Advertisement

HEC Forum

, Volume 25, Issue 1, pp 79–94 | Cite as

Is Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) Ever Ethically Justified? If so, Under What Circumstances

  • Mary Stefanazzi
Article

Abstract

The debate about ECT in Ireland in recent times has been vibrant and often polarised. The uniqueness of the Irish situation is that the psychiatric profession is protected by legislation whereby ECT treatment can be authorized by two consultant psychiatrists without the consent of the patient. This paper will consider if ECT is ever ethically justified, and if so, under what circumstances. The proposal is to investigate ECT from an ethical perspective with reference to the UNESCO Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights. The enquiry will begin with an historical context to the origin and development of ECT as a treatment for severe mental illness. The application of various ethical principles will be considered in conjunction with the relevant literature before arriving at a conclusion.

Keywords

UNESCO universal declaration on bioethics and human rights Electroconvulsive therapy ECT Ireland Psychiatry Mental illness Ethical principles Informed consent 

Notes

Acknowledgments

This article owes particular thanks to the late John McCarthy of Mad Pride Ireland for his commitment in lobbing for legislative change regarding ECT in Ireland and to Senator Dan Boyle for taking up the issue and initiating the debate in the Senate. I am grateful to John and Dan for their help in clarifying the myriad of systemic difficulties surrounding this issue after the Senate debate on 23rd March 2011. Finally, to Dr. David L. Magee M.B., MRC. Psych; Psychiatrist and Psychotherapist, for his willingness to debate the issues and recommend useful source materials with exceptional hospitality.

