Abstract
No single author presented Darwin with a more difficult question about his priority in discovering natural selection than the British comparative anatomist and paleontologist Richard Owen. Owen was arguably the most influential biologist in Great Britain in Darwin’s time. Darwin wanted his approbation for what he believed to be his own theory of natural selection. Unfortunately for Darwin, when Owen first commented in publication about Darwin’s theory of descent he was openly hostile (Edinb. Rev. vol. 111, Article VIII, 1860, pp. 487–533, anonymous). Darwin was taken off-guard. In private meetings and correspondence prior to 1860 Owen had been nothing but polite and friendly, even helping Darwin in cataloguing and analyzing Darwin’s zoological specimens from the Beagle voyage. Every early indication predicted a life-long friendship and collaboration. But that was not to be. Owen followed his slashing review with a mounting campaign in the 1860s to denounce and discredit both Darwin and his small but ascendant circle of friends and supporters. But that was not enough for Owen. Starting in 1866, perhaps by now realizing Darwin had landed the big fish, Owen launched a new campaign, to claim the discovery of “Darwin’s theory” for himself. Darwin naturally fought back, mainly in the “Historical Sketch” that he prefaced to Origin starting in 1861. But when we peel back the layers of personal animus and escalating vituperation we discover in fact their quarrel was generated more by mutual misunderstanding than scientific disagreement. The battle ended only when Darwin finally penetrated to the crux of the matter and put an end to the rivalry in 1872, in the final version of the Sketch.
Similar content being viewed by others
Brief Guide to Works by Charles Darwin and Richard Owen in the Darwin-Owen dispute 1858–1872
Darwin, Charles and Wallace, A. R. 1858a. “On the Tendency of Species to Form Varieties; and On the Perpetuation of Varieties and Species by Natural Means of Selection.” Journal of the Proceedings of the Linnaean Society 3: 45–62.
Darwin, Charles. 1959. On the Origin of Species: A Variorum Text. Edited by M. Peckham. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Darwin, Charles. 1975. Natural Selection. Edited by R. Stauffer. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Owen, Richard. 1849 [2008]. On the Nature of Limbs: A Discourse. Edited with Prefatory Essays, by Ronald Amundson and Brian Hall. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
Owen, Richard. 1850. “On Dinornis (Part IV): Containing the Restoration of the Feet of That Genus and of Palapteryx, with a Description of the Sternum in Palapteryx and Aptornis, Transactions of the Zoological Society 4: 1–20, and plates i–iv.
Owen, Richard. 1858. “Address of the President.” Report of the 28th meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, held at Leeds: xlix–cxi.
Owen, Richard. 1859a. “Summary of the Succession in Time and Geographical Distribution of Recent and Extinct Fossil Mammalia.” Proceedings of the Royal Institution of Great Britain 3: 109–116.
Owen, Richard. 1859b. On classification and geological distribution of the mammalia, with appendices on extinction and apes with references to the transmutation of species, being the Lecture delivered before the University of Cambridge. To which is added an appendix “On the Gorilla” and “On the extinction and transmutation of species.” London, J.W. Parker.
Owen, Richard. 1860a. Paleontology. Edinburgh: Adam & Charles Black (2nd ed., 1861).
Owen, Richard. 1860b. [Anonymous]. “Darwin On the Origin of Species.” Edinburgh Review 111: Article VIII, pp. 487–532.
Owen, Richard. 1866a. “Letter” to the London Review: May 5, p. 516.
Owen, Richard. 1866b. On the Anatomy of Vertebrates, volumes 1–2. London: Longman, Green & Co.
Owen, Richard. 1868a. On the Anatomy of Vertebrates, 3 vols. London: Longman, Green & Co.
References
Amundson, Ron. 2005. The Changing Role of the Embryo in Evolutionary Thought: Roots of Evo-Devo. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Amundson, Ron. 2008. See Owen, Richard, On the Nature of Limbs, 1849.
Appel, Toby. 1987. The Cuvier-Geoffroy Debate: French Biology in the Decades before Darwin. New York: Oxford University Press.
Benton, Michael. 1982. “Progressionism in the 1850’s: Lyell, Owen, Mantell, and the Elgin Fossil Reptile Leptopleuron (Telerpeton).” Archives of Natural History 11: 123–136.
Bowler, Peter. 1976. Fossils and Progress: Paleontology and the Idea of Progressive Evolution in the Nineteenth Century. New York: Science History Publications.
Brinkman, P. D. 2010. “Charles Darwin’s Beagle Voyage, Fossil Vertebrate Succession, and ‘the Gradual Birth & Death of Species’.” Journal of the History of Biology 43: 363–399.
Brooke, John Hedley. 1977a. “Richard Owen, William Whewell, and the Vestiges.” The British Journal for the History of Science 10: 132–145.
Brooke, John Hedley. 1977b. “The Natural Theology of the Geologists: Some Theological Strata.” British Journal for the History of Science 10: 132–145.
