Incentives and remuneration systems in dental services

Article

Abstract

The aim of this study was to examine the effects of an incentive-based remuneration system on number of individuals under supervision and on quality of public dental services in Norway. The basis for the study was a natural experiment in which all public dental officers in one county were given the opportunity to renegotiate their contract from a fixed salary contract to a combined per capita and fixed salary contract. Comprehensive data were collected before and after the change. A main finding is that the transition to an incentive-based remuneration system led to an increase in the number of individuals under supervision without either a fall in quality or a patient selection effect.

Keywords

Dentists Contracts Incentives Effectiveness Quality 

JEL Classification

I1 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Blinkhorn A.S., Hassall D.C., Holloway P.J., Mellor A.C., Worthington H.V. (1996) An assessment of capitation in the new General Dental Service contract. Community Dental Health 13(Supplement 1): 1–47Google Scholar
  2. Bramson J.B., Noskin D.E., Ruesch J.D. (1998) Differences in practice characteristics of capitation and PPO provider dentists. The Journal of the American Dental Association 129: 218–222Google Scholar
  3. Berk R.A. (1983) An introduction to sample selection bias in sociological data. American Sociological Review 48: 386–398. doi:10.2307/2095230 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bulman J.S., Osborn J.F. (1989) Statistics in dentistry. British Dental Association, London, pp 78–90Google Scholar
  5. Croxson B., Propper C., Perkins A. (2001) Do doctors respond to financial incentives? UK family doctors and the GP fundholder scheme. Journal of Public Economics 79: 375–398. doi:10.1016/S0047-2727(00)00074-8 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Davies M.H., Schechter B.L. (1987) The dentist and prepaid capitated systems. Dental Clinics of North America 31: 225–237Google Scholar
  7. Department of Health. (2002). NHS dentistry: Options for change. London: Crown.Google Scholar
  8. Ellis R.P., McGuire T.G. (1990) Optimal payments systems for health services. Journal of Health Economics 9: 375–396. doi:10.1016/0167-6296(90)90001-J CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Gaynor M., Gertler P.J. (1995) Moral hazard and risk spreading in partnerships. The Rand Journal of Economics 26: 591–613. doi:10.2307/2556008 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Gaynor M., Pauly M.V. (1990) Compensation and productive efficiency in partnerships: Evidence from medical group practice. The Journal of Political Economy 98: 544–573. doi:10.1086/261694 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Gimmestad A.L., Holst D., Fylkesnes K. (2003) Changes in restorative caries treatment in 15-year-olds in Oslo, Norway, 1979–1996. Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology 31: 246–251. doi:10.1034/j.1600-0528.2003.00041.x CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Giuffrida, A., Gosden, T., Forland, F., Kristiansen, I. S., Sergison, M., Leese, B., et al. (2002). Target payments in primary care: Effects on professional practice and health care outcomes (Cochrane Review). In The cochrane library (Issue 4). Oxford: Update Software.Google Scholar
  13. Gosden T., Forland F., Kristiansen I. S., Sutton M., Leese B., Giuffrida A. (2001) Impact of payment method on behaviour of primary care physicians: A systematic review. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy 6: 44–55. doi:10.1258/1355819011927198 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Gosden, T., Forland, F., Kristiansen, I. S., Sutton, M., Leese, B., Giuffrida, A., et al. (2005). Capitation, salary, fee-for-service and mixed systems of payment: Effects on the behaviour of primary care physicians (Cochrane Review). In The Cochrane Library (Issue 3). http://thecochranelibrary.com.
  15. Grytten J. (2005) Models for financing dental services. A review. Community Dental Health 22: 75–85Google Scholar
  16. Grytten J., Dalen D.M. (1997) Too many for too few? Efficiency among dentists working in private practice in Norway. Journal of Health Economics 16: 483–497. doi:10.1016/S0167-6296(96)00528-0 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Grytten J., Holst D., Berge K. (2001) Innsatsbasert avlønning i Den offentlige tannhelsetjenesten i Østfold. The Norwegian Dental Journal 111: 226–231Google Scholar
  18. Hassall D.C., Holloway P.J. (1998) Levels of restorative care under capitation. British Dental Journal 184: 348–350. doi:10.1038/sj.bdj.4809621 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Hellinger F.J. (1996) The impact of financial incentives on physician behaviour in managed care plans: A review of the evidence. Medical Care Research and Review 53: 294–314. doi:10.1177/107755879605300305 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Hemenway D., Killen A., Cashman S.B., Parks C.L., Bicknell W.J. (1990) Physicians’ response to financial incentives. The New England Journal of Medicine 322: 1059–1063Google Scholar
  21. Hickson G.B., Altemeier W.A., Perrin J.M. (1987) Physician reimbursement by salary or fee-for- service: Effect on physician practice behaviour in a randomised prospective study. Pediatrics 80: 344–350Google Scholar
  22. Holloway P.J., Blinkhorn A.S., Hassall D.C., MellorA .C., Worthington H.V. (1997) An assessment of capitation in the General Dental Service Contract.1. The level of caries and its treatment in regularly attending children and adolescents. British Dental Journal 182: 418–423Google Scholar
  23. Holloway P.J., Lennon M.A., Mellor A.C., Coventry P., Worthington H.V. (1990) The capitation study. 1. Does capitation encourage ‘supervised neglect?’. British Dental Journal 168: 119–121Google Scholar
