Environmental and Resource Economics

, Volume 73, Issue 2, pp 385–429 | Cite as

Demand-Pull Instruments and the Development of Wind Power in Europe: A Counterfactual Analysis

  • Marc Baudry
  • Clément BonnetEmail author


Renewable energy technologies are called to play a crucial role in the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. Since most of these technologies did not yet reach grid parity, public policies have been implemented in order to foster their deployment. The approach that has been privileged in Europe is the demand-pull approach that aims at creating a demand for these new technologies and at stimulating their diffusion. This paper examines the effect of demand-pull policies on the diffusion of onshore wind power technology in six European countries: Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, Portugal and Spain. In a first step, a micro-founded model of diffusion is calibrated in order to replicate the observed diffusion of wind power in these six countries. In a second step, a counterfactual analysis is conducted by investigating several scenarios. By taking into account the complex self-sustained dynamics of diffusion and the learning spillovers that operate in the wind power sector, we can derive several insights about demand-pull policies. First, the impact of a demand-pull policy on the diffusion of wind power is determined by the stage at which it comes to support it. The effect seems to be stronger at the beginning of the diffusion. Second, international spillovers do operate in the wind power sector. These international spillovers however are not strong enough to foster the diffusion of wind power in a country having no demand-pull support. We can derive from these two statements that a strategy consisting in not implementing any demand-pull policy, with the expectation that international spillovers will reduce the cost of wind power and foster the diffusion of the technology that then shall become competitive, is not a good option for a country targeting a high share of wind power in its energy mix.


