Journal of Indian Philosophy

, Volume 39, Issue 6, pp 599–646 | Cite as

The Ins and Outs of the Jains in Tamil Literary Histories

Article

Abstract

The Jains and their texts play a key role in the literary histories of the Tamil-speaking region. However, in their modern form, dating from 1856 to the present, these histories have been written almost exclusively by non-Jains. Driving their efforts have been agendas such as cultural evolutionism, Dravidian nationalism or Śaiva devotionalism. This essay builds on ideas articulated by the contemporary Tamil theorist K. Civatampi, examining how various models of periodization have frozen the Jains in the ancient past. Further, it will explore how this unfolding historical drama, which gloriously climaxes in Tamil literature, has attributed the Jains, as dramatis personae, merely a role in early Jain texts; their role as communities transmitting these texts has been ignored. In contrast to this typical pattern, this article will also introduce a literary history written in 1941 by the Jain A. Cakravarti Nāyaṉār (1880–1960). It will explore whether or not his voice, which emerged from within the same academic community contributing to the strange absence of Jains in the contemporary awareness of Tamil literary, was successful in finding another way for Jains of being heard, and for non-Jains, of listening.

Keywords

Cakravarti Tamil literature Historiography Jains 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Āṟumuka Nāvalar. (Ed.). (2005). Maṇṭala Puruṭar iyaṟṟiya Cūṭāmaṇi nikaṇṭu: Mulamum uraiyum. Ceṉṉai: Vacanta Patippakam (originally published Ceṉṉai, 1849).Google Scholar
  2. Aruṇācalam, Mu. [see also M. Arunachalan]. (1973). Tamiḻ ilakkiya varalāṟu. Mayuram: Gandhi Vidyalayam Thiruchitrambalam.Google Scholar
  3. Arunachalan, M. [see also Mu. Aruṇācalam]. (1979). The Kalabhras in the Pandiya country and their impact on the life and letters there. Madras: University of Madras.Google Scholar
  4. Baida I. (1987) Jaina tamil sāhitya aur tirukkural. Samyakjñāna prakārak maṇḍal, JayapurGoogle Scholar
  5. Berman R.A. (2001) Politics. Divide and rule. Modern Language Quarterly 62(4): 317–330Google Scholar
  6. Blackburn S. (2000) Corruption and redemption: The legend of Valluvar and Tamil literary history. Modern Asian Studies 34(2): 449–482CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Brown M. (2001) Periods and resistances. Modern Language Quarterly 62(4): 309–316CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Caldwell, R. R. (1974). In J. L. Wyatt & T. Ramakrishna Pillai (Eds.), A comparative grammar of the Dravidian, or, South-Indian family of languages (3rd ed., rev.). New Delhi: Oriental Books Reprint Corp (originally published London: Harrison, 1856).Google Scholar
  9. Celvanāyakam V. (1951) Tamil ilakkiya varalāṟu. St. Joseph’s Catholic Press, JaffnaGoogle Scholar
  10. Chaitanya K. (1971) A history of Malayalam literature. Orient Longman, DelhiGoogle Scholar
  11. Chakravarti, A. (Ed.). (1923). Mērumandirapurāṇa. Madras.Google Scholar
  12. Chakravarti, A. (1951a). Jainism in the Tamil land. Jaina Antiquary, 4(3).Google Scholar
  13. Chakravarti, A. (Ed.). (1951b). Tirukkuṟal, text, commentary and exhaustive introduction. Reprinted as Kural or Thirukkural. An ancient poem of Thevar. Tamil text and commentary of Kavirājapaṇḍ ita. Varanasi: Bhāratīya Jñānapīṭha Publication (originally published Varanasi, 1949).Google Scholar
  14. Chakravarti A. (1957) Religion of ahimsa. Shri Ratnachand Hirachand, BombayGoogle Scholar