  24. Holst D. (1997) Delivery of oral health care in the Nordic countries. In: Pine C.M. (eds) Community oral health. Wright, Oxford, pp 238–291Google Scholar
  25. Holst D., Grytten J., Berge K. (2001) Faktiske og ønskede arbeidsforhold i Den offentlige tannhelsetjenesten i Østfold. The Norwegian Dental Journal 111: 220–224Google Scholar
  26. Jackson Brown L., Ruesch J.D. (2000) Dentists’ participation in capitation and preferred provider organization dental plans. The Journal of the American Dental Association 131: 1485–1489Google Scholar
  27. Kidd E.A.M., van Amerongen J.P. (2003) The role of operative treatment. In: Fejerskov O., Kidd E. (eds) Dental caries. The disease and its clinical management. Oxford, Blackwell Munksgaard, pp 245–250Google Scholar
  28. Kletke P.R., Emmons D.W., Gills K.G. (1996) Current trend in physicians’ practice arrangements. Journal of the American Medical Association 276: 555–560. doi:10.1001/jama.276.7.555 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Lazear E.P. (1986) Salaries and piece rates. Journal of Business 59: 405–431. doi:10.1086/296345 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Lazear, E. P. (1996). Performance pay and productivity. NBER Working Paper 5672. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
  31. Lazear E.P. (1998) Personnel economics of managers. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  32. Lazear, E. P. (1999). Personnel economics: Past lessons and future directions. NBER Working Paper, 6957. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
  33. Lazear E.P. (2000) Performance pay and productivity. The American Economic Review 90: 1346–1361CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Le Grand, J., Mays, N., Mulligan J.-A., (Eds). (2001) Learning from the NHS Internal Market. King’s Fund, LondonGoogle Scholar
  35. Magnus S.A. (1999) Physicians’ financial incentives in five dimensions: A conceptual framework for HMO managers. Health Care Management Review 24: 57–72Google Scholar
  36. McGuire P.M., Pauly M.V. (1991) Physician response to fee changes with multiple payers. Journal of Health Economics 10: 385–410. doi:10.1016/0167-6296(91)90022-F CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Mechanic D., McAlpine D.D., Rosenthal M. (2001) Are patients’ office visits with the physicians getting shorter?. The New England Journal of Medicine 344: 198–204. doi:10.1056/NEJM200101183440307 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Mellor A.C., Blinkhorn A.S., Hassall D.C., Holloway P.J., Worthington H.V. (1997) An assessment of capitation in the General Dental Service Contract. 2. Patterns of treatment provided to regularly attending patients. British Dental Journal 182: 460–464Google Scholar
  39. Mellor A.C., Coventry P., Worthington H.V., Holloway P.J., Lennon M.A. (1990) The capitation study. 3. The views of participating dentists and the profession. British Dental Journal 168: 303–305Google Scholar
  40. Miller R.H., Luft H.S. (1994) Managed care plan performance since 1980. Journal of the American Medical Association 271: 1512–1519. doi:10.1001/jama.271.19.1512 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Ministry of Social Affairs. (1983). Lov om tannhelsetjenesten. Oslo: Ministry of Social Affairs.Google Scholar
  42. Norwegian Board of Health. (2004). Tannhelsetjenesten i Norge. Omfanget av den offentlige tannhelsetjenesten for de prioriterte gruppene og bemannings-situasjonen i tannhelsetjenesten. Rapport 5/2004. Available September 24, 2008, from Utrykte vedlegg http://www.helsetilsynet.no/templates/ArticleWithLinks____5978.aspx. Oslo: Norwegian Board of Health.
  43. Norwegian Board of Health. (2005). Ulike fylke, ulike tannhelsetilbod? Tilbodet frå den offentlege tannhelsetenesta til dei prioriterte gruppene, oversyn over bemanningssituasjonen og oppsummering av rapporteringa frå helsetilsynet i fylka. Rapport 8/2005. Oslo: Norwegian Board of Health.Google Scholar
  44. Office of Fair Trading. (2003). The private dentistry market in the UK. London: Crown.Google Scholar
  45. Prendergast C. (1999) The provision of incentives in firms. Journal of Economic Literature 37: 7–63Google Scholar
  46. Robinson R., Steiner A. (1998) Managed health care. Open University Press, BuckinghamGoogle Scholar
  47. Schoen M.H. (1974) Methodology of capitation payment to group dental practice and effects of such payment on care. Health Services Reports 89: 16–24Google Scholar
  48. Schoen M.H. (1991) Capitation in dentistry: Original concepts and current reality. Journal of Public Health Policy 12: 199–208. doi:10.2307/3342504 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Selden T.M. (1990) A model of capitation. Journal of Health Economics 9: 397–409. doi:10.1016/0167-6296(90)90002-K CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Sørensen R.J., Grytten J. (2003) Service production and contract choice in primary physician services. Health Policy (Amsterdam) 66: 73–93. doi:10.1016/S0168-8510(03)00026-5 Google Scholar
  51. Statistics Norway. (2005). StatBank Norway. Available August 15, 2007, from http://statbank.ssb.no//statistikkbanken/default_fr.asp?PLanguage=1.
  52. Vella F. (1998) Estimating models with sample selection bias: A survey. The Journal of Human Resources 33: 127–169CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Widström, E., & Eaton, K. A. (1999). Systems for the Provision of Oral Health Care, workforce and costs in the EU and EEA. A council of European chief dental officers’ survey. Helsinki: STAKES.Google Scholar
  54. Wooldridge J.M. (2002) Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts, pp 128–132Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2008

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Dental FacultyUniversity of OsloOsloNorway

Personalised recommendations