Can Opposing Dispositions be Co-instantiated?
- 222 Downloads
Is it possible that one and the same object x has opposing dispositions at the same time? One’s first reaction might be that it is evidently impossible. On the assumption that x is incombustible, it seems to follow that it is not combustible. Surprisingly enough, however, it is claimed that there are a number of examples in support of the possibility of simultaneous co-instantiation of opposing dispositions. In this paper, I will bring under scrutiny some of the examples and come to the conclusion that none of them achieve the desired goal. This will give support to the initial intuition that opposing dispositions cannot be co-instantiated by one and the same object at the same time.
My special thanks to Randolph Clarke for his valuable advice and encouragement. Also, I am much indebted to two anonymous referees for their very helpful comments. This work was supported by a grant from the Kyung Hee University in 2012 (KHU-20120798).
- Bird, A. (manuscript). Can dispositions have intrinsic finks and antidotes?. Available online at http://eis.bris.ac.uk/~plajb/research/inprogress/Intrinsic_Antidotes.pdf.
- Choi, S. (2009). The conditional analysis of dispositions and the intrinsic dispositions thesis. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 78, 563–590.Google Scholar
- Choi, S. (forthcoming_a). Intrinsic finks and dispositional/categorical distinction. Nous, doi:10.1111/j.1468-0068.2010.00789.x (published online).
- Choi, S. (forthcoming_b). What is a dispositional masker? Mind, doi:10.1093/mind/fzr083 (published online).
- Jackson, F. (1990). Classifying conditionals. Analysis, 50, 134–147.Google Scholar
- Jackson, F. (1991). Classifying conditionals II. Analysis, 51, 137–143.Google Scholar
- Lewis, D. (1986). ‘Events’ in his philosophical papers: Volume II. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Lowe, J. (1991). Jackson on classifying conditionals. Analysis, 51, 126–130.Google Scholar
- Schrenk, M. (2007). Can capacities rescue us from Ceteris paribus laws? In B. Gnassounou & M. Kistler (Eds.), Dispositions in philosophy and science, Ashgate.Google Scholar