  15. Chakravarti, A. (Ed. & Transl.). (1971). Samayasāra of Śrī Kundakunda with an English translation and commentary based on Amṛtacandra’s Ātmakhyāti (2nd ed.). Varanasi: Bhāratīya Jñānapīṭha Publication (originally published Varanasi, 1950).Google Scholar
  16. Chakravarti, A. (1974). Jaina literature in Tamil. With an introduction, footnotes, appendix and index by K. V. Ramesh, Deputy Superintending Epigraphist, Archaeological Survey of India. Jñānapīṭha Mūrtidevi Granthamālā, English Series, 3. Mysore: Bhāratīya Jñānapīṭha Publication (originally published Jaina literature in Tamil. Jaina Antiquary. Arrah: Siddhanta Bhavana, 1941).Google Scholar
  17. Chakravarti, A. (Transl.). (1994). Neelakesi (2nd ed.). Jaipur: Prakrit Bharati Academy (originally published Kumbakonam, 1936).Google Scholar
  18. Chakravartinayanar, A. [see also A. Chakravarti]. (Ed., Transl. & Comm.). (1920). Śrīpañāstikāyasāra. The building of the Cosmos or Pañāstikāyasāra (The five cosmic constituents) by Svami Sri Kundakundacharya. Bibliotheca Jainica (Vol. III), The sacred books of the Jainas. Arrah: The Central Jaina Publishing House.Google Scholar
  19. Champakalakshmi, R. (1994). Jaina literature in Tamil. Rishabh Saurabh. Published on the occasion of Seminar of “Jaina Heritage of Karnataka”, held at Bangalore on the 4th and 5th of April 1994 (pp. 23–77).Google Scholar
  20. Chettiar A.C. (1958) Introduction to Tamil poetry. Tamil Culture III 1: 20–26Google Scholar
  21. Chitty, S. C. (1982). The Tamil Plutarch. A summary account of the lives of the poets and the poetesses of Southern India and Ceylon from the earliest to the present times with select specimens of their compositions (2nd rev. ed.). New Delhi: Asian Educational Services (Repr. with notes based on the results of the latest research by T. P. Meenakshisundaram, Colombo, 1946; originally published Colombo, 1859).Google Scholar
  22. Cort, J.E. (ed.) (1998) Open boundaries. Jain communities and cultures in Indian history. State University of New York Press, AlbanyGoogle Scholar
  23. Cort J.E. (2004) How Jains know what they know: A lay Jain curriculum. In: Dhaky M.A., Shah J.B. (eds) Jambū-Jyoti (Munivara Jambūvijaya Festschrift). Shresthi Kasturbhai Lalbhai Smarak Nidhi, Ahmedabad, pp 399–413Google Scholar
  24. Cuppriramaṇiyaṉ Piḷḷai, Kā. (1968). Ilakkiya varalāṟu (4th ed.). Ceṉṉai: Ā ciriyar nūṟpatippuk kalakam (originally published Ceṉṉai, 1930).Google Scholar
  25. Cutler N. (2003) Three moments in the genealogy of Tamil literary culture. In: Pollock S. (ed.) Literary cultures in history. Reconstructions from South Asia. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 271–322Google Scholar
  26. Davis R.H. (1998) The story of the disappearing Jains. Retelling the Śaiva-Jain encounter in medieval South India. In: Cort J.E. (ed.) Open boundaries. Jain communities and cultures in Indian history. State University of New York Press, Albany, pp 213–224Google Scholar
  27. de Millone, L., & Senathi Raja, E. S. W. (Transl.). (1885). Essai sur le jainisme par un jain (traduit du tamoul en français et annoté). In Travaux de la sixième session, Congrès international des orientalistes. Leiden: Brill.. Leiden: Brill.Google Scholar
  28. Desai P.B. (1957) Jainism in South India and some epigraphic sources. Jainasamskriti Samrakshakasamgha, SholapurGoogle Scholar
  29. Devaneyan, G. (1979). Tamiḻ ilakkiya varalāṟu. N. Arcot.Google Scholar
  30. Dhaky, M. A. (1991). The date of Kundakundacarya. In M. D: hākī & S. Jain (Eds.), Paṇḍit Dālsukhbhāī Mālvaṇiyā Abhinandana Grantha I (English section, pp. 187–206). Vāraṇasī: Pārśvanāth Vidyāśrama Śodha Sam: sthān.Google Scholar
  31. Ekambaranathan A., Sivaprakasam C.K. (1987) Jaina Inscriptions in Tamilnadu (a topographical list). Research Foundation for Jainology, MadrasGoogle Scholar
