The Ethics of Ethics Reviews in Global Health Research: Case Studies Applying a New Paradigm
With increasing calls for global health research there is growing concern regarding the ethical challenges encountered by researchers from high-income countries (HICs) working in low or middle-income countries (LMICs). There is a dearth of literature on how to address these challenges in practice. In this article, we conduct a critical analysis of three case studies of research conducted in LMICs. We apply emerging ethical guidelines and principles specific to global health research and offer practical strategies that researchers ought to consider. We present case studies in which Canadian health professional students conducted a health promotion project in a community in Honduras; a research capacity-building program in South Africa, in which Canadian students also worked alongside LMIC partners; and a community-university partnered research capacity-building program in which Ecuadorean graduate students, some working alongside Canadian students, conducted community-based health research projects in Ecuadorean communities. We examine each case, identifying ethical issues that emerged and how new ethical paradigms being promoted could be concretely applied. We conclude that research ethics boards should focus not only on protecting individual integrity and human dignity in health studies but also on beneficence and non-maleficence at the community level, explicitly considering social justice issues and local capacity-building imperatives. We conclude that researchers from HICs interested in global health research must work with LMIC partners to implement collaborative processes for assuring ethical research that respects local knowledge, cultural factors, the social determination of health, community participation and partnership, and making social accountability a paramount concern.
KeywordsGlobal health research ethics Low and middle-income countries Ethical review
- Bhutta, Z. A. (2002). Ethics in international health research: a perspective from the developing world. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 80(2), 114–120.Google Scholar
- Breilh, J. (2009). Science by contract: The science and power relation, Chapter of Technology, Science and Society. In Ecuadorian Constitution (pp. 7-26). Ecuador. Hacia una construccion emancipadora del derecho a la salud. In Programa Andina de Derechos Humanos, compilador. Informe sobre derechos humanos. [Towards emancipatory construction of the right to health. Andean program in human rights] (pp. 263–83). Ecuador: University Andina Simon Bolivar.Google Scholar
- Breilh, J., Spiegel, J. M., & Yassi, A. (2012). Guía para la Evaluación Ética de Proyectos de Investigación No Experimentales. Quito: Academia Ecuatoriana de Medicina.Google Scholar
- Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) (2007). CIHR guidelines for health research involving aboriginal people. Available at http://www.cihr-irsc.gc.ca/e/29134.html
- Cárdenas, O. (2005). Evaluación Comparativa del Parto Vertical y Convencional. Cuenca: Universidad de Cuenca.Google Scholar
- Cash, R., Wikler, D., Saxena, A., & Capron, A., (Eds.) Casebook on Ethical Issues in International Health Research: World Health Organization, Geneva. 2009. Available at http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2009/9789241547727_eng.pdf
- Chandiwana, S., & Ornbjerg, N. (2003). Review of North-South and South-South cooperation and conditions necessary to sustain research capability in developing countries. Journal of Health, Population, and Nutrition, 21(3), 288–297.Google Scholar
- Davis, D. (2007). The secret history of the war on cancer. New York, NY: Basic Books.Google Scholar
- Global Health Research Program (GHRP) UBC (2012). Homepage. www.ghrp.ubc.ca, Website, accessed September 10, 2012.