Browne, Janet. 1995. Charles Darwin: Voyaging. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Corsi, Pietro. 1988. The Age of Lamarck: Evolutionary Theories in France, 1790–1830. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Darwin, Charles, and A.R. Wallace. 1858b. “On the Tendency of Species to Form Varieties; and On the Perpetuation of Varieties and Species by Natural Means of Selection.” Journal of the Proceedings of the Linnaean Society 3: 45–62.
Darwin, Charles. 1959. On the Origin of Species: A Variorum Text. Edited by M. Peckham. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Darwin, Charles. 1975. Natural Selection. Edited by R. Stauffer. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Darwin, Charles. 1985. The Correspondence of Charles Darwin. Edited by Frederick Burkhardt et’al. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Darwin, Charles. 1987. Charles Darwin’s Notebooks 1836–1842. Edited by P. Barrett et’al. New York and London: Cornell University Press.
Darwin, Charles. 1988. “Darwin’s Reading Notebooks.” Appendix IV, in Volume IV of The Correspondence of Charles Darwin. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 435–573.
Darwin, Charles. 1989. Voyage of the Beagle: Charles Darwin’s Journal of Researches. Edited by Janet Browne and Michael Neve. London: Penguin.
De Beer, Gavin, ed. 1960. “Darwin’s Notebooks on Transmutation of Species, Part I, First Notebook.” Bulletin of the British Museum (Natural History), Historical Series, 2: 23–73.
Desmond, Adrian J. 1979. “Designing the Dinosaur: Richard Owen’s Response to Robert Edmond Grant.” Isis 70: 224–234.
Desmond, Adrian J. 1982. Archetypes and Ancestors: Paleontology in Victorian London 1850–1875. London: Blond and Briggs.
Desmond, Adrian J. 1985a. “Richard Owen’s Reaction to Transmutation in the 1830’s.” British Journal for the History of Science 18: 25–50.
Desmond, Adrian J. 1985b. “The Making of Institutional Zoology in London 1822–1836: Parts I and II.” History of Science 23(153–185): 223–250.
Desmond, Adrian J. 2011. The Politics of Evolution: Morphology, Medicine, and Reform in Radical London. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Di Gregorio, Mario. 1990. Charles Darwin’s Marginalia. New York: Garland Press.
Elwick, James. 2007. “Styles of Reasoning in Early to Mid-Victorian Life Research: Analysis: Synthesis and Palaetiology.” Journal of the History of Biology 40: 35–69.
Friedman, William E. and Diggle, Pamela. 2011. “Charles Darwin and the Origins of Plant Evolutionary Developmental Biology.” Plant Cell 4: 1194–1207.
Gayon, Jean. 1998. Darwin’s Struggle for Survival: Heredity and the Hypothesis of Natural Selection. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ghiselin, Michael. 2009. Darwin: A Reader’s Guide. Occasional Papers of the California Academy of Sciences, Number 155. San Francisco: California Academy of Sciences.
Glick, Thomas F. and Kohn, David, eds. 1996. Darwin on Evolution. The Development of the Theory of Natural Selection. Indianapolis:Hackett Publishing Company.
Gould, S. J. 2002. The Structure of Evolutionary Theory. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
Hull, D. L. 1973. Darwin and His Critics: The Reception of Darwin’s Theory of Evolution by the Scientific Community. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Huxley, Leonard. 1900. Life and Letters of Thomas Henry Huxley. New York: D. Appleton and Co.
Huxley, Leonard. 2014. Darwin’s Dice: The Idea of Chance in the Thought of Charles Darwin. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
Johnson, Curtis. 2007. “The Preface to Darwin’s Origin of Species: The Curious History of the ‘Historical Sketch’.” Journal of the History of Biology 40: 529–556.
Kohn, David. 1980. “Theories to Work By: Rejected Theories, Reproduction, and Darwin’s Path to Natural Selection.” Studies in the History of Biology 4: 67–170.
Kohn, David, ed. 1985. The Darwinian Heritage. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Kohn, David et’al., eds. 2003–2017. The Darwin Manuscript Project. New York: American Museum of Natural History
—— 2014. Darwin’s Dice: The Idea of Chance in the Thought of Charles Darwin. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
Mayr, E. 1988. Toward a New Philosophy of Biology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Moore, James. 1989. History, Humanity, and Evolution. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.
MacLeod, R. M. 1965. “Evolutionism and Richard Owen, 1830–1868: An Episode in Darwin’s Century.” Isis 56: 259–280.
Ospovat, Dov. 1976. “The Influence of Karl Ernst von Baer’s Embryology, 1828–1859: A Reappraisal in Light of Richard Owen’s and William B. Carpenter’s ‘Palaeontological Application of ‘Von Baer’s Law’.” Journal of the History of Biology 9: 1–28.
Ospovat, Dov. 1978. “Perfect Adaptation and Teleological Explanation: Approaches to the Problem of the History of Life in the mid nineteenth century.” Studies in History of Biology 2: 33–56.
