Springer Nature is making SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19 research free. View research | View latest news | Sign up for updates

Case Study Part 1: How to Calculate Appropriate Deterministic Long-Term Toxicity to Exposure Ratios (TERs) for Birds and Mammals

Abstract

In the European Union, first-tier assessment of the long-term risk to birds and mammals from pesticides is based on calculation of a deterministic long-term toxicity/exposure ratio (TERlt). The ratio is developed from generic herbivores and insectivores and applied to all species. This paper describes two case studies that implement proposed improvements to the way long-term risk is assessed. These refined methods require calculation of a TER for each of five identified phases of reproduction (phase-specific TERs) and use of adjusted No Observed Effect Levels (NOELs) to incorporate variation in species sensitivity to pesticides. They also involve progressive refinement of the exposure estimate so that it applies to particular species, rather than generic indicators, and relates spraying date to onset of reproduction. The effect of using these new methods on the assessment of risk is described. Each refinement did not necessarily alter the calculated TER value in a way that was either predictable or consistent across both case studies. However, use of adjusted NOELs always reduced TERs, and relating spraying date to onset of reproduction increased most phase-specific TERs. The case studies suggested that the current first-tier TERlt assessment may underestimate risk in some circumstances and that phase-specific assessments can help identify appropriate risk-reduction measures. The way in which deterministic phase-specific assessments can currently be implemented to enhance first-tier assessment is outlined.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

References

  1. Bennett, R.S., Dewhurst, I., Fairbrother, A., Hooper, M., Leopold, A., Mineau, P., Mortensen, S., Shore, R.F. and Springer, T. (2005). A new interpretation of avian and mammalian reproduction toxicity test data in ecological risk assessment. Ecotoxicology, this volume

  2. Calow P., (1998). Ecological risk assessment: risk for what? How do we decide? Ecotoxicol Environ. Saf. 40:15–8

  3. Corbet G.B., Harris S., (1991). The Handbook of British Mammals. (Third). Blackwell Scientific Publications Oxford

  4. Crocker, D.R., Hart, A., Gurney, J. and McCoy, C. (2002a). Project PN0908: Methods for estimating daily food intake of wild birds and mammals. Central Science Laboratory final report to Defra

  5. Crocker D.R., Prosser P., Irving P.V., Bone P., Hart A., (2002b). Estimating avian exposure to pesticides on arable crops In Boatman N.D., Carter N., Evans A.D., Grice P.V., Stoate C., Wilson J.D., (eds). Birds and Agriculture Association of Applied Biologists Wellesbourne 237–44

  6. Crocker, D.R. (2005). Estimating the exposure of birds and mammals to pesticides in long-term risk assessments. Ecotoxicology, this volume

  7. Donald P.F., Buckingham D.L., Moorcroft D., Muirhead L.B., Evans A.D., Kirby W.B., (2001). Habitat use and diet of skylarks Alauda arvensis wintering on lowland farmland in southern Britain J. Appl. Ecol. 38:536–47

  8. Donald P.F., (2004). The Skylark Poyser London

  9. European Commission (2002). Guidance document on risk assessment for birds and mammals under council directive 91/414/EEC, SANCO/4145/2000

  10. Fischer, D. (2005). Accounting for differing exposure patterns between laboratory test and the field in the assessment of long-term risks of pesticides to terrestrial vertebrates. Ecotoxicology, this volume

  11. Garthwaite D.G., Thomas M.R., Dawson A., Stoddart H., (2003). Pesticide Usage Survey Report 187: Arable Crops in Great Britain 2002 Defra Publications London

  12. Gorman M.L., Zubaid A.M.A., (1993). A comparative study of the ecology of woodmice Apodemus sylvaticus in two contrasting habitats: deciduous woodland and maritime sand-dunes J. Zool. (Lond.) 229:385–96

  13. Green R.E., (1978). Factors affecting the diet of farmland skylarks Alauda arvensis J. Anim. Ecol. 47:913–28

  14. Hansson L., (1985). The food of bank voles, wood mice and yellow-necked mice Symp. Zool. Soc. Lond. 55:141–68

  15. Hart, A.D.M. and Thompson, H.M. (2005). Introduction to workshop. Ecotoxicology, this volume

  16. Luttik, R., Mineau, P. and Roelofs, W. (2005). A review of interspecies extrapolation in birds and mammals and a proposal for long-term toxicity data. Ecotoxicology, this volume