  32. Fabian J. (2002) Time and the other. How anthropology makes its object. Columbia University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  33. Flügel P. (2007) A short history of Jaina law. International Journal of Jaina Studies 3(4): 1–15Google Scholar
  34. Folkert K.W. (1993) The ‘canons’ of ‘scripture’. In: Cort J.E. (ed.) Scripture and community collected essays on the Jains. Scholars Press, AtlantaGoogle Scholar
  35. George K.M. (1968) A survey of Malayalam literature. Asia Publishing House, BombayGoogle Scholar
  36. Gopalan S. (1979) The social philosophy of Tirukkural. Affiliated East-West Press, New DelhiGoogle Scholar
  37. Jain C.R. (1926) The Jaina law. The Devendra Printing and Publishing Co., MadrasGoogle Scholar
  38. Jain J.P. (1985) Jaina authors and their works: Tamil. Jaina Antiquary 38(1): 24–26Google Scholar
  39. Jaini P.S. (1979) The Jaina path of purification. Motilal Banarsidass, DelhiGoogle Scholar
  40. Jesudasan C., Jesudasan H. (1961) A history of Tamil literature. YMCA Publishing House, CalcuttaGoogle Scholar
  41. Joseph P.M. (1997) Jainism in South India. The International School of Dravidian Linguistics, ThiruvananthapuramGoogle Scholar
  42. Kailācapati, K. (1961). Nādum nayanmarum. Kolumpu.Google Scholar
  43. Kanaganayakam, C. (2010, April). Reading the Pallava period through its religious and secular texts. Paper presented at the Tamil workshop, University of California, Berkeley.Google Scholar
  44. Lehmann, T. (2009). A survey of Tamil commentarial literature. In E. Wilden (Ed.), Between preservation and recreation. Tamil traditions of commentary. Proceedings of a workshop in honour of T.V. Gopal Iyer, 2009 (pp. 55–70). Pondicherry: Institut Français de Pondichéry, École Française d’Extrême-Orient.Google Scholar
  45. Maheshwari R.U. (2009) Yaks:ī worship among the Tamil Jainas. Understanding a relational concept within popular Jainism. Centre of Jaina Studies Newsletter 4: 33–35Google Scholar
  46. Maṟaimalai Aṭikaḷ [Swami Vedachalam]. (1930). Māṇickavācakar varalāṟum kālamum (St. Manickavachakar. His life and times. In Tamil). Pallavaram: T.M. Press.Google Scholar
  47. Meenakshisundaram, T. P. (1965). A history of Tamil literature. Annamalai Nagar.Google Scholar
  48. Mīṉāṭcicuntaraṉār Ṭē.Po. (1965) Camaṇat tamil ilakkiya varalāṟum. Kalaikkatir Veḷiyīṭu, KōvaiGoogle Scholar
  49. Monius A. (2004a) Love violence, and the aesthetics of disgust. Journal of Indian Philosophy 32: 113–172CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Monius A. (2004b) Siva as heroic father. Harvard Theological Review 92(2): 165–197Google Scholar
  51. Monius, A. (2009). Imagining a place for Buddhism: Literary culture and religious community in Tamilspeaking South India (Indian edition). Delhi: Navayana Press (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001).Google Scholar
  52. Monius, A. (forthcoming). U. Vē. Cāminātaiyar and the construction of Tamil literary “tradition”.Google Scholar
  53. Nilakanta Sastri K.A. (1996) A history of South India from prehistoric times to the fall of Vijayanagar. Oxford University Press, MadrasGoogle Scholar
  54. Orr L.C. (1998) Jain and Hindu ‘religious women’ in early medieval Tamil Nadu. In: Cort J.E. (ed.) Open boundaries. Jain communities and cultures in Indian history. State University of New York Press, Albany, pp 187–212Google Scholar
  55. Orr L.C. (2009) Orientalists, missionaries and Jains. The South Indian story. In: Trautmann T.R. (ed.) The Madras school of orientalism. Producing knowledge in colonial South India. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 264–278Google Scholar
