The paradox of the sustainable city: definitions and examples
- 2.9k Downloads
It is well known that sustainability has become a much needed target, especially considering the recent rapid urban sprawl and the subsequent exacerbation of social, environmental, and economic problems. Thus, many studies have been conducted to define sustainability and the sustainable city. However, many of these definitions suggest a range of contradictions, implying that the achievement of sustainability is elusive. The problem lies in setting unreasonable definitions of sustainability and in the various contradictions to these definitions, making sustainability seemingly unattainable. Hence, some models of cities are emerging that are labeled as sustainable cities; among these are the “zero-carbon city” and the “ubiquitous eco-city” (“U-eco-city”). This study reviews the history and definitions of sustainability, in order to acknowledge the contradictions inherent in these concepts. It also briefly presents the compact city, the zero-carbon eco-city, and the U-eco-city by determining their individual pros and cons and highlighting where there are any conflicts with the principles of sustainability. The aim of the study was to adjust the use of sustainability as a terminology in the field of urban sustainable development and to demonstrate the extent to which we use marketing names for eco-cities without compliance with sustainable dimensions. The study will also discuss the key sustainability pillar required for a project to be kept sustainable. The study concludes that the use of the term “sustainable city” may limit the potential for further enhancing sustainability in future projects; using the term “transition toward the sustainable city” may be more accurate and more effective. The results show that reducing energy consumption through efficient use, and relying on renewable energies, will be the keys to reaching urban sustainability. The study also finds that recent tyranny in the name of ecology will not result in real sustainability. Although the free eco-city and the u-eco-city are considered advanced models, their limitations are related more to the economic and social aspects than to the compact city, which clearly reflected the pillars of sustainability, despite its being an outdated model.
KeywordsSustainable city Transition into sustainability Zero-carbon city Compact city Ubiquitous eco-city
This research was supported by a Grant (14RDRP-B076574-01-000000) from Regional Development Research Program funded by Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport of Korean government.
Conflict of interest
- Abdul-Kadir, S., & Jamaludin, M. (2013). Universal design as a significant component for sustainable life and social development. Journal of Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences, 85, 180.Google Scholar
- Arthur, L. (2012). Masdar City: A model of urban environmental sustainability. 77 SOCI SCICS. pp. 77–82.Google Scholar
- Berke, P., Manta, M. (1999). Planning for sustainable development: Measuring progress in plans. Lincoln Institute of Land policy (Working Paper): p. 3.Google Scholar
- Caetano, M., Araújo, J. B., & Amaral, D. C. (2012). A framework for the application of eco-efficiency to the technology development process. Technology Management and Innovation, 7(2), 29.Google Scholar
- Cibworld (2014). CIB pro-active approach priority theme 1—sustainable construction CIB: News on CIB and Sustainable Construction. Online access: <http://cibworld.xs4all.nl/dl/ib/9903/pages/pro1.html#anchor413919>. Accessed 09 Jan 2014.
- Dempsey, N., Brown, C., & Bramley, G. (2012). The key to sustainable urban development in UK cities? The influence of density on social sustainability. Journal of Progress in Planning, 77, 94.Google Scholar
- Dominski, T. (1992). The three stage evolution of eco-cities: Reduce, reuse, recycle. In A. Walter, et al. (Eds.), Sustainable cities (pp. 16–18). Los Angeles: Eco-Home Media.Google Scholar
- Gilman, R. (2013). The dynamic planetary context for intentional communities. Social Sciences Directory, 2(3), 2–31.Google Scholar
- Hassan, A. M., Hyowon, L., Yoo, U. (2013). Reviving the cultural heritage of Arabian–Islamic cities by new technological tools: From Islamic Cairo into Masdar City. Creative Renaissance, the 7th conference international forum on urbanism (IFOU); College of planning and design, National Cheng Kung University, Taiwan, Oct. 7–11, 2013. CD, ISBN: 9789860382396, pp. 342–351.Google Scholar
- Hofstad, H. (2012). Compact city development: High ideals and emerging practices. European Journal of Spatial Development; 49. Available Online: http://www.nordregio.se/Global/EJSD/Refereed%20articles/refereed49.pdf; access date: may, 30th, 2014.