Renewable energy Diffusion Wind power Demand-pull Counterfactual analysis 


Academic Literature

  1. Bass FM (1969) A new product growth for model consumer durables. Manage Sci 15:215–227CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bass FM (1980) The relationship between diffusion rates, experience curves, and demand elasticities for consumer durable technological innovations. J Bus 53:551–567CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Bean P, Blazquez J, Nezamuddin N (2017) Assessing the cost of renewable energy policy options—a Spanish wind case study. Renew Energy 103:180–186CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Benhmad F, Percebois J (2014) Wind power feed-in impacts on electricity system. Cahiers de recherche du CREDEN 14(11):110Google Scholar
  5. Boljesko T, Eltvig P, Nygaard JE (2014) An econometric analysis of support scheme effects on renewable energy investments in Europe. Energy Proced. 58:2–8CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Brancucci Martinez-Anido C, Brinkman G, Hodge B-M (2016) The impact of wind power on electricity prices. Renew. Energy 94:474–487CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Blanco MI (2009) The economics of wind energy. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 13:1372–1382CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Boccard N (2009) Capacity factor of wind power realized values vs. estimates. Energy Policy 37:2679–2688CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Bolinger M, Wiser R (2012) Understanding wind turbine price trends in the U.S. over the past decade. Energy Policy 42:628–641CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Carley S (2009) State renewable energy policies: an empirical evaluation of effectiveness. Energy Policy 37:3071–3081CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Couture T, Gagnon Y (2010) An analysis of feed-in tariff remuneration models: implications for renewable energy investment. Energy Policy 38:955–965CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Cló S, Cataldi A, Zoppoli P (2015) The merit-order effect in the Italian power market: the impact of solar and wind generation on national wholesale electricity prices. Energy Policy 77:79–88CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Cludius J, Hermann H, Matthes FC, Graichen V (2014) The merit order effect of wind and photovoltaic electricity generation in Germany 2008–2016: estimation and distributional implications. Energy Econ 44:302–313CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Coulomb L, Neuhoff K (2006) Learning curves and changing product attributes: the case of wind turbines. Cambridge Working Papers in Economics. 0618Google Scholar
  15. Chow GC (1967) Technological change and the demand for computers. Am Econ Rev 57:1117–1130Google Scholar
  16. Danchev S, Tsakanikas A (2010) Returns on investment in electricity producing photovoltaic systems under de-escalating feed-in tariffs: the case of Greece. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 14:500–505CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Dechezlepretre A, Glachant M (2014) Does foreign environmental policy influence domestic innovation? Evidence from the wind industry. Environ Resour Econ 58:391–413CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Delmas M, Montes-Sancho M (2011) U.S. state policies for renewable energy: context and effectiveness. Energy Policy 39:2273–2288CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Dong CG (2012) Feed-in tariff vs. renewable portfolio standard: An empirical test of their relative effectiveness in promoting wind capacity development. Energy Policy 42:476–485CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Ek K, Soderhölm P (2010) Technology learning in the presence of public R&D: the case of European wind power. Ecol Econ 69(12):2356–2362CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Ferioli F, Schoots K, van der Zwaan BCC (2009) Use and limitations of learning curves for energy technology policy: a component-learning hypothesis. Energy Econ 37:2525–2535Google Scholar
  22. Gavard C (2016) Carbon price and wind power support in Denmark. Energy Policy 92:455–467CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Gelabert L, Labandeira X, Linares P (2011) An ex-post analysis of the effect of renewables and cogeneration on Spanish electricty prices. Energy Econ 33:S59–S65CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Grafstrom J (2017) International knowledge spillovers in the wind power industry: evidence from the European Union. Econ Innov New Technol 27:205–224CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Grafström J, Lindman A (2017) Invention, innovation and diffusion in the European wind power sector. Technol Forecast Soc Chang 114:179–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Griliches Z (1957) Hybrid corn: an exploration in economics of technological change. Econometrica 25:501–522CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Griliches Z (1980) Hybrid corn revisited: a reply. Econometrica 48:1463–1465CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Gross R, Blyth W, Heptonstall P (2010) Risks, revenues and investment in electricity generation: why policies needs to look beyond the costs. Energy Policy 32:796–804Google Scholar
  29. Hirth L (2013) The market value of variable renewables, the effect of solar wind power variability on their relative price. Energy Econ 38:218–236CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Hitaj C, Schymura M, Loeschel A, (2014) The impacts of feed-in tariffs on wind power development in Germany. Discussion paper of the ZEW. 14-035Google Scholar
  31. Hitaj C (2013) Wind power development in the United States. J Environ Econ Manag 65:394–410CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Jacobsson S, Lauber V (2006) The politics and policy of energy system transformation—explaining the German diffusion of renewable energy technology. Energy Policy 34:256–276CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Jaffe AB, Newell RG, Stavins RN (2005) A tale of two market failures: technology and environmental policy. Ecol Econ 54:164–174CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Jenner S, Groba F, Indvik J (2013) Assessing the strength and effectiveness of renewable electricity feed-in tariffs in European Union countries. Energy Policy 52:385–401CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Kemp R (1998) The diffusion of biological wasterwater treatment plants in the Dutch food and beverage industry. Environ Resource Econ 12:113–136CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Ketterer J (2014) The impact of wind power generation on the electricity price in Germany. Energy Econ 44:270–280CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Kouvaritakis N, Soria A, Isoard S (2000) Modelling energy technology dynamics: methodology for adaptive expectations models with learning by doing and learning by searching. Int J Global Energy Issues 14:104–115CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Langniss O, Neij L (2004) National and international learning with wind power. Energy Environ 15(2):175–185CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Lindman A, Söderholm P (2012) Wind power learning rates: a conceptual review and meta-analysis. Energy Econ 34:754–761CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Luthi S, Prassler T (2011) Analyzing policy support instruments and regulatory risk factors for wind energy deployment- a developers’ perspective. Energy Policy 39:4876–4892CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Mansfield E (1961) Technological change and the rate of imitation. Econometrica 29:741–766CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Marques AC, Fuinhas JA (2011) Drivers promoting renewable energy: a dynamic panel approach. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 15:1601–1608CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Marques AC, Fuinhas JA (2012) Are public policies towards renewable successful? Evid Eur Ctries Renew Energy 44:109–118CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Menanteau P, Finon D, Lamy M (2003) Price versus quantities: choosing policies for promoting the development of renewable energy. Energy Policy 31:799–812CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Menz F, Vachon S (2006) The effectiveness of different policy regimes for promoting wind power: experiences from the states. Energy Policy 34:1786–1796CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Meyer N (2003) European schemes for promoting renewables in liberalised markets. Energy Policy 31:665–676CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Mercure J-F, Pollitt H, Chewpreecha U, Salas P, Foley AM, Holden PB, Edwards NR (2014) The dynamics of technology diffusion and the impacts of climate policy instruments in the decarbonisation of the global electricity sector. Energy Policy 73:686–700CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Mitchell C, Bauknecht D, Connor PM (2006) Effectiveness through risk reduction: a comparison of the renewable obligation in England and Wales and the feed-in system in Germany. Energy Policy 34:297–305CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Mir-Artigues P, Del Rio P (2014) Combining tariffs, investment subsidies and soft loans in a renewable electricity deployment policy. Energy Policy 69:430–442CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Mulder A (2008) Do economic instruments matter? Wind turbines investments in the EU(15). Energy Econ 30:2980–2991CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Pettersson M, Ek K, Soderholm K, Soderholm P (2010) Wind power planning and permitting: comparative perspectives from the Nordic countries. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 14:3116–3123CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Popp D, Hascic I, Medhi N (2011) Technology and the diffusion of renewable energy. Energy Economics 33:648–662CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Ragwitz M, Winkler J, Klessmann C, Gephart M, Resch G (2012) Recent developments of feed-in systems in the EU-A. Research paper for the international Feed-in Cooperation. 16 ppGoogle Scholar
  54. Sarzynski A, Larrieu J, Shrimali G (2012) The impact of state financial incentives on market deployment of solar technology. Energy Policy 46:550–557CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Schmid G (2012) The development of renewable energy power in India: which policies have been effective. Energy Policy 45:317–326CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Sensfuß F, Ragwitz M, Genoese M (2008) The merit-order effect: a detailed analysis of the price effect of renewable electricity generation on spot market prices in Germany. Energy Policy 36:3086–3094CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Smith M, Urpelainen J (2014) The effect of feed-in tariffs on renewable electricity generation: an instrumental variables approach. Environ Resource Econ 57:367–392CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Söderholm P, Klaassen G (2007) Wind power in Europe: a simultaneous innovation-diffusion model. Environ Resource Econ 36:163–190CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Sovacool B (2013) Energy policymaking in Denmark: implications for global energy security and sustainability. Energy Policy 61:829–839CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Usha Rao K, Kishore VVN (2010) A review of technology diffusion models with special reference to renewable energy technologies. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 14:1070–1078CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Verbruggen A, Volkmar L (2012) Assessing the performance of renewable electricity support instruments. Energy Policy 45:635–644CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Winter SG, (2005) Developing evolutionary theory for economics and management. Working paper of the Reginald H. Jones Center. WP 2005-01Google Scholar
  63. Zachmann G, Peruzzi M (2014) When and how to support renewables? Letting the data speak. Bruegel working paperGoogle Scholar

