Advertisement

HEC Forum

, Volume 26, Issue 4, pp 285–297 | Cite as

Health Care Voluntourism: Addressing Ethical Concerns of Undergraduate Student Participation in Global Health Volunteer Work

  • Daniel McCall
  • Ana S. IltisEmail author
Article

Abstract

The popularity and availability of global health experiences has increased, with organizations helping groups plan service trips and companies specializing in “voluntourism,” health care professionals volunteering their services through different organizations, and medical students participating in global health electives. Much has been written about global health experiences in resource poor settings, but the literature focuses primarily on the work of health care professionals and medical students. This paper focuses on undergraduate student involvement in short term medical volunteer work in resource poor countries, a practice that has become popular among pre-health professions students. We argue that the participation of undergraduate students in global health experiences raises many of the ethical concerns associated with voluntourism and global health experiences for medical students. Some of these may be exacerbated by or emerge in unique ways when undergraduates volunteer. Guidelines and curricula for medical student engagement in global health experiences have been developed. Guidelines specific to undergraduate involvement in such trips and pre-departure curricula to prepare students should be developed and such training should be required of volunteers. We propose a framework for such guidelines and curricula, argue that universities should be the primary point of delivery even when universities are not organizing the trips, and recommend that curricula should be developed in light of additional data.

Keywords

Developing world Global health Resource poor Service trip Students Volunteer Voluntourism 

Notes

Acknowledgments

We wish to acknowledge the generous support of the Richter Scholars Program administered through the URECA Center at Wake Forest University. The scholarship enabled Daniel McCall to travel to Nicaragua in the summer of 2012, where he observed first-hand some of the concerns that arise when undergraduate students participate in health related volunteer work in resource poor settings. We also acknowledge the very helpful comments from two reviewers whose insights helped to improve this paper and Dr. Pat Lord of Wake Forest University, with whom we have had many helpful conversations on this topic.

