Advertisement

Journal of the History of Biology

, Volume 38, Issue 1, pp 101–121 | Cite as

Against “Revolution” and “Evolution”

  • Jonathan Hodge
Article

Abstract

Those standard historiographic themes of “evolution” and “revolution” need replacing. They perpetuate mid-Victorian scientists’ history of science. Historians’ history of science does well to take in the long run from the Greek and Hebrew heritages on, and to work at avoiding misleading anachronism and teleology. As an alternative to the usual “evo-revo” themes, a historiography of origins and species, of cosmologies (including microcosmogonies and macrocosmogonies) and ontologies, is developed here. The advantages of such a historiography are illustrated by looking briefly at a number of transitions the transition from Greek and Hebrew doctrines to their integrations by medieval authors; the transition from the Platonist, Aristotelian, Christian Aquinas to the Newtonian Buffon and to the no less Newtonian Lamarck; the departures the early Darwin made away from Lamarck’s and from Lyell’s views. Issues concerning historical thinking about nature, concerning essentialism and concerning classification are addressed in an attempt to challenge customary stereotypes. Questions about originality and influence are raised, especially concerning Darwin’s “tree of life” scheme. The broader historiography of Darwinian science as a social ideology, and as a “worldview,” is examined and the scope for revisions emphasised. Throughout, graduate students are encouraged to see this topic area not as worked out, but as full of opportunities for fresh contributions.

Keywords

Buffon cosmologies Darwin Greeks Hebrews historiography Lamarck ontologies origins species 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Hodge, Michael Jonathan 1990“Origins and species before and after Darwin.”Olby, R.C.Cantor, G.N.Christie, J.R.R.Hodge, M.J.S. eds. Companion to the History of Modern ScienceRoutledgeLondon and New York374395Google Scholar
  2. Hodge, Michael Jonathan 1991Origins and Species: A Study of the Historical Sources of Darwinism and the Contexts of Some Other Accounts of Organic Diversity from Plato and AristotleGarlandNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  3. Hodge, Michael JonathanRadick, Gregory eds. 2003The Cambridge Companion to DarwinCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  4. Sapp, Jan. 2003. Genesis. The Evolution of Biology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Division of History and Philosophy of Science, School of PhilosophyUniversity of LeedsLeedsUK

Personalised recommendations