Environmental and Resource Economics

, Volume 33, Issue 2, pp 223–250 | Cite as

The Empirics of Wetland Valuation: A Comprehensive Summary and a Meta-Analysis of the Literature

  • Luke M. Brander
  • Raymond J. G. M. Florax
  • Jan E. Vermaat
Article

Abstract

Wetlands are highly productive ecosystems, providing a number of goods and services that are of value to people. The open-access nature and the public-good characteristics of wetlands often result in these regions being undervalued in decisions relating to their use and conservation. There is now a substantial literature on wetland valuation, including two meta-analyses that examine subsets of the available wetland valuation literature. We collected over 190 wetland valuation studies, providing 215 value observations, in order to present a more comprehensive meta-analysis of the valuation literature that includes tropical wetlands (e.g., mangroves), estimates from diverse valuation methodologies, and a broader range of wetland services (e.g., biodiversity value). We also aim for a more comprehensive geographical coverage. We find that socio-economic variables, such as income and population density, that are often omitted from such analyses are important in explaining wetland value. We also assess the prospects for using this analysis for out-of-sample value transfer, and find average transfer errors of 74%, with just under one-fifth of the transfers showing errors of 10% or less.

Keywords

meta-analysis valuation value transfer wetlands 

JEL classifications

C53 D62 H23 Q20 Q25 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Acharya, G. 2000‘Approaches to Valuing the Hidden Hydrological Services of Wetland Ecosystems’Ecological Economics356374CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Acharya, G., Barbier, E. B. 2000‘Valuing Ground Water Recharge through Agricultural Production in the Hadejia-Nguru Wetlands in Northern Nigeria’Agricultural Economics22247259Google Scholar
  3. Amacher, G. S., Brazee, R. J., Bulkley, J. W., Moll, R. A. 1989Application of Wetland Valuation Techniques: Examples from Great Lakes Coastal WetlandsUniversity of Michigan, School of Natural ResourcesAnn Arbor, MIGoogle Scholar
  4. Anderson, R. and M. Rockel (1991), ‘Economic Valuation of Wetlands’, American Petroleum Institute, Discussion Paper No. 65, Washington D.CGoogle Scholar
  5. Bann, C. 1997An Economic Analysis of Alternative Mangrove Management Strategies in Koh Kong Province, CambodiaEEPSEA research report seriesSingaporeGoogle Scholar
  6. Batie, S. S., Shabman, L. 1979‘Valuing Non-Market Goods: Conceptual and Empirical Issues’American Journal of Agricultural Economics61931932Google Scholar
  7. Bateman, I., Langford, I. H. 1997‘Non-Users Willingness to Pay for a National Park: An Application of the Contingent Valuation Method’Regional Studies31571582Google Scholar
  8. Bateman, I., Jones, L. P. 2003‘Contrasting Conventional with Multi-level Modeling Approaches to Meta-analysis: Expectation Consistency in U.K. Woodland Recreation Values’Land Economics79235258Google Scholar
  9. Bateman, I.J., A.A. Lovett and J.S. Brainard (2004), Applied Environmental Economics: A GIS Approach to Cost-Benefit Analysis. Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  10. Barbier, E. B. 1991

    ‘An Approach to Economic Evaluation of Tropical Wetlands: With Examples from Guatemala and Nicaragua’

