Looking for Professor Right: mentee selection of mentors in a formal mentoring program
- First Online:
Finding a suitable mentor is crucial to the success of mentoring relationships. In the mentoring literature, however, there is conflicting evidence about the best ways to support the pairing process in organisational mentoring programs. This paper presents a detailed analysis of the pairing process in an academic mentoring program that has implications for building a mentoring culture in higher education. The program which began with a pilot and has continued for five years with one hundred and twenty one participants, was conducted with mentees selecting their own mentor from a pool of mentors who volunteered to be part of the program. In the pilot program, where mentors and mentees first met as one group, some mentees reported that the process of selecting and approaching a mentor was uncomfortable and intimidating. Nine of twenty-three potential mentees did not form mentoring relationships. Analysis of subsequent program evaluation data pointed to the importance of two factors in the pairing process: personal connections and facilitation of the selection process. This study at a research-intensive university demonstrates that when the pairing process is tailored to individual mentees, they are comfortable selecting a mentor and to then develop a successful mentoring relationship.
KeywordsAcademic development Flexible mentoring Mentor-mentee choice Pairing process
- Alleman, E., Cochran, J., Doverspike, J., & Newman, I. (1984). Enriching mentoring relationships. The Personnel and Guidance Journal, 62, 329–332.Google Scholar
- Becher, T., & Trowler, P. R. (2001). Academic tribes and territories: Intellectual enquiry and the cultures of disciplines (2nd ed.). Buckingham: Open University Press/SRHE.Google Scholar
- Boice, R. (1992b). The new faculty member: Supporting and fostering professional development. Jossey-Bass Publishers: San Francisco.Google Scholar
- Clarke, M. (2004). Reconceptualising mentoring: Reflections by an early career researcher. Issues in Educational Research, 14(2), 121–143.Google Scholar
- Fives, H., Buehl, M. M., & Myers, S. D. (2008). The cultivation of a professional association-based new faculty mentoring program. In C. A. Mullen (Ed.), The handbook of formal mentoring in higher education: A case study approach (pp. 165–190). Northwood, MA: Christopher-Gordon Publishers, Inc.Google Scholar
- Gardiner, M. (1999). Making a difference: Flinders University mentoring scheme for early career women researchers. Pilot program report. http://www.flinders.edu.au/staffdev/courses/research/resources/Full_report1999.pdf. Accessed 22 July 2009.
- Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. New Jersey: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Long, J. (1997). The dark side of mentoring. Australian Educational Researcher, 24(2), 115–133.Google Scholar
- Madison, J., Knight, B. A., & Watson, K. (1993). Mentoring amongst academics in Australia: A case study. Australian Educational Researcher, 20(1), 77–91.Google Scholar
- Metros, S. E., & Yang, C. (2006). The importance of mentors. Educase www.educause.edu/content.asp?page_id=10631&bhcp=1. Accessed 12 December 2006.
- Mullen, C. A. (2008). Conclusion: Mentoring, change, and diversity: Findings and lessons. In C. A. Mullen (Ed.), The handbook of formal mentoring in higher education: A case study approach (pp. 297–319). Northwood, MA: Christopher-Gordon Publishers Inc.Google Scholar
- Murray, M. (1991). Beyond the myths and magic of mentoring. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
- Treleaven, L. (1994). Making a space: Collaborative inquiry as staff development. In P. Reason (Ed.), Participation in human inquiry (pp. 138–162). London, United Kingdom: SAGE.Google Scholar
- University of Sydney. (2009a). http://www.usyd.edu.au/about/profile/pub/facts.shtml. Accessed 7 January 2009.
- University of Sydney. (2009b). Statistics Unit http://www.planning.usyd.edu.au/statistics/staff/staff.php?yr=2008&type=1&fac=u. Accessed 7 January 2009.
- University of Sydney. (2009c). Statistics Unit http://www.planning.usyd.edu.au/statistics/load/ls08/bfcat.php?fac=6&semind=3&ci=3. Accessed 7 January 2009.
- Zachary, L. J. (2005). Creating a mentoring culture: The organization’s guide. Jossey-Bass: San Francisco.Google Scholar