant production. Unfortunately, though, we know very little about the scale of the problem. This matters for two reasons. First, we can’t decide how many resources to devote to the problem without a better sense of its scope. Second, this information shortage throws a wrench in arguments for veganism, since it’s always possible that a diet that contains animal products is complicit in fewer deaths than a diet that avoids them. In this paper, then, we have two aims: first, we want to collect and analyze all the available information about animal death associated with plant agriculture; second, we try to show just how difficult it’s to come up with a plausible estimate of how many animals are killed by plant agriculture, and not just because of a lack of empirical information. Additionally, we show that there are significant philosophical questions associated with interpreting the available data—questions such that different answers generate dramatically different estimates of the scope of the problem. Finally, we document current trends in plant agriculture that cause little or no collateral harm to animals, trends which suggest that field animal deaths are a historically contingent problem that in future may be reduced or eliminated altogether.

Keywords

Field animals Plant agriculture New omnivorism Steven Davis Mike Archer 

References

  1. Albers, P. H., Linder, G., & Nichols, J. D. (1990). Effects of tillage practices and carbofuran exposure on small mammals. The Journal of Wildlife Management, 54(1), 135–142.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. All Animals Australia. (2014). Debunking ordering the vegetarian meal? There’s more animal blood on your hands. All Animals Australia. https://allanimalsaustralia.wordpress.com/2014/11/12/debunking-ordering-the-vegetarian-meal-theres-more-animal-blood-on-your-hands/.
  3. American Bird Conservancy. (2017). Protect birds from pesticides. https://abcbirds.org/program/pesticides/.
  4. Animal Liberation South Australia. (2014a). Archer’s dodgy claims I … health advice.” Animal Liberation South Australia. Accessed 26 Sept. http://www.animalliberation.org.au/blog/2014/9/1/archers-dodgy-claims-i-health-advice.
  5. Animal Liberation South Australia. (2014b). Archer’s dodgy claims II … land use.” Animal Liberation South Australia. Accessed 26 Sept. http://www.animalliberation.org.au/blog/2014/9/1/archers-dodgy-claims-ii-land-use.
  6. Animal Liberation South Australia. (2014c). Archer’s dodgy claims III … mouse deaths. Animal Liberation South Australia. Accessed 26 Sept. http://www.animalliberation.org.au/blog/2014/9/1/archers-dodgy-claims-iii-mouse-deaths.
  7. Archer, M. (2011a). Slaughter of the singing sentients: Measuring the morality of eating red meat. Australian Zoologist, 35(4), 979.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Archer, M. (2011b). Ordering the vegetarian meal? There’s more animal blood on your hands. The Conversation. Accessed 25 Sept. http://theconversation.com/ordering-the-vegetarian-meal-theres-more-animal-blood-on-your-hands-4659.
  9. Australian Export Grains Innovation Centre. (2016). Australian grain production—A snapshot. Accessed 22 August. http://aegic.org.au/australian-grain-production-a-snapshot/.
  10. Australian Government: Department of Agriculture and Water Resources. (2017). Wheat. Accessed 25 September. http://www.agriculture.gov.au:80/ag-farm-food/crops/wheat.
  11. Bollinger, E., Bollinger, P. B., & Gavin, T. A. (1990). Effects of hay-cropping on eastern populations of the bobolink. Wildlife Society Bulletin (1973–2006), 18(2), 142–150.Google Scholar
  12. Bruckner, D. (2015). Strict vegetarianism is immoral. In B. Bramble & B. Fischer (Eds.), The moral complexities of eating meat. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  13. Cahoone, L. (2009). Hunting as a moral good. Environmental Values, 18, 67–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Calvert, A., Bishop, C., Elliot, R., Krebs, E., Kydd, T., Machtans, C., et al. (2013). A synthesis of human-related avian mortality in Canada. Avian Conservation and Ecology, 8(2), 1–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Carruthers, P. (2007). Invertebrate minds: A challenge for ethical theory. The Journal of Ethics, 11, 275–297.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Castrale, J. S. (1985). Responses of wildlife to various tillage conditions. Transactions of the North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference (USA), 50, 142–156.Google Scholar
  17. Caughley, J., Bomford, M., Parker, B., Sinclair, R., Griffiths, J., & Kelly, D. (1998). Managing vertebrate pests: Rodents. Canberra: Bureau of Resource Sciences.Google Scholar
  18. Cavia, R., Villafañe, I. E. G., Cittadino, E. A., Bilenca, D. N., Miño, M. H., & Busch, M. (2005). Effects of cereal harvest on abundance and spatial distribution of the rodent Akodon azarae in central Argentina. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 107(1), 95–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Cholbi, M. (2017). The Euthanasia of companion animals. In C. Overall (Ed.), Pets and People: The Ethics of our Relationships with Companion Animals (pp. 264–278). Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  20. Cochrane, A. (2012). Animal rights without liberation: Applied ethics and human obligations. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