    Girvan, N. P.Simons, D. eds. Caribbean Ecology and EconomicsCaribbean Conservation AssociationSt. Michael, Barbados207231
    Google Scholar
  11. Barbier, E. B., Acreman, M., Knowler, D. 1997Economic Valuation of Wetlands: A Guide for Policy Makers and PlannersRamsar Convention BureauGland, SwitzerlandGoogle Scholar
  12. Barbier, E. B., Strand, I. 1998‘Valuing Mangrove-Fishery Linkages’Environmental and Resource Economics12151166CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Barbier, E. B., Thompson, J. R. 1998‘The Value of Water: Floodplain versus Large-scale Irrigation Benefits in Northern Nigeria’Ambio26434440Google Scholar
  14. Bardecki, M. J. 1998Wetlands and Economics: An Annotated Review of the Literature, 1988–1998Environment CanadaOntarioGoogle Scholar
  15. Bell, F. W. 1997‘The Economic Valuation of Saltwater Marsh Supporting Marine Recreational Fishing in the Southeastern United States’Ecological Economics21243254CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Bergstrom, J. C., Stoll, J. R., Titre, J. P., Wright, V. L. 1990‘Economic Valuation of Wetlands-based Recreation’Ecological Economics2129147CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Bergstrom, J. C., Stoll, J. R. 1993‘Value Estimator Models for Wetlands-based Recreational use Values’Land Economics69132137Google Scholar
  18. Blomquist, G. C., Whitehead, J. C. 1998‘Resource Quality Information and Validity of Willingness to Pay in Contingent Valuation’Resource and Energy Economics20179196CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Breaux, A., Farber, S. C., Day, J. 1995‘Using Natural Coastal Wetlands Systems for Wastewater Treatment: An Economic Benefit Analysis’Journal of Environmental Management44285291CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Brouwer, R. 2000‘Environmental Value Transfer: State of the Art and Future Prospects’Ecological Economics32137152CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Brouwer, R., Langford, I. H., Bateman, I. J., Crowards, T. C., Turner, R. K. 1999‘A Meta-Analysis of Wetland Contingent Valuation Studies’Regional Environmental Change14757CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Brouwer, R., Spaninks, F. A. 1999‘The Validity of Environmental Benefits Transfer: Further Empirical Testing’Environmental and Resource Economics1495117CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Bystrom, O., Andersson, H., Gren, I.-M. 2000‘Economic Criteria for Using Wetlands as Nitrogen Sinks under Uncertainty’Ecological Economics353545Google Scholar
  24. Carson, R. T., Flores, N. E., Martin, K. M., Wright, J. L. 1996‘Contingent Valuation and Revealed Preference Methodologies: Comparing the Estimates for Quasi-Public Goods’Land Economics72(Feb)8099Google Scholar
  25. Cooper, J., Loomis, J. 1991

    Economic Value of Wildlife Resources in the San Joaquin Valley: Hunting and Fishing Values

    Dinar, A.Zilberman, D. eds. The Economics and Management of Water and Drainage in AgricultureKluwer Academic PublishersNorwell Mass
    Google Scholar
  26. Cooper, J., Loomis, J. 1993‘Testing whether Waterfowl Hunting Benefits Increase with Greater Water Deliveries to Wetlands’Environmental and Resource Economics3545561Google Scholar
  27. Costanza, R., Farber, S. C., Maxwell, J. 1989‘Valuation and Management of Wetland Ecosystems’Ecological Economics1335361Google Scholar
  28. Creel, M., Loomis, J. 1992‘Recreation Value of Water to Wetlands in the San Joaquin Valley: Linked Multinomial Logit and Count Data Trip Frequency Models’Water Resources Research2825972606CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Cummings, R. G., Harrison, G. W. 1995‘‘The Measurement and Decomposition of Non-use Values: A Critical Review’’Environmental and Resource Economics5225247CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Dahuri, R. 1991An Approach to Coastal Resource Utilisation: The Nature and Role of Sustainable Development in East Kalimantan Coastal Zone, IndonesiaDalhousie UniversityHalifax, CanadaPhD ThesisGoogle Scholar
  31. Dharmaratne, G. and I. Strand (2002), Adaptation to Climate Change in the Caribbean: The Role of Economic Valuation. Report to the CPACC, LondonGoogle Scholar
  32. Dalecki, M. G., Whitehead, J. C., Blomquist, G. C. 1993‘Sample Non-Response Bias and Aggregate Benefits in Contingent Valuation: An Examination of Early, Late and Non-Respondents’Journal of Environmental Management38133143CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Dixon, J. A. and P. N. Lal (1997). ‘The Management of Coastal Wetlands: Economic Analysis of Combined Ecologic-Economic Systems’, in P. Dasgupta and K.-G. Mäler, eds., The Environment and Emerging Development Issues, Vol 2. Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
  34. Doss, C. R., Taff, S. J. 1996‘The Influence of Wetland Type and Wetland Proximity on Residential Property Values’Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics21120129Google Scholar
  35. Downing, M., Ozuna, T. 1996‘Testing the Reliability of the Benefit Function Transfer Approach’Journal of Environmental Economics and Management30316322CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Efron, B. 1982The Jackknife, the Bootstrap and other Resampling PlansSociety for Industrial and Applied MathematicsPhiladelphiaGoogle Scholar
  37. Ellis, G. M., Fisher, A. C. 1987‘Valuing the Environment as Input’Journal of Environmental Management25149156Google Scholar
  38. Emerton, L., Iyango, L., Luwum, P., Malinga, A. 1998The Present Economic Value of Nakivubo Urban Wetland, UgandaIUCN ReportNairobi, KenyaGoogle Scholar
  39. Emerton, L. and B. Kekulandala (2002). ‘Assessment of the Economic Value of Muthurajawela Wetland’, IUCN – The World Conservation Union, Sri Lanka Country OfficeGoogle Scholar
  40. Engel, S. 2002

