Mulesing and Animal Ethics

Articles

Abstract

People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) called for a ban on mulesing in the Australian sheep industry in 2004. Mulesing is a surgical procedure that removes wool-bearing skin from the tail and breech area of sheep in order to prevent flystrike (cutaneous myiasis). Flystrike occurs when flies lay their eggs in soiled areas of wool on the sheep and can be fatal for the sheep host. PETA claimed that mulesing subjects sheep to unnecessary pain and suffering and took action against the Australian wool industry that resulted in a number of international clothing retailers choosing not to use Australian wool. Although the Australian sheep industry agreed to phase out mulesing in 2010, there is some uncertainty as to whether this deadline will be achieved. The changing social ethic towards animal welfare suggests that the way the Australian sheep industry manages the phase out of mulesing in 2010 is vital to its future survival and success. It is likely that if mulesing does not cease in 2010 there will be a negative market reaction to Australian wool and the risk of legislation to ban mulesing. To avoid losing control of its animal welfare strategy, the Australian sheep industry should ensure that mulesing is phased out in 2010 and endorse the animal welfare ethic underpinning this change. The industry should also educate farmers and other industry stakeholders in how the changing social ethic for animal welfare can create new market opportunities for wool.

Keywords

Animal welfare Ethics Australia Flystrike Sheep Mulesing 

Notes

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank two anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments on an earlier draft of this paper.