  21. Corliss, R. (2002). Should we all be vegetarians? Time.Google Scholar
  22. Davis, S. L. (2003). The least harm principle may require that humans consume a diet containing large herbivores, not a vegan diet. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 16(4), 387–394.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Elder, M., & Fischer, B. (2017) Focus on Fish: A Call to Effective Altruists. Essays in Philosophy.  https://doi.org/10.7710/1526-0569.1567.Google Scholar
  24. Elvers, B. (Ed.). (2017). Ullmann’s food and feed (Vol. 2). Weinheim: Wiley.Google Scholar
  25. Environmental Protection Agency. (1975). Fish kills caused by pollution: Fifteen-year summary 1961–1975. Washington, DC: Environmental Protection Agency.Google Scholar
  26. Fagerstone, K. A., & Ramey, C. A. (1996). Rodents and lagomorphs. In P. R. Kausmann (Ed.), Range wildlife. Denver, CO: The Society of Range Management.Google Scholar
  27. Flegenheimer, M. (2013). As rats escape death, MTA turns to sterilization. New York: The New York Times.Google Scholar
  28. Fleharty, E. D., & Navo, K. W. (1983). Irrigated cornfields as habitat for small mammals in the sandsage prairie region of Western Kansas. Journal of Mammalogy, 64(3), 367–379.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Getz, L. L., & Brighty, E. (1986). Potential effects of small mammals in high-intensity agricultural systems in east-central Illinois, USA. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 15(1), 39–50.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Gianessi, L. (2014). Importance of herbicides for no-till agriculture in South America. Washington, DC: Croplife Foundation. https://croplife.org/case-study/importance-of-herbicides-for-no-till-agriculture-in-south-america/.
  31. Horta, O. (2010). Debunking the idyllic view of natural processes: Population dynamics and suffering in the wild. Telos, 17, 73–88.Google Scholar
  32. Jacob, J., & Hempel, N. (2003). Effects of farming practices on spatial behaviour of common voles. Journal of Ethology, 21(1), 67.Google Scholar
  33. Jensen, R. A., Wisz, M. S., & Madsen, J. (2008). Prioritizing refuge sites for migratory geese to alleviate conflicts with agriculture. Biological Conservation, 141(7), 1806–1818.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Johnson, D. R. (1987). Effect of alternative tillage systems on rodent density in the palouse region. Northwest Science, 61(1), 37–40.Google Scholar
  35. Kertész, Á., & Madarász, B. (2014). Conservation agriculture in Europe. International Soil and Water Conservation Research, 2(1), 91–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Klein, C., & Barron, A. (2016). Insects have the capacity for subjective experience. Animal Sentience9(1).Google Scholar
  37. Lamey, A. (2007). Food fight! Davis versus regan on the ethics of eating beef. Journal of Social Philosophy, 38(2), 331–348.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Lamey, A. (forthcoming). Duty and the beast: Should we eat animals in the name of animal rights? Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  39. MacDonald, F. (2015). This indoor farm is 100 times more productive than outdoor fields. ScienceAlert. https://www.sciencealert.com/this-indoor-farm-is-100-times-more-productive-than-an-outdoor-one.
  40. Marcelis, L. F. M., & Hemming, S. (2013). Greenhouse production in The Netherlands. Resource: Engineering & Technology of a Sustainable World, 20(2), 14.Google Scholar
  41. McLeod, R. (2004). Counting the cost: Impact of invasive animals in Australia, 2004. Canberra: Cooperative Research Centre for Pest Animal Control.Google Scholar
  42. McMahan, J. (2002). The ethics of killing: Problems at the margins of life. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  43. Meyers, C. D. (2013). Why it’s morally good to eat (certain kinds of) meat: The case for entomophagy. Southwest Philosophy Review, 29(1), 119–126.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Mineau, P. (2010). Avian mortality from pesticides used in agriculture in Canada. Ottawa: Report: Science and Technology Branch, Environment Canada.Google Scholar
  45. Molteni, M. (2017). NYC’s newest weapon against the rats? Sterilization. Wired. https://www.wired.com/2017/04/nycs-newest-weapon-rats-sterilization/. Accessed 13 June 2018.
  46. Nass, R. D., Hood, G. A., & Lindsey, G. D. (1971). Fate of polynesian rats in hawaiian sugarcane fields during harvest. The Journal of Wildlife Management, 35(2), 353–356.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. New South Wales Government: Department of Primary Industries. (2017). Mouse biology. http://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/biosecurity/vertebrate-pests/pest-animals-in-nsw/mouse-and-mice-plagues/mouse-biology.
