Plagiarism Among Dissertations: Prevalence at Online Institutions
The current research literature has claimed that plagiarism is a significant problem in postsecondary education. Unfortunately, these claims are primarily supported by self-report data from students. In fact little research has been done to quantify the prevalence of plagiarism particularly at the advanced graduate education level. Further, few studies exist on online education even though this is a rapidly growing sector of higher education. This descriptive study quantified the amount of plagiarism that existed among 100 doctoral dissertations that were published by institutions granting doctorate degrees through a primarily online format. The dissertations were submitted to Turnitin plagiarism detection software for analysis. The mean similarity index of these dissertations was 15.1 (SD = 13.02). The results were then categorized per previous research. Forty-six percent of the dissertations were classified as having a low level of plagiarism while 11 % had a medium level and 3 % had a high level. Further analysis revealed that 72 % of the dissertations had at least one case of improper paraphrasing and citation (verbatim text accompanied by a citation) and 46 % had verbatim text without any citation. The results of this study should encourage faculty, dissertation committee members, university administrators, and accrediting bodies to take action to help reduce the level of plagiarism among doctoral learners. Suggestions for future research include comparing online and brick-and-mortar dissertation plagiarism rates, a larger study to investigate plagiarism trend data, and surveys of faculty about how they address plagiarism and ethics during the dissertation process.
KeywordsPlagiarism Higher education Doctorate Dissertation Research Ethics Turnitin
- Allan, G., Callagher, L., Connors, M., Joyce, D., & Rees, M. (2005). Some Australasian perspective on academic integrity in the internet age. EDUCAUSE Conference. Auckland, NZ: University of Auckland.Google Scholar
- Auer, N. J., & Krupar, E. M. (2001). Mouse click plagiarism: the role of technology in plagiarism and the librarian’s role in combating it. Library Trends, 49(3), 415–432.Google Scholar
- Batane, T. (2010). Turning to Turnitin to fight plagiarism among university students. Educational Technology & Society, 13(2), 1–12.Google Scholar
- Bretag, T., & Mahmud, S. (2009b). A model for determining student plagiarism: electronic detection and academic judgment. Journal of University Teaching & Learning Practice, 6(1).Google Scholar
- Chao, C., Wilhelm, W., & Neureuther, B. (2009). A study of electronic detection and pedagogical approaches for reducing plagiarism. The Delta Pi Epsilon Journal, LI(1), 31–42.Google Scholar
- Garden, C. (2009). What does my Turnitin report mean? Edinburgh: Edinburgh Napier University.Google Scholar
- Gilmore, J., Strickland, D., Timmerman, B., Maher, M., & Feldon, D. (2010). Weeds in the flower garden: an exploration of plagiarism in graduate students’ research proposals and its connection to enculturation, ESL, and contextual factors. International Journal for Educational Integrity, 6(1), 13–28.Google Scholar
- iParadigms. (2010a). Literature review: Independently published studies on Turnitin services. Retrieved from http://turnitin.com/en_us/results/middle-and-high-school.
- iParadigms. (2010b). A summary of the effectiveness of Turnitin. Retrieved from http://pages.turnitin.com/rs/iparadigms/images/Turnitin_Summary_of_Effectiveness.pdf.
- iParadigms. (2011). Turnitin instructor manual. Retrieved from http://turnitin.com/static/resources/documentation/turnitin/training/en_us/Instructor_Manual_en_us.pdf.
- Martin, D., Rao, A., & Sloan, L. (2011). Ethnicity, acculturation, and plagiarism: a criterion study of unethical academic conduct. Human Organization, 70(1), 88–96.Google Scholar
- Moss, S. (2005). A history of plagiarism (not my own work). Retrieved from http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2005/nov/23/comment.stephenmoss.
- Plagiarism. (2011). Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Retrieved from http://www.learnersdictionary.com/search/plagiarism.
- Plagiarism. (n.d.). Online Etymology Dictionary. Retrieved from http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/plagiarism.
- Scaife, B. (2007). Plagiarism detection software report for JISC Plagiarism Advisory Service. Manchester: IT Consultancy.Google Scholar
- Scanlon, P. M., & Neumann, D. R. (2002). Internet plagiarism among college students. Journal of College Student Development, 43(3), 374–385.Google Scholar
- Teesside University. (2010). Interpreting Turnitin originality reports. Tees Valley: Author.Google Scholar
- Ward, J. (2002, May 23). University sees rise in reports of cheating. Washington Times, p. B-1.Google Scholar