    Benefit Function Transfer versus Meta-Analysis as Policy-making Tools: A Comparison

    Florax, R. J. G. M.Nijkamp, P.Willis, K. G. eds. Comparative Environmental Economic AssessmentCheltenhamEdward Elgar133153
    Google Scholar
  41. Farber, S. 1988‘Non-user’s WTP for a National Park: An Application and Critique of the Contingent Valuation Method’Regional Studies31571582Google Scholar
  42. Farber, S. 1992‘The Economic Cost of Residential Environmental Risk: A Case Study of Louisiana’Journal of Environmental Management36116Google Scholar
  43. Farber, S., Costanza, R. 1987‘The Economic Value of Wetland Systems’Journal of Environmental Management244151Google Scholar
  44. Florax, R. J. G. M.Nijkamp, P.Willis, K. G. eds. 2002Comparative Environmental Economic AssessmentCheltenhamEdward ElgarGoogle Scholar
  45. Freeman, A. M.,III 1991‘Valuing Environmental Resources under Alternative Management Regimes’Ecological Economics3247256CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Freeman, A. M.,III 2003The Measurement of Environmental and Resource Values: Theories and MethodsResources for the FutureWashington D.CGoogle Scholar
  47. Gren, I.-M., Soderqvist, T. 1994Economic Valuation of Wetlands: A SurveyBeijer Discussion Paper Series No. 54Stockholm: SwedenGoogle Scholar
  48. Gren, I.-M., Folke, C., Turner, K., Bateman, I. 1994‘Primary and Secondary Values of Wetland Ecosystems’Environmental and Resource Economics45574Google Scholar
  49. Gren, I.-M. 1995‘The Value of Investing in Wetlands for Nitrogen Abatement’European Review of Agricultural Economics22157172Google Scholar
  50. Haab, T.C. and K.E. McConnell (1997). ‘A Simple Method for Bounding WTP using a Probit or Logit Model’. Economic Working Paper 9713, East Carolina UniversityGoogle Scholar
  51. Hammack, J., Brown, G. M. 1974Waterfowl and Wetlands: Toward A Bio-Economic AnalysisResources for the Future, John Hopkins University PressWashington, D.CGoogle Scholar
  52. Janssen, R., Padilla, J. E. 1999‘Preservation of Conversion? Valuation and Evaluation of a Mangrove Forest in the Philippines’Environmental and Resource Economics14297331Google Scholar
  53. Kazmierczak, R. F. 2001Economic Linkages between Coastal Wetlands and Hunting and Fishing: A Review of Value Estimates Reported in the Published LiteratureLouisiana State University Agricultural CenterBaton RougeStaff Paper 2001 – 03Google Scholar
  54. Klein, R. J. T., Bateman, I. J. 1998‘The Recreational Value of Cley Marshes Nature Reserve: An Argument Against Managed Retreat?’Journal of the Chartered Institution of Water and Environmental Management12280285Google Scholar
  55. Kopp, R. J.Smith, V. K. eds. 1993Valuing Natural Assets, The Economics of Natural Resource Damage AssessmentResources for the FutureWashington, D.CGoogle Scholar
  56. Lant, C. L., Roberts, R. S. 1990‘Greenbelts in the Cornbelt: Riparian Wetlands, Intrinsic Values and Market Failure’Environment and Planning2213751388Google Scholar
  57. Larson, J. S., P. R. Adamus and E. J. Clairain Jr (1989), ‘Functional Assessment of Freshwater Wetlands: A Manual and Training Outline’, Glaud, Switzerland: WWF Publication 89–6:62 ppGoogle Scholar
  58. Leitch, J. A., Hovde, B. 1996‘Empirical Valuation of Prairie Potholes: Five Case Studies’Great Plains Research62539Google Scholar
  59. Loomis, J. B. 1992‘The Evolution of a More Rigorous Approach to Benefit Transfer: Benefit Function Transfer’Water Resources Research28701705CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Lupi, F., T. Graham-Tomasi and S. J. Taff (1991), ‘A Hedonic Approach to Urban Wetland Valuation’. Staff Paper P91-8, Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, University of MinnesotaGoogle Scholar
  61. Parsons, G. R., Kealy, M. J. 1994‘Benefit Transfer in a Random Utility Model of Recreation’Water Resources Research3024772484CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Pate, J., Loomis, J. 1997‘The Effect of Distance on Willingness to Pay Values: A Case Study of Wetlands and Salmon in California’Ecological Economics20199207CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Pearce, D., Turner, R. K. 1990Economics of Natural Resources and the EnvironmentHarvester WheatsheafHemel Hempstead, UKGoogle Scholar
