HEC Forum

pp 1–21 | Cite as

When Religion and Medicine Clash: Non-beneficial Treatments and Hope for a Miracle

  • Philip M. RosoffEmail author


Patient and family demands for the initiation or continuation of life-sustaining medically non-beneficial treatments continues to be a major issue. This is especially relevant in intensive care units, but is also a challenge in other settings, most notably with cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Differences of opinion between physicians and patients/families about what are appropriate interventions in specific clinical situations are often fraught with highly strained emotions, and perhaps none more so when the family bases their desires on religious belief. In this essay, I discuss non-beneficial treatments in light of these sorts of disputes, when there is a clash between the nominally secular world of fact- and evidence-based medicine and the faith-based world of hope for a miraculous cure. I ask the question whether religious belief can justify providing treatment that has either no or a vanishly small chance of restoring meaningful function. I conclude that non-beneficial therapy by its very definition cannot be helpful, and indeed is often harmful, to patients and hence cannot be justified no matter what the source or kind of reasons used to support its use. Therefore, doctors may legitimately refuse to provide such treatments, so long as they do so for acceptable clinical reasons. They must also offer alternatives, including second (and third) opinions, as well the option of transferring the care of the patient to a more accommodating physician or institution.


Non-beneficial treatment Futility Miracles 


  1. Ayeh, D. D., Tak, H. J., Yoon, J. D., & Curlin, F. A. (2016). U.S. Physicians’ opinions about accommodating religiously based requests for continued life-sustaining treatment. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 51(6), 971–978. Scholar
  2. Bain, E., Puopolo, M., Agarwal, A., Lam, M., Chow, E., & Henry, B. (2017). Cultural and religious considerations in cancer care: Where do desires for life-sustaining care and miracles come from? Journal of Pain Management, 10(1), 49–57.Google Scholar
  3. Bandini, J. I., Courtwright, A., Zollfrank, A. A., Robinson, E. M., & Cadge, W. (2017). The role of religious beliefs in ethics committee consultations for conflict over life-sustaining treatment. Journal of Medical Ethics, 43(6), 353–358. Scholar
  4. Berg, R. C., Underland, V., Odgaard-Jensen, J., Fretheim, A., & Vist, G. E. (2014). Effects of female genital cutting on physical health outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis. British Medical Journal Open. Scholar
  5. Bernat, J. L. (2009). Chronic consciousness disorders. Annual Review of Medicine, 60(1), 381–392. Scholar
  6. Biggar, N. (2015). Why religion deserves a place in secular medicine. Journal of Medical Ethics, 41(3), 229–233. Scholar
  7. Billings, J., & Krakauer, E. L. (2011). On patient autonomy and physician responsibility in end-of-life care. Archives of Internal Medicine, 171(9), 849–853. Scholar
  8. Blackler, L. (2017). Hope for a miracle. Treatment requests at the end of life. Journal of Hospice and Palliative Nursing, 19(2), 115–119.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bock, G. L. (2008). Medically valid religious beliefs. Journal of Medical Ethics, 34(6), 437–440. Scholar
  10. Bock, G. L. (2012). Making martyrs of our children: Religiously based requests in pediatrics. Ethics & Medicine, 28(2), 89–98.Google Scholar
  11. Brett, A. S., & Jersild, P. (2003). Inappropriate treatment near the end of life: Conflict between religious convictions and clinical judgment. Archives of Internal Medicine, 163(14), 1645–1649. Scholar
  12. Brierley, J., Linthicum, J., & Petros, A. (2013). Should religious beliefs be allowed to stonewall a secular approach to withdrawing and withholding treatment in children? Journal of Medical Ethics, 39(9), 573–577. Scholar
  13. Brody, H. (1994). The physician’s role in determining futility. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 42(8), 875–878. Scholar
  14. Brody, B. A., & Halevy, A. (1995). Is futility a futile concept? The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 20(2), 123–144. Scholar
  15. Brody, H., & Macdonald, A. (2013). Religion and bioethics: Toward an expanded understanding. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 34(2), 133–145. Scholar
  16. Buryska, J. F. (2001). Assessing the ethical weight of cultural, religious and spiritual claims in the clinical context. Journal of Medical Ethics, 27(2), 118–122. Scholar
  17. Carpenter, L. M. (2010). On remedicalisation: Male circumcision in the United States and Great Britain. Sociology of Health & Illness, 32(4), 613–630. Scholar
  18. Cassell, E. J. (1982). The nature of suffering and the goals of medicine. New England Journal of Medicine, 306(11), 639–645. Scholar