  56. Paṇḍārattār, S. (1955). Tamil ilakkiya varalāṟu. (A.D. 250–600). Aṇṇāmalai University.Google Scholar
  57. Paniker A. (1990) A perspective on Malayalam literature. Annu Chitra Publications, MadrasGoogle Scholar
  58. Perkins D. (1992) Is literary history possible?. The John Hopkins University Press, BaltimoreGoogle Scholar
  59. Peterson I. (1998) Śramaṇas against the Tamil way Jains as others in Tamil Saiva literature. In: Cort J.E. (ed.) Open boundaries. Jain communities and cultures in Indian history. State University of New York Press, Albany, pp 163–185Google Scholar
  60. Pollock S. (2006) The language of gods in the world of men. Berkeley University Press, BerkeleyGoogle Scholar
  61. Purnalingam Pillai, M. S. (1994). A primer of Tamil literature. New Delhi: Asian Educational Services (revised and enlarged Munirpallam: The Bibliotheca, 1929; originally published Madras 1904).Google Scholar
  62. Rajarigam D. (1958) The history of Tamil Christian literature. The Christian Literature Society, MadrasGoogle Scholar
  63. Rāmakirus:ṇaṉ S. (1962) Tamil ilakkiya varalāṟu. Oru Arimukam, MadrasGoogle Scholar
  64. Ramaswami Ayyangar, M. S. (1988). Studies in South Indian Jainism. Part I: South Indian Jainism. Delhi: Sri Satguru Publications (originally published Madras: Hoe & Co. 1922).Google Scholar
  65. Ryan, J. (1985). The ‘Civakacintamani’ in historical perspective. PhD Dissertation, University of California, Berkeley.Google Scholar
  66. Ryan J. (1998) Erotic excess and sexual danger in the Cīvakacintāmaṇi. In: Cort J.E. (ed.) Open boundaries. Jain communities and cultures in Indian history. State University of New York Press, Albany, pp 67–83Google Scholar
  67. Sangave, V. A. (1980). Jaina community. A social survey. Bombay: Popular Book Depot (originally published Bombay, 1959).Google Scholar
  68. Sekhar V. (2009) Jaina insights in Tamil classical literary tradition. The International Journal of Tamil Studies 4(1): 75–92Google Scholar
  69. Schalk, P., & Ā ḷvāppiḷḷai Vēluppiḷḷai (Eds.). (2002). Buddhism among Tamils in pre-colonial Tamilakam and īlam (2 Vols.). Uppsala: Uppsala Universitet.Google Scholar
  70. Sivaraja Pillai, K. N. (1997). The chronology of the early Tamils based on the synchronistic tables of their kings, chieftains and poets appearing in the Sangam literature (2nd ed.). New Delhi: Asian Educational Services (originally published Madras, 1932).Google Scholar
  71. Sivathamby K. (1986) Literary history in Tamil. Tamil University, ThanjavurGoogle Scholar
  72. Somasundaram Pillai, J. M. (1968). A history of Tamil literature. Annamalai Nagar.Google Scholar
  73. Srinivasa Aiyangar, M. (1986). Tamil studies. Essays on the history of the Tamil people, language, religion and literature (2nd ed.). New Delhi: Asian Educational Services (originally published Madras, 1914).Google Scholar
  74. Subramanian, N. (1981). An introduction to Tamil literature. Madras.Google Scholar
  75. Swaminathaiyer, U. V. (Ed.). (1907). Cīvakacintāmaṇi. By Tīruttakkatēvar, with the commentary of Nacciṇārkkiṇiyar (2nd ed.). Madras (originally published Madras, 1887).Google Scholar
  76. Swaminathaiyer, U. V. [see also Cāmināt Aiyar]. (1980). The story of my life. Translated into English by S. K. Guruswamy & A. Rama Iyer. Mahamahopadhyaya. Madras: Dr. Swaminathaiyer Library.Google Scholar
  77. Takahashi, T. (2009a, September 1–5). Jain authorship. Reassessment. Paper presented at the 14th world Sanskrit conference, Kyōto.Google Scholar