  64. Ramdial, B. S. (1975), ‘The Social and Economic Importance of the Caroni Swamp in Trinidad and Tobago’. PhD thesis, University of Michigan.Google Scholar
  65. Raphael, C. N., Jaworski, E. 1979‘Economic Value of Fish, Wildlife, and Recreation in Michigan’s Coastal Wetlands’Coastal Zone Management Journal5181194Google Scholar
  66. Rosenberger, R., Loomis, J. B. 2000‘‘Using Meta-Analysis For Benefit Transfer: In Sample Convergent Validity Tests of an Outdoor Recreation Database’’Water Resources Research3610971107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Rosenberger, R. and T. T. Phipps (2001). ‘Site correspondence effects in benefit transfers: A meta-analysis transfer function’. Research Paper 2001–6, West Virginia University.Google Scholar
  68. Rosenthal, R., DiMatteo, M. R. 2001‘Meta-Analysis: Recent Developments in Quantitative Methods for Literature Reviews’Annual Review of Psychology525982CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Ruitenbeek, H. J. (1992), ‘Mangrove Management: An Economic Analysis of Management Options with a Focus on Bintuni Bay, Irian Jaya’. Environmental Management Development in Indonesia Project, EMDI Environmental Report 8, Jakarta, IndonesiaGoogle Scholar
  70. Sathirathai, S., Barbier, E. B. 2001‘Valuing Mangrove Conservation in Southern Thailand’Contemporary Economic Policy19109122CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Schuijt, K. 2004Land and Water Use of Wetlands in Africa: Economic Values of African WetlandsInternational Institute for Applied Systems AnalysisLaxenburg, AustriaReport No. IR-02 – 063Google Scholar
  72. Shaw, W. D., Ozog, M. T. 1999‘Modeling Overnight Recreation Trip Choice: Application of a Repeated Nested Multinomial Logit Model’Environmental and Resource Economics13397414CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Shrestha, R. K., Loomis, J. B. 2001‘Testing a Meta-Analysis Model for Benefit Transfer in International Outdoor Recreation’Ecological Economics396783CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Smith, V. K., Pattanayak, K. 2002‘Is Meta-Analysis A Noah’s Ark for Non-Market Valuation?’Environmental and Resource Economics2227196CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Stanley, T. D. 2001‘Wheat from Chaff: Meta-Analysis as Quantitative Literature Review’Journal of Economic Perspectives1513150Google Scholar
  76. Turner, R. K., Bergh, J. C. J. M., Soderqvist, T., Barendregt, A., Straaten, J., Maltby, E., Ierland, E. C. 2000‘Ecological-Economic Analysis of Wetlands: Scientific Integration for Management and Policy’Ecological Economics35723CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  77. Bergh, J., Barendregt, A., Gilbert, A., Herwijnedn, M., Horssen, P., Kandelaars, P., Lorenz, C. 2001‘Spatial Economic-Hydrological Modeling and Evaluation of Land Use Impacts in the Vecht Wetlands Area’Environmental Modeling and Assessment687100Google Scholar
  78. Wagtendonk, A., Omtzigt, N. 2003Analysis of Population Density Around Wetland Areas in GPW (Gridded Population of the World) FilesSPINlab document, Institute for Environmental StudiesAmsterdamGoogle Scholar
  79. Willig, R. D. 1976‘Consumers’ Surplus without An Apology’American Economic Review66589597Google Scholar
  80. Woodward, R. T., Wui, Y.-S. 2001‘The Economic Value of Wetland Services: A Meta-Analysis’Ecological Economics37257270CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer 2006

Authors and Affiliations

  • Luke M. Brander
    • 1
  • Raymond J. G. M. Florax
    • 2
    • 3
  • Jan E. Vermaat
    • 1
  1. 1.Institute for Environmental Studies (IVM)Vrije UniversiteitAmsterdamThe Netherlands
  2. 2.Department of Agricultural EconomicsPurdue UniversityWest LafayetteUSA
  3. 3.Department of Spatial EconomicsVrije UniversiteitAmsterdamThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations