Application of the DNDC model to the Rodale Institute Farming Systems Trial: challenges for the validation of drainage and nitrate leaching in agroecosystem models
Ecosystem models are increasingly used to guide natural resource management policy decisions. In this study, we build on available agroecosystem policy modeling tools by testing two methodologies for applying the Denitrification-Decomposition (DNDC) model to naturally-drained, temperate grain cropping systems. We used long-term observations from the Rodale Institute Farming Systems Trial (FST) to validate the DNDC model for application to grain cropping systems on silty clay loam soils typical of mid-Atlantic farmlands. Based on modeling efficiency (EF), Theil’s Inequality (U 2), and correlation coefficient (r) metrics, the DNDC model showed moderate fit between observations and simulations at annual time scales for drainage (EF = 0.34, U 2 = 0.12, r = 0.74) and nitrate leaching (EF = −0.05, U 2 = 0.4, r = 0.86). Replication of observed seasonal water flux and nitrate leaching trends were difficult to capture in model simulations, resulting in a weak fit between observations and simulations for drainage (EF = −1.2, U 2 = 0.89, r = 0.28) and nitrate leaching (EF = −2.5, U 2 = 2.1, r = 0.3). Our comparison of observations and model outcomes highlights the challenge of scaling up belowground fluxes to farm or watershed scales. Ecosystem model representation of water transport generally assumes highly homogeneous soil conditions. In contrast, data from lysimeter sampling represents a small percentage of the total study area and is unlikely to capture average soil field properties. Additionally, our Rodale work highlights the limitation of biogeochemistry models which use vertical mass movement to describe water drainage and nitrate leaching. The application of the DNDC model to the Rodale FST demonstrates that model studies are not a simple substitute for field observation. The predictive utility of model outcomes can only be broadened through rigorous testing against long-term field observations.
KeywordsAgroecosystem modeling DNDC model Farming Systems Trial Nitrate leaching Rodale Institute
Support for this research was provided by an NSF Biocomplexity in the Environment/Coupled Natural-Human Cycles Program (Grant # 0508028 to Drinkwater et al.) and a modeling grant from the Cornell University Agricultural Ecosystems Program: Understanding Sources and Sinks of Nutrients and Sediment in the Upper Susquehanna River Basin funded by the USDA CSREES program (award # 2005-34244-15740). The authors are grateful to Mark B. David and anonymous reviewers for insightful comments on an earlier draft of the manuscript.
- U.S.DOE, USDA (2009) Sustainability of biofuels future research opportunities: Report from the October 2008 workshop. DOE/SC-0114 U.S. DOE and USDAGoogle Scholar
- Gassman PW, Williams JR, Benson VW et al. (2005) Historical development and applications of the EPIC and APEX models. Working paper 05-WP 397 Center for Agricultural and Rural Development, Iowa State University Ames. IowaGoogle Scholar
- Jemison JM Jr, Jabro JD, Fox RH (1994) LEACHM evaluation: II. Simulation of nitrate leaching from nitrogen-fertilized and manured corn. Agron J 86:852–859Google Scholar
- Jones CA, Kiniry JR (1986) CERES-Maize. A simulation model of maize growth and development. Texas A&M University Press, College Station, TexasGoogle Scholar
- Li CS, Frolking S, Frolking TA (1992) A model of nitrous-oxide evolution from soil driven rainfall events. 1. model structure and sensitivity. J Geophys Res-Atmos 97(D9):9759–9776Google Scholar
- Neitsch SL, Arnold JG, Kiniry JR, Williams JR, King KW (2005) Soil and water assessment tool user’s manual. TWRI Report TR-191 Texas Water Resources Institute College Station, TexasGoogle Scholar
- Peters S, Wander M, Saporito L, Harris G, Friedman D (1997) Management impacts on SOM and related soil properties in a long-term farming systems trial in Pennsylvania: 1981–1991. In: Paul E, Paustian K, Elliott E, Cole C (eds) Soil organic matter in temperate acroecosystems: long-term experiments in North America. CRC Press, Boca Raton, p 432pGoogle Scholar
- Ritchie JT, Godwin DC, Otter-Nache S (1988) CERES-Wheat. A simulation model of wheat growth and development. Texas A&M University Press, College Station, TexasGoogle Scholar
- Skaggs RW (1978) A water management model for shallow water table soils. University of North Carolina Water Resources Research Institute Raleigh, NCGoogle Scholar
- Williams JR, Dyke PT, Jones CA (1983) EPIC: a model for assessing the effects of erosion on soil productivity. In: Laurenoth WK et al (eds) Analysis of ecological systems: state-of-the-art in ecological modeling. Amsterdam, The Netherlands, pp 553–572Google Scholar
- Youssef MA, Skaggs RW, Chescheir GM, Gilliam JW (2005) The nitrogen simulation model, DRAINMOD-N II. Trans ASAE 48(2):611–626Google Scholar