Journal of the History of Biology

, Volume 37, Issue 3, pp 515–555

The Ibis: Transformations in a Twentieth Century British Natural History Journal

  • Kristin Johnson
Article

Abstract

The contents of the British Ornithologists' Union's journal, The Ibis, during the first half of the 20th century illustrates some of the transformations that have taken place in the naturalist tradition. Although later generations of ornithologists described these changes as logical and progressive, their historical narratives had more to do with legitimizing the infiltration of the priorities of evolutionary theory, ecology, and ethology than analyzing the legacy of the naturalist tradition on its own terms. Despite ornithologists' claim that the journal's increasing focus on "biology" represented a natural development after the preliminary phase of systematics and geographical ornithology, in fact a small group campaigned to bring the priorities of population ecology, behavior, and selection theory into the journal and British ornithology more generally. The problems involved in this transition highlight the importance of methodological and institutional context in determining and reinforcing appropriate research programs for ornithologists. Comparing the discipline-building rhetoric of moderns with the contents of the past illustrates how modern evaluations of 19th century research programs have been enmeshed in ornithologists' endeavors to forge new identities for traditional disciplines.

biogeography British natural history Claude B. Ticehurst commemoration David Lack ecology Ernst Mayr ornithology Reginald E. Moreau systematics 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Abir-Am,P.G.1982.''Essay Review:How Scientists View their Heroes:Some Remarks on the Mechanism of Myth Construction.''Journal of the History of Biology 15:281-315.Google Scholar
  2. Abir-Am,P.G.and Elliott,C.A.(eds.).1999.''Commemorative Practices in Science: Historical Perspectives on the Politics of Collective Memory.''Osiris Volume 14.Google Scholar
  3. Ainley,M.G.1985.From Natural History to Avian Biology:Canadian Ornithology, 1860-1950.Ph.D Dissertation:McGill University.Google Scholar
  4. Ainley,M.G.1993.Restless Energy:A Biography of William Rowan,1891-1957.Vehicule Press.Google Scholar
  5. Allen,D.L.1976.The Naturalist in Britain:A Social History.London: Allen Lane.Google Scholar
  6. Allen,D.L.1996.''The Struggle for Specialist Journals:Natural History in the British Periodical Market in the First Half of the 19th Century.''Archives of Natural History 23: 107-123.Google Scholar
  7. Allen,D.L.1998.''On Parallel Lines:Natural History and Biology from the Late Victorian Period.''Archives of Natural History 25:361-371.Google Scholar
  8. Bannerman,D.A.1924.''Letter to the Editor.''The Ibis 11th Series 6:816-818.Google Scholar
  9. Allen,D.L.1931.''Review of 'Glover M Allen 's The Birds of Liberia.'''The Ibis 13th Series 1: 593.Google Scholar
  10. Barclay-Smith,P.1959.''The British Contribution to Bird Protection.''The Ibis 101: 115-122.Google Scholar
  11. Barrow,M.V.1998.A Passion for Birds:American Ornithology after Audubon. Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  12. Bates,G.L.1931.''On Geographical Variation within the Limits of West Africa:Some Generalizations.''The Ibis 13th Series 1:255-302.Google Scholar
  13. Bensaude-Vincent,B.1996.''Between History and Memory:Centennial and Bicen-tennial Images of Lavoisier.''Isis 87:481-499.Google Scholar
  14. Bowler,P.J.1996.Life 's Splendid Drama:Evolutionary Biology and the Reconstruction of Life 's Ancestry,1860-1940.University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  15. Browne,J.1983.The Secular Ark:Studies in the History of Biogeography.Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  16. Browne,J.1996.''Biogeography and Empire.''In N.Jardine, J.A.Secord and E.C. Spary (eds.),Cultures of Natural History.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.305-321.Google Scholar