  19. Cassell, E. J. (1999). Pain, suffering, and the goals of medicine. In M. J. Hanson & D. Callahan (Eds.), The goals of medicine: The forgotten issue in health care reform (pp. 101–117). Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
  20. Catlin, E. A., Cadge, W., Ecklund, E. H., Gage, E. A., & Zollfrank, A. A. (2008). The spiritual and religious identities, beliefs, and practices of academic pediatricians in the United States. Academic Medicine, 83(12), 1146–1152. Scholar
  21. Chung, G. S., Lawrence, R. E., Curlin, F. A., Arora, V., & Meltzer, D. O. (2011). Predictors of hospitalised patients’ preferences for physician-directed medical decision-making. Journal of Medical Ethics. Scholar
  22. Coleman, D. L., & Rosoff, P. M. (2013). The legal authority of mature minors to consent to general medical treatment. Pediatrics, 131(4), 786–793. Scholar
  23. Curlin, F. A., Chin, M. H., Sellergren, S. A., Roach, C. J., & Lantos, J. D. (2006). The association of physicians’ religious characteristics with their attitudes and self-reported behaviors regarding religion and spirituality in the clinical encounter. Medical Care, 44(5), 446–453.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Curlin, F. A., Lantos, J. D., Roach, C. J., Sellergren, S. A., & Chin, M. H. (2005). Religious characteristics of U.S. physicians. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 20(7), 629–634. Scholar
  25. Curlin, F. A., Lawrence, R. E., Chin, M. H., & Lantos, J. D. (2007). Religion, conscience, and controversial clinical practices. New England Journal of Medicine, 356(6), 593–600.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Darby, R. (2016). Moral hypocrisy or intellectual inconsistency? A historical perspective on our habit of placing male and female genital cutting in separate ethical boxes. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 26(2), 155–163.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Duffin, J. (2007). The doctor was surprised; or, how to diagnose a miracle. Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 81(4), 699–729.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Duffin, J. (2009). Medical miracles: Doctors, saints, and healing in the modern world. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Dworkin, G. (1988). The theory and practice of autonomy. Cambridge Studies in Philosophy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Ecklund, E. H., Cadge, W., Gage, E. A., & Catlin, E. A. (2007). The religious and spiritual beliefs and practices of academic pediatric oncologists in the United States. Journal of Pediatric Hematology/oncology, 29(11), 736–742. Scholar
  31. El Bcheraoui, C., Zhang, X., Cooper, C. S., Rose, C. E., Kilmarx, P. H., & Chen, R. T. (2014). Rates of adverse events associated with male circumcision in us medical settings, 2001 to 2010. JAMA Pediatrics, 168(7), 625–634. Scholar
  32. Faden, R. R., & Beauchamp, T. L. (1986). A history and theory of informed consent. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  33. Fadiman, A. (1997). The spirit catches you and you fall down. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.Google Scholar
  34. Fischer, G. W. (1981). When oracles fail—A comparison of four procedures for aggregating subjective probability forecasts. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 28(1), 96–110. Scholar
  35. Gillett, G. (2011). Minimally conscious states, deep brain stimulation, and what is worse than futility. The Journal of Bioethical Inquiry, 8(2), 145–149. Scholar
  36. Gould, S. J. (1997). Nonoverlapping magisteria. Natural History, 106(2), 16–22.Google Scholar
  37. Griener, G. G. (1995). The physician’s authority to withhold futile treatment. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 20(2), 207–224. Scholar
  38. Halevy, A., & Brody, B. A. (1996). A multi-institution collaborative policy on medical futility. JAMA, the Journal of the American Medical Association, 276(7), 571–574. Scholar
  39. Helft, P. R., Siegler, M., & Lantos, J. (2000). The rise and fall of the futility movement. New England Journal of Medicine, 343(4), 293–296. Scholar
  40. Henrich, N. J., Dodek, P. M., Alden, L., Keenan, S. P., Reynolds, S., & Rodney, P. (2016). Causes of moral distress in the intensive care unit: A qualitative study. Journal of Critical Care, 35, 57–62. Scholar
  41. Hoffmann, T. C., & Del, C. (2015). Patients’ expectations of the benefits and harms of treatments, screening, and tests: A systematic review. JAMA Internal Medicine, 175(2), 274–286. Scholar
  42. Kattan, M. W., O’Rourke, C., Changhong, Yu., & Chagin, K. (2016). The wisdom of crowds of doctors: Their average predictions outperform their individual ones. Medical Decision Making, 36(4), 536–540. Scholar
  43. Kelley, A. S., Ettner, S. L., Sean Morrison, R., Qingling, D., Wenger, N. S., & Sarkisian, C. A. (2011). Determinants of medical expenditures in the last 6 months of life. Annals of Internal Medicine, 154(4), 235–242. Scholar