References

  1. Australian Wool Innovation. (2005a). Federal Court sets date for Australian wool industry legal case. AWI. http://www.wool.com/Media-Releases.htm?item=MR_2005APR_11.htm. Accessed August 28 2009.
  2. Australian Wool Innovation. (2005b). PETA’s position totally unclear. AWI. http://www.wool.com/Media-Releases.htm?item=MR_2005AUG_2.htm. Accessed August 28 2009.
  3. Australian Wool Innovation. (2007a). The Australian wool industry and alternatives to mulesing: the facts. AWI, Sydney, NSW. http://www.wool.com.au/mediaLibrary/attachments/Publications/Sheep_health/Mulesing_TheFacts.pdf. Accessed February 2009.
  4. Australian Wool Innovation. (2007b). Australian wool wins historic agreement with PETA on mulesing. AWI, Sydney, NSW. http://www.wool.com/Media-Releases.htm?item=MR_2007JUN_17.htm. Accessed February 2009.
  5. The Hon. Peter Costello MP. (2007). Doorstop interview. Duxton Hotel, Perth, Australia.Google Scholar
  6. Australian Wool Innovation. (2008a). AWI Strategic Plan: 2008/09-2010/11. AWI Ltd, Sydney, NSW. http://www.wool.com.au/mediaLibrary/attachments/Publications/Corporate/StrategicPlan-0809-1011.pdf. Accessed February 2009.
  7. RSPCA Australia. (2008a). Can the RSPCA prosecute farmers for performing painful husbandry procedures without anaesthetic or pain relief? KBPublisher. http://kb.rspca.org.au/Can-the-RSPCA-prosecute-farmers-for-performing-painful-husbandry-procedures-without-anaesthetic-or-p_84.html. Accessed August 28 2009.
  8. Australian Wool Innovation. (2008b). Find out the facts about mulesing. AWI Ltd, Sydney, NSW. http://www.wool.com.au/Mulesing_Alternatives/Background_on_Mulesing/page__9063.aspx. Accessed June 26 2009.
  9. RSPCA Australia. (2008b). What is mulesing and what are the alternatives? KBPublisher. http://kb.rspca.org.au/What-is-mulesing-and-what-are-the-alternatives_113.html. Accessed August 28 2009.
  10. Australian Wool Innovation. (2008c). Progress of Australian Wool Innovation R&D on mulesing alternatives. AWI Ltd, Sydney, NSW. www.wool.com.au/2010. Accessed February 2009.
  11. Akin, C. (2004). The urgent need for a permanent ban on mulesing and live sheep exports in the Australian wool industry based on animal welfare concerns. PETA. http://www.savethesheep.com/report.asp. Accessed February 2009.
  12. Animal Health Australia. (2009). Animal health in Australia 2008. Canberra, Australia: Australian Animal Health Council Ltd. ISBN 978 1 876714 85 7.Google Scholar
  13. Australian Veterinary Association. (2008). Part 10—Sheep and goat health and welfare. Australian Veterinary Association. http://avacms.eseries.hengesystems.com.au/AM/Template.cfm?Section=Policies&Template=/CM/HTMLDisplay.cfm&ContentID=2151. Accessed June 25 2009.
  14. Australian Wool and Sheep Industry Taskforce. (2008). The Australian Wool Industry. AWSIT, New South Wales, Australia. http://www.detmjuke.no/Facts%20about%20Mulesing.pdf. Accessed February 2009.
  15. Australian Wool Innovation. (2007). Strategic plan for Australian wool innovation 2007–2012. Sydney, NSW: AWI.Google Scholar
  16. Australian Wool Innovation and People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. (2007). Agreement between AWI and PETA. http://www.wool.com/mediaLibrary/attachments/Media_Events/MR_300607.pdf. Accessed February 26 2009.
  17. Bell, K., & Sackett, D. (2005). The economic and research implications of managing Merino sheep without mulesing. In 2005 Agribusiness Sheep Updates. Department of Agriculture and Food WA, Perth, WA, p. 4. http://www.agric.wa.gov.au/objtwr/imported_assets/content/aap/sl/welf_02.pdf. Accessed February 2009.
  18. Bennett, R. M. (1996). People’s willingness to pay for farm animal welfare. Animal Welfare, 5, 3–11.Google Scholar
  19. Bowles, V. M., Meeusen, E. N. N. T., Young, A. R., Andrews, A. E., Nash, A. D., & Brandon, M. R. (1996). Vaccination of sheep against larvae of the sheep blowfly (Lucilia cuprina). Vaccine, 14, 1347–1352.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Chapman, R. E. (1993). Progress towards a non-surgical alternative to the Mules operation for the control of blowfly strike. Wool Technology and Sheep Breeding, 41(1), 1–10.Google Scholar
  21. Chapman, R. E., Fell, L. R., & Shutt, D. A. (1994). A comparison of stress in surgically and non-surgically mulesed sheep. Australian Veterinary Journal, 71, 247–249.Google Scholar
  22. Commonwealth of Australia. (1974). Trade practices act. Australia: Commonwealth Consolidated Acts.Google Scholar
  23. Commonwealth of Australia. (2005). Wool industry: Mulesing. The Senate. Hansard, Canberra, Australia. http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/genpdf/chamber/hansards/2005-10-11/0044/hansard_frag.pdf;fileType%3Dapplication%2Fpdf. Accessed August 26 2009.
  24. Cook, D. F., & Steiner, E. C. (1990). Susceptibility of mulesing wounds to oviposition and strike development by the Australian sheep blowfly Lucilia cuprina. Australian Veterinary Journal, 67, 352–355.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Corish, P. (2005). PETA backpeddles from unjustified attack on farmers. National Farmers Federation. http://archive.nff.org.au/pages/nr05/106.html. Accessed February 2009.