  17. Burkhardt,F.1974.''England and Scotland:The Learned Societies.''In T.F.Glick, (ed.),The Comparative Reception of Darwinism.Austin: University of Texas Press, pp.32-74.Google Scholar
  18. Cain,J.1993.''Common Problems and Cooperative Solutions:Organizational Activity in Evolutionary Studies,1936-1947.''Isis 84:1-25.Google Scholar
  19. Cain,J.1994.''Ernst Mayr as Community Architect:Launching the Society for the Study of Evolution and the Journal Evolution.''Biology and Philosophy 9:387-427.Google Scholar
  20. Camerini,J.1993.''Evolution,Biogeography,and Maps:an Early History of Wallace 's Line.''Isis 84:700-727.Google Scholar
  21. Cox,D.1979.Charles Elton and the Emergence of Modern Ecology.Dissertation: Washington University.Google Scholar
  22. Crocroft,P.1991.Elton 's Ecologists:A History of the Bureau of Animal Population. University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  23. Davis,W.E.Jr.,and Jackson,J.A.(eds.).1995.Contributions to the History of North American Ornithology,Vol.I.Cambridge: Nuttall Ornithological Club.Google Scholar
  24. Crocroft 2000.Contributions to the History of North American Ornithology,Vol.II. Cambridge: Nuttall Ornithological Club.Google Scholar
  25. Desmond,A.1985.''The Making of Institutional Zoology in London 1822-1836.'' History of Science 23:153-185,223-250.Google Scholar
  26. Crocroft 2001.''Rede ning the X Axis:'Professionals,''Amateurs 'and the Making of Mid-Victorian Britain-A Progress Report.''Journal of the History of Biology 34:3-50.Google Scholar
  27. Egerton,F.N.1968.''Studies of Animal Populations from Lamarck to Darwin.'' Journal of the History of Biology 1:225-259.Google Scholar
  28. Ellegard,A.1958.Darwin and the General Reader:The Reception of Darwin 's Theory of Evolution in the British Periodical Press,1859-1872,[Vol.LXIV ].Go ¨teborg:Acta Universitatis Gothoburgensis,Go ¨teborg Universitets Arsskrift.Google Scholar
  29. Elton,C.1929.''Ecology,Animal.''Encyclopedia Brittanica 14th ed.7:915-924.Google Scholar
  30. Farber,P.L.1980.''The Development of Ornithological Collections in the Late Eighteenth and Early Nineteeth Centuries and their Relationship to the Emergence of Ornithology as a Scientific Discipline.''Journal of the Society for the Bibliography of Natural History 9:391-394.Google Scholar
  31. Farber,P.L.1982.The Emergence of Ornithology as a Scientific Discipline:1760-1850.London: D.Reidel Publishing Company.Google Scholar
  32. Farber,P.L.1985.''Theories for the Birds:An Inquiry into the Significance of the Theory of Evolution for the History of Systematics.''In M.Osler and P.L.Farber (eds.), Religion,Science,and Worldview:Essays in Honor of Richard S.Westfall. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,pp.321-339.Google Scholar
  33. Farber,P.L.2000.Finding Order in Nature:The Naturalist Tradition from Linnaeus to E.O. Wilson.John Hopkins University Press.Google Scholar
  34. Fisher,J.1949.''Letter to the Editor.''Bird Notes 91:171-172.Google Scholar
  35. Futuyama,D.J.1986.''Reflections on Reflections:Ecology and Evolutionary Biology,'' Journal of the History of Biology 19:303-312.Google Scholar
  36. Grant,C.H.B.1943.''Preface.''The Ibis 85:iii.Google Scholar
  37. Grant,P.R.1986.Ecology and Evolution of Darwin 's Finches.Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  38. Gross,A., Harmon,J.and Reidy,M.S.2002.Communicating Science:The Scientific Article from the Seventeenth Century to the Present.Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  39. Gunther,A.1975.A Century of Zoology:Through the Lives of Two Keepers.London: Wm.Dawson &Sons Ltd.Google Scholar
