Tax competition and the efficiency of “benefit-related” business taxes
We construct a tax competition model in which local governments finance business public services with either a source-based tax on mobile capital, such as a property tax, or a tax on production, such as an origin-based value-added tax, and then assess which of the two tax instruments is more efficient. Many taxes on business apply to mobile inputs or outputs, such as property taxes, retail sales taxes, and destination-based VATs, and their inefficiency has been examined in the literature; however, proposals from several prominent tax experts to utilize a local origin-based VAT have not been analyzed theoretically. Our primary finding is that the production tax is less inefficient than the capital tax under many—but not all—conditions. The intuition underlying this result is that the efficiency of a user fee on the public business input is roughly approximated by a production tax, which applies to both the public input and immobile labor (in addition to mobile capital). In marked contrast, the capital tax applies only to mobile capital and is thus likely to be relatively inefficient.
KeywordsTax competition Business taxes Business public services Production tax Capital tax
JEL ClassificationH410 H420 H210 H110
We thank an anonymous referee, Steve Billon, Jed Brewer, Alexander Ebertz, Bill Fox, Timothy Goodspeed, Brad Hackinen, Andreas Haufler, James Hines, Margaret McKeehan, Matt Krzepkowski, David Wildasin, and John Wilson for helpful comments on earlier versions of this paper.
- Bird, R. M. (2000). Subnational VATs: Experience and prospects. In Proceedings. Annual conference on taxation and minutes of the annual meeting of the National Tax Association (Vol. 93, pp. 223–228).Google Scholar
- Bird, R. M. (2003). A new look at business taxes. Tax Notes International, 30(7), 695–711.Google Scholar
- CBC News. (2011). B.C. promises HST cut to 10% by 2014: Tax hike for corporations and cheques for families also promised. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/britishcolumbia/story/2011/05/25/bc-hst-changes.html. Accessed 15 August 2018.
- Crawford, I., Keen, M., & Smith, S. (2010). Value-added tax and excises. In Institute for Fiscal Studies (Ed.), Dimensions of tax design: The Mirrlees review (pp. 275–362). London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Faggiano, M. (2017). Origin-based and destination-based sales tax collection 101. https://blog.taxjar.com/charging-sales-tax-rates/. Accessed 31 August 2018.
- Hall, R., & Rabushka, A. (2007). The flat tax. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press.Google Scholar
- Hines, J. R., Jr. (2003). Michigan’s flirtation with the single business tax. In C. L. Ballard, P. N. Courant, D. C. Drake, R. C. Fischer, & E. R. Gerber (Eds.), Michigan at the Millennium: A benchmark and analysis of its fiscal and economic structure (pp. 603–628). East Lansing: Michigan State University Press.Google Scholar
- Kanbur, R., & Keen, M. (1993). Jeux sans frontiers: Tax competition and tax coordination when countries differ in size. American Economic Review, 83(4), 877–892.Google Scholar
- Oates, W. E., & Schwab, R. M. (1991). The allocative and distributive implications of local fiscal competition. In D. A. Kenyon & J. Kincaid (Eds.), Competition among states and local governments: Efficiency and equity in American federalism (pp. 127–146). Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press.Google Scholar
- The Independent Panel. (2011). HST or PST/GST: It’s your decision. http://www.slideshare.net/hstinbc/its-your-decisionhstgstpst. Accessed 15 August 15 2018.
- Wilson, J. D. (1999). Theories of tax competition. National Tax Journal, 52(2), 269–304.Google Scholar