References

  1. Appelbaum, P. S. (1994). Almost a revolution—Mental health law and the limits of change. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  2. Barnes, J. (Ed.) (1984). Nicomachean ethics. In The complete works of Aristotle (Bollingen Series; 71:2). Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  3. Beauchamp, T. L., & Childress, J. F. (1983). Principles of biomedical ethics (6th ed.). New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  4. Berg, J. W., Applebaum, P. S., Lidz, C. W., & Parker, L. S. (2001). Informed consent, legal theory and clinical practice. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  5. Bracken, P. (2011). Retrieved Feb 25, 2011 from http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/letters/2011/0225/1224290841439.html.
  6. Breggin, P. R. (2007). ECT damages the brain: Disturbing news for patients and shock doctors alike. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry, 9(2), 83–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Cooper, J. (2003). Remembering Robert Kendell. British Journal of Psychiatry, 182, 279–280.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Donnellan, E. (2011). See change may not be the best use of money. Irish Times. Retrieved March 15, 2011 from http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/health/2011/0315/1224292155316.html.
  9. Duffett, R. (2004). Book review of electroshock: Healing mental illness by Max Fink. British Journal of Psychiatry, 184, 93–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Dunn, L. B., Holtzheimer, P. E., Hoop, J. G., Mayberg, H. S., Roberts, L. W., & Appelbaum, P. S. (2011). Ethical issues in deep brain stimulation research for treatment-resistant depression: Focus on risk and consent. AJOB Neuroscience, 2(1), 29–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Dunne, R., Kavanagh, A., & McLoughlin, D. M. (2009). Electroconvulsive therapy, capacity and the law in Ireland. Irish Journal Psychological Medicine, 26(1), 3–5.Google Scholar
  12. Expert Group on Mental Health Policy. (2006). Vision for change report. Retrieved Feb 7, 2011 http://www.dohc.ie/publications/vision_for_change.html.
  13. Ferlier, O. (2010). St. Ita’s Hospital Portrane, and the development of mental hospitals in Ireland. Retrieved Feb 9, 2011 http://www.buildingsofireland.ie/Surveys/Buildings/BuildingoftheMonth/Archive/Name,804,en.html.
  14. Fink, M. (2009). The electroshock riddle: Effective but rejected. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 195, 390.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Flanagan, E. H., Miller, R., & Davidson, L. (2009). Unfortunately, we treat the chart: Sources of stigma in mental health settings. Psychiatric Quarterly, 80(1), 55–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Freeman, C. P. L., & Robert, E. K. (1980). ECT: I. Patients’ experiences and attitudes. British Journal of Psychiatry, 137, 8–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Funk, M., Drew, N., Freeman, M., & Faydi, E. (2010). Mental health and development: Targeting people with mental health conditions as a vulnerable group. Geneva: World Health Organization.Google Scholar
  18. Gabor, G., Istvan, B., Gabor, S. U., & Brigitta, B. (2009). Convulsive therapy turns 75. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 194, 387–388.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Gelder, M. G., Juan J. L.-I., & Nancy A. (2004). New Oxford textbook of psychiatry, Vol 1 & 2. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  20. Gelder, M., Gath, D., & Mayou, R. (1991). Oxford textbook of psychiatry (2nd ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  21. Greally, H. (2008). Bird’s nest soup. Cork: Attic Press.Google Scholar
  22. Irish Senate Debates Online. (2011). Retrieved March 24, 2011 from http://debates.oireachtas.ie/seanad/2011/03/23/00005.asp; March 30, 2011 from http://historical-debates.oireachtas.ie/S/0186/S.0186.200702210009.html.
  23. Kaplan, H. I., Saddock, B. J., & Grebb, J. A. (1994). Kaplan and Sadock’s synopsis of psychiatry: Behavioural sciences clinical psychiatry (7th ed.). Maryland: Williams & Wilkins.Google Scholar
  24. Keating, T. (2009). Foundations for centering prayer and the Christian contemplative life. New York: Continuum.Google Scholar
  25. Kendell, R. E. (1981). The present status of electroconvulsive therapy. British Journal of Psychiatry, 139, 265–283.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Kipnis, K. (2006). Vulnerability in research subjects: A bioethical taxonomy. Retrieved Feb 9, 2011 from http://www.onlineethics.org/cms/8087.aspx.
  27. Lambourn, J., & Gill, D. (1978). A controlled comparison of simulated and real ECT. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 133, 514–519.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Lawrence, D., & Kisely, S. (2010). Review: Inequalities in healthcare provision for people with severe mental illness. Journal of Psychopharmacology, 24, 61–68.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Levine, C., Faden, R., Grady, C., Hammerschmidt, D., Eckenwiler, L., & Sugarman, J. (2004). The limitations of “vulnerability” as a protection for human research participants. The American Journal of Bioethics, 4(3), 44–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Mental Capacity and Guardianship Bill. (2008). Retrieved Feb 14, 2011 from http://www.oireachtas.ie/viewdoc.asp?fn=/documents/bills28/bills/2008/1308/document1.htm.
  31. Mental Health Act. (2001a). Retrieved Feb 14, 2011 from http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/2001/en/act/pub/0025/print.html.
  32. Mental Health Act. (2001b). Register of approved centers. Retrieved Feb 14, 2011 from http://www.mhcirl.ie/Registration_of_Approved_Centres/Approved_Centres.pdf.
  33. Mental Health Commission. (2011). The administration of electro-convulsive therapy in approved centres: Activity report 2009. Retrieved March 2, 2011 from http://www.mhcirl.ie/Publications/2009_ECT_Activity_Report.pdf.
  34. Mental Health Commission Statutory Form 16 (2007). Retrieved Feb 9, 2010 from http://www.mhcirl.ie/documents/statutory/March%202009%20Form%2013.pdf.
  35. Read, J., & Bentall, R. (2010). The effectiveness of electroconvulsive therapy: A literature review. Epidemiologia e Psichiatria Sociale, 19(3), 333–347.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Rose, D., Wykes, T., Leese, M., Bindman, J., & Fleischmann, P. (2003). Patients’ perspectives on electroconvulsive therapy: Systematic review. British Medical Journal, 326, 1–5.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Rush, G., McCarron, S., & Lucey, J. V. (2008). Consent to ECT: Patients’ experiences in an Irish ECT clinic. Psychiatric Bulletin, 32, 15–17.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Sackeim, H. A., Prudic, J., Fuller, R., Keilp, J., Lavori, P. W., & Olfson, M. (2007). The cognitive effects of electroconvulsive therapy in community settings. Neuropsychopharmacology, 32, 244–254.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Sadock, B. J., & Sadock, V. A. (Eds.). (2005). Kaplan & Sadock’s comprehensive textbook of psychiatry (8th ed.), Vol. 2. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.Google Scholar
  40. Schneider, J., Beeley, C., & Repper, J. (2011). Campaign appears to influence subjective experience of stigma. Journal of Mental Health, 20(1), 89–97.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Semkovska, M., & Mc Loughlin, D. M. (2010). Objective cognitive performance associated with ECT for depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Biological Psychiatry, 568–577.Google Scholar
  42. ten Have, H., & Jean, M. S. (2009). The UNESCO universal declaration on bioethics and human rights: Background, principles and application. Paris: UNESCO Publishing.Google Scholar
  43. UK ECT Review Group. (2003). Efficacy and safety of ECT in depressive disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis. The Lancet, 361, 799–808.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. UK NHS National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence. (2009). Depression the treatment and management of depression in adults. NICE clinical guidelines 90. Retrieved Feb 7, 2011 from http://www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/live/12329/45888/45888.pdf.
  45. Wertheimer, A. (1993). A philosophical examination of coercion for mental health issues. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 11, 239–258.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. World Health Organization. (2010). Mental health and development: Targeting people with mental health conditions as a vulnerable group. Retrieved Feb 9, 2010 from http://www.who.int/mental_health/policy/mhtargeting/en/index.html.
  47. World Health Organization. (2011). Definition of health. Retrieved Jan 31, 2011 from http://www.who.int/topics/mental_health/en.

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Private PracticeDublin 7Ireland

Personalised recommendations