Is there confusion over what is meant by ‘open population’?
Opinion Paper Received: 03 March 2004 Revised: 12 January 2005 Accepted: 26 January 2005 Abstract
Marine species possessing widely dispersing larvae are often considered to have open populations. However, two concepts are covered by the phrase ‚open population’. One concept stresses the supply of recruits from outside the local population (genetically open) while the alternative use describes situations where recruitment rate is independent of the local population size (demographically open). These two concepts are not necessarily equivalent. A review of recent literature suggests that there is no consensus on whether a demographic or genetic concept is associated with the use of the phrase ‚open population’. The different meanings of open population are never formally acknowledged. Explicit recognition of the different concepts of openness would remove an ambiguity from the literature and may aid communication between disciplines. Processes in natural populations, such as gregarious settlement and homing behaviour, are more clearly described by distinguishing between demographic and genetic degrees of openness. Changes in spatial scale will affect the degree of population openness. However, demographic and genetic aspects of population structure will not necessarily respond in the same ways to changes in scale. This provides further support for the explicit separation of genetic and demographic concepts of openness.
Keywords larvae demographic genetic definitions models References Armsworth, P. R. 2002 Recruitment limitation, population regulation, and larval connectivity in reef fish metapopulations Ecology 83 1092 1104 Google Scholar Avise, J. C. 1994Molecular Markers, Natural History and Evolution Chapman & Hall London Google Scholar Barnay, A. S., Ellien, C., Gentil, F., Thiebaut, E. 2003 A model study on variations in larval supply: are populations of the polychaete Owenia fusiformis in the English Channel open or closed? Helgoland Marine Research 56 229 237 Google Scholar Bertness, M. D., Gaines, S. D. 1993 Larval dispersal and local adaptation in acorn barnacles Evolution 47 316 320 Google Scholar Caley, M. J., Carr, M. H., Hixon, M. A., Hughes, T. P., Jones, G. P., Menge, B. A. 1996 Recruitment and the local dynamic of open marine populations Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 27 477 500 Google Scholar Camus, P. A., Lima, M. 2002 Populations, metapopulations, and the open-closed dilemma: the conflict between operational and natural population concepts Oikos 97 433 438 Google Scholar Cowen, R. K., Lwiza, K. M. M., Sponaugle, S., Paris, C. B., Olson, D.␣B. 2000 Connectivity of marine populations: Open or closed? Science 287 857 859 PubMed Google Scholar Cropper, W. P., DiResta, D. 1999 Simulation of a Biscayne Bay, Florida commercial sponge population: effects of harvesting after Hurricane Andrew Ecological Modelling 118 1 15 Google Scholar Danilowicz, B. S., Sale, P. F. 1999 Modelling settlement in open populations of reef fishes Ecological Modelling 121 261 276 Google Scholar Dixon, P. A., Milicich, M. J., Sugihara, G. 1999 Episodic fluctuations in larval supply Science 283 1528 1530 PubMed Google Scholar Emerson, B. C., Paradis, E., Thebaud, C. 2001 Revealing the demographic histories of species using DNA sequences Trends in Ecology and Evolution 16 707 715 Google Scholar Etherington, L. L., Eggleston, D. B. 2000 Large-scale blue crab recruitment: linking postlarval transport, post-settlement planktonic dispersal, and multiple nursery habitats Marine Ecology Progress Series 204 179 198 Google Scholar Forde, S. E. 2002 Modelling the effects of an oil spill on open populations of intertidal invertebrates Journal of Applied Ecology 39 595 604 Google Scholar Gaines, S. D., Bertness, M. D. 1992 Dispersal of juveniles and variable recruitment in sessile marine species Nature 360 579 580 Google Scholar Gilg, M. R., Hilbish, T. J. 2003 The geography of marine larval dispersal: coupling genetics with fine-scale physical oceanography Ecology 84 2989 2998 Google Scholar Gilmour, J. 1999 Experimental investigation into the effects of suspended sediment on fertilization, larval survival and settlement in a scleractinian coral Marine Biology 135 451 462 Google Scholar Hixon, M. A., Pacala, S. W., Sandin, S. A. 2002 Population regulation: Historical context and contemporary challenges of open vs closed systems Ecology 83 1490 1508 Google Scholar Hughes, T. P., Tanner, J. E. 2000 Recruitment failure, life