Advertisement

Ethics and Information Technology

, Volume 6, Issue 2, pp 73–81 | Cite as

The tragedy of the digital commons

  • Gian Maria Greco
  • Luciano Floridi
Article

Abstract

In the paper it is argued that bridging the digital divide may cause a new ethical and social dilemma. Using Hardin's Tragedy of the Commons, we show that an improper opening and enlargement of the digital environment (Infosphere) is likely to produce a Tragedy of the Digital Commons (TDC). In the course of the analysis, we explain why Adar and Huberman's previous use of Hardin's Tragedy to interpret certain recent phenomena in the Infosphere (especially peer-to-peer communication) may not be entirely satisfactory. We then seek to provide an improved version of the TDC that avoids the possible shortcomings of their model. Next, we analyse some problems encountered by the application of classical ethics in the resolution of the TDC. In the conclusion, we outline the kind of work that will be required to develop an ethical approach that may bridge the digital divide but avoid the TDC.

artificial agents digital divide Garrett Hardin Infosphere tragedy of the commons tragedy of the digital commons 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. E. Adar and B. A. Huberman. Free Riding on Gnutella. First Monday, 5(10), 2000. http://rstmonday.org/issues/issue5_10/adar/index.html.Google Scholar
  2. R. N. L. Andrews. Cost-Bene t Analysis and Regulatory Reform. In D. Swartzman, R. Liro. and K. Croke, editors. Cost-Benefit Analysis and Environmental Regulations: Politics, Ethics, and Methods, pp. 107–135. The Conservation Foundation, Washington, 1982.Google Scholar
  3. J. P. Barlow. The Economy of Ideas. Wired Magazine, 2(3), 1994. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/2.03/economy.ideas.html.Google Scholar
  4. A. Brennan and Y. Lo. Environmental Ethics. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http: //plato. stanford. edu/ entries/ethics-environmental, 2002.Google Scholar
  5. eEurope. An Information Society For All. Action Plan prepared by the Council and the European Commission for the Feira European Council 19–20 June 2000, http: // europa. eu. int/information_society/eeurope/action_plan/ pdf/actionplan_en. pdf, 2000.Google Scholar
  6. eEurope 2002. Accessibility of Public Web Sites and their Content, September 25, http: //europa. eu. int/information_society/eeurope/news_library/pdf_les/communication_accessibility_en. doc, 2001.Google Scholar
  7. J. A. Fletcher and M. Zwick. N-Player Prisoner's Dilemma in Multiple Groups: A Model of Multilevel Selection, In E. Boudreau and C. Maley, editors. Proceedings of the Artificial Life VII Workshops. Portland, 2000.Google Scholar
  8. L. Floridi. Information Ethics: On the Theoretical Foundations of Computer Ethics. Ethics and Information Technology, 1(1): 37–56, 1999.Google Scholar
  9. L. Floridi. Information Ethics: An Environmental Approach to the Digital Divide. Philosophy in the Contemporary World,9(1): 39–45, 2002.Google Scholar
  10. L. Floridi. On the Intrinsic Value of Information Objects and the Infosphere. Ethics and Information Technology, 4(4): 287–304, 2003.Google Scholar
  11. L. Floridi and J. W. Sanders. On the Morality of Articial Agents. Minds and Machines, forthcoming.Google Scholar
  12. G. M. Greco. La Tragedia dei Beni Digitali Collettivi. Talk given at the yearly national conference of the Societa` Italiana di Filoso a (Italian Philosophical Association), ''Filoso a e Societa`della Conoscenza (Philosophy and Knowledge Society)'', Foggia, 17–19 October 2002.Forthcoming in the Proceedings.Google Scholar
  13. G. M. Greco and L. Floridi. The Tragedy of the Digital Commons. IEG Research Report, IEG-RR1, Information Ethics research Group, Computing Laboratory, Oxford University, 14 October 2003.Google Scholar
  14. H. Grotius. On the Law of War and Peace, John W. Parker, Cambridge, 1853 [1625 ].Google Scholar
  15. G. Hardin. The Tragedy of the Commons. Science, 162(3859): 1243–1248, 1968.Google Scholar
  16. G. Hardin. Extensions of ''The Tragedy of the Commons ''. Science, 280(5364): 682–683, 1998.Google Scholar
  17. B. A. Huberman and R. M. Lukose. Social Dilemmas and Internet Congestion. Science, 277(5325): 535–537, 1997.Google Scholar
  18. A. Kneese and B. Bower. Environmental Quality and Residuals Management. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1979.Google Scholar
  19. D. Marietta, Jr. The Interrelationship of Ecological Science and Environmental Ethics. Environmental Ethics, 1(3): 195–207, 1979.Google Scholar
  20. Nielsen//NetRatings Global Internet Trends Q4 2002, 20 February 2003.Google Scholar
  21. E. Ostrom. Collective Action and the Tragedy of the Commons. In G. Hardin and J. Baden, editors. Managing the Commons. Freeman, New York, 1977.Google Scholar
  22. E. Ostrom. How Inexorable is the ''Tragedy of the Commons''? Institutional Arrangements for Changing the Structure of Social Dilemmas. Workshop in Political Theory and Policy Analysis, Distinguished Faculty Research Lecture, Indiana University, Bloomington, 3 April 1986.Google Scholar
  23. T. Pfeifier, S. Schuster and S. Bonhoeer. Cooperation and Competition in the Evolution of ATP-Producing Pathways. Science, 292(5516): 504–507, 2001.Google Scholar
  24. M. Robert and G. Sorci. The evolution of obligate interspeci c brood parasitism in birds. Behavioral Ecology, 12(2): 128–133, 2001.Google Scholar
  25. Special issue on ''Remapping the Digital Divide ''. The Information Society, 19(4), 2003.Google Scholar
  26. Stopping spam. The Economist, 367(8321): 58, 2003.Google Scholar
  27. R. M. Turner. The tragedy of the commons and distributed AI systems. Presented at the XII International Workshop on Distributed Arti cial Intelligence, University of New Hampshire, Durham, 1991.Google Scholar
  28. United Nations Development Programme. Human Development Report 2001. Making new technologies work for human development. Oxford University Press, New York Oxford, 2001.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  • Gian Maria Greco
    • 1
  • Luciano Floridi
    • 2
  1. 1.Università degli Studi di Lecce, Italy; Information Ethics research Group, Computing Laboratory, Oxford UniversityDipartimento di Filologia Classica e di Scienze FilosoficheGreat Britain
  2. 2.Università degli Studi di BariDipartimento di Scienze FilosoficheItaly; Information Ethics research Group, Computing Laboratory, Oxford University, Great Britain

Personalised recommendations