  17. McKay H.V., Prosser P.J., Hart A.D.M., Langton S.D., Jones A., McCoy C., Chandler-Morris S.A., Pascual J.A., (1999). Do wood-pigeons avoid pesticide-treated cereal seed? J. Appl. Ecol. 36:283–96

  18. Mineau P., Hooper M., Elmegaard N., Grau R., Luttik R., Ringer B., (2001). Case Study 5: foliar insecticide II. In Hart A.D.M., Balluff D., Barfknecht R., Chapman P.F., Hawkes T., Joermann G., Leopold A., Luttik R., (eds). Avian Effects Assessment: A Framework for Contaminants Studies Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) Pensacola, FL, 113–36

  19. Mineau P., (2002). Estimating the probability of bird mortality from pesticide sprays on the basis of the field study record Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 21:1497–506

  20. Mineau, P. (2005). A review and analysis of study endpoints relevant to the assessment of ‘long term’ pesticide toxicity in avian and mammalian wildlife. Ecotoxicology, this volume

  21. OECD (1998). Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) guidelines for the testing of chemicals (up to and including tenth addendum) Version consulted for guidelines 206, 401, 402, 407, 408, 409, 410, 411, 412, 413, 415. Paris, OECD

  22. Poulsen J.G., Sotherton N.W., Aebischer N.J., (1998). Comparative nesting and feeding ecology of skylarks Alauda arvensis on arable farmland in southern England with special reference to set-aside J. Appl. Ecol. 35:131–47

  23. Roelofs, W., Crocker, D.R., Shore, R.F., Topping, C., Akcakaya, H.R., Bennett, R.S., Chapman, P.F., Clook, M., Crane, M., Dewhurst, I.C., Edwards, P.J., Fairbrother, A., Ferson, S., Fischer, D., Hart, A.D.M., Holmes, M., Hooper, M.J., Lavine, M., Leopold, A., Luttik, R., Mineau, P., Moore, D.R.J., Mortenson, S.R., Noble, D.G., O’Connor, R.J., Sibly, R.M., Smith, G., Spendiff, M., Springer, T.A. and Thompson, H.M. (2005). Case Study Part 2: Probabilistic modelling of long-term effects of pesticides on individual breeding success in birds and mammals. Ecotoxicology, this volume

  24. Rogers L.M., Gorman M.L., (1995). The diet of the wood mouse Apodemus sylvaticus on set-aside land J. Zool. 235:77–83

  25. Sibley, R.M., Akçakaya, H.R., Topping, C.J. and O’Connor, R.J. (2005). Population-level assessment of risks of pesticides to birds and mammals in the UK. Ecotoxicology, this volume

  26. Solomon K., Giesy J., Jones P., (2000). Probabilistic risk assessment of agrochemicals in the environment Crop Protection 19:649–55

  27. Tattersall F.H., Macdonald D.W., (2003). Wood mice in the arable system. In Tattersall F., Manley W., (eds). Conservation and Conflict: Mammals and Farming in Britain. Occasional Publication of the Linnean Society, The Linnean Society, London, 82–96

  28. Tiebout H.M., Brugger K.E., (1995). Ecological risk assessment of pesticides for terrestrial vertebrates: Evaluation and application of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s quotient model Conserv. Biol. 9:1605–18

  29. Watts C.H.S., (1968). The foods eaten by wood mice (Apodemus sylvaticus) and bank voles (Clethrionomys glareolus) in Wytham Woods, Berkshire J. Anim. Ecol. 37:25–41

Download references

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge the UK Department for Food and Rural Affairs and its Pesticide Safety Directorate for funding the workshop on long-term risk assessment.

Author information

Correspondence to R.F. SHORE.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

SHORE, R., CROCKER, D., AKCAKAYA, H. et al. Case Study Part 1: How to Calculate Appropriate Deterministic Long-Term Toxicity to Exposure Ratios (TERs) for Birds and Mammals. Ecotoxicology 14, 877–893 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10646-005-0034-4

Download citation

Keywords

  • risk assessment
  • pesticide exposure
  • no observed effect level
  • skylark
  • wood mouse