  40. Haffer,J.1992.''The History of Species Concepts and Species Limits in Ornithology.'' Bulletin of the British Ornithologists 'Club,Centenary Supplement 112:107-158.Google Scholar
  41. Haffer,J.1994.''Die Seebohm-Hartert-'Schule 'der europa ¨ischen Ornithologie.''Journal fu ¨r Ornithologie 135:37-54.Google Scholar
  42. Haffer,J.2001.''Die 'Stresemannsche Revolution 'in der Ornithologie des fru ¨hen 20. Jahrhunderts.''Journal fu ¨r Ornithologie 142:381-389.Google Scholar
  43. Haffer,J.2001.''Ornithological Research Traditions in Central Europe during the 19th and 20th Centuries,''Journal fu ¨r Ornithologie 142:27-93.Google Scholar
  44. Haffer,J.H., Erich,R.and Klaus,W.2000.''Erwin Stresemann (1889-1972):Leben und Werk eines Pioniers der wissenschaftlichen Ornithologie.''Acta Historica Leopoldina 34:399-427.Google Scholar
  45. Hagen,J.1984.''Experimentalists and Naturalists in Twentieth-Century Botany: Experimental Taxonomy,1920-1950.''Journal of the History of Biology 17:249-270.Google Scholar
  46. Hagen,J.1992.The Entangled Bank.New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
  47. Hartert,E.1904.''Some Anticriticisms.''The Ibis 8th Series 4:542-551.Google Scholar
  48. Hesse,R.1937.Ecological Animal Geography.London: Chapman and Hall,Ltd. Hickling,R.(ed.).1983.Enjoying Ornithology:A Celebration of Fifty-Years of the British Trust for Ornithology,1933-1983.Calton:T&A.D.Poyser.Google Scholar
  49. Ingram,C.1966.In Search of Birds.London: H.F.and G.Witherby.Google Scholar
  50. Jardine,N., Secord,J.A.and Spary,E.C.(eds.).1996.Cultures of Natural History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  51. Keeney,E.B.1992.The Botanizers:Amateur Scientists in Nineteenth-Century America. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press,1992.Google Scholar
  52. Kimler,W.1983.''Mimicry:Views of Naturalists and Ecologists before the Modern Synthesis.''In M.Greene,(ed.),Dimensions of Darwinism.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,pp.97-127.Google Scholar
  53. Kingsland,S.1985.Modeling Nature:Episodes in the History of Population Ecology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  54. Kohler,R.E.2002.Landscapes and Labscapes:Exploring the Lab-Field Border in Biology.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  55. Kohlstedt,S.G.1985.''Institutional History.''Osiris 2nd series:17-36.Google Scholar
  56. Lack,D.1937.''A Review of Bird Census Work and Bird Population Problems.''The Ibis 14th Series 1:369-396.Google Scholar
  57. Lack,D.1941.''The Evolution of the Galapagos Finches.''The Ibis 14th Series 5:637-638.Google Scholar
  58. Lack,D.1943a.''Huxley on Evolution.''The Ibis 85:116-117.Google Scholar
  59. Lack,D.1943b.''Mayr on Systematics and the Origin of Species.''The Ibis 85:360-361.Google Scholar
  60. Lack,D.1949.''The Position of the Edward Grey Institute,Oxford.''Bird Notes 23:231-236.Google Scholar
  61. Lack,D.1959.''Some British Pioneers in Ornithological Research,1859-1939.''The Ibis 101:71-81.Google Scholar
  62. Lack,D.1965.''Evolutionary Ecology.''The Journal of Ecology 53:237-245.Google Scholar
  63. Laudan,R.1977.''Ideas and Organizations in British Geology:A Case Study in Institutional History.''Isis 68:527-538.Google Scholar
  64. Lewontin,R.C.1980.''Theoretical Population Genetics in the Evolutionary Synthesis.''In E.Mayr and W.Provine,(eds.),The Evolutionary Synthesis:Perspectives on the Unification of Biology.Cambridge: Harvard University Press,pp.58-68.Google Scholar
  65. Lodge,G.E.1940.''The Bird-Room at the British Museum (Natural History).''The Ibis 14th Series 4:385-386.Google Scholar
  66. Longsta.,T.G.1924.''Notes from Spitsbergen,1923.''The Ibis 11th Series 6:480-495.Google Scholar