  78. Takahashi, T. (2009b, May 22–23). Is clearing or plowing equal to killing? Tamil culture and the spread of Jainism in Tamilnadu. Paper presented at the Workshop on “Bilingual discourse and cross-cultural fertilisation: Sanskrit and Tamil in mediaeval India,” Cambridge University.Google Scholar
  79. Tāmōtaram Piḷḷai, Ci. Vai. (1920). Vīracōliyam. Ceṉṉai: Vittiyāvarttaṉi Accukkūṭam (originally published Ceṉṉai, 1881).Google Scholar
  80. Trautmann T. (1999) Inventing the history of South India. In: Ali D. (ed.) Invoking the past: The uses of history in South Asia. Oxford University Press, London, pp 36–54Google Scholar
  81. Trautmann T. (2006) Languages and nations. The Dravidian proof in colonial Madras. University of California Press, Berkeley, CAGoogle Scholar
  82. Upadhye, A. N. (Ed. & Transl.). (1964). Śrī Kundakundācārya’s Pravacanasāra (Pavayaṇasāra). A procanonical text of the Jainas (2nd ed.). Bombay: Shri Raojibhai Chhaganbhai Desai, Parama-Śruta- Prabhāvaka Śrimad Rājachandra Jaina Śāstramālā.Google Scholar
  83. Uwise M.M. (1953) Muslim contribution to Tamil literature. Kandy Tamil Manram Publishers, GalhinnaGoogle Scholar
  84. Vaiyāpuri Piḷḷai, Es. [see also S. Vaiyapuri Pillai]. (1962a). Ilakkiya cintaṉaikaḷ (2nd ed.). Madras: Puttakanilayam (originally published Madurai, 1947).Google Scholar
  85. Vaiyāpuri Piḷḷai, Es. (1962b). Kāviyakālam (2nd ed.). Madras: Puttakanilayam (originally published Madurai, 1957).Google Scholar
  86. Vaiyapuripillai, S. [see also Vaiyāpuri Piḷḷai, Es.]. (1988). History of Tamil language and literature (from the beginning to 1000 CE) (2nd rev. ed.). Madras: New Century Book House (originally published Madras: New Century Book House, 1956).Google Scholar
  87. Varatarāc Aiyar, E. Es. (1957). Tamil ilakkiya varalāru. Camaṇa pautta vaiṇava ilakkiyam (ki.pi. 1 mutal 1100). Madras: Annamalai University.Google Scholar
  88. Vāratarācaṉ M.M. (1972) Tamiḻ ilakkiya varalāṟu. Sahitiya Academy, MadrasGoogle Scholar
  89. Vēlupiḷḷai, Ā . (1969). Tamiḻ ilakkiyattil kālamum karuttum. Madras.Google Scholar
  90. Vēēnkaṭacāmi, M. C. (2000). Camaṇamum tamiḻum (3rd ed.). Chennai: Tirunelveli, Thennindiya Saiva Siddhanta Noorpathippu Kazhagam (originally published Madras, 1954).Google Scholar
  91. Vinson E.H.J. (1903) Manuel de la langue tamoul (Grammaire, textes, vocaboulaire). Ernest Leroux, ParisGoogle Scholar
  92. Wagoner P.B. (2003) Precolonial intellectuals and the production of colonial knowledge. Comparative Studies in Society and History 45(4): 783–814CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  93. Wellek R., Warren A. (1962) Theory of literature (3rd ed.). Harcourt, Brace & World, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  94. Zvelebil K.V. (1957) Tentative periodization of the development of Tamil. Tamil Culture I 1: 50–55Google Scholar
  95. Zvelebil K.V. (1973) The smile of Murugan. On Tamil literature of South India. E. J. Brill, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  96. Zvelebil, K. V. (1974). Tamil literature. A history of Indian literature (Vol. X, fasc. 1). Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz.Google Scholar
  97. Zvelebil K.V. (1975) Tamil literature. E.J. Brill, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  98. Zvelebil K.V. (1992) Companion studies to the history of Tamil literature. E.J. Brill, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  99. Zvelebil K.V. (1995) Lexicon of Tamil literature. E.J. Brill, LeidenGoogle Scholar
  100. Zweig, S. (1970). Sternstunden der Menschheit. Zwölf historische Miniaturen. Gesammelte Werke in Einzelbänden. Frankfurt/M.: S. Fischer Verlag.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department for the Study of ReligionUniversity of TorontoTorontoCanada

Personalised recommendations