- HoLee, S., Hoon, H. J., Taik, L. Y., et al. (2008). Towards ubiquitous city: Concept, planning, and experiences in the Republic of Korea. In T. Yigitcanlar, K. Velibeyoglu, & S. Baum (Eds.), Knowledge-based urban development: Planning and applications in the information Era (pp. 148–169). Hershey, PA: IGI Global, Information Science Reference.Google Scholar
- Hornby, A. S. (1995). Oxford advanced learner’s dictionary of current English (5th ed., p. 1205). UK: Oxford university press.Google Scholar
- Inaba, J. (2012). Adaptation: Architecture, technology, and the city. ISBN: 0615738737, 9780615738734. p. 7. Available Online at: http://www.inaba.us/project/adaptation-architecture-technology-and-city. Accessed 26th March 2014.
- ITU-T (2013). Smart cities—Seoul: A case study. ITU-T Technology Watch Report. Available Online: http://www.itu.int/dms_pub/itut/oth/23/01/T23010000190001PDFE.pdf. Accessed 26th March 2014.
- Jiang, Y., Shen, J. (2010). Measuring the urban competitiveness of Chinese cities in. Cities. 27, 312.Google Scholar
- Jung, H. S., Jeong, C. S., Lee, Y. W., et al. (2009). An intelligent ubiquitous middleware for U-City: SmartUM. Journal of Information Science and Engineering, 25, 375–388.Google Scholar
- Kim, Y. M., Kim, H. S., Moon, S. Y., et al. (2009). Ubiquitous eco-city planning in Korea. A Project for the Realization of Ecological City Planning and Ubiquitous Network Society. REAL CORP 2009: CITIES 3.0—Smart, Sustainable, Integrative. Proceedings of 14th International Conference on Urban Planning, Region al Development and Information Society, 22–25th, April, 2009; pp. 925–930. Catalonia, Spain. Available Online at: <http://programm.corp.at/cdrom2009/papers2009/CORP2009_174.pdf>. Accessed 26th March 2014.
- Lehmann, S. (2010). The principles of green urbanism: Transforming the city for sustainability. London: Earthscan.Google Scholar
- Lindfield, M., Steinberg, F. (2012). Green cities. Asian Development Bank, p. 86. Available Online at: http://www10.iadb.org/intal/intalcdi/PE/2012/10650.pdf. Accessed 26th March 2014.
- Maclaren, V. W. (1996). Urban sustainability reporting. Journal of the American Planning Association, 62(2), 185. Available also Online at <http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/01944369608975684>. Accessed 26th Jan 2013.
- Masdarconnect (2013). Exploring Masdar city, Available at : <http://www.masdarconnect.com/userfiles/files/Exploring-Masdar-City-Site-Tour-Booklet.pdf>. Accessed 12 Aug 2013.
- McDonough, W. (1992). The hannover principles: Design for sustainability. Prepared for EXPO 2000, The World’s Fair. Hannover, Germany. Available Online at: <http://www.mcdonough.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/Hannover-Principles-1992.pdf>. Accessed 19th July 2014.
- Oktay, D. (2012). Human sustainable urbanism: In pursuit of ecological and social–cultural sustainability. Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences, 36, 19.Google Scholar
- Rai, P. T. (2012). Townships for sustainable cities. Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences, 37, 419.Google Scholar
- Rasoolimanesh, S. M., Badarulzaman, N., & Jaafar, M. (2012). City development strategies (CDS) and sustainable urbanization in developing world. Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences, 36, 626.Google Scholar
- Rogers, R. (1997). Cities for a small planet (p. 26). London: Faber and Faber Limited.Google Scholar
- Scheurer, J. (2007). Compact city policy: How Europe rediscovered its history and met resistance. 2005–2007 the urban reinventors Journal, issue 2. celebration of urbanity. Available online at: <http://www.urbanreinventors.net/2/scheurer/scheurer-urbanreinventors.pdf>. Accessed 17th Feb 2014.
- The National Council of Architecture Registration Boards (NCARB) (2001). Sustainable design. First edition, Washington, USA: (NCARB), the National Council of Architecture Registration Boards, 2001, pp. 3–21.Google Scholar
- WCED. (1987). Our common future. London: Oxford University Press. 46.Google Scholar
- Whitehead, M. (2003). (Re)Analysing the sustainable city: Nature, urbanisation and the regulation of socio-environmental relations in the UK. Urban Studies Journal, 40(7), 1186. Available also online at <http://usj.sagepub.com/content/40/7/1183>. Accessed 27th Jan 2014.
- Whitehead, I. (2010). Models of Sustainability? A Comparative Analysis of Ideal City Planning in Saltaire and Masdar City. GEO View: Online Undergraduate Review of Geography and Environmental Studies. ISSN: 1448-6482.Google Scholar