Everything is ok on YouTube! Quality assessment of YouTube videos on the topic of phacoemulsification in eyes with small pupil
- 180 Downloads
Usage of YouTube as an educational tool is gaining attention in academic research. To date, there has been no study on the content and quality of eye surgery videos on YouTube. The aim of this study was to analyze YouTube videos on phacoemulsification in eyes with small pupil.
We searched for the phrases “small pupil cataract surgery,” “small pupil phacoemulsification,” “small pupil cataract surgery complications,” and “small pupil phacoemulsification complications” in January 2015. Each resulting video was evaluated by all authors, and Krippendorff’s alpha was calculated to measure agreement. Videos were classified according to pupil size (small/very small) in the beginning of the surgery, and whether pupillary diameter was large enough to continue surgery safely after pupillary dilation by the surgeon in the video (safe/not safe). Methods of dilatation were also analyzed. Any stated ocular comorbidity or surgical complications were noted.
A total of 96 videos were reviewed. No mechanical intervention for pupillary dilatation was performed in 46 videos. Fifty-eight operated eyes had no stated ocular comorbidity. Ninety-five operations ended successfully without major complication. There was fair agreement between the evaluators regarding pupil sizes (Kα = 0.670) but poor agreement regarding safety (Kα = 0.337).
YouTube videos on small pupil phacoemulsification have low complication rates when compared to the literature, although no reliable mechanical dilatation methods are used in almost half of these videos. Until YouTube’s place in e-learning becomes clearer, we suggest that viewers be cautious regarding small pupil phacoemulsification videos on YouTube.
KeywordsYouTube Cataract Phacoemulsification Small pupil E-learning Surgical videos
Compliance with ethical standards
Conflict of interest
This article does not contain any studies with human participants performed by any of the authors.
- 3.Verhage J (2015) A bank of America analysis says YouTube is worth more than 85 percent of companies in the S&P 500. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-05-27/a-bank-of-america-analysis-says-YouTube-is-worth-more-than-85-percent-of-companies-in-the-s-p-500. Accessed 13 Mar 2016
- 9.Masket S (2000) Cataract surgery complicated by the miotic pupil. In: Buratto L, Osher RH, Masket S (eds) Cataract surgery in complicated cases. SLACK Inc, Thorofare, pp 132–135Google Scholar