Vanilla bicolor Lindl. (Orchidaceae) from the Peruvian Amazon: auto-fertilization in Vanilla and notes on floral phenology
- 1.6k Downloads
Minimal documentation exists for natural pollination in wild Vanilla spp., despite the economic importance of this genus, additionally commercial vanilla (V. planifolia Jacks.) is one of very few crops whose production depends entirely on artificial pollination. Flowering and fruiting phenology of Vanilla bicolor Lindl., a close relative of V. planifolia, was documented in a palm swamp in the Peruvian Amazon. V. bicolor was found to auto-fertilize via bagging experiments. This ecotype had an average fruit set per raceme of 42.50 ± 2.5%. Pollen removal experiments suggest that stigmatic leak may be the mechanism by which auto-pollination occurs in V. bicolor.
KeywordsAguajales Auto-pollination Orchidaceae Palm swamps Phenology Self-fertilization Vanilla
Scant documentation exists on pollination mechanisms in wild Vanilla species (Lubinsky et al. 2006). With vanilla being a crop of global significance surprisingly little attention has been paid to its wild relatives for crop improvement. Recent work demonstrating historical plant breeding and crop development via hybridization opens a new window onto the possibilities of crop improvement in vanilla (Lubinsky et al. 2008a). Vanilla cultivation relies upon the use of cheap labor to carry out hand pollination in order to obtain fruits for the spice trade, and this results in vanilla being an expensive crop (Lubinsky et al. 2006). Understanding pollination in this economically valuable genus is of currency.
Vanilla displays considerable reproductive diversity both between and within species (Cameron and Soto Arenas 2003). Few studies have documented the natural mechanisms of pollination, phenology, and seed dispersal of Vanilla despite its economic importance (Lubinsky et al. 2006; Householder 2007). Recently, Euglossine bees have been shown to pollinate and disperse the seeds of V. pompona subsp. grandiflora Lindl. in the neotropics (Lubinsky et al. 2006). Furthermore, natural hybridization seems to have occurred in several neotropical Vanilla spp. (Nielsen 2000; Lubinsky et al. 2008a). In addition to out-crossing and asexual propagation, auto-pollination has also been reported in Vanilla (van der Pijl and Dodson 1966). Examples of species that are thought to auto-pollinate, as evidenced by their high fruit sets, atypical in outcrossing species, are V. palmarum (Salzm. ex Lindl.) Lindl., V. savannarum Britton, and V. griffithii Rchb. f. (Cameron and Soto Arenas 2003). The mechanisms and concomitant selective pressures for auto-pollination in Vanilla remain unclear at best.
There are three proposed mechanisms for auto-pollination in Vanilla: (1) “stigmatic leak” by which stigma lobes release a fluid, that contacts the pollen and induces germination of the pollen tubes (van der Pijl and Dodson 1966), (2) by dehydration or underdevelopment of the rostellum, which could also allow for pollen to contact the stigmatic cavity (Garay and Sweet 1974), (3) a third mechanism of self-fertilization in Vanilla that has remained over looked is agamospermy. In the Neuwiedia veratrifolia Blume (Apostasioideae) the method of self-pollination was determined to be auto-pollination not agamospermy via emasculation experiments (Okada et al. 1996; Kocyan and Endress 2001). Thus, auto-pollination is the method of self-fertilization that occurs at the clade sister to the rest of Orchidaceae. Documentation of any of the above three mechanisms remain absent in Vanilla.
Vanillabicolor Lindl. is a widespread locally common hemi-epiphyte endemic to the Neotropics (Christenson 1995). They are found in open swampy areas along rivers in northern South America and exposed humid thickets along mountain crests in the Carribean (Adams 1972; Werkhoven 1986; Christenson 1995; Borhidi 1996). V. bicolor is a close relative of the widely cultivated V. planifolia Jacks (Cameron and Soto Arenas 2003; Lubinsky et al. 2008a) making it an important wild relative. Unlike the exceedingly sparse density of wild V. planifolia plants (Lubinsky et al. 2006, 2008a, b) V. bicolor occur at high densities in southern Peru and we were curious if higher density resulted in higher pollination rate due to increased reward. In this short communication we provide evidence regarding the floral phenology, pollination syndrome (i.e., outcrossing or self-fertilization) and possible mechanism of pollination in a cleistogamous ecotype of V. bicolor from the Southern Peruvian Amazon.