  26. Counsell, D. (2001). A benefit-cost analysis of the mules operation to the Australian sheep flock. In Proceedings of FLICS Conference. Launceston, Australia (pp. 369–373).Google Scholar
  27. Cuming, M. (2006). PETA may be down, but it’s not out. Farm Weekly. January 5 2006.Google Scholar
  28. Cuming, M., & Gray, D. (2008). New threat to 2010 mulesing ban. The Age. November 20 2008.Google Scholar
  29. Davidson, B. S., Chaplin, S. J., & Laird, C. (2006). Effect of fibre supplementation on dag formation and flystrike in sheep grazing spring pastures. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture, 46, 783–786.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Dawkins, M. S. (1980). Animal suffering. The science of animal welfare. London: Chapman and Hall Ltd.Google Scholar
  31. Department of Agriculture Fisheries and Forestry. (2007). Animal welfare roles and responsibilities Commonwealth of Australia. http://www.daff.gov.au/animal-plant-health/welfare/aaws/online/roles#community. Accessed June 22 2009.
  32. Department of Agriculture Fisheries and Forestry. (2008). The Australian Animal Welfare Strategy. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.Google Scholar
  33. Dymock, J. J., & Forgie, S. A. (1995). Large-scale trapping of sheep blowflies in the northern North Island of New Zealand using insecticide-free traps. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture, 35(6), 699–704.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Fell, L. R., & Shutt, D. A. (1988). Salivary cortisol and behavioural indicators of stress in sheep. In Proceedings of the Australian Society of Animal Production, 186–189.Google Scholar
  35. Fell, L. R., & Shutt, D. A. (1989). Behavioural and hormonal responses to acute surgical stress in sheep. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 22, 283–294.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Fenton, A., Wall, R., & French, N. P. (1998). The effect of farm management strategies on the incidence of sheep strike in Britain: A simulation analysis. Veterinary Parasitology, 79(3), 341–357.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. French, N., Wall, R., Cripps, P. J., & Morgan, K. L. (1994). Blowfly strike in England and Wales: The relationship between prevalence and farm management factors. Medical and Veterinary Entomology, 8, 51–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Frewer, L. J., Kole, A., Van De Kroon, S. M. A., & De Lauwere, S. (2005). Consumer attitudes towards the development of animal-friendly husbandry systems. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 18, 345–367.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Frewer, L. J., & Salter, B. (2002). Public attitudes, scientific advice and the politics of regulatory policy: The case of BSE. Science and Public Policy, 29, 137–145.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Garran, J. C., & White, L. (1985). Merinos, myths and Macarthurs: Australian graziers and their sheep, 1799–1900. Canberra, ACT: Australian National University Press.Google Scholar
  41. Gherardi, S. G. (2002). Mulesing for flystrike control. Farm note 46/96. Western Australia Department of Agriculture. Perth, WA. http://agspsrv34.agric.wa.gov.au/agency/pubns/farmnote/1996/f04696.htm. Accessed February 2009.
  42. Graham, N. P. H. (1959). The control of fly strike. Wool Technology and Sheep Breeding, 6(2), 111–115.Google Scholar
  43. Greeff, J., & Karlsson, J. (2005). Merino sheep can be bred for resistance to breech strike. In 2005 agribusiness sheep updates. Perth, WA: Department of Agriculture and Food WA.Google Scholar
  44. Greeff, J., Karlsson, J., Slocombe, L., Jones, K., & Underwood, N. (2008). A practical method to select for breech strike resistance in non-pedigreed Merino flocks. In Proceedings of the 2008 Agribusiness Sheep Updates. Department of Agriculture and Food WA, Perth, WA.Google Scholar
  45. Harper, G. C., & Makatouni, A. (2002). Consumer perception of organic food production and farm animal welfare. British Food Journal, 104(3–5), 287–299.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Harrington, S. A., & Steiner, E. C. (1993). Susceptibility of freshly-mulesed lambs to flystrike and the effectiveness of propetamphos as a wound dressing. Australian Veterinary Journal, 70, 190–191.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Harrison, R. (1992). Case study: Animal welfare. In R. J. Berry (Ed.), Environmental dilemmas: Ethics and decisions. London: Chapman & Hall.Google Scholar
  48. Heath, A. C. G. (1994). Ectoparasites of livestock in New Zealand. New Zealand Journal of Zoology, 21, 23–38.Google Scholar
  49. Heath, A. C. G., & Bishop, D. (2006). Flystrike in New Zealand: an overview based on a 16-year study, following the introduction and dispersal of the Australian sheep blowfly, Lucilia cuprina Widermann (Diptera: Calliphoridae). Veterinary Parasitology, 137, 333–344.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Horton, J. D., & Champion, S. C. (2001). Wool producer knowledge of flystrike control. In Proceedings of FLICS Conference. Launceston, Tasmania, Australia.Google Scholar
