A Virtue of Precaution Regarding the Moral Status of Animals with Uncertain Sentience
- 535 Downloads
We address the moral importance of fish, invertebrates such as crustaceans, snails and insects, and other animals about which there is qualified scientific uncertainty about their sentience. We argue that, on a sentientist basis, one can at least say that how such animals fare make ethically significant claims on our character. It is a requirement of a morally decent (or virtuous) person that she at least pays attention to and is cautious regarding the possibly morally relevant aspects of such animals. This involves having a moral stance, in the sense of patterns of perception, such that one notices such animals as being morally relevant in various situations. For the person who does not already consider these animals in this way, this could be a big change in moral psychology, and can be assumed to have behavioural consequences, albeit indeterminate. Character has been largely neglected in the literature, which focuses on act-centred approaches (i.e. that the evidence on sentience supports, or does not support, taking some specific action). We see our character-centred approach as complementary to, not superior to, act-centred approaches. Our approach has the advantage of allowing us to make ethically interesting and practically relevant claims about a wider range of cases, but it has the drawback of providing less specific action guidance.
KeywordsEthics Insects Invertebrates Fish Pain Sentience
We are grateful to Oscar Horta, Brian Tomasik, Bengt Brülde, Dorna Behdadi, Ragnar Francén, Peter Singer and especially Joakim Sandberg for generous feedback on earlier versions of this paper. We also thank Benjamin Martens and Gordon Hanzmann-Johnson for improving the English of earlier versions of the paper.
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
- Broom, D. M. (2013). The welfare of invertebrate animals such as insects, spiders, snails, and worms. In T. A. van der Kemp & M. Lachance (Eds.), Animal suffering: From science to law (pp. 135–152). Paris: Éditions Yvon Blais.Google Scholar
- Dennett, D. C. (1991). Consciousness explained. Boston: Little, Brown and Co.Google Scholar
- Entomological Society of America (ESA). (2010). Frequently asked questions on entomology. http://www.entsoc.org/resources/faq/#triv1. Accessed June 21, 2016.
- Gren, J. (2004). Applying utilitarianism: The problem of practical action-guidance (PhD dissertation). University of Gothenburg.Google Scholar
- Hölldobler, B., & Wilson, E. O. (2009). The superorganism: The beauty, elegance, and strangeness of insect societies. New York: W.W. Norton.Google Scholar
- Hopkin, S. P. (1997). Biology of the springtails: (Insecta: Collembola). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Horta, O. (2010). Disvalue in nature and intervention. Pensata Animal, 34.Google Scholar
- Horvath, K., Angeletti, D., Nascetti, G., & Carere, C. (2013). Invertebrate welfare: An overlooked issue. Annali dell’Istituto Superiore di Sanità, 49(1), 9–17.Google Scholar
- Hume, D. (1978). A treatise of human nature (2nd ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Lockwood, J. A. (2011). Do bugs feel pain? OUPblog. http://blog.oup.com/2011/11/bug-pain/. Accessed June 20, 2016.
- Slote, M. (1992). From morality to virtue. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Sømme, L. (2005). Sentience and pain in invertebrates (Report to Norwegian Scientific Committee for Food Safety, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Dept. of Animal and Aquacultural Sciences.).Google Scholar
- Taurek, J. M. (1977). Should the numbers count? Philosophy & Public Affairs, 6(4), 293–316.Google Scholar
- Tomasik, B. (2016a). The importance of insect suffering. Essays on Reducing Suffering. http://reducing-suffering.org/the-importance-of-insect-suffering/. Accessed June 20, 2016.
- Tomasik, B. (2016b). Convert grass lawns to gravel to reduce insect suffering. Essays on Reducing Suffering. http://reducing-suffering.org/convert-grass-lawns-to-gravel-to-reduce-insect-suffering/. Accessed June 20, 2016.
- Tomasik, B. (2016c). Is brain size morally relevant? Essays on Reducing Suffering. http://reducing-suffering.org/is-brain-size-morally-relevant/. Accessed June 21, 2016.
- Tomasik, B. (2016d). Humane insecticides. Essays on Reducing Suffering. http://reducing-suffering.org/humane-insecticides/. Accessed June 21, 2016.
- Urmson, J. O. (1973). Aristotle’s doctrine of the mean. American Philosophical Quarterly, 10(3), 223–230.Google Scholar
- Wigglesworth, V. B. (1980). Do insects feel pain? Antenna, 4, 8–9.Google Scholar
- Williams, C. B. (1964). Patterns in the balance of nature: And related problems in quantitative ecology. New York: Academic Press.Google Scholar