Rethinking the Imposter Phenomenon
The Imposter Phenomenon—i.e., the phenomenon of feeling like a fraud and like your successes aren’t really yours—is typically construed not just as a crisis of confidence, but as a failure of rationality. On the standard story, “imposters” have bad beliefs about their talents because they dismiss the evidence provided by their successes. Here I suggest that this standard picture could be mistaken, and that these “imposters” may actually be more rational (on average) than non-imposters. Why? Accounting for the non-talent causes of your successes may require you to lower your confidence in your talents, in which case, “imposter” beliefs are rational. I then go on to suggest a second reason to worry about the standard picture: It does not adequately address the possible role that one’s environment has in the production of the phenomenon. To give an example, I hypothesize that environments that host a “culture of genius” can alter our evidential landscape in a way that promotes the Imposter Phenomenon. Finally, I argue that my alternative picture of the Imposter Phenomenon should prompt us to opt for a conception of self-worth that is more deeply tied to virtues like intellectual humility than to relative talent possession.
KeywordsImposter phenomenon Imposter syndrome Culture of genius Self-worth Intellectual humility
I’m grateful to Harry Brighouse, Gina Schouten, Russ Shafer-Landau, Michael Titelbaum, and audiences at the 2017 APA Pacific meeting and the Munich Center for Mathematical Philosophy’s 2017 “Values in Science” workshop for their helpful criticisms and suggestions. I owe special thanks to Erin Beeghly for her comments and conversation at the APA Pacific and to Reuben Stern for extensive discussion.
- Beard J (1990) Personality correlates of the imposter phenomenon: An exploration in gender differences in critical needs. Unpublished masters’s thesis, Georgia State University, AtlantaGoogle Scholar
- Brighouse H, Swift A (2014) The place of educational equality in educational justice. In: Meyer K (ed) Education, justice and the human good: Routledge international studies in the philosophy of education. London. Routledge, New York, pp 14–33Google Scholar
- Clance PR, O’Toole MA (1987) The imposter phenomenon: an internal barrier to empowerment and achievement. Women Ther 6:3, 51–64Google Scholar
- Flewelling AL (1985) The impostor phenomenon in individuals succeeding in self-perceived atypical professions: the effects of mentoring and longevity. Unpublished master's thesis. Georgia State University, AtlantaGoogle Scholar
- Harvey JC (1981) The impostor phenomenon and achievements: a failure to internalize success. Doctoral dissertation. Retrieved from Dissertation Abstracts International, 42, 4969–4970BGoogle Scholar
- Harvey JC, Katz C (1985) If I'm so successful, why do I feel like a fake?: the impostor phenomenon, 1st edn. St. Martin's Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Hawley K (2016) Philosophical reflections on imposter syndrome. A talk given at the Munich Center for Mathematical Philosophy on 27(07):2016 Available at: https://videoonline.edu.lmu.de/en/sommersemester-2016/8140. Accessed 1 March 2019
- Lawler KN (1984) The impostor phenomenon in high achieving persons and Jungian personality variables. Doctoral dissertation. Retrieved from Dissertation Abstracts International, 45B, 2693Google Scholar
- Olberding A (06 March 2018). “The Outsider”. Aeon. Last retrieved from https://aeon.co/essays/how-useful-is-impostor-syndrome-in-academia on 22 June 2018. Accessed 1 March 2019
- Sosis C (5 October 2017). “Rebecca Tuvel.” What it’s like to be a philosopher? Last retrieved from http://www.whatisitliketobeaphilosopher.com/rebecca-tuvel/ on 22 June 2018. Accessed 1 March 2019
- Tanesini, Alessandra (2016). “Intellectual humility as attitude.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. Version of Record online: 4 AUG 2016. https://doi.org/10.1111/phpr.12326