Journal of Financial Services Research

, Volume 43, Issue 1, pp 99–126 | Cite as

Deconstructing Herding: Evidence from Pension Fund Investment Behavior



In this paper, we examine herding across asset classes and industry levels. We also study what incentives managers at various layers of the financial industry face when investing. To do so, we use unique and detailed monthly portfolios between 1996 and 2005 from pension funds in Chile, a pioneer in pension-fund reform. The results show that pension funds herd more in assets that have more risk and for which pension funds have less market information. Furthermore, the results show that herding is more prevalent for funds that narrowly compete with each other, namely, when comparing funds of the same type across pension fund administrators (PFAs). There is much less herding across PFAs as a whole and in individual pension funds within PFAs. These herding patterns are consistent with incentives for managers to be close to industry benchmarks, and might be also driven by market forces and partly by regulation.


Institutional investors Portfolio allocation Investment patterns Capital market development 

JEL Classification

G11 G12 G23 G28 O16 


  1. Amihud Y, Mendelson H (1986) Asset pricing and the bid-ask spread. J Financ Econ 17(2):223–249CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Andrade L, Farrell D, Lund S (2007) Fulfilling the potential of Latin America’s financial systems. McKinsey QuarterlyGoogle Scholar
  3. Arrau P, Chumacero R (1998) Tamaño de los fondos de pensiones en Chile y su desempeño financiero. Cuad Econ 35(105):205–235Google Scholar
  4. Badrinath SG, Wahal S (2002) Momentum trading by institutions. J Finance 57(6):2449–2478CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Banerjee AV (1992) A simple model of herd behavior. Quar J Econ 107(3):797–817CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Bekaert G, Harvey CR, Lundblad C (2007) Liquidity and expected returns: lessons from emerging markets. Rev Financ Stud 20(6):1783–1831CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Berstein SM, Chumacero R (2006) Quantifying the costs of investment limits for Chilean pension funds. Fisc Stud 27(1):99–123CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bessembinder H, Maxwell W (2008) Transparency and the corporate bonds market. J Econ Perspect 22(2):217–234CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bikhchandani S, Hirshleifer D, Welch I (1992) A theory of fads, fashion, custom, and cultural change in informational cascades. J Pol Econ 100(5):992–1026CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Blake D, Lehmann B, Timmermann A (2002) Performance clustering and incentives in the UK pension fund industry. J Asset Manag 3(2):173–194CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Blommestein H (2001) Ageing, pension reform, and financial market implications in the OECD area. CeRP Working paper 9/01Google Scholar
  12. Bodie Z (1990) Managing pension funds and retirement assets: an international perspective. J Financ Serv Res 4(4):419–460CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Bolton P, Scheinkman J, Xiong W (2006) Executive compensation and short-termist behavior in speculative markets. Rev Econ Studies 73(3):577–610CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Catalán M (2004) Pension funds and corporate governance in developing countries: what do we know and what do we need to know? J Pension Econ Finance 3(2):197–232CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Catalán M, Impavido G, Musalem AR (2000) Contractual savings or stock market development: which leads? J Appl Soc Sci Stud 120(3):445–487Google Scholar
  16. Chevalier J, Ellison G (1999) Career concerns of mutual fund managers. Q J Econ 114(2):389–432CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Choi N, Sias RW (2009) Institutional industry herding. J Financ Econ 94(3):469–491CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Chordia T, Roll R, Subrahmanyam A (2001) Market liquidity and trading activity. J Finance 56(2):501–530CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Corbo V, Schmidt-Hebbel K (2003) Macroeconomic effects of the pension reform in Chile. In: Pension reforms: results and challenges. International Federation of Pension Fund Administrators, Santiago, pp 241–329Google Scholar
  20. Dahlquist M, Punkiwutz L, Stulz R, Williamson R (2003) Corporate governance and the home bias. J Financ Quant Anal 38(1):87–110CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Davis EP (1995) Pension funds: retirement income security and capital markets—an international perspective. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
  22. Davis EP, Steil B (2001) Institutional investors. MIT Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  23. de la Torre A, Schmukler S (2006) Emerging capital markets and globalization: the Latin American experience. Stanford University Press and World BankGoogle Scholar
  24. Eterovic EF, Silva A, Oyarzun C (2011) Risk, return, and equilibrium: empirical tests. J Polit Econ 81(3):607–636Google Scholar
  25. Fama EF, MacBeth JD (1973) Risk, return, and equilibrium: empirical tests. J Pol Econ 81(3):607–636CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Ferson W, Khang K (2002) Conditional performance measurement using portfolio weights: evidence for pension funds. J Financ Econ 65(2):249–282CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Flannery MJ, Kwan SH, Nimalendran M (2004) Market evidence on the opaqueness of banking firms’ assets. J Financ Econ 71(3):419–460CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Froot KA, Scharfstein DS, Stein JC (1992) Herd on the street: informational inefficiencies in a market with short-term speculation. J Finance 47(4):1461–1484CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Gompers PA, Metrick A (2001) Institutional investors and equity prices. Q J Econ 116(1):229–259CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Graham JR (1999) Herding among investment newsletters: theory and evidence. J Finance 54(1):237–268CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Greenwood R, Nagel S (2009) Inexperienced investors and bubbles. J Financ Econ 93(2):239–258CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Grinblatt M, Keloharju M (2000) The investment behavior and performance of various investor types: a study of Finland’s unique data set. J Financ Econ 55(1):43–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Grinblatt M, Titman S, Wermers R (1995) Momentum investment strategies, portfolio performance, and herding: a study of mutual fund behavior. Amer Econ Rev 85(5):1088–1105Google Scholar