Materials and methods
Annual average rainfall in the region where our study occurred is 2,995 ± 455 mm. Rainfall is unevenly distributed throughout the year, with greater than 80% falling between October and April. Average temperature fluctuates minimally between 21 and 26°C, however southerly cold fronts rapidly progress northward from Patagonia, known as “friajes” and are common in June through August (Amazon Conservation Association, unpublished data). These friajes are known to decrease temperatures to 10°C or less in a matter of minutes. Climate data since 2001 is publicly available provided by the Amazon Conservation Association (ATRIUM 2007).
Data was collected on V. bicolor in the Peruvian Amazon near the Los Amigos research station in the center of an aguajale (palm swamp) (S12°33.453′ W70°07.312′ at ~330 m). We set up a 50 × 55 m plot in which phenological data (excluding the frequency of bloom and auto-fertilization tests which were recorded in the same aguajal but outside of the plot) for V. bicolor vines were recorded during August 17–18, 2005. Most plants had finished blooming during this time of the year in August during the dry season.
Rate of fruit set in V. bicolor
Multiple individuals of V. bicolor plants are commonly encountered climbing up sides of palm trees (Mauritia flexuosa). We will refer to multiple V. bicolor vines growing up the sides of a single palm tree as a “clump”. We counted the number of vines per clump of V. bicolor, the number of individual racemes of V. bicolor per clump, the number of un-pollinated flowers per raceme, the number of pollinated flowers per raceme, and the number of buds or new flowers per raceme. An un-pollinated flower was recognized by the presence of a bract on the raceme, but lacking a flower or a fruit as abscission of flowers occurs. A pollination event was also denoted by the presence of fruit on a raceme or a flower with a drooping ovary. The height at which each raceme occurred was measured.
The average fruit set per raceme, number of racemes per clump of V. bicolor, average height of the racemes occurring on the V. bicolor vines, and percent of V. bicolor vines that did not produce racemes were calculated. Only racemes that had no new buds and completely finished blooming were used for calculating the fruit set rate. A total of 131 racemes from 49 clumps of V. bicolor growing up palm tree trunks occurred in our study plot.
Fruit set data was tested for a normal distribution by looking at a scatter plot of residuals using SYSTAT Version 9.01© SPSS Inc.1998. Residual scatter plots were made for the height of individual racemes to their fruit set rate, and fruit set rate to number of clumps of V. bicolor growing over individual palm trees in our study site. Scatter plots of the residuals were both normal so the next step was to perform a linear regression analysis on the data to see if any trends existed. Finally trend lines were plotted for the linear regression analyses using Microsoft Excell® 2004 edition. Linear regression analyses were conducted to see if any immediate phenological patterns stood out as well as to add to documentation of the floral phenology for comparisons between any future studies. Height of racemes and their density have been correlated with increased pollinator visitation in some plants (Pyke et al. 1977; Engel and Irwin 2003). We were also curious if these tests might point toward any possible effects of pollinators on V. bicolor floral phenology. Finally histograms were constructed from the data collected.
Auto-fertilization in V. bicolor was determined two ways (1) an intensive survey across the entire Los Amigos aguajal for open or partially open flowers was conducted on August 22, 2005, 17 cleistogamous flowers that showed recent evidence of fertilization (1–2 days previous) via drooping ovaries were inspected for pollen removal or pollen granules placed on the stigma (2) 10 racemes of 10 different V. bicolor plants were bagged with Wirlpak® plastic bags. Bags excluded any pollinators from entering the flowers. Fertilization was determined by presence of developing fruits. The following dry season in April of 2006 13 additional racemes from 13 different plants were bagged in a similar manner using 1 mm mesh net to prevent any possible temperature differences between bagged flowers and outside environment. Plants to bag were chosen based on presence of flowers and accessibility from the 50 × 55 plot.
To test for agamospermy, ten flowers from different racemes and plants had their pollen removed by hand before completion of flower development. Racemes along with removed flowers were bagged with 1 mm mesh nets and allowed to mature. They were later checked once flowers had finished blooming. Manipulated buds were periodically monitored until either fruit development began, suggesting agamospermy, or senescing flowers fell from the raceme, indicating unsuccessful pollination.