histories, and long term decline of Caribbean corals Ecology 81 2250 2263 Google Scholar Hughes, T. P., Baird, A. H., Dinsdale, E. A., Moltschaniwskyj, N. A., Pratchett, M. S., Tanner, J. E., Willis, B. L. 2000 Supply-side ecology works both ways: The link between benthic adults, fecundity, and larval recruits Ecology 81 2241 2249 Google Scholar James, M. K., Armsworth, P. R., Mason, L. B., Bode, L. 2002 The structure of reef fish metapopulations: modelling larval dispersal and retention patterns Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 269 2079 2086 Google Scholar Jeffery, C. J. 2000 Settlement in different-sized patches by the gregarious intertidal barnacle Chamaesipho tasmanica Foster and Anderson in New South Wales Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 252 15 26 PubMed Google Scholar Jenkins, S. R., Aberg, P., Cervin, G., Coleman, R. A., Delany, J., Della Santina, P., Hawkins, S. F., LaCroix, E., Myers, A. A., Lindegarth, M., Power, A. M., Roberts, M. F., Hartnoll, R. G. 2000 Spatial and temporal variation in settlement and recruitment of the intertidal barnacle Semibalanus balanoides (L.) (Crustacea : Cirripedia) over a European scale Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 243 209 225 Google Scholar Johnson, M. P. 2000 Scale of density dependence as an alternative to local dispersal in spatial ecology Jounal of Animal Ecology 69 536 540 Google Scholar Jones, G. P., Milicich, M. J., Emslie, M. J., Lunow, C. 1999 Self-recruitment in a coral reef fish population Nature 402 802 804 Google Scholar Lambert, W. J., Todd, C. D., Thorpe, J. P. 2003 Genetic population structure of two intertidal nudibranch molluscs with contrasting larval types: temporal variation and transplant experiments Marine Biology 142 461 471 Google Scholar Lewin, R. 1986 Supply-side ecology Science 234 25 27 Google Scholar Mora, C., Sale, P. F. 2002 Are populations of coral reef fish open or closed? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 17 422 428 Google Scholar Muko, S., Sakai, K., Iwasa, Y. 2001 Dynamics of marine sessile organisms with space limited growth and recruitment: application to corals Journal of Theoretical Biology 210 67 80 PubMed Google Scholar Paine, R. T. 2002 Advances in ecological understanding: by Kuhnian revolution or conceptual evolution? Ecology 83 1553 1559 Google Scholar Roberts, C. M. 1997 Connectivity and management of Caribbean coral reefs Science 278 1454 1457 PubMed Google Scholar Roughgarden, J., Iwasa, Y., Baxter, C. 1985 Demographic theory for an open marine population with space-limited recruitment Ecology 66 54 67 Google Scholar Sale, P. F. 1990 Recruitment of marine species: is the bandwagon rolling in the right direction? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 5 25 27 Google Scholar Schmitt, R. J., Holbrook, S. J. 1999 Mortality of larval damselfish: implications for assessing processes that determine abundance Ecology 80 35 50 Google Scholar Schmitt, R. J., Holbrook, S. J., Osenberg, C. W. 1999 Quantifying the effects of multiple processes on local abundance: a cohort approach for open populations Ecology Letters 2 304 310 Google Scholar Shanks, A. L., Mcculloch, A., Miller, J. 2003 Topographically generated fronts, very nearshore oceanography and the distribution of larval invertebrates and holoplankters Journal of Plankton Research 25 1251 1277 Google Scholar Shima, J. S. 1999 Variability in relative importance of determinants of reef fish recruitment Ecology Letters 2 304 310 Google Scholar Shkedy, Y., Roughgarden, J. 1997 Barnacle recruitment and population dynamics predicted from coastal upwelling Oikos 80 487 498 Google Scholar Swearer, S. E., Caselle, J. E., Lea, D. W., Warner, R. R. 1999 Larval retention and recruitment in an island population of a coral-reef fish Nature 402 799 802 Google Scholar Swearer, S. E., Shima, J. S., Hellberg, M. E., Thorrold, S. R., Jones, G.␣P., Robertson, D. R., Morgan, S. G., Selkoe, K. A., Ruiz, G. M., Warner, R. R. 2002 Evidence of self-recruitment in demersal marine populations Bulletin of Marine Science 70 251 271 Google Scholar Thomas, C. D., Kunin, W. E. 1999 The spatial structure of populations Journal of Animal Ecology 68 647 657 Google Scholar Wright, J. T., Steinberg, P. D. 2001 Effect of variable recruitment and post-recruitment herbivory on local abundance of a marine alga Ecology 82 2200 2215 Google Scholar Yund, P. O., Stires, A. 2002 Spatial variation in population dynamics in a colonial ascidian ( Botryllus schlosseri) Marine Biology 141 955 963 Google Scholar