  44. Kemp, E., Min, K. S., & Joint, E. (2015). Selling hope: The role of affect-laden health care advertising in consumer decision making. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice, 23(4), 434–454.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Kruskal, W. (1988). Miracles and statistics: The casual assumption of independence. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 83(404), 929–940. Scholar
  46. Larmer, Robert A. H. (1988). Water into wine? An investigation of the concept of miracle. Kingston, ON: McGill-Queen’s University Press.Google Scholar
  47. Lax, E. (2004). The mold in Dr. Florey’s coat: The story of the penicillin miracle. New York: Henry Holt.Google Scholar
  48. Locke, J. (2003). Two treatises of government: And a letter concerning toleration. In J. Locke & I. Shapiro (Eds.), Rethinking the Western tradition. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  49. Masters, K. S., Spielmans, G. I., & Goodson, J. T. (2006). Are there demonstrable effects of distant intercessory prayer? A meta-analytic review. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 32(1), 21–26. Scholar
  50. Orr, R. D., & Genesen, L. B. (1997). Requests for “inappropriate” treatment based on religious beliefs. Journal of Medical Ethics, 23(3), 142–147. Scholar
  51. Rawls, J. (1996). Political liberalism (2nd ed.). New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
  52. Rawls, J. (1999). A theory of justice (revised ed.). Cambridge, MA: Belknap (Harvard University Press).Google Scholar
  53. Roberts, L., Ahmed, I., & Davison, A. (2009). Intercessory prayer for the alleviation of ill health. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (2). Scholar
  54. Robson, N., & Rew, D. (2010). Collective wisdom and decision making in surgical oncology. European Journal of Surgical Oncology (EJSO), 36(3), 230–236. Scholar
  55. Rosoff, P. M. (2013). Institutional futility policies are inherently unfair. HEC Forum, 25(3), 191–209. Scholar
  56. Rosoff, P. M. (2014). Rationing is not a four-letter word: Setting limits on healthcare. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Rosoff, P. M. (2017a). Licensing surrogate decision-makers. HEC Forum, 29(2), 145–169.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Rosoff, P. M. (2017b). Drawing the line: Healthcare rationing and the cutoff problem. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Rosoff, P. M., & Schneiderman, L. J. (2017). Irrational exuberance: Cardiopulmonary resuscitation as fetish. The American Journal of Bioethics, 17(2), 26–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Savulescu, J. (1998). Two worlds apart: Religion and ethics. Journal of Medical Ethics, 24(6), 382–384. Scholar
  61. Schneiderman, L. J., Jecker, N. S., & Jonsen, A. R. (1990). Medical futility: Its meaning and ethical implications. Annals of Internal Medicine, 112(12), 949–954. Scholar
  62. Schneiderman, L. J., Jecker, N. S., & Jonsen, A. R. (1996). Medical futility: Response to critiques. Annals of Internal Medicine, 125(8), 669–674. Scholar
  63. Schwartz, L. M., & Woloshin, S. (2016). Cancer center advertising—Where hope meets hype. JAMA Internal Medicine, 176(8), 1068–1070. Scholar
  64. Shinall, M. C., Ehrenfeld, J. M., & Guillamondegui, O. D. (2014). Religiously affiliated intensive care unit patients receive more aggressive end-of-life care. Journal of Surgical Research, 190(2), 623–627. Scholar
  65. Tobian, A. A. R., Kacker, S., & Quinn, T. C. (2014). Male circumcision: A globally relevant but under-utilized method for the prevention of HIV and other sexually transmitted infections. Annual Review of Medicine, 65(1), 293–306. Scholar
  66. Tomlinson, T., & Brody, H. (1990). Futility and the ethics of resuscitation. JAMA, 264(10), 1276–1280. Scholar
  67. Unroe, K. T., Greiner, M. A., Hernandez, A. F., et al. (2011). Resource use in the last 6 months of life among medicare beneficiaries with heart failure, 2000–2007. Archives of Internal Medicine, 171(3), 196–203. Scholar
  68. Vater, L. B., Donohue, J. M., Arnold, R., White, D. B., Chu, E., & Schenker, Y. (2014). What are cancer centers advertising to the public? A content analysis of cancer center advertisements. Annals of Internal Medicine, 160(12), 813–820. Scholar
  69. Wocial, L., Ackerman, V., Leland, B., Benneyworth, B., Patel, V., Tong, Y., et al. (2017). Pediatric Ethics and Communication Excellence (PEACE) rounds: Decreasing moral distress and patient length of stay in the PICU. HEC Forum, 29(1), 75–91. Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V., part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Trent Center for Bioethics, Humanities and History of MedicineDuke University Medical CenterDurhamUSA
  2. 2.Departments of Pediatrics and MedicineDuke University Medical CenterDurhamUSA

Personalised recommendations