  51. Hustvedt, G., & Bernard, J. C. (2008). Consumer willingness to pay for sustainable apparel: The influence of labelling for fibre origin and production methods. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 32, 491–498.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Hustvedt, G., Peterson, H. H., & Chen, Y. (2008). Labelling wool products for animal welfare and environmental impact. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 32(5), 427–437.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. James, P. J. (2006). Genetic alternatives to mulesing and tail docking in sheep: A review. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture, 46, 1–18.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Joint Blowfly Committee. (1940). The prevention and treatment of blowfly strike in sheep. Report No. 98. Melbourne: CSIR.Google Scholar
  55. Jones, A. (2001). The cutting edge (an account of mulesing in Tasmania). In Proceedings of FLICS Conference. Launceston, Tasmania, Australia, 357–363. http://www.wool.com.au/awi/flics/PDFs/Chapter_8/Jones_Mulesing_in_Tas.pdf.
  56. Karlsson, L. J. E., Evans, D. L., & Greeff, J. C. (2001). Future options to reduce reliance on surgical mulesing. In Proceedings of FLICS Conference. Launceston, Tasmania, Australia.Google Scholar
  57. Leathwick, D. M., & Atkinson, D. S. (1995) Dagginess and flystrike in lambs grazed on Lotus corniculatus or ryegrass. In Proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Animal Production. New Zealand Society of Animal Production Publications, 196–198.Google Scholar
  58. Lee, C., & Fisher, A. D. (2007). Welfare consequences of mulesing sheep. Australian Veterinary Journal, 85(3), 89–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. MAF. (1996). Code of recommendations and minimum standards for the welfare of sheep. New Zealand Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry.Google Scholar
  60. Makin, M. (2005). AVA welcomes mulesing pain relief. Australian Veterinary Association. St Leonards, New South Wales. http://avacms.eseries.hengesystems.com.au/AM/Template.cfm?Section=Home&TEMPLATE=/CM/ContentDisplay.cfm&CONTENTFILEID=821. Accessed August 2009.
  61. Massey, C. (1990). The Australian Merino. Ringwood, Victoria: Viking O’Neil Penguin Books Australia Ltd.Google Scholar
  62. McLachlan, I., & Pietsch, R. (2005). A declaration of commitments made by the Australian wool and sheep industry taskforce in relation to animal welfare and the phasing out of mulesing. Australian Wool and Sheep Industry Taskforce, www.woolisbest.com.
  63. McMahon, P. R. (1954). Thoughts on the technology of wool production. Wool Technology and Sheep Breeding, 1(1), 87–90.Google Scholar
  64. Morris, M. C. (2000). Ethical issues associated with sheep fly strike research, prevention and control. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 13(3–4), 205–217.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. Morris, M. C. (2005). Tests on a new bait for flies (Diptera: Calliphoridae) causing cutaneous myiasis (flystrike) in sheep. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research, 48(1), 151–156.Google Scholar
  66. Munro, I. (2008). Tarred and fleeced by PETA yarn. The Sydney Morning Herald, 24 May 2008.Google Scholar
  67. Paton, M. (2005). Mulesing accreditation—Vital for wool’s future. In Proceedings of 2005 Agribusiness Sheep Updates. Department of Agriculture and Food WA, Perth, WA.Google Scholar
  68. Paull, D. R., Colditz, I., Lee, C., Atkinson, S. J., & Fisher, A. (2008). Effectiveness of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and epidural anaesthesia in reducing pain and stress responses to a surgical husbandry procedure (mulesing) in sheep. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture, 48, 1034–1039.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. (2004). An examination of two major forms of cruelty in Australian wool production: mulesing and live exports. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals Norfolk, VA. http://www.savethesheep.com/pdf/WoolReport12-04.pdf. Accessed February 2009.
  70. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. (2005a). The Animals: Death “Down Under.” http://www.savethesheep.com/animals.asp. Accessed February 29 2009.
  71. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. (2005b). Group urges retailers to boycott Australian wool until lamb mutilations, live sheep exports end. http://www.peta.org/mc/NewsItem.asp?id=6125. Accessed March 2009.
  72. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. (2007). PETA’s boycott of Australian wool gains ground. http://www.savethesheep.com/f-wool_boycott_update.asp. Accessed June 28 2009.
  73. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. (2008a). H&M, Perry Ellis, Adidas, and Others Boycott Mulesed Wool. http://www.savethesheep.com/f-hm_perryellis_adidas_boycott.asp. Accessed June 26 2009.
  74. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. (2008b). How much do you really know? The six myths of mulesing. http://www.savethesheep.com/f-MuelsingMyths.asp. Accessed September 5 2009.
  75. Phillips, C. J. C. (2009). A review of mulesing and other methods to control flystrike (cutaneous myiasis) in sheep. Animal Welfare, 18, 113–121.Google Scholar