Frequency of bloom in V. bicolor
Survey for V. bicolor in aguajales of Madre de Dios Peru
Thirteen different aguajales in the Madre de Dios Province of the Peruvian Amazon were surveyed for presence or absence of various Vanilla spp. The presence or absence of V. bicolor was noted as well as the growing condition. This was done to learn more about the preferred habitat of V. bicolor. This was an exhaustive survey covering 13 different aguajales over a 300 km stretch of the Madre de Dios drainage system in Peru. An Arc GIS map of the survey was constructed. Based on field experience it seemed that eastern aguajales lacked V. bicolor. To look for a possible explanation to this pattern the GIS map was transposed onto rainfall isohyte maps from Sombroek (2001) to see if any rainfall and dry season intensity patterns of the region affected where V. bicolor grew. Upon constructing this map it was clear that V. bicolor was absent from aguajales of southern Peru that characteristically receive less than 4 months out of the year with <100 mm per month, thus a measure of dry season intensity. This was followed by a linear regression analysis to see if a relationship existed between presence and absence data and intensity of the dry season using Microsoft Excell® 2004.
Rate of fruit set in V. bicolor
Summary of phenological data compiled on V. bicolor in an aguajale (palm swamp) in the Peruvian Amazon (S12°33.453′ W70°07.312′ at ~330 m) from a 50 × 55 m plot in which all V. bicolor “clumps” (multiple tangled vines of V. bicolor) were growing on palm trees (Mauritia flexuosa)
μ ± SE
Average fruit set/raceme
42.50 ± 2.5%
N = 131
Average number of florets/raceme
5.25 ± 0.18
N = 131
Average number of racemes/clump
5.10 ± 0.68
N = 41
Average raceme height
3.14 ± 0.07 m
N = 253
% V. bicolor clumps on palms not blooming
N = 8
Days between a single bloom
N = 10
After visually inspecting 17 recently fertilized flowers all 17 had no pollen removed or pollen placed on stigma area. Furthermore all of these flowers had fully developed rostellums and were not dry or shriveled in any way suggesting that auto-pollination via “stigmatic leak” or agamospermy are possible mechanisms for auto-fertilization. Results from bagged racemes from the August experiment was that 3 out of 10 bagged racemes developed fruit. These results indicate that self-fertilization is occurring in this population. Results from the April 2006 bagging experiment that included 13 racemes on different plants lend further support to this conclusion. Eighty-five percent of bagged racemes developed fruit. Seventy-one percent of all flowers developed fruit under bagged conditions in the April 2006 experiment. This again indicates that self-fertilization is occurring in this population.
Pollen removal experiments concluded that no flowers became pollinated after pollen was removed, thus agamospermy may not be a method by which this species may self-fertilize and auto-pollination is perhaps the method for self-fertilization. This sample size (10 flowers) is rather small, but it does suggest that agamospermy is not a mechanism affecting auto-pollination.
Frequency of bloom in V. bicolor
There was a single bloom for each florescence at 5-day intervals per raceme, although variation on this would be expected with a larger sample size. Each flower was only open or slightly open for a single day at a time. Over the duration of the blooming season from August to mid-September only one individual flower (Fig. 2b) was fully open out of 68 cleistogamous flowers (Fig. 2a) that were observed blooming across the aguajale. Thus an estimated 98.5% of flowers during the dry season exhibit a cleistogamous appearance. Cleistogamy is a common characteristic of auto-pollination in the Orchidaceae (Catling 1990). Furthermore there is no evidence of cross-pollination in cleistogamous flowers in the Orchidaceae (Catling 1990).
Survey for V. bicolor in aguajales of Madre de Dios Peru
Across thirteen aguajales sampled for V. bicolor a distinct geographical trend emerged. In eastern most aguajales V. bicolor was absent (Fig. 1). Size of aguajal did not seem to affect presence or absence of this species because relatively large and small aguajales both contained V. bicolor. Furthermore after transposing rainfall isohyte data from Sombroek (2001) onto the GIS map of aguajales combined with presence or absence data of V. bicolor distributions it was clear that intensity of the dry season prohibits this species from growing farther eastward (Fig. 1). Specifically the cut off point seemed to be in areas with <100 mm of rainfall for more than 4 months out of the year prohibiting the growth of V. bicolor (Fig. 1). Results from the linear regression analysis clearly indicate that the intensity of the dry season is related to where V. bicolor can grow in the aguajales of southern Peru (df = 12; R 2 = 0.606; P = 2E−3). Hopefully future more detailed isohyte data will be available to test our observations as data provided here is a rough fitting of regional rainfall patterns.