  67. Longsta.,T.G.1926.''Local Changes in Distribution.''The Ibis 12th Series 2:637-656.Google Scholar
  68. Lowe,P.R.1920.''de Haviland on Forest,Steppe and Tundra.''The Ibis 11th Series 2: 321.Google Scholar
  69. Lowe,P.R.1922.''A Note on Acquired or Somatic Variations.''The Ibis 11th Series 4:712-715.Google Scholar
  70. Lowe,P.R.1941.''Evolution of the Galapagos Finches.''The Ibis 14th Series 5:315-317.Google Scholar
  71. Lowe,W.P.1940.''The Bird-Room at the British Museum (Natural History).''Ibis 14th Series 4:386.Google Scholar
  72. Lynes,H.1924.''On the Birds of North and Central Darfur with Notes on the West-Central Kordofan and North Nuba Provinces of British Sudan.''Ibis 11th Series 6: 399-446,648-719.Google Scholar
  73. Lynes,H.and Sclater,W.L.1933.''Lynes-Vincent Tour in Central and West Africa in 1930-31.''The Ibis 13th Series 3:694-730.Google Scholar
  74. Mayr,E.and Provine,W.(eds.).1980.The Evolutionary Synthesis:Perspectives on the Unification of Biology.Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  75. Mearns,B.and Mearns,R.1998.The Bird Collectors.London: Academic Press,1998.Google Scholar
  76. Meinertzhagen,R.1959.''Recollections of Some Famous British ornithologists.''The Ibis 101:46-52.Google Scholar
  77. Mitman,G.1992.The State of Nature:Ecology,Community,and American Social Thought,1900-1950.Chicago: Chicago University Press.Google Scholar
  78. Mitman,G.and Burkhardt R.W.Jr.1991.''Struggling for Identity:The Study of Animal Behavior in America,1930-1945.''In K.R.Benson, J.Maienschein and R.Rainger,(eds.),The Expansion of American Biology.New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press,pp.164-194.Google Scholar
  79. Moreau,R.E.1940a.''Lack 's Recent Papers.''The Ibis 14th Series 4:162-163.Google Scholar
  80. Moreau,R.E.1940b.''Lack and Venables on British Woodland Birds.''The Ibis 14th Series 4: 163-164.Google Scholar
  81. Moreau,R.E.1959.''The Centenarian 'Ibis.'''The Ibis 101:19-38.Google Scholar
  82. Moreau,R.E.1979.''R.E.Moreau.''The Ibis 121:549-565.Google Scholar
  83. Nicholson,E.M.1959.''The British Approach to Ornithology.''The Ibis 101:39-45. ''Notice to Contributors.''1932.The Ibis 13th Series 2:216.Google Scholar
  84. Nyhart,L.1991.''Writing Zoologically:the Zeitschrift fu ¨r wissenschaftliche Zoologie and the Zoological Community in late Nineteenth-Century Germany.''In P.Dear, (ed.),The Literary Structure of Scientific Argument:Historical Studies.University of Pennsylvania Press,pp.43-71.Google Scholar
  85. Nyhart,L.1995.''Essay Review:Biology and Imperialism.''Journal of the History of Biology 28:533-543.Google Scholar
  86. Nye,M.J.1996.Before Big Science:The Pursuit of Modern Chemistry and Physics 1800-1940.New York: Twayne Publishers. Obituary.1945.''William Lutley Sclater.''The Ibis 87:115-121.Google Scholar
  87. Oreskes,N.1999.The Rejection of Continental Drift:Theory and Method in American Earth Science.New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  88. Paget Wilkes, A.H.1928.''The Birds of the Region South of Lake Nyasa,Part I.Non-passerine Birds.''The Ibis 12th Series 4:690-748.Google Scholar
  89. Provine,W.1971.The Origins of Theoretical Population Genetics.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  90. Review.1924.''Walter.P Taylor 's 'A Distributional and Ecological Study of Mount Rainer,Washington 'in Ecology.''The Ibis 11th Series 6:181.Google Scholar
  91. Review.1928.''McWilliams on the Birds of Bute.''The Ibis 12th Series 4:152.Google Scholar
  92. Review.1929a.''Linsdale on Censuses.''The Ibis 12th Series 5:166-167.Google Scholar
  93. Review.1929b.''Linsdale on the Birds of Kansas.''The Ibis 12th Series 5:367.Google Scholar
  94. Review.1931.''H.S.Swarth 's 'The Avifauna of the Galapagos Islands.'''The Ibis 13th Series 1:801.Google Scholar
