, Volume 63, Issue 3, pp 375–385 | Cite as

Problems with Priors in Probabilistic Measures of Coherence



Two of the probabilistic measures of coherence discussed in this paper take probabilistic dependence into account and so depend on prior probabilities in a fundamental way. An example is given which suggests that this prior-dependence can lead to potential problems. Another coherence measure is shown to be independent of prior probabilities in a clearly defined sense and consequently is able to avoid such problems. The issue of prior-dependence is linked to the fact that the first two measures can be understood as measures of coherence as striking agreement, while the third measure represents coherence as agreement. Thus, prior (in)dependence can be used to distinguish different conceptions of coherence.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Akiba, K. 2000‘Shogenji’s Probabilistic Measure of Coherence Is Incoherent’Analysis60356359CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bovens, L., Hartmann, S. 2003Bayesian EpistemologyOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  3. Bovens, L., Olsson, E. J. 2000‘Coherentism, Reliability and Bayesian Networks’Mind109685719CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Fitelson, B. 2003‘A Probabilistic Theory of Coherence’Analysis63194199CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Glass, D. H.: 2002, ‘Coherence, Explanation and Bayesian Networks’, Proceedings of the 13th Irish Conference in Artificial Intelligence and Cognitive Science, edited by M. O’Neill et al., Lecture Notes in AI 2646, Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 177–182.Google Scholar
  6. Kemeny, J. G., Oppenheim, P. 1952‘Degrees of Factual Support’Philosophy of Science19307324CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Olsson, E. J. 2001‘Why Coherence Is Not Truth-Conducive’Analysis61236241CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Olsson, E. J. 2002‘What Is the Problem of Coherence and Truth?’The Journal of Philosophy99246272Google Scholar
  9. Shogenji, T. 1999‘Is Coherence Truth-Conducive?’Analysis59338345CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Shogenji, T. 2001‘Reply to Akiba on the Probabilistic Measure of Coherence’Analysis61147150CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Siebel, M. 2004‘On Fitelson’s Measure of Coherence’Analysis64189190CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.School of Computing and MathematicsUniversity of UlsterU.K.

Personalised recommendations