Auto-fertilization in V. bicolor
Several lines of evidence illuminate auto-fertilization as a method by which V. bicolor in our study site can reproduce. The combination of a high fruit set, ubiquity of closed flowers during the dry season, and fertilization of bagged flowers, all point toward auto-fertilization. Furthermore the pollination rate for this auto-fertilizing V. bicolor is high compared to other Vanilla species that are Euglossine pollinated such as V. pompona subsp. grandiflora (Lubinsky et al. 2006), which has a pollination rate of ~1% (personal observation, Householder 2007). Other populations of V. bicolor may exhibit a non-cleistogamous phenotype (see Christenson 1995). Furthermore we provide some initial evidence that the method of auto-fertilization may be auto-pollination and not agamospermy through emasculation experiments. Also morphological examination of V. bicolor flowers shows a fully developed rostellum in pollinated flowers making “stigmatic leak” the most likely mechanism of auto-pollination in this species.
Drought conditions may eliminate V. bicolor from aguajales under certain circumstances thus reducing the Vanilla and consequent plant diversity in those aguajales (Fig. 1). Meteorological evidence from the Amazon basin points to large-scale deforestation of primary forests effectively shifting sub-regional climate conditions to be significantly drier (Sombroek 1962, 2001). Implications of large-scale deforestation for conservation of plant diversity within aguajales would suggest a regional approach is needed. A regional approach would include maintaining substantial tracks of primary forest around aguajales as opposed to just fencing off aguajales from development.
Rapid loss of neotropical habitat where wild Vanilla species occur supports urgency in documenting valuable wild genetic resources in Vanilla (Lubinsky et al. 2008b). We provide evidence for an auto-fertilizing Vanilla. Discovering the underpinnings of genetic and environmental conditions that bring about this breeding system strategy in the individuals studied, could be useful in breeding programs for improving vanilla yields via auto-fertilization. This demonstrates the need to conserve wild neotropical Vanilla species as most life history data on these species is completely unknown.
The authors thank Dr. William E. Walton for advise on statistical analysis. We also thank Dr. Nigel Pitman for field assistance at the Los Amigos Research Station.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
- Adams CD (1972) Flowering plants of Jamaica. University of the West Indies, Mona, JamaicaGoogle Scholar
- ATRIUM (2007) http://atrium.andesamazon.org/meteo_station_list.php. Accessed 9 May 2007
- Borhidi A (1996) Phytogeography and vegetation ecology of Cuba. Janus Pannonius University Pécas, HungaryGoogle Scholar
- Cameron K, Soto Arenas MA (2003) Vanilloideae. In: Pridgeon AM, Cribb PJ, Chase MW, Rasmussen FN (eds) Genera Orchidacearum, vol 3, Orchidoideae, part 2, Vanilloideae. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 281–334Google Scholar
- Catling PM (1990) Auto-pollination in the Orchidaceae. In: Arditti J (ed) Orchid biology reviews and perspectives, vol 5. Timber Press, Portland, pp 121–158Google Scholar
- Christenson EA (1995) The long-lost Vanilla bicolor. Am Orchid Soc Bull 64:844–847Google Scholar
- Garay LA, Sweet HR (1974) Orchidaceae. In: Howard RA (ed) Flora of the lesser Antilles: leeward and windward Islands. Harvard University, Massachusetts, pp 1–228Google Scholar
- Householder JE (2007) Diversity, natural history, and conservation of Vanilla of Madre de Dios, Peru. Masters Thesis, Texas Christian University, Fort Worth, USAGoogle Scholar
- Lubinsky P, Van Dam M, Van Dam A (2006) Pollination of Vanilla and evolution in Orchidaceae. Lindleyana 75:926–929Google Scholar
- Lubinsky P, Bory S, Hernandez Hernandez J, Kim SC, Gomez-Pompa A (2008b) Origins and dispersal of cultivated Vanilla (Vanilla planifolia Jacks. [Orchidaceae]). Econ Bot 62:127–138Google Scholar
- Okada H, Kubo S, Mori Y (1996) Pollination system of Neuwiedia veratrifolia Blume (Orchidaceae, Apostasioideae) in the Malesian wet Tropics. Acta Phytotaxon Geobot 47:173–181Google Scholar
- Sombroek WG (1962) Reconnaissance soil survey of the Guamá-Imperatriz area (area along the upper part of the Belém-Brasilia highway). Mimeo report of SPVEA/SUDAM, Belém and FAO, Rome, ItalyGoogle Scholar
- van der Pijl L, Dodson CH (1966) Orchid flowers: their pollination and evolution. University of Miami Press, Coral GablesGoogle Scholar
- Werkhoven MCM (1986) Orchids of Suriname. Vaco, Paramirabo, SurinameGoogle Scholar