  76. Pratt, M. S., & Hopkins, P. S. (1976). Chemical mulesing of sheep. Wool Technology and Sheep Breeding, 23(2), 26–27.Google Scholar
  77. Primary Industries Standing Committee. (2006). Model code of practice for the welfare of animals: The Sheep. PISC Report 89, Canberra.Google Scholar
  78. Project, The. Mackinnon. (2004). Report on the increased prevalence of breech strike and increased mortalities from flystrike if sheep were not mulesed. Melbourne, Australia: University of Melbourne.Google Scholar
  79. Queensland Department of Primary Industries and Fisheries. (2001). Blowflies and Lice Information Manual. QDPI&F.Google Scholar
  80. Reiman, T. (2009). Something stinks down under. PETA. http://blog.peta.org/archives/2009/07/something_stink.php. Accessed September 5 2009.
  81. Rollin, B. (1990). Animal welfare, animal rights and agriculture. Journal of Animal Science, 68(10), 3456–3461.Google Scholar
  82. Rollin, B. (1995). Farm animal welfare: Social, bioethical and research issues. Ames: Iowa State University Press.Google Scholar
  83. Rollin, B. (2004). Annual meeting keynote address: Animal agriculture and emerging social ethics for agriculture. Journal of Animal Science, 82, 955–964.Google Scholar
  84. Rollin, B. (2006). Animal rights and human morality (3rd ed.). Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books.Google Scholar
  85. Scobie, D. R., O’Connell, D., Morris, C. A., & Hickey, S. M. (2007). A preliminary genetic analysis of breech and tail traits with the aim of improving the welfare of sheep. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research, 58(2), 161–167.Google Scholar
  86. Shiell, K. (2006). Animal Welfare Inventory Report to AAWS—Livestock Production Working Group. http://www.daff.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0014/152105/aaws_stocktake_livestock_prod.pdf. Accessed September 2009.
  87. Shutt, D. A., Fell, L. R., Connell, R., Bell, A. K., Wallace, C. A., & Smith, A. I. (1987). Stress-induced changes in plasma concentrations of immunoreactive β-endorphin and cortisol in response to routine surgical procedures in lambs. Australian Journal of Biological Science, 40, 97–103.Google Scholar
  88. Sinclair, A. N. (2003). Contributions by veterinarians in developing the Mules operation for control of breech flystrike in sheep. The Australian Veterinary History Record, 37, 21–23.Google Scholar
  89. Southwell, A., Bessey, A., & Barker, B. (2006). Attitudes towards animal welfare. Report 90248. Canberra, ACT: Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry.Google Scholar
  90. Steenkamp, J. B. E. M. (1997). Dynamics in consumer behaviour with respect to agriculture and food products. In B. Wierenga, V. A. Tilberg, K. Grunert, J. B. E. M. Steenkamp, & M. Wedel (Eds.), Agricultural marketing and consumer behaviour in a changing world (pp. 207–215). Dordrect: Kluwer.Google Scholar
  91. Tellam, R. L., & Bowles, V. M. (1997). Control of blowfly strike in sheep: Current strategies and future prospects. International Journal for Parasitology, 27(3), 261–273.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  92. Townend, C. (1987). Sheep strike and mulesing. Parasitology Today, 3(1), 68–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Trade Practices Amendment (Small Business Protection) Bill 2007 (Cth).Google Scholar
  94. Tribe, D. E., & Peel, L. J. (1988). Innovation, science and the farmer. Australian Science and Technology Heritage Centre, University of Melbourne. http://www.austehc.unimelb.edu.au/tia/contents.html. Accessed May 2004.
  95. Turner, H. N. (1977). Some aspects of sheep breeding in the tropics. In Animal breeding: Selected articles from the World Animal Review. FAO, Rome.Google Scholar
  96. Verbeke, W., van Oekel, M. J., Warnants, N., Viane, J., & Boucque, C. V. (1999). Consumer perception. Facts and possibilities to improve acceptability of health and sensory characteristics of pork. Meat Sciences, 53, 77–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  97. Ville, S. (1998). Business development in colonial Australia. Australian Economic History Review, 38(1), 16–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Wardhaugh, K. G., & Morton, R. (1990). The incidence of flystrike in sheep in relation to weather conditions, sheep husbandry, and the abundance of the Australian sheep blowfly Lucilia cuprina. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research, 41, 1155–1167.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  99. Watts, J. E., Murray, M. D., & Graham, N. P. H. (1979). The blowfly strike problem of sheep in New South Wales. Australian Veterinary Journal, 55, 325–334.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  100. Wells, A., Blache, D., & Sneddon, J. (Unpublished). What are the salient beliefs of woolgrowers in regards to mulesing? Unpublished working paper. University of Western Australia (available on request from authors).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.The University of Western AustraliaCrawleyAustralia
  2. 2.Department of PhilosophyColorado State UniversityFort CollinsUSA

Personalised recommendations