References

  1. Adams, L., Naburi, H., Lyatuu, G., Palumbo, P., & von Reyn, C. F. (2012). Closing the gaps in pediatric HIV/AIDS care, one step at a time. Narrative Inquiry in Bioethics, 2(2), 75–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Anderson, K. D., Slatnik, M. A., Pereira, I., Cheung, E., Xu, K., & Brewer, T. F. (2012). Are we there yet? Preparing Canadian medical students for global health electives. Academic Medicine, 87, 206–209.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Anspacher, M., Frintner, M. P., Denno, D., Pak-Gorstein, S., Olness, K., Spector, J., et al. (2011). Global health education for pediatric residents: a national survey. Pediatrics, 128(4), e959–e965.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Asgary, R., & Junck, E. (2012). New trends of short-term humanitarian medical volunteerism: professional and ethical considerations. Journal of Medical Ethics, 39(10), 625–631.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) (2011). Guidelines for Premedical and Medical Students Providing Patient Care During Clinical Experiences Abroad. Washington DC. (AAMC). Retrieved from https://www.aamc.org/download/181690/data/guidelinesforstudentsprovidingpatientcare.pdf.
  6. Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC). (2012). Medical School Graduation Questionnaire: 2012 All Schools Summary Report. Washington, DC. AAMC. Retrieved from https://www.aamc.org/download/300448/data/2012gqallschoolssummaryreport.pdf.
  7. Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada (AFMC) Global Health Resource Group and Canadian Federation of Medical Students Global Health Program. (2008). Preparing Medical Students for Electives in Low-Resource Settings: A Template for National Guidelines for Pre-Departure Training. Retrieved from www.cfms.org/pictures/file/Global%20Health/Pre-departure%20Guidelines%20Final.
  8. Banatvala, N., & Doyal, L. (1998). Knowing when to say “no” on the student elective. BMJ, 316, 1404–1405.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bateman, C., Baker, T., Hoornenborg, E., & Ericsson, U. (2001). Bringing global issues to medical teaching. The Lancet, 358, 1539–1542.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Battat, R., Seidman, G., Chadi, N., Chanda, M. Y., Nehme, J., Hulme, J., et al. (2010). Global health competencies and approaches in medical education: a literature review. BMC Medical Education, 10, 94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Beamon, C. J., Vik, D., Jill, M., Forcina, H., William, H., & Shumate, J. A., (2006). A Guide to Incorporating Cultural Competency into Health Professionals’ Education and Training. Retrieved from http://njms.umdnj.edu/culweb/medical/documents/CulturalCompetencyGuide.pdf.
  12. Bezruchka, S. (2000). Medical tourism as medical harm to the third world: Why? For whom? Wilderness Environmental Medicine, 11, 77–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Bishop, R., & Litch, J. (2000). Medical tourism can do harm. BMJ, 320(7240), 1017.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Chu, K., Stokes, C., Trelles, M., & Ford, N. (2011). Improving effective surgical delivery in humanitarian disasters: lessons from Haiti. PLoS Medicine, 8(4), e1001025.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Clem, K., & Green, S. (1996). Emergency medicine expeditions to the developing world: Loma Linda University experience in Papua New Guinea. Academic Emergency Medicine, 3(6), 624–633.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Conant, E., (2007). Having fun doing good. Newsweek. Retrieved October 16, from http://www.newsweek.com/id/49470.
  17. Crump, J.A. & Sugarman, J. and the Working Group on Ethics Guidelines for Global Health Training (WEIGHT). (2010). Ethics and best practice guidelines for training experiences in global health. American Journal of Tropical Medicine Hygiene, 83, 1178–1182.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Crump, J. A., & Sugarman, J. (2008). Ethical considerations for short-term experiences by trainees in global health. JAMA, 300(12), 1456–1458.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. DeCamp, M. (2007). Scrutinizing global short-term medical outreach. Hastings Center Report, 3(6), 21–23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. DeCamp, M. (2011). Ethical review of short-term medical volunteerism. HEC Forum, 2, 91–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. DeCamp, M., Rodriguez, J., Hecht, S., Barry, M., & Sugarman, J. (2013). An ethics curriculum for short-term global health trainees. Global Health, 9, 5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Deonandan, R., Jinha, A., Benovoy, J., Sarazin, M., & Doswell, J. (2012). A pilot study for case-based learning among undergraduate students in global health. Internet Journal of Medical Education, 2(2).Google Scholar
  23. Elansary, M., Graber, L. K., Provenzano, A. M., Barry, M., Khoshnood, K., & Rastegar, A. (2011). Ethical dilemmas in global clinical electives. Journal of Global Health, 1(1), 24–27.Google Scholar
  24. Finch, T., Chae, S. R., Shafaee, M. N., Siegel, K. R., Ali, M. K., Tomei, R., et al. (2011). Role of students in global health delivery. Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine, 78, 373–381.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Fischer, K. (2013). Some health programs overseas let students do too much, too soon. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved November 4, from http://chronicle.com/article/Overseas-Health-Programs-Let/142777/.
  26. Frontier. (2013). Medical Volunteering. Irvine, CA. The Society of Environmental Exploration. Retrieved from http://www.frontier-usa.org//Volunteer/Medical-Volunteering.aspx?setsite=1.
  27. Global Health Training Education Consortium (GHTEC). (2011). Training in graduate medical education: A guidebook (2nd ed.). San Francisco: Global Health Education Consortium.Google Scholar
  28. Gunderson, A. (2005). More vacationers answer the call to help. New York Times. Retrieved February 20, from http://www.nytimes.com/2005/02/20/travel/20volunteer.html?_r=0a.