Books and Chapters

  1. Burton T, Sharpe D, Jenkins N, Bossanyi E (2001) Conceptual design of horizontal-axis turbines. In: Lang P (ed) Wind energy handbook. Wiley, HobokenGoogle Scholar
  2. Dinica V (2002) Renewable energy policies in Spain. In: Handbook of renewable energy in the European States-case studies of all member states. Peter Lang Publishing Group, Frankfurt am MainGoogle Scholar
  3. Greene WH (2011) Econometric analysis, 7th edn. Pearson Education, New York CityGoogle Scholar

Reports and Non-academic Studies

  1. Agence De l’Environnement et de la Maîtrise de l’Énergie. Premieres conclusions tirées de l’analyse économiques des projets éoliens en terre et en mer. November 2011Google Scholar
  2. Carbon Trust (2006) Analysis on policy frameworks to drive future investment in near and long-term renewable power in the UK. Policy frameworks for renewablesGoogle Scholar
  3. Commission de Régulation de l’Enérgie (2014) Coûts et rentabilité des énergies renouvelables en France métropolitaineGoogle Scholar
  4. De Jager D, Rathmann M (2008) Policy instruments design to reduce financing costs in renewable energy technology projects. ECOFYS. 2008Google Scholar
  5. DiaCore project. Noothout P, de Jager D, Tesniere L, van Rooijen S, Karypidis N (Ecofys); Bruckmann R, Jirous F (eclareon), Breitschopf B (Fraunhofer ISI); Angelopoulos D, Doukas H (EPU-NTUA); Konstantinaviciute I (LEI), Resch G, (TU Wien) (2010) The impact of risks in renewable energy investments and the role of smart policies, final report. DiaCore projectGoogle Scholar
  6. EWEA (2012) Green growth-the impact of wind energy on jobs and the economyGoogle Scholar
  7. GHK (2006) Strategic evaluation on environment and risk prevention under structural and cohesion funds for the period 2007–2013. Main Report, National Evaluation Report for PortugalGoogle Scholar
  8. IEA (2010) Projected costs of generating electricity. IEA/OECDGoogle Scholar
  9. IEA Wind, 1978–2013. Annual reports. IEA/EWEA/CWEAGoogle Scholar
  10. IRENA-GWEC (2012) 30 years of policies for wind energy, lessons from 12 wind energy marketsGoogle Scholar
  11. EWEA (2009) The economics of wind energy, a report by the European Wind Energy Association. p. 45Google Scholar
  12. European Renewable Energy Council (2004) Renewable energy policy review: GermanyGoogle Scholar
  13. European Renewable Energy Council (2009) Renewable energy policy review: ItalyGoogle Scholar
  14. IPCC (2012) Special Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Renewable energy sources and climate change mitigationGoogle Scholar
  15. U.S. department of energy, 2010. 2010 Wind technologies market reportGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Nature B.V. 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.UPLUniv Paris NanterreNanterreFrance
  2. 2.Climate Economics ChairParisFrance
  3. 3.IFP Energie NouvelleRueil-MalmaisonFrance

Personalised recommendations