  48. Ng, Y.-K. (1995). Towards welfare biology: Evolutionary economics of animal consciousness and suffering. Biology and Philosophy, 10, 255–285.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Nilsson, L., Bunnefeld, N., Persson, J., & Månsson, J. (2016). Large grazing birds and agriculture—Predicting field use of common cranes and implications for crop damage prevention. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 219(Supplement C), 163–170.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Parfit, D. (1984). Reasons and persons. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  51. Pearse, A. S. (1946). Observations on the microfauna of the Duke forest. Ecological Monographs, 16, 127–150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Pech, R., Hood, G., Singleton, G., Salmon, E., Forrester, R., & Brown, P. (1999). Models for predicting plagues of house mice (Mus Domesticus) in Australia. In G. R. Singleton, L. A. Hinds, H. Leirs & Z. Zhang (Eds.), Ecologically-based management of rodent pests (pp. 81–112). Canberra: Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research.Google Scholar
  53. Pinkert, M., Meerbeek, J., Scholten, G., & Jenks, J. (2002). Impact of crop harvest on small mammal populations in brookings county, South Dakota. Proceedings of the South Dakota Academy of Science, 81, 39–45.Google Scholar
  54. Pollan, M. (2002). An animal’s place. New York: The New York Times.Google Scholar
  55. Regan, T. (1983). The case for animal rights. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  56. Sabrosky, C. W. (1952). How many insects are there? In Insects: The yearbook of Agriculture. Washington, D. C.: U. S. Dept. of AgricultureGoogle Scholar
  57. Schedler, G. (2005). Does ethical meat eating maximize utility? Social Theory and Practice, 31(4), 499–511.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Schwer, L. (2011). Small mammal populations in switchgrass stands managed for biomass production compared to hay and corn fields in Kentucky. Master’s. Lexington: University of Kentucky.Google Scholar
  59. Singer, P. (1975). Animal liberation. New York: The New York Review of Books.Google Scholar
  60. Singleton, G. R., Brown, P. R., Pech, R. P., Jacob, J., Mutze, G. J., & Krebs, C. J. (2005). One hundred years of eruptions of house mice in australia—A natural biological curio. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 84(3), 617–627.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Smart Floating Farms. (2017). Smart floating farms. http://smartfloatingfarms.com/.
  62. Solomon, M. (2016). The final days of hawaiian sugar. NPR.Org. Accessed 26 Sept. http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2016/12/17/505861855/the-final-days-of-hawaiian-sugar.
  63. Strasser, A.-R. (2014). The weird and wonderful world of indoor farming. ThinkProgress. Accessed 26 Sept. https://thinkprogress.org/the-weird-and-wonderful-world-of-indoor-farming-333b6a12cdec/.
  64. Tew, T. E., & Macdonald, D. W. (1993). The effects of harvest on arable wood mice apodemus sylvaticus. Biological Conservation, 65(3), 279–283.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Tomasik, B. (2015). The importance of wild animal suffering. Relations, 3(2), 133–152.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Tye, M. (2017). Tense Bees and Shell-Shocked Crabs. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. UCLA. (1994). UCLA animal care and use training manual. NewYork: UCLA Office for the Protection of Research Subjects.Google Scholar
  68. USDA. (2014). Pesticide use in U.S. agriculture: 21 Selected crops, 19602008. https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/publications/43854/46734_eib124.pdf?v=41830.
  69. Visak, T., & Garner, R. (2015). The ethics of killing animals. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Wegner, J., & Merriam, G. (1990). Use of spatial elements in a farmland mosaic by a woodland rodent. Biological Conservation, 54(3), 263–276.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Wang, F. K.-H. (2016). Hawaii’s last sugar plantation finishes its final harvest. NBC News. Accessed 26 Sept. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/asian-america/hawaii-s-last-sugar-plantation-finishes-its-final-harvest-n695396.
  72. Warburton, D. B., & Klimstra, W. D. (1984). Wildlife use of no-till and conventionally tilled corn fields. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 39(5), 327–330.Google Scholar
  73. White, J., Hoskins, K., & Wilson, J. (1998). The control of rodent damage in Australian macadamia orchards by manipulation of adjacent non-crop habitats. Crop Protection, 17(4), 353–357.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Witmer, G. (2007). The ecology of vertebrate pests and integrated pest management (IPM). USDA National Wildlife Research Center—Staff Publications, Paper 730. Available at http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/icwdm_usdanwrc/730.
  75. Young, R. (1984). Response of small mammals to no-till agriculture in southwestern Iowa. M.S. Thesis, Ames: University of Iowa.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V., part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of PhilosophyTexas State UniversitySan MarcosUSA

Personalised recommendations