  95. Review.1932.''Nicholson on Bird-watching.''The Ibis 13th Series 2:187-188.Google Scholar
  96. Review.1933a.''Baldwin and Kendeigh on the Physiology of the Temperature of Birds.''The Ibis 13th Series 3:145.Google Scholar
  97. Review.1933b.''Dr.Ernst Hartert 's Die vogel der palaarktischen fauna.''The Ibis 13th Series 1:151-152.Google Scholar
  98. Review.1934a.''Lack on the Control of Breeding Time.''The Ibis 13th Series 4:188-189.Google Scholar
  99. Review.1934b.''Lack on Habitat Distribution.''The Ibis 13th Series 4:845-846.Google Scholar
  100. Review.1935.''Richmond 's 'Quest for Birds.'''The Ibis 13th Series 5:224-226.Google Scholar
  101. Review.1940a.''Hosking and Newberry 's 'Intimate Sketches from Bird Life.'''The Ibis 14th Series 4:366-367.Google Scholar
  102. Review.1940b.''Lack on Changes Due to A.orestation.''The Ibis 14th Series 4:367-368.Google Scholar
  103. Review.1941.''Moreau on the Breeding Biology of Hirundo s.smithii.''The Ibis 14th Series 5:198-199.Google Scholar
  104. Ricklefs,R.E.2000a.''Lack,Skutch,and Moreau:the Early Development of Life-History Thinking.''The Condor 102:3-8.Google Scholar
  105. Ricklefs,R.E.2000b.''Density Dependence,Evolutionary Optimization,and the Diversi cation of Avian Life Histories.''The Condor 102:9-22.Google Scholar
  106. Rothschild,M.1983.Dear Lord Rothschild:Birds,Butter.ies and History.Balaban: Philadelphia.Google Scholar
  107. Sibley,C.G.1955.''Ornithology.''In E.L.Kessel,(ed.),A Century of Progress in the Natural Sciences.San Francisco: California Academy of Sciences,pp.629-659.Google Scholar
  108. Smocovitis,V.B.1992.''Unifying Biology:The Evolutionary Synthesis and Evolutionary Biology.''Journal of the History of Biology 25:1-65.Google Scholar
  109. Snow,D.1992.Birds,Discovery,and Conservation:100 Years of the British Ornithologists 'Club.Helm Information.Google Scholar
  110. Sorensen,W.C.1995.Brethren of the Net:American Entomology,1840-1880.Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press.Google Scholar
  111. Stresemann,E.1975.Ornithology:From Aristotle to the Present.Cambridge,MA: Harvard University.Originally published in 1951 as Die Entwicklung der Ornithologie von Aristoteles bis zur Gegenwart.Berlin:F.W.Peters.Google Scholar
  112. Thorpe,W.1925.''Some Ecological Aspects of British Ornithology.''British Birds 24: 106-119.Google Scholar
  113. Thorpe,W.1974.''David Lambert Lack 1910-1973.''Biographical Memoirs of the Fellows of the Royal Society of London,pp.271-293.Google Scholar
  114. Ticehurst,C.B.1924.''Letter to the Editor.''The Ibis 11th Series 6:813-815.Google Scholar
  115. Ticehurst,C.B.1931.''Editorial.''The Ibis 13th Series 1:i-iii.Google Scholar
  116. Ticehurst,C.B.1940.''The Bird-Room at the British Museum (Natural History).''The Ibis 14th Series 4:183-185.Google Scholar
  117. Tinbergen,N.1959.''Recent British Contributions to Scientific Ornithology.''The Ibis 101:126-131.Google Scholar
  118. Trott,A.C.1947.''Notes on Birds seen in the Lar Valley in 1943 and 1944.''The Ibis 89:232.Google Scholar
  119. Vincent,J.1933.''The Birds of Northern Portuguese East Africa.Comprising a List of, and Observations on,Collections Made during the British Museum Expedition of 1931-32.''The Ibis 13th Series 3:611-652.Google Scholar
  120. Walters,M.2003.A Concise History of Ornithology:The Lives and Works of its Founding Figures.London: Christopher Helm.Google Scholar
  121. Whistler,H.1941.''Claud Buchanan Ticehurst.''The Ibis 14th Series 5:321-335.Google Scholar
  122. Witherby,H.F 1943.''Hubert Lynes:a Biographical Sketch.''The Ibis 85:198-213.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Kristin Johnson
    • 1
  1. 1.Center for Biology and Society, School of Life Sciences 874501Arizona State UniversityTempeUSA

Personalised recommendations