  34. Impavido G, Musalem AR (2000) Contractual savings, stock, and asset markets. World Bank Policy Research Paper 2490Google Scholar
  35. Impavido G, Musalem AR, Tressel T (2003) The impact of contractual savings institutions on securities markets. World Bank Policy Research Paper 2948Google Scholar
  36. Kacperczyk M, Sialm C, Zheng L (2005) On the industry concentration of actively managed equity mutual funds. J Finance 60(4):2379–2416CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Kacperczyk M, Sialm C, Zheng L (2008) Unobserved actions of mutual funds. Rev Financ Studies 21(6):2379–2416CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Kaminsky G, Lyons R, Schmukler S (2004) Managers, investors, and crises: mutual fund strategies in emerging markets. J Inter Econ 64(1):113–134CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Kapur S, Timmermann A (2005) Relative performance evaluation contracts and asset market equilibrium. Econ J 115(506):1077–1102CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Lakonishok J, Shleifer A, Vishny RW (1992) The impact of institutional trading on stock prices. J Financ Econ 32(1):23–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Langford B, Faff R, Marisetty V (2006) On the choice of superannuation funds in Australia. J Financ Serv Res 29(3):255–279CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Lazen V (2005) El mercado secundario de deuda en Chile. Documento de Trabajo N°5, Superintendencia de Valores y Seguros, Santiago, ChileGoogle Scholar
  43. Lefort F, Walker E (2002a) Premios por plazo, tasas reales y catástrofes: evidencia de Chile. El Trimestre Económico 69(2):191–225Google Scholar
  44. Lefort F, Walker E (2002b) Pension reform and capital markets: are there any (hard) links? World Bank Social Protection Discussion Paper 0201Google Scholar
  45. Livingston M, Naranjo A, Zhou L (2007) Asset opaqueness and split bond ratings. Financ Manag 36(3):49–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Morgan DP (2002) Rating banks: risk and uncertainty in an opaque industry. Amer Econ Rev 92(4):874–888CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Nofsinger J, Sias RW (1999) Herding and feedback trading by institutional and individual investors. J Finance 54(6):2263–2295CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Olivares JA (2005) Investment behavior of the Chilean pension funds. Financial Management Association European Conference Paper 360419Google Scholar
  49. Opazo L, Raddatz C, Schmukler S (2009) The long and the short of emerging market debt. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 5056Google Scholar
  50. Piñera J (1991) El cascabel al gato: la batalla por la reforma previsional. Zig-Zag, SantiagoGoogle Scholar
  51. Raddatz C, Schmukler S (2011) Deconstructing herding: evidence from pension fund Investment behavior. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 5700Google Scholar
  52. Scharfstein DS, Stein JC (1990) Herd behavior and investment. Amer Econ Rev 80(3):465–479Google Scholar
  53. Shiller RJ, Pound J (1989) Survey evidence on diffusion of interest and information among investors. J Econ Behav Organ 12(1):47–66CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Shleifer A, Vishny R (1990) Equilibrium short horizons of investors and firms. Amer Econ Rev 80(2):148–153Google Scholar
  55. Sias RW (2004) Institutional herding. Rev Financ Studies 17(1):165–206CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Sias RW (2007) Reconcilable differences: momentum trading by institutions. Financ Rev 42(1):1–22CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Sias RW, Starks R (1997) Return autocorrelation and institutional investors. J Financ Econ 46(1):103–131CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Stein J (2003) Agency, information, and corporate investment. In: Constantinides G, Harris M, Stulz R (eds) Handbook of the economics of finance. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 115–165Google Scholar
  59. Stein J (2005) Why are most funds open-end? Competition and the limits of arbitrage. Q J Econ 120(1):247–272Google Scholar
  60. The Economist (2008) Money for old hope. Special report on asset management, March 1Google Scholar
  61. Vittas D (1999) Pension reform and financial markets. Harvard Institute for International Development, Development Discussion Paper 697Google Scholar
  62. Voronkova S, Bohl M (2005) Institutional traders’ behavior in an emerging stock market: empirical evidence on polish pension fund investors. J Bus Finance Account 32(7–8):1537–1560CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Wermers R (1999) Mutual fund herding and the impact on stock prices. J Finance 54(2):581–622CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Yermo J (2005) The contribution of pension funds to capital market development in Chile. Mimeo, Oxford University and OECDGoogle Scholar
  65. Zurita F (1999) Are pension funds myopic? Revista de Administración y Economía, Catholic University of Chile 39:13–15Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2012

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Banco Central de ChileSantiagoChile
  2. 2.World BankWashingtonUSA

Personalised recommendations