  29. Guttentag, D. (2009). The possible negative impacts of volunteer tourism. International Journal of Tourism Research, 11, 537–551.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Howard, C. R., Gladding, S. P., Kiguli, S., Andrews, J. S., & John, C. C. (2011). Development of a competency-based curriculum in global child health. Academic Medicine, 86(4), 521–528.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Izadnegahdar, R., Correia, S., Ohata, B., Kittler, A., ter Kuile, S., Vaillancourt, S., et al. (2008). Global health in Canadian medical education: current practices and opportunities. Academic Medicine, 83(2), 192–198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Jesus, J. E. (2010). Ethical challenges and considerations of short-term international medical initiatives: an excursion to Ghana as a case study. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 55(1), 17–22.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Krippendorf, J. (1999). The holiday makers. London: Heinemann.Google Scholar
  34. Lahey, T. (2012). Perspective: A proposed medical school curriculum to help students recognize and resolve ethical issues of global health outreach work. Academic Medicine, 87(2), 210–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Langowski, M. K., & Iltis, A. S. (2011). Global health needs and the short-term medical volunteer: Ethical considerations. HEC Forum, 23(2), 71–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Levi, A. (2009). The ethics of nursing student international clinical experiences. Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, and Neonatal Nursing, 38(1), 94–99.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. McIntosh, A., & Zahra, A. (2007). A cultural encounter through volunteer tourism: Towards the ideals of sustainable tourism. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 15, 541–556.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Montgomery, L. M. (1993). Short-term medical missions: Enhancing or eroding health? Missiology: An international. Review, 21(3), 333–341.Google Scholar
  39. Mystakidou, K., Panagiotou, I., Katsaragakis, S., Tsilika, E., & Parpa, E. (2009). Ethical and practical challenges of implementing informed consent in HIV/AIDS clinical trials in developing or resource-limited countries. SAHARA Journal, 6(2), 46–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Pellegrino, E. D. (1991). Trust and distrust in professional ethics. In E. D. Pellegrino, R. Veatch, & J. Langan (Eds.), Ethics, trust, and the professions: Philosophical and cultural perspective (pp. 69–91). Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
  41. Pinto, A. D., & Upshur, R. E. (2009). Global health ethics for students. Developing World Bioethics, 9(1), 1–10.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Powell, A. C., Mueller, C., Kingham, P., Berman, R., Pachter, H. L., & Hopkins, M. A. (2007). International experience, electives, and volunteerism in surgical training: A survey of resident interest. Journal of the American College of Surgeons, 205(1), 162–168.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Projects Abroad Inc. (2013). International Volunteer Opportunities of College Students with Projects Abroad. New York, NY: Projects Abroad Inc. Retrieved from http://www.projects-abroad.org/more-info/planning-your-time-abroad/university-students/.
  44. Radstone, S. J. (2005). Practicing on the poor? Healthcare workers’ beliefs about the role of medical students during their elective. Journal of Medical Ethics, 31(2), 109–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Ramsey, K. M., & Weijer, C. (2007). Ethics of surgical training in developing countries. World Journal of Surgery, 31, 2067–2069.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Rekart, M. L., Rekart, J. T., Patrick, D. M., & Brunham, R. C. (2003). International health: Five reasons why Canadians should get involved. Canadian Journal of Public Health, 94(4), 258–259.Google Scholar
  47. Roberts, M. (2006). Duffle bag medicine. JAMA, 295, 1491–1492.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Shah, S., & Wu, T. (2008). The medical student global health experience: Professionalism and ethical implications. Journal of Medical Ethics, 35(5), 375–378.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Sin, H. L. (2009). Volunteer tourism – “Involve me and I will learn”? Annals of Tourism Research, 36, 480–501.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Sin, H. L. (2010). Who are we responsible to? Locals’ tales of volunteer tourism. Geoforum, 41, 983–992.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Suchdev, P., Shah, A., Derby, K. S., Hall, L., Schubert, C., Pak-Gorstein, S., et al. (2012). A proposed model curriculum in global health for pediatric residents. Academic Pediatrics, 12(3), 229–237.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Unite for Site Inc. (2013). Global Health Course: Module 7. New Haven, CT. Available at: Unite for Site. http://www.uniteforsight.org/global-health-course/module7.
  53. Van Tilburg, C. S. (1995). Attitudes toward medical aid to developing countries. Wilderness Environmental Medicine, 6, 264–268.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Wall, A. E. (2006). Ethics for international medicine: A practical guide for aid workers in developing countries. Sudbury: Dartmouth Publishing Inc.Google Scholar
  55. Wall, L. L., Arrowsmith, S. D., Lassey, A. T., & Danso, K. (2006). Humanitarian ventures or “fistula tourism”? The ethical perils of pelvic surgery in the developing world. International Urogynecology Journal and Pelvic Floor Dysfunction, 17, 559–562.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Wallace, L. J. (2012). Does pre-medical volunteerism improve the health of communities abroad? Journal of Global Health Perspectives, Retrieved from http://jglobalhealth.org/article/does-pre-medical-voluntourism-improve-the-health-of-communities-abroad-3/.
  57. Wearing, S. (2001). Volunteer tourism: Experiences that make a difference. New York: CABI Publishing.Google Scholar
  58. White, M., & Cauley, K. (2006). A caution against medical student tourism. Virtual Mentor, 8, 852–854.Google Scholar
  59. Zaner, R. (1991). The phenomenon of trust and the patient-physician relationship. In E. D. Pellegrino, R. Veatch, & J. Langan (Eds.), Ethics, trust, and the professions: Philosophical and cultural perspective (pp. 45–67). Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
  60. Zuckerman, J. (1998). Medical students’ electives abroad: Students need extensive advice on planning electives. BMJ, 317(7171), 1528.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Center for Bioethics, Health and Society and Department of PhilosophyWake Forest UniversityWinston-SalemUSA
  2. 2.Wake Forest School of MedicineWinston-SalemUSA

Personalised recommendations