- Kirkness, V. J., & Barnhardt, R. (2001). First nations and higher education: The four R's - respect, relevance, reciprocity, responsibility. Knowledge across cultures: A contribution to dialogue among civilizations. R. Hayoe and J. Pan. Hong Kong, Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong.Google Scholar
- Lairumbi, G. M., Parker, M., Fitzpatrick, R., & English, M. C. (2012). Forms of benefit sharing in global health research undertaken in resource poor settings: a qualitative study of stakeholders' views in Kenya. Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine, 7(1), 7–15.Google Scholar
- Lavery, J., Tinadana, P., Scott, T., Harrington, L., Ramsey, J., Ytuarte-Nuñez, C., et al. (2010). Towards a framework for community engagement in global health research. Trends in Parasitology, 26(6), 279–283.Google Scholar
- Margolis, C. Z., Deckelbaum, R. J., Henkin, Y., & Alkan, M. (2002). Bringing global issues to medical teaching. The Lancet, 359(9313), 1253–1254.Google Scholar
- Mena, J., Orrego, E., Spiegel, J. M., Rojas-Orrego, T., Orrego, P., & Yassi, A. (2010). Is Progress Always Progressive? Addressing the environmental, social, health and economic concerns of women who make their living from solid waste disposal sites in Ecuador – a multimedia presentation. Paper presented at the EcoHealth 2010 Conference, London, England, 18 - 20 August.Google Scholar
- Mideros, R. (2011). La Atención Intercultural Obstétrica y sus Efectos [Intercultural Obstetric Care and its Effects]. Quito: Universida Andina Simón Bolívar. Thesis in partial fulfillment of Doctorate in Collective Health, Environment and Society.Google Scholar
- O'Donnell, M. R., Jarand, J., Loveday, M., Padayatchi, N., Zelnick, J., Werner, L., et al. (2010). High incidence of hospital admissions with multidrug-resistant and extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis among South African health care workers. Annals of Internal Medicine, 153(8), 516–522.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Parkes, M., Spiegel, J. M., Breilh, J., Cabarcas, F., Huish, R., & Yassi, A. (2009). Building sustainable capacity to promote the health of marginalized populations through international collaboration: Examining community-oriented training innovations in Ecuador. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 87(4), 245–324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Reimer Kirkham, S., & Anderson, J. (2002). Postcolonial nursing scholarship: From epistemology to method. Advances in Nursing Science, 25(1), 1–17.Google Scholar
- Roth, D. (2001). Humanitarian aid and medical research: an illusion of dichotomy in international health. CMAJ Canadian Medical Association Journal, 164(13), 1862–64.Google Scholar
- Sacher, W., & Baez, M. (2011). Revision critica parcial del Estudio de impacto ambiental para la fase de beneficio del Proyecto minero de Cobre Mirador de la empresa Ecuadcorriente, Ecuador. Quito, Ecuador: Accion Ecologica.Google Scholar
- Spiegel, J. M., Bonet, M., Ibarra, A., Pagliccia, N., Ouellette, V., & Yassi, A. (2007a). Social and environmental determinants of Aedes aegypti infestation in Central Havana: Results of a case-control study nested in an integrated dengue surveillance program in Cuba. Tropical Medicine & International Health, 12(4), 503–10.Google Scholar
- Spiegel, J. M., Breilh, J., Parkes, M., Bowie, W., Pearce, L., & Yassi, A. (2007b). UBC’s experience in building partnerships for development in Ecuador – 1. From the top down: Establishing sustainable community-focused networks. Paper presented at the 11th UNESCO-APEID International Conference "Reinventing Higher Education: Toward Participatory and Sustainable Development, Bangkok, Thailand, December 12–14Google Scholar
- Spiegel, J. M., Breilh, J., Beltran, E., Parra, J., Solis, F., Yassi, A., et al. (2011). Establishing a community of practice of researchers, practitioners, policy-makers and communities to sustainably manage environmental health risks in Ecuador. BMC International Health and Human Rights, 11(Suppl 2), S5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- The Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada (2010). The future of medical education in Canada: A collective vision for MD Education. Available at www.afmc.ca/fmec/pdf/collective_vision.pdf (pp. 54). Ottawa, ON, Canada.
- World Health Organization. (2010). A systematic evidence review to support development of policy guidelines for improving health worker access to prevention, treatment, and care services for HIV and TB / prepared for the World Health Organization by Annalee Yassi, Lyndsay M O’Hara, Karen Lockhart, Justin LoChang, Jerry M Spiegel, December 2009. Available from: http://www.who.int/occupational_health/systematic_review_for__treat_policy_final.pdf.
- World Health Organization, International Labour Office, & the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS). (2010). Joint WHO-ILO-UNAIDS policy guidelines on improving health workers’ access to HIV and tuberculosis prevention, treatment, care and support services. Switzerland: WHO. Available from: http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2010/9789241500692_eng.pdfGeneva.Google Scholar
- Yassi, A., Cabarcas, F., Fujii, R., Orrego, E., Silva, F., & Spiegel, J. M. (2007). UBC’s experience in building partnerships for development in Ecuador – 2. From the bottom up: Creating communities of learning and practice. Paper presented at the 11th UNESCO-APEID International Conference "Reinventing Higher Education: Toward Participatory and Sustainable Development", Bangkok, Thailand, December 12-14.Google Scholar
- Yassi, A., Dharamsi, S., Spiegel, J. M., Rojas, A., Dean, E., & Woollard, R. (2010). The good, the bad and the ugly of partnered research: Revisiting the sequestration thesis and the role of universities in promoting social justice. International Journal of Health Services, 40(3), 485–505.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Yassi, A., O’Hara, L., Lockhart, K., & Spiegel, J. M. (2012). Workplace programmes for HIV and Tuberculosis: A systematic review to support development of international guidelines for the health workforce. AIDS care, 1(19), iFirst.Google Scholar