Ospovat, Dov. 1981. The Development of Darwin’s Theory: Natural History, Natural Theology, and Natural Selection, 1838–1859. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
Owen, R. 1844. “Report on the Extinct Mammals of Australia, with Descriptions of Certain Fossils Indicative of the Former Existence in that Continent of Large Marsupial Representatives of the Order PACHYDERMATA.” Report of the 14th Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 14: 223–240.
Owen, R. 1846. “On the Geographical Distribution of Extinct Mammalia.” Athenaeum 14: 178–179.
Owen, R. 1849 [2008]. On the Nature of Limbs: A Discourse. Edited with Prefatory esSays, by Ronald Amundson and Brian Hall. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Owen, R. 1850. “On Dinornis (Part IV): Containing the Restoration of the Feet of that Genus and of Palapteryx, with a Description of the Sternum in Palapteryx and Aptornis. Transactions of the Zoological Society 4: 1–20, and plates i–iv.
Owen, R. 1858. “Address of the President.” Report of the 28th Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, held at Leeds: xlix–cxi.
Owen, R. 1859a. “Summary of the Succession in Time and Geographical Distribution of Recent and Extinct Fossil Mammalia.” Proceedings of the Royal Institution of Great Britain 3: 109–116.
Owen, R. 1859b. On Classification and Geological Distribution of the Mammalia, with Appendices on Extinction and Apes with References to the Transmutation of Species, being the Lecture delivered before the University of Cambridge. To which is added an Appendix “On the Gorilla” and “On the Extinction and Transmutation of Species.” London: J.W. Parker.
Owen, R. 1860a. Paleontology. Edinburgh: Adam & Charles Black (2nd. ed., 1861).
Owen, R. 1860b. [Anonymous]. “Darwin on the Origin of Species.” Edinburgh Review 111, Article VIII: 487–532.
Owen, R. 1863. “On the Aye-aye (Chiromus, Cuvier; Ciromus madagascariensis, Desm.; Sciurus madagascariensis Gmel., Sonnerat; Lemur psiodactylis, Schreber, Shaw). Transactions of the Zoological Society 5(pt. 2): 33–101.
Owen, R. 1866a. “Letter” to the London Review, May 5: 516.
Owen, R. 1866b. On the Anatomy of Vertebrates, volumes 1–2. London: Longman, Green & Co.
Owen, R. 1868b. On the Anatomy of Vertebrates, 3 volumes. London: Longman, Green & Co.
Owen, Richard S. 1894. The Life of Richard Owen. New York: D. Appleton and Company.
Richards, Eveleen. 1987. “A Question of Property Rights: Richard Owen’s Evolutionism.” British Journal for the History of Science 20: 129–171.
Richards, Robert J. 1989. Darwin and the Emergence of Evolutionary Theories of Mind and Behavior. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Richards, Robert J. 1992. The Meaning of Evolution: The Morphological Construction and Ideological Reconstruction of Darwin’s Theory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Richards, Robert J. 2017. “Did Goethe and Schelling Endorse Species Evolution?” Joshua Lambier and Joel Faflak (eds.), Marking Time: Romanticism and Evolution. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Rudwick, Martin. 1976. The Meaning of Fossils. New York: Science History Publications.
Rupke, Nicolaas. 1985. “Richard Owen’s Hunterian Lectures 1837–1855.” Medical History 29: 237–258.
Rupke, Nicolaas. 1994. Richard Owen: Victorian Naturalist. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
Rupke, Nicolaas. 2009. Richard Owen: Biology Without Darwin. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ruse, M. 1979. The Darwinian Revolution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Secord, James, ed. 2008. Charles Darwin: Evolutionary Writings. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Secord, James. 2014. Visions of Science: Books and Readers at the Dawn of the Victorian Age. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Sloan, Philip R. 1985. “Darwin’s Invertebrate Program, 1826–1836: Preconditions for Transformism.” D. Kohn (ed.), The Darwinian Heritage. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Stott, Rebecca. 2012. Darwin’s Ghosts: The Secret History of Evolution. New York: Spiegel and Grau.
Sulloway, F. 1982. “Darwin’s Conversion.” Journal of the History of Biology 15: 325–396.
Van Wyhe, John, ed. 2002–. The Complete Work of Charles Darwin Online. http://darwin-online.org.uk/.
Young, R. M. 1980. “Natural Theology, Victorian Periodicals, and the Fragmentation of a Common Context.” C. Chant and J. Fauvel (eds.), Darwin to Einstein: Historical Studies on Science and Belief. Harlow: Longman.
Acknowledgements
I owe debts of gratitude to the editors of the Journal of the History of Biology Michael Dietrich, Karen Rader, and Marsha Richmond for their encouragement of this project, the anonymous reviewers of earlier versions of the manuscript, and the many scholars who have preceded me, whose contributions are registered in the text, footnotes, and references. Alexis Johnson provided valuable assistance in layout and graphics.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Johnson, C.N. Charles Darwin, Richard Owen, and Natural Selection: A Question of Priority. J Hist Biol 52, 45–85 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-018-9514-2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-018-9514-2